Anyone from the UK?

[Hodes101]

Oh some definitely are

Time for another Lord Of The Rings marathon I guess

Extended or normal?

Do you include the Hobbit?

 

[Thirsty_Hellcat_J]

Oh some definitely are

Time for another Lord Of The Rings marathon I guess

Ha ha. I did so many, I don't think I ever had the urge to lick them. Any part of them.

 

[Thirsty_Hellcat_J]

Extended or normal?

Do you include the Hobbit?

I thought the hobbit was awful. I loved the book though.

 

[RosewoodTulip]

Do you rate the Hobbit too?

Extended or normal?

Do you include the Hobbit?

Extended always

I tolerate the Hobbit. First one is the best - especially the Dwarves at Bag End and the Trolls but the studios got greedy instead of just trusting PJ and Del Toro

 

[Great_Scot]

Extended always

Yay!

I tolerate the Hobbit. First one is the best - especially the Dwarves at Bag End and the Trolls but the studios got greedy instead of just trusting PJ and Del Toro

Agreed. The dwarves in bagend is brilliant!

Don't get me started in the made up extra elf wifey.

 

[RosewoodTulip]

Yay!

Agreed. The dwarves in bagend is brilliant!

Don't get me started in the made up extra elf wifey.

Evangeline Lilly did a great job but she shouldn't have been there.
A lot of it was so unnecessary. The Hobbit is such a simple story. Yes we have the benefit of knowledge from Tolkien's notes and Appendices for everything else that was happening but it did not need to be a trilogy at all

 

[Wand3rlust]

*walks in, hears the geek fest, decides to sit in the corner and wait for biscuits*

 

[RosewoodTulip]

*walks in, hears the geek fest, decides to sit in the corner and wait for biscuits*

Sorry I can't help myself. The nerd can't be contained

 

[Hodes101]

You can't out nerd a geek Rose.

 

[Great_Scot]

Evangeline Lilly did a great job but she shouldn't have been there.
A lot of it was so unnecessary. The Hobbit is such a simple story. Yes we have the benefit of knowledge from Tolkien's notes and Appendices for everything else that was happening but it did not need to be a trilogy at all

One film only! Yeah she was fine but, another part of what ruined it all for me.

 

[Hodes101]

One film only! Yeah she was fine but, another part of what ruined it all for me.

2 films for me. I think one film would have lost the awesomeness that was Smaug

 

[RosewoodTulip]

One film only! Yeah she was fine but, another part of what ruined it all for me.

I can see the need for two films. I liked how they did Mirkwood and Riddles in the Dark and Smaug. They spent too much time in Lake Town and far too much time on the final battle

 

[Great_Scot]

2 films for me. I think one film would have lost the awesomeness that was Smaug

Fair.

 

[RosewoodTulip]

Anyway...
I'll stop boring everyone else now

 

[NorthernCardinal]

Ello

 

[Hodes101]

Anyway...
I'll stop boring everyone else now

No keep talking.......

 

[Secretintoelderly]

Yes, I love this dirty talk

 

[Cwtchseeker]

Evening all

 

[Great_Scot]

*hands Wander a biscuit*

It's fine Rosie, that'll keep her busy for a minute.

Favourite scene in LOTR?

 

[Wand3rlust]

Anyway...
I'll stop boring everyone else now

I was happy listening!

*eats a garibaldi*

 

[Hodes101]

Is there anything better than the bridge of khazad dum?

 

[Great_Scot]

Is there anything better than the bridge of khazad dum?

It's very cool but it's not the Riders if Rohan, with Gandalf flooding down to Helms deep. IMHO.

 

[Cwtchseeker]

Where’s that biscuit tin??

 

[Hodes101]

It's very cool but it's not the Riders if Rohan, with Gandalf flooding down to Helms deep. IMHO.

In the book or film only?

 

[RosewoodTulip]

Is there anything better than the bridge of khazad dum?

My friend pointed out that during that scene it sounds like the chorus is singing "rhubarb salami" and now that's all I can hear