Quasimodem said:Actually, celebrities are real people. (Sort of.) Character-based fan fiction is about fictional characters.
The difference between those two types, and straight historical fiction, is that Celebrity fiction is pseudo biographical.
(Right! About as close to reality as 'The Simple Life'.)
Fan fiction is fiction based upon some other (professional) writer's character(s) and setting.
Historical fiction tends to be about fictional characters within a real (historical) setting . . . at least as close as that writer's abilities and research can get him/her.
Alternately, some stories are fictional (or fictionalized) events in a real historical character's life. Again, as good as the writers' talent and research can get him/her.
In this light, the real-life celebrity's story and the fictionalized event in a historical character's (celebrity) life shares similar ground, without really sharing a similar goal.
Celebrity fiction is fantasizing about an actual person's reality.
Historical fiction applies historical fact to fictional events to increase the story's verisimilitude.
Fan fiction tries only to recreate whatever reality was accomplished by the original writer(s).
We already have a number of authors publishing historical stories, and in whichever category they are filed, they are never a comfortable fit. The writer must always feel that some portion of his/her story is not being considered. The reader is also being partially mislead, or failing to be lead, either away from, or toward these stories.
The same kind of nonsupport is true of Celebrity and Fan Fiction; but, only in that way are they similar. It would be equally misleading to consider them each other's equivalent.
Oh, I do hope we get a historical section. I really like reading those books. There is this one author, I can't think of her name. She is an archealogist (or anthropoligist? I forget), she builds entire romantical tales just from odd scientific discoveries they find.
There is this one, based on a mummy they found in an odd place in like England or someplace there-abouts. She turned it into this whole, hmm, a story like Romeo and Juliette (and if I could spell... that would be a miracle).
That would be completely cool to read, more history based stuff.