9ers WIN

Chuckus said:
So your saying he is better than Harrison, Rice, Tim Brown, Isaac Bruce, Tory Holt..........on and on. Sure he is good but I don't see him as one of the Top 2. Maybe in the Top 25.
Top 2: TO and Harrison.
 
Getting past the Shockey Owens debate, I believe that the Giants lost the game because they were stupid. They let Owens rile them and the penalties that were called on them could have been avoided. That is what cost them the game. What the hell was Sean Williams thinking?
 
islandman said:
Top 2: TO and Harrison.


Your entitled to your belief. I disagree and would venture to say as I did earlier, TO is in the Top 20 (maybe even Top 15) but not one of the Top 2.
 
*Eve* said:
Getting past the Shockey Owens debate, I believe that the Giants lost the game because they were stupid. They let Owens rile them and the penalties that were called on them could have been avoided. That is what cost them the game. What the hell was Sean Williams thinking?

Yup, I agree with that. The Giants got pissed off and were more focused on being mad, than on playing the game.
 
*Eve* said:
Getting past the Shockey Owens debate, I believe that the Giants lost the game because they were stupid. They let Owens rile them and the penalties that were called on them could have been avoided. That is what cost them the game. What the hell was Sean Williams thinking?

Disagree. The Giants lost the game with 10 minutes in the third quarter when they started to coast, well before the rumble in the 4th.

By the time they realized it, the 9ers were too much on a roll.
 
*Eve* said:
Getting past the Shockey Owens debate, I believe that the Giants lost the game because they were stupid. They let Owens rile them and the penalties that were called on them could have been avoided. That is what cost them the game. What the hell was Sean Williams thinking?


Indeed, if the Giants simply had not reacted...........

.........but they did.
 
islandman said:
Disagree. The Giants lost the game with 10 minutes in the third quarter when they started to coast, well before the rumble in the 4th.

By the time they realized it, the 9ers were too much on a roll.


Still if they'd have remained calm and "played" the game, they could have stopped that roll.
 
Chuckus said:
So your saying he is better than Harrison, Rice, Tim Brown, Isaac Bruce, Tory Holt..........on and on. Sure he is good but I don't see him as one of the Top 2. Maybe in the Top 25.

Owens, Terrell:

Stat, Total, NFL ranking

receptions, 100, 4th (tie)
yards, 1300, 8th
yards per game, 92.9, 2nd
TD, 13, 1st
fumbles, 0, 1st (tie)

Every one of those numbers is better than Shockey's, BTW.
 
Thrillhouse said:
Owens, Terrell:

Stat, Total, NFL ranking

receptions, 100, 4th (tie)
yards, 1300, 8th
yards per game, 92.9, 2nd
TD, 13, 1st
fumbles, 0, 1st (tie)

Every one of those numbers is better than Shockey's, BTW.


Umm..........Shockey is a TE and a ROOKIE. I wasn't even comparing TO to Shockey as to being one of the Top Receivers in the League.
 
cybergirly1989 said:
Still if they'd have remained calm and "played" the game, they could have stopped that roll.

Nah. The 9ers D made adjustments that the Giants coaches did adjust too. That, combined with lack of execution, ended the game.

That and TO stepped up big. Hard combo to beat.
 
Sticking tongue out as I run

though.... ok ok they won. So what? Sulking.

Serious note the Giants did show some poor sportmanship. Well, at least one player did. So be it they are out now. Can't say it wasn't an interesting game.

Peace,
Tulip
 
Thrillhouse said:
Owens, Terrell:

Stat, Total, NFL ranking

receptions, 100, 4th (tie)
yards, 1300, 8th
yards per game, 92.9, 2nd
TD, 13, 1st
fumbles, 0, 1st (tie)

Every one of those numbers is better than Shockey's, BTW.
Sweet. Comparing a WR to and TE. A veteran to rook.

Watch much football, do you?
 
Re: Sticking tongue out as I run

tulip2lipservice said:
though.... ok ok they won. So what? Sulking.

Serious note the Giants did show some poor sportmanship. Well, at least one player did. So be it they are out now. Can't say it wasn't an interesting game.

Peace,
Tulip

Ditto to that. I just came into to peek around in the thread. I have no real allegiance to either team that played in the late game.
 
The Giants turned too conservative with their offense in the second half and then they left Seahorn on Owens in single coverage for way too long. They should have doubled up on him and took him out of the equation. Owens is their best receiver, make it impossible, or at least harder for Garcia to get him the ball and you shut SF down.
 
Chuckus said:
Umm..........Shockey is a TE and a ROOKIE. I wasn't even comparing TO to Shockey as to being one of the Top Receivers in the League.

True, the last comment about Shockey wasn't really fair, i.e. comparing a WR and a TE's stats.

However, TO's numbers clearly show he is better than, as you put it, "maybe in the Top 25."
 
Thrillhouse said:
True, the last comment about Shockey wasn't really fair, i.e. comparing a WR and a TE's stats.

However, TO's numbers clearly show he is better than, as you put it, "maybe in the Top 25."


IMHO TO is that he is one of the Top 20. Not Top 2. I am not talking about any stats or otherwise, just IMHO.

To me, numbers don't always tell the story. Harrison, is a consumate professional and doesn't stir anything up......he lets his game do the talking. TO (for example) has skills but chooses to run his mouth before, during and after games to pick up the slack where his skills lack. That says alot to me, IMHO.

Look over the past 5-10 years, timespan that TO has been in the NFL (I believe), and you will see his numbers aren't necesssarily up to the level of a Jerry Rice, Tim Brown, Marvin Harrison or even Randy Moss............

Sure maybe statistacally TO has "Top 5" numbers this season but by the sheer weight of all the shenanigans he has created and done, that knocks him out of being a true "Top" anything IMHO to me.

TO is an overrated reciever (IMHO), who CAN do some great things and who does have skill, but tends to run his mouth when it really isn't necessary; wherein he might take a page from Jerry Rice and let your GAME speak for itself and keep outta the friggin BS and comotion that he tends to have surrounding himself.
 
Back
Top