A Beautiful Mind: Overrated?

lavender said:
~~SPOILERS!!!~~

.

Lavender....
I've not seen it yet, but I plan to. In fact, I have an old High School friend who managed to land a couple *VERY small extra rolls in it. She was telling me about the movie around Christmastime.

Nonetheless, I've heard many others mention some of the things you have. I guess I'll withhold opinion until I make the time to see it.

Best,
V~~~~
 
An Opposing view

lavender said:
But, what do you expect when the Director of Backdraft and Willow decide to tackle a project about a sexual nonconformist, suffering from paranoid schizophrenia (sp?) who is a genius mathematician and finally won the Nobel Prize?
___________________________________________________
To each their own opinions, naturally, but I fully disagree on your viewpoint about Ron "Opie" Howard whose direction is to be applauded. The weaving in and out of Nash's invisible friends was accomplished in a way to make you/me question what was & wasn't actually real. Of course, I saw the film at its L.A. premiere and was not subjected to others tipping me off--whether it be friends or "critics."

The mood created by the lighting, camera angles, lense sizes (at times adding to the schizophrenic 'feel", interior sets, and even casting was all done thru Ron.

Was the film a stretch of Nash's actual life? Of course, thus the title "film".

As far as a smaller independent production company tackling the subject matter in a different manner-- Independence doesn't equivocate honesty, in Hollywood.
 
Lav

Haven't seen it yet, but I do know about it and I agree with your concerns. I work in mental health, and the movies Girl Interrupted and 28 days have had a huge impact on our hospital. A negative one. I am only glad that you can't just "become" schizophrenic or schizoaffective like you can borderline or anorexic/bulemic. Oh, the self inflicted wounds that Girl Interrupted caused...... :mad:

BTW, nice AV, Lav!!!
 
lavender said:
~~SPOILERS!!!~~ But, what do you expect when the Director of Backdraft and Willow decide to tackle a project about a sexual nonconformist, suffering from paranoid schizophrenia (sp?) who is a genius mathematician and finally won the Nobel Prize?

I'm not sure what that's supposed to mean. Why isn't Opie capable? He's very capable.
 
I thought so *yawn*. I did like the interraction between Nash and his 'room-mate', and I thought Jennifer Connolly was exceptional, but on the whole I was squirming in my seat waiting for the credits.

On the other hand, my parents loved it.
 
Gotta go with the fat boy again here...


Campaign against 'Beautiful' is ugly

March 11, 2002

BY ROGER EBERT

Judging by the attacks against it, "A Beautiful Mind" is the most reprehensible film of the year. Amazing it was made, let alone nominated for an Academy Award. The mugging of this film is the most disturbing element of this year's Oscar season.

Ron Howard's film stars Russell Crowe as John Forbes Nash Jr., a schizophrenic who won the Nobel Prize for mathematics. We see him struggling with demons and fantasies, aided by a loyal wife (Jennifer Connelly). Like Nash, the audience is sometimes deluded about what's real in the story, and what is a phantasm.

The film is well written, directed and acted. But the film's detractors see more, or less. They charge:

* Nash has been whitewashed; the film suppresses the facts that he fathered a child out of wedlock, and refused to support it, was bisexual, and faced molestation charges after an incident in a public toilet.

**A book about Nash reports him making anti-Semitic comments. Joy Behar on "The View'' said the movie should have included that behavior. Would she have preferred a movie about an anti-Semite who wins the Nobel?

* Russell Crowe, angry that the British Academy Awards telecast edited out four lines of poetry in his speech, pushed and shoved the director of the program.

**Press Release: "Claiming that the film 'A Beautiful Mind' distorts the life of John Nash, a coalition of 100 mental health advocacy groups issued a public statement today to Universal asking for an apology and retraction." The coalition is angry about a USA Today article reporting that "this brilliant mathematician stopped taking antipsychotic drugs in 1970 and slowly recovered over two decades.''

My thoughts:

**The movie is caught in the controversy between those supporting drugs in the
treatment of schizophrenia, and those interested in other approaches. The coalition is really disturbed not because the movie changed the facts, but because it didn't change them enough; in the film, Nash speaks of "newer medications" that in real life he was not taking, so they should be calling for an apology from USA Today, not the studio.

**A schizophrenic has a serious mental illness, yet Behar and others hold him to the standard of a healthy person. Who knows what he thought he was doing, or saying, during the episodes involving sex and anti-Semitism? In the film, he lives with imaginary characters for years.

To say he should have "sought treatment" is to assume he was sane enough to do so, and to ignore his belief that medication would cloud his mathematical work.

**Crowe has a hot head, but he also has a point. Awards shows are inflated with endless gassy lists of people the winners want to thank. Crowe read four lines by Patrick Kavanaugh that directly express his humility as an artist. Cutting them made his speech pointless.

Are the attacks against "A Beautiful Mind" orchestrated? "I'm not going to reveal my sources," says the Web's Matt Drudge, whose report on the anti-Semitic remarks caused an uproar. His statement tips his hand: He didn't find out about the statements himself, but was told about them.

Isn't he missing the real story--that someone came to him with a vested interest in hurting the film?

"If you are a responsible writer," says shell-shocked Universal chairman Stacey Snider, "you don't take statements out of context that someone made during a 35-year battle with schizophrenia." True. "A Beautiful Mind" is a parable about triumph in the face of disaster, not a drive-by shooting.
 
You know what... I just saw this film tonight and I loved it.

I didn't think about what the mental health community might think. I don't recall hearing about any of this controversy.

I just thought it was a wonderful, scary, joyous and ultimately uplifting movie.

I hadn't even read this thread when lavy first posted it because it said right up front there were spoilers.

I usually try to search on topics that are likely to have already been discussed before starting a brand new thread. So I did a search on Beautiful Mind and found this thread. Which is why I'm posting to this instead of starting a new thread. Nice and neat and saves server space and all that good stuff.

I truly enjoyed this film.
 
I thought the movie was going to be complete crap when I went to see it in Spain, probably because Spanish TV had advertised it as some smarmy love story in order to appeal to their audience. So I was pleasantly surprised that it concentrated on Nash's illness instead of his love life. I also thought the directing was awesome...and I loved being tricked by the invisible friends.

But Lord of the Rings was better.
 
Goddamnit, that was me. I deleted all my temporary internet files, so I was uncookiefied.
 
The movie hardly delegitimizes people with schizophrenia! If anything it did the exact opposite. Would an institutionalized character made it more legit? Exactly what was sugarcoated? How should they have portrayed it? What are you talking about?
 
I thought the movie was very good. I don't think it down plays the disease at all.

As far as 28 Days and Girl Interrupted...how can a movie cause you do something that isn't already there in some way?
 
About the anti-semetism, I don't know what nash might have said, but I read in Time magazine that he is Jewish, so I would imagine that if he made anti-semetic statements, it might have had to do with him being ill.

I thought the film was great. It was well made, well acted, etc. I was under the impression from the film that in the movie, Nash stopped taking the meds and went downhill, but when he got the newer stuff and took them, he was at least a little more stable.

I was glad the film concentrated on the mental illness, instead of love life and illegitimate children. That gets really tired after a while.


Storm1969,
If people inflict harm on themselves or conjure up illnesses -I have a sister that has that problem- because of a film they have seen, doesn't that make them disturbed anyway?
 
The film begged many questions. The severity of his schizophrenia not being the least. He was able to coup with his illness because he found a safe familiar environment where stimuli became predictable. I believe that there are societies in the world that have coped with mental illness in much the same way by tolerating and protecting those affected. A schizophrenic, homeless, hungry, and paranoid living on the street would have little ability to cope with his delusion and would more than likely sink deeper into the delusional state. Nash was able to isolate and "control" his delusions because he was in a safe protected environment. In that sence he was lucky.

I thought the film did nothing at all with his bi sexuality. I did think the portrayal of his delusion from his persective was done well. I found it interesting that he never seemed to loose a sence of who he was. I worked for a time in psych hospitals and have met jesus, satan, and several kings, presidents brothers etc. Interesting that Nash seemed to always have been grounded in the reality of who he was.
 
I thought the movie was good too. It showcased some of the struggles of a mentally ill person and the toll it took on the family too. I thought they did an excellent job and kept it fairly reality based in the process. Having lived with someone who was paranoid schiz, I thought it captured some of the pain and even the humor this malady brings to life.

If you want to talk about a overrated film then talk about the English Patient. That was and remains to this day the most boring flick I ever seen beside that Tess film by Roman Polanski. Talk about snooze material. Whenever I want to go comatose I just think of those two films and its zzzzzz time.
 
Last edited:
Aren't Paranoid Psitzophrenia and Multiple Personality Disorder two completely different diseases?

I thought MPD was when you actually think YOU are someone else VS see other people or have people in your head.

What does Nash's bisexuality have to do with anything? If the film had said "Nash was or is bisexual" wouldn't that come off like saying he is bi because he is mentally ill and therefore being bisexual is equated to being a head case?

____________________________

Eyes Wide Shut is the most boring movie I have ever seen. I have not seen the English patient. I heard it was boring from others too though.
 
Leaving aside the issues of veracity to Nash's real life, or the particulars of how the film deals with the issue of schizophrenia, I just found it to be shallow and not particularly engaging.

I will say that Jennifer Connolly is a marvelous actress. If you haven't seen it, I recommend to check out her performance in Requiem For A Dream.
 
I really liked it. I guess I enjoy so many movies that others don't because I don't analize them and pick them apart vs real world. It's entertainment.
 
lavender said:


Of course I'm probably in the minority here.

Nah. Not in the minority at all. I saw it last week and felt it was good, better than a lot of films I'd seen, but not the best of the year. I enjoyed it but have no desire to see it again. I didn't even think about it until this thread. From a technical standpoint Lord of the Rings was superior. As far as acting and storyline, In The Bedroom was far more deserving of recognition.
 
I don't think the movie could ever live up to the hype that was forced on it. It was a good movie, not great. I thought Russell Crowe did a fantastic job, but I know I went in to the theatre expecting way more than any movie could deliver.
 
Interesting point. I actually had lowered expectations about the movie because of what I had heard here on the board. So not expecting much I wave very pleasantly surprised perhaps.

I remember quite a while ago when Beetlejuice came out. The hype was incredible. I went to see that movie expecting to have my mind blown and I was incredibly disappointed by it.
 
Folks, it IS just a movie.

Having said that, here's why I loved it.

I'm a mathematician and I know that 'finding the solution' angst. I also am familiar with Nash's work so it was pretty cool from that aspect.

I am a crazy romantic. So the idea of a woman staying with him through hell well...that spoke to me.

I am also one who WANTS to apply intellect to problems even those of the heart, and mind. I understood his motivation.

Is this a story? Yes, I am positive no one could accurately portray ANYONE's life in a 3 hour movie. But, I did enjoy and appreciate the 3 hour journey we were taken on, by Crowe, Connelly and Howard.
 
Damn, bitch! How do you start so many threads in such a small amount of time?

(You know I'm only calling you bitch because I think you don't mind)
 
There is a great special that was on PBS about John Nash called "A Brilliant Madness." In many ways I liked it better. We watched the two back to back, the documentary first and then "A Beautiful Mind." I recommend it.

It makes you wonder how many ideas and how much art have been suppressed by the drugs we give to people now.
 
Back
Top