A new one...

STEPHEN is re-cycled LANCE.

Lance did disappear for a minute. But Lance usually seemed to understand what was being talked about in the thread. Stephen usually can't figure out what's going on so he drops some anecdotal information or pseudo-autobiographical story that has no bearing. Then when he's questioned about what he's talking about he starts with the "This is sarcasm, Ta Dah!" bit.
 
I like the title of the story, and I think it has potential. The problem is that the first few paragraphs are somewhat garbled and those first two paragraphs are where an audience is won or lost. If those first sentences don't work, the audience won't go further.

You have some grammatical and stylistic errors that detract from the reader's ability to focus. Also, it's hard to determine whose perspective you want the story to be from--his or hers?

Just my thoughts. Take them for what they're worth.
 
If the story is not written in the first person...why can't both characters' perspectives be observed?
 
If the story is not written in the first person...why can't both characters' perspectives be observed?

Opinions definitely vary on this point. For me personally, though, it is extremely confusing to shift narrative focus frequently unless it's done with great skill and razor precision. I'm no great writer, just a talented amateur, so I avoid that shifting focus. Perspective is the entry way for the reader and if they can't figure out whose perspective they are following, they will stop reading the story altogether and click away, which is not what you want. Again, just my opinion.
 
Observe some football and baseball on teevee; viewpoints change all over the place but the viewer is never confused.
 
Observe some football and baseball on teevee; viewpoints change all over the place but the viewer is never confused.

True enough, but with football on television we have the benefit of visualization, something we don't have in writing, so shifting focus if done ineffectively ruins the whole experience of reading.
 
If the story is not written in the first person...why can't both characters' perspectives be observed?

Okay. I fought hard with that one for the last failure I wrote. I got introduced to a concept called 'head-hopping'. It's to be avoided, as is writing in the second person.

Head hopping is where you can hear the thoughts of more than one character in a story. When you have several characters, whose motives are central to a plot, then it is okay IF they are reasonably separated. But when you have them together (say, at a meeting, or in a restaurant or bar) then you want to tell the story from only one point of view.

The reason for this is that when you talk as more than one character in a story (especially more than one in a scene) it can confuse the reader at times as to who is actually doing what. It gets tricky to do it right and leave the reader with a clear sense of who said what. Even more so when both characters are the same gender, because you can't even use gender pronouns to distinguish them.

The challenge posed to me was essentially: "I think you can pull this story off from a one-person perspective, give it a shot." And when I completely rewrote it, it read much clearer.

Can you do head hopping? Yes. It is allowed. It's your story. But the challenge is, can you make the motivations and reasonings of the other protagonists (or antagonists as the case may be) known without having to spell their thoughts out for the reader?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If the story is not written in the first person...why can't both characters' perspectives be observed?

It simply isn't a popular style now, so the pedantic will say it's never done and is against the law. If it doesn't work, it's usually because it caused confusion; if it does work, readers won't really notice it's been used at all.
 
It simply isn't a popular style now, so the pedantic will say it's never done and is against the law. If it doesn't work, it's usually because it caused confusion; if it does work, readers won't really notice it's been used at all.

I don't think it's a law or a fashion statement either. It's just trying to keep the reader in mind when writing.
 
Back
Top