A Question For Libertarians

Thrillhouse

Back from the dead
Joined
Jun 22, 2002
Posts
1,752
PLEASE do not take this question the wrong way. I think I have Libertarian tendencies, but what I really want to know is, what exactly is the difference between Libertarianism and Anarchy? I'm not trying to start anything, or criticize anyone's political beliefs, but, what little I know about Libertarianism sounds a lot like anarchy. Thank you in advance.

:confused:
 
No. Government is for defense, infrastructure, etc. The other guys think it's mom and dad dole-ing (sp? p_p_?) out the allowance no matter how good or bad you've been or whether or not you've done your chores.
 
As I understand it, libertarians believe in limited government.

Anarchists believe in none.

Thrill, can I steal your sig line? j/k
 
I'm actually surprised the Libertarians don't have a stronger presence in our political system. They seem to believe in the purest form a government. Then again it does make sense why the current parties are in power. The party of the Dolist and the party of the Rich and Big Business.

But, Libertarians are definitely NOT similar to anarchists. They believe in the purest form of a constitutional government.
 
Our system is based on a mutual, or symbiotic, bribery between the pols and the people.

Libertarians believe this should end, but ain't no one in this mob giving up a cut of their swag...
 
Any government not deviating from it's constitution...?

"What a load of crap...
Like that's ever going to happen!"
 
First of all - NEVER WHISTLE WHILE YOU'RE PISSING.

Let's talk REAL Libertarianism, rather than the watered down bastardization propounded by the Libertarian party.

Human society can be structured either according to the principle of authority or according to the principle of liberty. Authority is a static social configuration in which people act as superiors and inferiors: a sado- masochistic relationship. Liberty is a dynamic social configuration in which people act as equals: an erotic relationship. In every interaction between people, either Authority or Liberty is the dominant factor. Families, churches, lodges, clubs and corporations are either more authoritarian than libertarian or more libertarian than authoritarian. It becomes obvious as we proceed that the most pugnacious and intolerant form of authority is the State, which even today dares to assume absolutism which the church itself has long ago surrendered and to enforce obedience with the Church's old and shameful Inquisition. Every form of authoritarianism is, however, a small "State," even if it has a membership of only two. Freud's remark to the effect that the delusion of many men is religion can be generalized: The authoritarianism of one man is crime and the authoritarianism of many is State.

Benjamin Tucker wrote quite accurately:

"Aggression is simply another name for government. Aggression, invasion, government are interchangeable terms. The essence of government is control, or the attempt to control. He who attempts to control another is a governor, an aggressor, an invader; and the nature of such invasion is not changed, whether it be made by one man upon another man, after the manner of the ordinary criminal, or by one man upon all other men, after the manner of an absolute monarch, or by all other men upon one man, after the manner of a modern democracy."

Tucker's use of the word "invasion" is remarkably precise, considering that he wrote more than fifty years before the basic discovery of ethology. Every act of authority is, in fact, an invasion of the psychic and physical territory of another.

If authority implies submission, liberation implies equality; authority exist when one person obeys another, and liberty exists when people do not obey other people. Thus, to say that authority exists is to say that class and caste exis, that submission and inequality exist. To say the liberty exists is to that classlessness exists, to say that brotherhood and equality exist. Authority, by dividing people into classes, creates dichotomy, disruption, hostility, fear, disunion. Liberty, by placing people on an equal footing, creates association, amalgamation, union, security. When the relationships between people are based on authority and coercion, they are driven apart; when based on liberty and non-aggression, they are drawn together. The facts are self-evident and axiomatic. If authoritarianism did not possess the in-built, preprogrammed double-bind structure of a Game Without End, people would long ago have rejected it and embraced libertarianism.
 
Well said, Dillinger! Of curiosity, what do you see as the moral/philosophical value system most closely apropos to the libertarian ideas you note?

To answer simply, Libertarians see government as the means of protecting the individual's rights. There is no other legitimate purpose for government.

As stated in the Preamble to the Constitution:
. . . and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
You should note that the Constitution places explicit limits on the authority of government. It does not limit the freedom of the citizens. It's purpose was to keep the loathsome burden of tyrannical government from becoming once again the oppressor as has been typical throughout mankind's history.

The government defined by our Constitution and as envisioned by Libertarians creates an orderly society under the principle of self-governance in the main. Government should become involved only when the rights of a citizen are violated which is the act of the criminal.

Anarchy on the other hand is essentially a chaotic society with no rules except survival of the fittest in which the most murderous thug enjoys a morally equal status with the honest citrizen or businessman.
Originally posted by ScarlettRose
Purest being what? The most literal translation?
Presuming you are referring to the Constitution, there is no translation required. It is written in clear, definitive terms. There are specific powers consigned to the Federal government and there exists no legitimate authority for those limits to be exceeded.

If you read the Constitution, it is quite clear what those powers are and which branch of government is assigned those powers.

The men who wrote that document purposefully wrote it in clear and unambiguous terms for the specific purpose that the people could read and understand it without the need for some arbitrary authority's interpretation.

Read the Federalist Papers, a collections of writings of these same men, in which they explain their ruminations in the process of composing the Constitution and the considerations of various kinds regarding the assignment of powers and the separation of same and you can come to a very good understanding of the scope, purpose and structure of the Federal government as they designed it.

They had very clear and cogent reasons for making the decisions they did. Their entire motivation was to protect the freedom of the individual, particularly from government, because they understood that government is the most prevalent threat to mankind's freedom.

And if you look closely today, it is obvious that they were very perceptive and accurate in that surmise.

Look carefully at the clarity with which the Constitution is written and then look at the ever more complex, labyrinthine and vague legislation that has been produced by Congress over the past 150 years. The difference is striking.

The purpose of the writers of the Constitution was clarity easily understood by the citizen governed by it. The legislation produced today is written by and for lawyers. It for the most part is written in complex and vague terms virtually defying understanding of the common man.

I frankly have difficulty believeing that the intent of those creating such laws is honorable if they wish me to not understand the laws by which I am to be governed.

Here's a link to the Declaration of Independence: http://www.archives.gov/exhibit_hall/charters_of_freedom/declaration/declaration_transcription.html

Here's a link to the Constitution: http://www.archives.gov/exhibit_hal.../constitution/constitution_transcription.html

And the Federalist papers: http://www.law.ou.edu/hist/federalist/
 
Unclebill said:
Well said, Dillinger! Of curiosity, what do you see as the moral/philosophical value system most closely apropos to the libertarian ideas you note?

Natural Law as the framework for the original concepts behind Libertarianism and the philosophy of the Framers of the US Constitution.

The concept of Natural Law and its integration with constitutionalism was fundamental to the political philosophy of Henry Bracton, whose (Latin language) document On the Laws and Customs of England written some 30 years after the Magna Carta, the Great Charter of 1215, is one of the oldest systematic treatises on English Common Law.

Many of the Framers of the US Constitution felt that Liberty should be more specifically defined and protected. Among them was Richard Henry Lee of Virginia, who argued that the Constitution as it stood directly after its adoption would "put Civil Liberty and happiness of the people at the mercy of Rulers who may possess the great unguarded powers given."

He demanded such amendments "as will give security to the just rights of human nature, and better secure from injury the discordant interests of the different parts of this Union." The result was the first ten Amendments, collectively known as the Bill of Rights which set specific bounds on the range and extent of law.

The significance of the Bill of Rights, as with similar constitutional limitations on government activity, lies in its recognition of a higher law endowing mankind with certain fundamental rights and liberties to which even elected legislatures must defer.

Acceptance of a higher, natural law requires that "... the legislator who formulates laws is a priest of justice, the practitioner of a true philosophy, not a pretender to an imitation. Natural Law meant interpretation in the light of such conceptions as equality before the law, faithfulness to engagements, fair dealing or equity."

George H. Sabine: A History Of Political Theory

Check out http://libertariannation.org

And specifically:

http://libertariannation.org/a/f42l1.html
 
Interesting reading, indeed

In reading a few of the passages referenced, I see some similarities between Locke's ideas and those of Ayn Rand's Objectivism.

Thus far, the major difference I see is his refers mostly to the realm of law and commerce while her endeavors were vastly more widely integrated into human endeavors of every nature including even art, love, romance, and sex.

Locke's references to lex mercatoria smack heavily of the capitalist economic system which is by nature a self-regulating, self-cleansing system and much more responsive that the governmental regulatory agencies' heavy but inertia-bound hand.

I find it an interesting parallel that the more stringent the governmental controls and reglatory influence over the business community, the more frequent and calamitous the incidents like Enron, Worldcom, et al, which the government regulators never seem to nip in the bud. In fact, it is frequently the regulatory red tape and frequently political intervention that inhibits normal market forces (or government regulators, recall the Keating Five; Cranston, McCain, Diminici, Glenn, and ?) from purging these diseased portions of the body economic before the infection becomes serious, e. g., Global Crossing, Enron, Worldcom, etc.

I can only wonder what this latest crop of bureaucratic red tape is going to bring about in terms of future debacles. They certainly do nothing to punish the people who perpetrated the current crop of frauds. There are already more than enough laws to deal with the criminal actions involved and the rush to create more laws is nothing but politicians trying to appear efficacious in some manner, Bush included.
 
This is how you turn around the system...

At their own game!

A Georgia businesswoman and longtime Libertarian activist has agreed to challenge U.S. Rep. Bob Barr for his seat in Congress, creating a "two-pronged attack" intended to help unseat the four-term incumbent.

On July 23, Carole Ann Rand, the chair of the board of directors of the Advocates for Self-Government, announced that she will campaign against Barr to represent Georgia's seventh district in the U.S. House.

By focusing on the issue of medical marijuana, Rand will try to cause Barr -- widely considered the most fanatical Drug Warrior in Congress -- to lose in the Republican primary election on August 20, said LP Political Director Ron Crickenberger.

In an unprecedented move for a Libertarian candidate, Rand is already planning to run a flurry of pre-primary television advertisements attacking Barr for his stance on medical marijuana. The ads are tentatively scheduled to begin running about two weeks prior to the election.

Crickenberger, who is also serving as Rand's campaign consultant, said he was "extremely pleased" that Rand agreed to take on Barr.

"We had about a dozen Libertarians volunteer to run against Barr, but Carole Ann was my top choice," he said. "Not only does she have a long history of libertarian activism, but she is a wonderful communicator of libertarian ideas as well."

Rand is running as part of the Libertarian Party's "Incumbent Killer Strategy," which targets the worst Drug Warriors in Congress for defeat. The strategy is one component of the party's plan to end federal Drug Prohibition by 2010.

That's why Rand's signature issue will be medical marijuana, said Crickenberger. A staunch social conservative, Barr opposes decriminalizing marijuana even for patients who have a doctor's prescription.

Furthermore, Barr pushed three amendments through Congress to prevent voters in Washington, DC from approving medical marijuana initiatives. He also has been a vocal cheerleader of federal raids on medical marijuana clinics in states where medical use of the drug has been legalized.

Meanwhile, Rand's professional credentials -- including her current position as the chief financial officer for Food Partners, a wholesale food brokerage company -- make her an "ideal candidate" to run on the Drug Prohibition issue, said Crickenberger.

"Carole Ann is a professional businesswoman and a person of great integrity and character," he said. "It is impossible to caricature her as a stereotypical dope-smoker."

Rand said she is eager to call attention in her campaign to how "out of touch" Barr is on the medical marijuana issue.

"To arrest and jail people who are just trying to relieve their pain and treat their diseases is the true crime involved in medical marijuana," she said. "We must replace our policy of handcuffs for patients with a policy of compassion and understanding."

Currently, Barr is in a hotly contested primary battle with fellow Republican Congressman John Linder. Both are incumbents, but are facing each other in a GOP primary because of redistricting.

Although Linder previously boasted on his website that the Libertarian Party endorsed him for re-election, Crickenberger said the party has done no such thing.

"Targeting Bob Barr for defeat in no way means the party endorses John Linder," he said. "Obviously, we are endorsing our own candidate in this election."

Crickenberger said there is one potential obstacle to Rand's campaign: Given the onerous ballot access requirements in Georgia, it may be difficult to qualify her for the ballot for the November general election.

State law requires about 16,000 valid petition signatures from one Congressional district to place a candidate on the ballot.

However, at least three lawsuits have been filed to overturn the law on Constitutional ground, or to reduce the signature requirement or postpone the deadline because of delays in the redistricting process, said Crickenberger.

But getting Rand's name on the November ballot is not the main concern at this point, said Crickenberger -- since Rand can start running TV ads even before her ballot status has been confirmed.

"We aim to hammer Bob Barr with the medical marijuana issue and cause him to lose the primary election [on August 20]," he said. "If Barr loses the primary, whether or not Carole Ann is on the ballot, we will have achieved our main goal."

If Rand does qualify for the ballot and Barr wins his primary, the focus will shift to trying to cause the Congressman to lose the November general election, said Crickenberger.

"We have two opportunities to retire Barr, and we're prepared to take advantage of both of them," he said.

The footage for Rand's first TV commercial has already been shot, and features a medical marijuana patient with multiple sclerosis who can barely move or speak, said Crickenberger.

"This woman takes marijuana to ease her chronic pain and to allow for more flexibility in her limbs," he said. "It will be a very emotionally stirring commercial."

Barr is the first politician to be targeted in the LP's so-called Incumbent Killer Strategy. Also targeted for defeat are U.S. Rep. Henry Bonilla (R-TX), Senator Max Cleland (D-GA), Senator Tim Hutchison (R-AR), and Senator Max Baucus (D-MT).

The strategy of focusing on the War on Drugs as a "wedge" issue is one of 20 political strategies incorporated in the LP's comprehensive Strategic Plan, which was approved by the Libertarian National Committee in 2001.

In 1990, Rand became the first woman in Georgia history to run for governor. Her Libertarian campaign won over 37,000 votes, earning the party ballot status at that time.

Rand is also a former president of the Advocates for Self-Government, and a past member of its board of directors. She is married, and has four children and eight grandchildren.

For more information about Carole Ann Rand, medical marijuana, Bob Barr's record, or to make a contribution, visit: www.randforcongress.com.


:D
 
Re: Interesting reading, indeed

Unclebill said:
In reading a few of the passages referenced, I see some similarities between Locke's ideas and those of Ayn Rand's Objectivism.

Personally I think Ayn Rand got lost somewhere along the way. I don't think she was a Libertarian.

Locke expounded on a political philosophy. Rand had a philosophic system. The application is not necessary appropriate in both circumstances.

Most Americans are better versed in the political and economic premises of Vladimir Lenin and Adolph Hitler than in those of Thomas Jefferson and George Washington.

Locke argued that each individual possesses the rights to life, liberty and property, that these rights exist in nature prior to the formation of government, and that the only legitimate government is one whose function is limited to protecting these rights. Rand argued that man's essential nature is to use his reason to produce the values on which his life depends, which in turn requires a government whose function is strictly limited to protecting him from the initiation of physical force by other men. Locke's ideas were the basis for The Declaration of Independence and the Constitution the United States.

Complicating matters for most people is the prevalence in the culture of the antithetical moral, political, and economic ideas of Jean Jacques Rousseau, Immanuel Kant, G. W. F. Hegel, and Karl Marx. (Just as Locke's ideas provided the intellectual foundation for the relatively free governments of the 19th century, such as England and the United States, the ideas of Rousseau, Kant, Hegel and Marx provided the intellectual foundation for the totalitarian governments of the 20th century, such as Nazi Germany and Communist Russia.)

People in this country (the US) would do well to become acquainted with the intellectual case for political freedom.

Second Treatise on Government
by John Locke (1690) http://libertyonline.hypermall.com/Locke/Default.htm

"Reason... teaches all Mankind, who would but consult it, that being all
equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his Life, Health, Liberty, or Possessions.

Knowing precisely what our words stand for would...in many cases...end the dispute."


-- John Locke (1632-1704)

http://www.island-of-freedom.com/LOCKE.HTM
 
Last edited:
Re: This is how you turn around the system...

Lost Cause said:
At their own game!

A Georgia businesswoman and longtime Libertarian activist has agreed to challenge U.S. Rep. Bob Barr for his seat in Congress, creating a "two-pronged attack" intended to help unseat the four-term incumbent.

On July 23, Carole Ann Rand, the chair of the board of directors of the Advocates for Self-Government, announced that she will campaign against Barr to represent Georgia's seventh district in the U.S. House.

By focusing on the issue of medical marijuana, Rand will try to cause Barr -- widely considered the most fanatical Drug Warrior in Congress -- to lose in the Republican primary election on August 20, said LP Political Director Ron Crickenberger.

In an unprecedented move for a Libertarian candidate, Rand is already planning to run a flurry of pre-primary television advertisements attacking Barr for his stance on medical marijuana. The ads are tentatively scheduled to begin running about two weeks prior to the election.


Barr is the first politician to be targeted in the LP's so-called Incumbent Killer Strategy. Also targeted for defeat are U.S. Rep. Henry Bonilla (R-TX), Senator Max Cleland (D-GA), Senator Tim Hutchison (R-AR), and Senator Max Baucus (D-MT).

For more information about Carole Ann Rand, medical marijuana, Bob Barr's record, or to make a contribution, visit: www.randforcongress.com.


:D

I live in this district. John Linder is an incumbent. The Democratic Georgia House redrew the districts to pit two incumbent Republican Congressmen against each other. If Bob Barr loses in the primary, it will be because the majority of the Republicans in the district prefer John Linder to continue representing the district in Congress, NOT because of anything this woman has done.
 
Re: Re: This is how you turn around the system...

morninggirl5 said:


I live in this district. John Linder is an incumbent. The Democratic Georgia House redrew the districts to pit two incumbent Republican Congressmen against each other. If Bob Barr loses in the primary, it will be because the majority of the Republicans in the district prefer John Linder to continue representing the district in Congress, NOT because of anything this woman has done.

We live in the same district, MG.

Bob Barr is a conservative in the classic sense, which is why I'll never vote for him. His stance on medical marijuana use is nothing less than Neanderthal. He believes in using the force of government to control women's bodies, what we read, and what we do in our bedrooms. He can kiss my ass.

Linder has some potential. He's a strong proponent of a National Sales Tax. But I have personal issues with him going back a couple of years ago. I contacted his office four times for what they call "constituent services," and didn't get a response until a couple of months later. His job is to represent his constituents - me - and he failed. Sen. Cleland's office cut through red tape for me in two days.
 
Dillinger, I'm curious about this:

When the relationships between people are based on authority and coercion, they are driven apart; when based on liberty and non-aggression, they are drawn together. The facts are self-evident and axiomatic. If authoritarianism did not possess the in-built, preprogrammed double-bind structure of a Game Without End, people would long ago have rejected it and embraced libertarianism.

Expound, please.
 
Sandia said:
Dillinger, I'm curious about this:

When the relationships between people are based on authority and coercion, they are driven apart; when based on liberty and non-aggression, they are drawn together. The facts are self-evident and axiomatic. If authoritarianism did not possess the in-built, preprogrammed double-bind structure of a Game Without End, people would long ago have rejected it and embraced libertarianism.

Expound, please.

The "Game" of authoritarianism perpetuates itself. Once you buy into it, its a closed loop - it doesn't show the open door to freedom.

No trust is ever built by forcing people to do things. By forcing them to follow laws they may or may not believe in. We might follow them because the consequences are not worth the risk, but we ultimately resent having to do so.

Embrasing liberty we accept the idea that people are free to do whatever they choose, as long as they hurt no one. They're even welcome to hurt themselves - just no one else without permissing. Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the law (Aleister Crowley). Non-aggression is the 2nd half of the equations. Agression, in my mind, equaling violence toward others. This violence need not be physical - it can be emotional. It can be intellectual. By denying anyone the right to do what they want, you are perpetuating an injustice - indeed, you are inflicting violence on them.
 
Dillinger said:


The "Game" of authoritarianism perpetuates itself. Once you buy into it, its a closed loop - it doesn't show the open door to freedom.

No trust is ever built by forcing people to do things. By forcing them to follow laws they may or may not believe in. We might follow them because the consequences are not worth the risk, but we ultimately resent having to do so.

Embrasing liberty we accept the idea that people are free to do whatever they choose, as long as they hurt no one. They're even welcome to hurt themselves - just no one else without permissing. Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the law (Aleister Crowley). Non-aggression is the 2nd half of the equations. Agression, in my mind, equaling violence toward others. This violence need not be physical - it can be emotional. It can be intellectual. By denying anyone the right to do what they want, you are perpetuating an injustice - indeed, you are inflicting violence on them.

Damn, what did I get myself into? I stumbled through all that, and here, finally, I think I get it. I definitely have Libertarian leanings, except for one issue: gun control. I don't believe that everyone should be forced to give up their guns; the cat's out of the bag, as it were. But I definitely wouldn't be upset if one day all the guns disappeared. I can see the Libertarian argument: "Anyone can own a gun as long as they don't use it on someone else." With that argument, why couldn't Joe Average Citizen own C4, dynamite, ICBMs, NBC weapons, etc.? Freedom is a wonderful thing, but there are a lot of bad people out there.
 
Re: Re: Interesting reading, indeed

Originally posted by Dillinger
Personally I think Ayn Rand got lost somewhere along the way. I don't think she was a Libertarian. . .
Rand was not politically active that I'm aware during her lifetime beyond understanding the principles of government as they pertained to men free or otherwise. But the philosophy she developed is the perfect moral and intellectual basis for Libertarianism.

She wrote a beautiful treatise explaining why the Soviet Chess Masters would virtually always triumph over an American opponent on the chess board.
Originally posted by Dillinger
. . . Most Americans are better versed in the political and economic premises of Vladimir Lenin and Adolph Hitler than in those of Thomas Jefferson and George Washington.
Sadly, that's all too true and a shameful indictment of the public education system which is more appropriately a public indoctrination system. I'll wager REDWAVE is a product ot the public school system.

Have you read Frederic Bastiat's The Law? If not, I recommend it.
 
Very well said all. I'll not attempt to add much, as I think the question has been answered. But Thrillhouse, remember to distinguish between philosophy and a political platform.

I've always seen the Libertarian party's biggest strength in that one can subscribe to the philosophy and NOT necessarily the 'platform' Whereas for a Democrat or Republican to come out against one of the big issues of their party it would be political suicide. And I think we all know examples of those 'moderates' that never seem to go very far.

All I know for sure is for the past 200 years Legislature has done little else than ADD laws. Maybe it's time to spend a year or two taking a few away?
 
Re: Re: Re: Interesting reading, indeed

Unclebill said:


Have you read Frederic Bastiat's The Law? If not, I recommend it.

I haven't - I don't suppose you know if its available online?
 
Oh, Libertarians. I thought you had said Librarians. Ook. Anyone got a banana?
 
Back
Top