Affluenza

The military freedom point of view?

Poorly phrased I grant you. :D

While it's not entirely true we are often sold that the 2nd Amendment is about keeping Americans free from a government/military take over the United States right?

Well I live in the modern world there are much more effective things the government could do to shut me down if they wanted than taking away my guns. I don't grow my own food or pump my own water. Granted I live in SoCal so I don't need to cut trees to burn in the winter but I presume the American North East could easily be quite fatal if the government decided to kill the power for an extended period of time.

I just imagine that a lot of these things weren't included in any formal way during the Founding Fathers because they either A didn't exist yet or B were the kinds of things that were so obviously human rights that they didn't need to be mentioned. Like (and feel free to point out that I'm wrong) owning a horse (transportation and labor) isn't something any ancient ruler would dream of taking away. Today however you have to earn the privelege to operate a car.
 
I saw these headlines on TV in a bar where there was no volume or subtitles. I assumed the "affluenza" they were refering to had to do with some form of bird flu contracted from the Aflac duck. I was kind of laughing at the kid for being so dumb as to get close enough to a bird that he contracted an illness.

Now that I know it's because he was overly rich I truly feel bad for him. I mean his over privilege should certainly be an excuse for not being punished for a crime. It's completely his parents fault. Just like kids from poor families who turn to dealing drugs to make ends meet. Instead of being sent to jail they all end up in 450k rehab facilities in California where Lindsay Lohan is sure to appear to perform oral sex on them. Maybe even some penetration, who knows.
 
He is old enough to know drinking and driving is dangerous and illegal.
He got behind the wheel of a car and drove drunk and killed innocent people.

He made the choices he did and should face the consequences.

A least once a week there is a news story like this where a teenager
decided to drink and drive or hoon around and caused an accident that was
of their making.

Bleeding hearts say;
"Awww poor teenager will have to live with this the rest of their lives. Lets go easy on them."

What about setting the precedent that if you do something really dangerous
like drink/drive and maim someone or even worse kill them then you will not be dealt with leniently by a Judge or the court.

If you want to try and punish and then rehabilitate a teenager who drives drunk and kills someone then perhaps the answer is to put them in a minimum security prison with inmates who have done similar crimes. Give them intense therapy, work programs, education and have them go through restorative justice programs. Encourage them to want to do the right thing and make better choices.

Let the families of the drunk drivers victim see that the teenager is facing the consequences of their behaviour. Allow the families or victims to have a voice and the teenager has to personally front up to the family and see what they have done.

Then put the teenager before a parole type board and assess how they have behaved in minimum security and where they are in their journey towards becoming a productive member of society. Have programs in place to ease them back into society with job opportunities or further study.

If the teenagers do not face and deal with what they have done then they are more likely to repeat what they did wrong. Being talked at by a therapist and molly coddled because your parents are well off and you feel entitled is a slap in the face to the victims and their families.

Being rich is not a get out of jail free card. You cannot kill someone, throw money at their family and say;

"All better now."
 
Frankly. I think the kid got off easy. Four people died for God's sake. They even stole the beer. I think he should have been tried as an adult and given at least five years hard time and ten years probation.

For this miscarriage of justice, the judge should probably be impeached and removed from office.

This raises an interesting question, should punishment be based on the crime committed (reckless driving in this case) or the unintended consequence of the crime (vehicular manslaughter in this case).




Vettebottom is very defensive today. He loves his man.
:rolleyes:
Don't worry, you will never be a man. :D
:rolleyes:

Both of you need fresh material.
 
He is old enough to know drinking and driving is dangerous and illegal.
He got behind the wheel of a car and drove drunk and killed innocent people.

He made the choices he did and should face the consequences.

A least once a week there is a news story like this where a teenager
decided to drink and drive or hoon around and caused an accident that was
of their making.

Bleeding hearts say;
"Awww poor teenager will have to live with this the rest of their lives. Lets go easy on them."

What about setting the precedent that if you do something really dangerous
like drink/drive and maim someone or even worse kill them then you will not be dealt with leniently by a Judge or the court.

If you want to try and punish and then rehabilitate a teenager who drives drunk and kills someone then perhaps the answer is to put them in a minimum security prison with inmates who have done similar crimes. Give them intense therapy, work programs, education and have them go through restorative justice programs. Encourage them to want to do the right thing and make better choices.

Let the families of the drunk drivers victim see that the teenager is facing the consequences of their behaviour. Allow the families or victims to have a voice and the teenager has to personally front up to the family and see what they have done.

Then put the teenager before a parole type board and assess how they have behaved in minimum security and where they are in their journey towards becoming a productive member of society. Have programs in place to ease them back into society with job opportunities or further study.

If the teenagers do not face and deal with what they have done then they are more likely to repeat what they did wrong. Being talked at by a therapist and molly coddled because your parents are well off and you feel entitled is a slap in the face to the victims and their families.

Being rich is not a get out of jail free card. You cannot kill someone, throw money at their family and say;

"All better now."

I say force them to undergo training as assistants for rehabilitation centres where they will be forced to face, and interact with, accident victims just like the ones they caused. Make it a condition of their jail time.... if they don't do the course it's a mandatory 15 years jail. If they do the course and agree to work in a high-dependency facility, they get out in 5 years... but have to serve the remaining 10 working there (use ankle-trackers to restrict their movements.)
 
I say force them to undergo training as assistants for rehabilitation centres where they will be forced to face, and interact with, accident victims just like the ones they caused. Make it a condition of their jail time.... if they don't do the course it's a mandatory 15 years jail. If they do the course and agree to work in a high-dependency facility, they get out in 5 years... but have to serve the remaining 10 working there (use ankle-trackers to restrict their movements.)
I'd prefer hard time in a bare cell

but for the people who spout the rehabiliation mantra, your idea has a lot of merit
 
I'd prefer hard time in a bare cell

but for the people who spout the rehabiliation mantra, your idea has a lot of merit

Sadly, it'll never happen.
The 'do-gooder' bunch of soft idiots will cry 'FOUL!', because it infringes on the rights of the criminal to choose his/her own future.
:rolleyes:
 
America is weird like that. Haven't you seen any high school set movies or tv-series from the US? All the cool kids have wheels.

What's "weird" about letting a 16 year old get a driver's license? The problem isn't that he was driving, it was that he was drinking and driving (and that he had never had to face the consequences of his actions before this).
 
Sadly, it'll never happen.
The 'do-gooder' bunch of soft idiots will cry 'FOUL!', because it infringes on the rights of the criminal to choose his/her own future.
:rolleyes:

The other thing that some people don't think of is if this young man gets off for the most part scot free then he is probably likely to do it again.

Why wouldn't he? It was probably fun being a bad boy stealing and drink driving. Especially when Mummy and Daddy foot the bill and he gets to sit on his butt nodding and saying the right thing in therapy till he can get what he wants.

Nip this behaviour and the affluenza defence in the butt. Before it flourishes and spreads like wildfire.


Another rich boy who's parents tried to cover up what he did.

A 'spoilt, jealous mummy's boy' who throttled his model girlfriend before his parents tried to cover it up smashed his victim's head against a table in the 24 hours before he murdered her, it was revealed today.

Her murderer had enjoyed a privileged life where his parents denied him nothing.

Turner had been educated at a £12,000 private school, and as an adult would carry up to £1,000 cash on him to 'show off'.

His arrogance was such that even his own defence lawyer was forced to describe him as 'brash, flash, boastful, spoilt, volatile, obsessive, possessive and obsessed'. He will serve a minimum of 16 years."


http://www.nzherald.co.nz/crime/news/article.cfm?c_id=30&objectid=11171968
 
I'd prefer hard time in a bare cell

but for the people who spout the rehabiliation mantra, your idea has a lot of merit

It couldn't hurt.

Sadly, it'll never happen.
The 'do-gooder' bunch of soft idiots will cry 'FOUL!', because it infringes on the rights of the criminal to choose his/her own future.
:rolleyes:

Because it's pointless, stupid, expensive. If you feel that strongly about it put a bullet in his head and lets move along.
 
Because it's pointless, stupid, expensive. If you feel that strongly about it put a bullet in his head and lets move along.

His parents have money. The court could order they pay any of his expenses since they were part of creating his delinquency.

Or we could be clever and create private prisons funded by rich Mummies and Daddies for their naughty offspring to have time out in.

I would put my money where my outrage is and send a donation towards
building some stocks for hours of fun with the pelt the spoiled brats parents with soft fruit game.



Or a shame board where the teen wears an appropriate sign and walks the streets. They could get sponsors to pay for advertising space and give the money to charity.

;)
 
His parents have money. The court could order they pay any of his expenses since they were part of creating his delinquency.

Or we could be clever and create private prisons funded by rich Mummies and Daddies for their naughty offspring to have time out in.

I would put my money where my outrage is and send a donation towards
building some stocks for hours of fun with the pelt the spoiled brats parents with soft fruit game.



Or a shame board where the teen wears an appropriate sign and walks the streets. They could get sponsors to pay for advertising space and give the money to charity.

;)

It actually states in the originally referenced article that the court DID order that he be removed from his parents and that they pay for him to live elsewhere for treatment.

.. should probably throw the parents in jail for financially enabling him to disregard previous concerns..

when you remove the money from the situation - this garbage is seen all over. Parents who refuse to parent. The cash kind of warps the view on this one because it became an attempted defense.. Seriously though - how F'd up are these parents
 
The problem with that is at most you could force the parents to pay until he was an adult, then they'd magically disown him and when/if he got out magically find him again as well. If you have mechanics in place for parental alimony until the children make enough money to support themselves or something similar go with it but we don't.

Same problem for those private prisons, who's gonna fund them? Especially since they'd never fill up since the rich are more likely to dodge even with out crazy bullshit like this. There are plenty of times where people get off because they should and the reason a poor person wouldn't get off isn't really because of a broken system (well it is) but because they can't afford quality defense and instead get stuck with someone who couldn't get a real job.

It doesn't sound like a workable plan.
 
.. should probably throw the parents in jail for financially enabling him to disregard previous concerns..
Seriously though - how F'd up are these parents

I bet if you interview them they would say they loved their son and they wanted to give him everything.

"His family felt their wealth brought privilege. He learned at home never to apologize if he hurt someone but to send money, he said."



Nothing says you're sorry like a pocketful of cash. :(

Except money cannot bring back the people who were killed.
Money cannot fix brain damage or heal paralyzed limbs.

If you love your children you don't give them everything, you love and discipline them. Teach them about right and wrong. You give them rules, boundaries and consequences when they screw up.


You encourage them to do the right thing and you are a role model for them.

"Earlier Tuesday, a psychologist testified that the teen essentially raised himself. His parents had a volatile and co-dependent relationship, and had a contentious divorce, said Gary Miller, who began evaluating the teen on the day he was released from a hospital after the wreck.

The parents argued often, which the teen witnessed, Miller said. The teen’s father “does not have relationships, he takes hostages,” Miller said.

Miller described the mother as a desperate woman who used her son as a tool to get her husband to act the way she wanted. The mother gave the teen things, Miller said. “Her mantra was that if it feels good, do it,” Miller said.

The teen’s intellectual age was 18, but his emotional age was 12, Miller told Boyd. “The teen never learned to say that you’re sorry if you hurt someone,” Miller said. “If you hurt someone, you sent him money.”

http://dallasmorningviewsblog.dalla...-actions-dont-have-to-have-consequences.html/


http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/affluenza-defense-earns-ethan-couch-probation-in-fatal-dui-1.2462273

"Dr. Suniya Luthar, a psychologist who specializes in the costs of affluence in suburban communities, said her research at Columbia University in New York has shown that 20 percent of upper middle-class adolescents believe their parents would help them get out of a sticky situation at school, such as being caught for the third time on campus with a bottle of vodka. Boyd's sentence reinforces that belief.

"What is the likelihood if this was an African-American, inner-city kid that grew up in a violent neighbourhood to a single mother who is addicted to crack and he was caught two or three times ... what is the likelihood that the judge would excuse his behaviour and let him off because of how he was raised?" Luthar asked.

"We are setting a double standard for the rich and poor," she added, noting the message is "families that have money, you can drink and drive. This is a very, very dangerous thing we're telling our children."
 
To be fair by any fair estimation it's hard to really call this poor parenting. I mean isn't the job of a parent to prepare a child to live in the world? If we've learned nothing else from Lindsey Lohan, Charlie Sheen, OJ Simpson and this kid it's that the rules don't apply if you're rich. He is in fact rich. Teaching him to play by the rules would make the same amount of sense as teaching me how to field dress a deer to keep from starving or how to shoe a horse or evade a pack solves.
 
I believe that one of the identified problems with "affluenza" is that children are being given the impression that they can get out of any kind of trouble. If it's not up to the parents to squash that attitude, then who? I know plenty of children who have grown up in wealthy families and have managed to be taught that there are consequences to their actions.
 
Poorly phrased I grant you. :D

While it's not entirely true we are often sold that the 2nd Amendment is about keeping Americans free from a government/military take over the United States right?

Well I live in the modern world there are much more effective things the government could do to shut me down if they wanted than taking away my guns. I don't grow my own food or pump my own water. Granted I live in SoCal so I don't need to cut trees to burn in the winter but I presume the American North East could easily be quite fatal if the government decided to kill the power for an extended period of time.

I just imagine that a lot of these things weren't included in any formal way during the Founding Fathers because they either A didn't exist yet or B were the kinds of things that were so obviously human rights that they didn't need to be mentioned. Like (and feel free to point out that I'm wrong) owning a horse (transportation and labor) isn't something any ancient ruler would dream of taking away. Today however you have to earn the privelege to operate a car.

According to Wiki: "As automobile-related fatalities soared in North America, public outcry provoked legislators to begin studying the French and German statutes as models.[5] On August 1, 1910, North America's first licensing law for motor vehicles went into effect in the U.S. state of New York, though it initially applied only to professional chauffeurs.[6] In July 1913, the state of New Jersey became the first to require all drivers to pass a mandatory examination before receiving a license.[7]"

Government licensing of motor vehicle operation was not an arbitrary infringement of one's right to move about freely. It was a response to a growing public health and safety issue. Had the negligent operation of a horse frequently resulted in a similar number of injuries and fatalities, there is no reason not to believe that the government would have been compelled to restrict the riding of domesticated animals.

The fact that government highly subsidizes public transportation systems (however inconvenient their usage may be in practice) aptly demonstrates governments' recognition of the importance of a mobile citizenry whether said recognition is motivated on legal, economic or a host of other interrelated considerations.
 
The judge was not necessarily wrong in giving little Ethan a light sentence. All sorts of considerations are appropriately involved in sentencing, although I personally find it difficult to justify in this case.

But she was out of her freaking mind for creating or even affirming the validity of a legal defense known as "affluenza."

She should have called it "assluenza" because that is clearly where she extracted it from.
 
i heard this on bbc ameroica this morning and i found it idiotic and offensive, but then the idiot commenting on the story said something about how the worst aspect of this case was that the kid stole the booze. at that point i very nearly lost it. it was way too early for something that fucking stupid. i just hope i misheard him in the early morning brain fog.
 
Are there not states where the parents can be held accountable for the criminal actions of minor children? Is Texas one of them? If so, while the poor spoiled worthless little piece of shit 16 year old goes to his vacation at the spa. Lets put Mommy and Daddy on trial and see how long we can sit their idiotic asses in prison. And no, I do not mean Camp Cupcake minimum security. We are talking about 4 DEAD PEOPLE AND 2 PERMANENTLY INJURED. Send them to at least medium security- along with the brain dead judge who let the kid off with essentially no punishment.

I am not sure what can be done to straighten out this country, but letting kids off of manslaughter x4 with a few years at rich kid camp is not going to be the answer.
 
According to Wiki: "As automobile-related fatalities soared in North America, public outcry provoked legislators to begin studying the French and German statutes as models.[5] On August 1, 1910, North America's first licensing law for motor vehicles went into effect in the U.S. state of New York, though it initially applied only to professional chauffeurs.[6] In July 1913, the state of New Jersey became the first to require all drivers to pass a mandatory examination before receiving a license.[7]"

Government licensing of motor vehicle operation was not an arbitrary infringement of one's right to move about freely. It was a response to a growing public health and safety issue. Had the negligent operation of a horse frequently resulted in a similar number of injuries and fatalities, there is no reason not to believe that the government would have been compelled to restrict the riding of domesticated animals.

The fact that government highly subsidizes public transportation systems (however inconvenient their usage may be in practice) aptly demonstrates governments' recognition of the importance of a mobile citizenry whether said recognition is motivated on legal, economic or a host of other interrelated considerations.

You know I like you a lot more when you're supporting my points than when you're tearing em down. :mad:

Though I would argue that still if the government were to decide to make a move against us denying us transportation would be a far more effective model with much quicker results than taking away our weapons. As people are fond of pointing out if you want someone dead bad enough you can cobble together some horrible shit with the stuff under your sink. Not a whole lot of people can cobble together a car or even a bike.
 
Are there not states where the parents can be held accountable for the criminal actions of minor children? Is Texas one of them? If so, while the poor spoiled worthless little piece of shit 16 year old goes to his vacation at the spa. Lets put Mommy and Daddy on trial and see how long we can sit their idiotic asses in prison. And no, I do not mean Camp Cupcake minimum security. We are talking about 4 DEAD PEOPLE AND 2 PERMANENTLY INJURED. Send them to at least medium security- along with the brain dead judge who let the kid off with essentially no punishment.

I am not sure what can be done to straighten out this country, but letting kids off of manslaughter x4 with a few years at rich kid camp is not going to be the answer.

A liberal social worker neighbor of mine buried her three children following their bouts of alcohol fueled misbehavior, much of it criminal. She defended them to the death. Its her and the cat now.
 
Back
Top