Sean Renaud
The West Coast Pop
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2004
- Posts
- 59,804
The military freedom point of view?
Poorly phrased I grant you.

While it's not entirely true we are often sold that the 2nd Amendment is about keeping Americans free from a government/military take over the United States right?
Well I live in the modern world there are much more effective things the government could do to shut me down if they wanted than taking away my guns. I don't grow my own food or pump my own water. Granted I live in SoCal so I don't need to cut trees to burn in the winter but I presume the American North East could easily be quite fatal if the government decided to kill the power for an extended period of time.
I just imagine that a lot of these things weren't included in any formal way during the Founding Fathers because they either A didn't exist yet or B were the kinds of things that were so obviously human rights that they didn't need to be mentioned. Like (and feel free to point out that I'm wrong) owning a horse (transportation and labor) isn't something any ancient ruler would dream of taking away. Today however you have to earn the privelege to operate a car.