AH Status: Preliminary Poll

AH Status: Preliminary Poll

  • Status quo

    Votes: 30 47.6%
  • Moderator moves all political material to newly established Politcal Subforum

    Votes: 21 33.3%
  • Leave AH as is; open a moderated AH Subforum

    Votes: 10 15.9%
  • Make AH subscription for current story contributors

    Votes: 11 17.5%
  • Combination of one or more of the above (explain)

    Votes: 1 1.6%
  • Other (explain)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No opinion

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    63
Considering this is Monday morning, how long is the duration of this poll before any numbers are tossed? And tossed to whom? And will a summary of comments/suggestions be passed along as well?
If not, then, what is the purpose?

It's completely open. It's not a decisive vote of anything. It's just writing on the wall for everyone to view (and perhaps to show just how big the group of complainers is). No need to pass it on. If Laurel isn't looking at it already, all the yammering is useless anyway. She'll do whatever she wants to do. As already has been noted, what she's done so far is to say "rots of ruck" about instituting any changes at all.

This isn't my vote against change. I'd change what is happening here if I owned the site. I don't.
 
YOU think it's fair. Why doesn't someone else get to start a poll then on what they think is fair? Maybe we can have everyone make up a poll based on what they think is fair. We can flood AH with polls, but the position wasn't yours to take. Personally, I wish this whole fucking mess would just stop, so we can get back to reading and posting comments on issues we're really interested in.

What does it matter whether it's fair or not?

It has zero authority. It's for curiosity or whatever else the thread maker chooses it's for.

This IS still a free forum, even though someone sent Laurel a PM and has proposed changes, those changes are not implemented yet.

ANY position is my right to take. Good Lord.

My main concern is that it'll only be seen by peole who don't have sr71plt on ignore and so the numbers are bound to be skewed.

But to tell the truth, Crimson's probably on ignore by some also. So who decides what's more valid and which one is more important and why we should give a damn in the first place?
 
Crimson, none of this answer is aimed at you. I know that you're doing what you think is best. I don't agree with you, but I respect you for the way you're handling it.

Thanks. Nice to know that some on the other side are not so blinded by their position that they can't be civil about it (and that's only aimed at those who have decided it's okay to attack my character because they don't agree).
 
So far the purpose is satire.

But if the numbers came streaming in for "Change" I'd take notice.

I don't think the majority wants change.

Silly me! I took him seriously!
And isn't change the only constant in the universe? Oh shit! Did I just go off topic?
 
But to tell the truth, Crimson's probably on ignore by some also. So who decides what's more valid and which one is more important and why we should give a damn in the first place?

I'm on ignore because I stated my opinion and didn't resort to personal attacks? :rolleyes: Okay then.
 
YOU think it's fair. Why doesn't someone else get to start a poll then on what they think is fair? Maybe we can have everyone make up a poll based on what they think is fair. We can flood AH with polls, but the position wasn't yours to take. Personally, I wish this whole fucking mess would just stop, so we can get back to reading and posting comments on issues we're really interested in.

You haven't pointed out where it's unfair, Lance. You've been invited to do so.

And, yes, by all means put up any poll you want to too. That's quite acceptable in today's AH.
 
Silly me! I took him seriously!
And isn't change the only constant in the universe? Oh shit! Did I just go off topic?

Taking things seriously. Biiiiig mistake.

I'll let you go this time.

But I take bribes. And I can send a PM to Laurel aaaany time I want. I've got my eye on you.

*does the two fingers to two eyeballs thing back and forth*
 
Excuse me? It permits multiple choice and full discussion.

What I disagree with Crim on is that she's still stuck back in the "no way" zone--and is being bullheaded. This is the third time this stuff has come up on the board that I can recall. Each time I have flatly said I think the Web site should just erase whatever is offensive in its view. Each time we've had this same yammering which has become just as devisive as anything anyone is complaining about. Each time nothing happens. Crim's approach is dead at the gate. And yet she wants to prolong the nonsense.

I don't mind if something happens--I wouldn't slit my wrist over any of the options being implemented. I'd just like the devisive yammering to stop--until the next time someone creeps it in (which, under current AH rules is their right to do).

If Laurel is watching this, she can implement whatever she wants. She always could and never has. She has set amusingly impossible conditions this time around. If she's going to make any changes, she will.

Like I said, I think it's a pretty good poll. I happen to agree with pretty much everything you just said, except about Crim. I don't think it's nonsense and I don't think she's being any more bullheaded than anyone else in this discussion. And isn't 'divisive yammering' why this whole topic got started?

It might or might not be dead at the gate, but as it's a sincerely held concern that the AH is too hostile, it's not wrong of her to try to work towards an improvement.
 
I'm on ignore because I stated my opinion and didn't resort to personal attacks? :rolleyes: Okay then.

Crim, you're falling for the biggest debate fallacy in history.

You keep associating attacks on your argument with attacks on you. And then because you don't want to hear the reasoning, you ignore them. And then you wonder why people are blowing you off.

Maybe if you stopped the martyrdom mantra and listened, you'd realize this is NOT ABOUT YOU. It's about your proposed interference in OTHER PEOPLE'S LIVES.

So if you wish to be taken seriously as a debate person or someone who is listening, you should really get that knee-jerk sensitivity and oversensitivity handled before you attempt to moderate or be an authority over people who don't take any of this as seriously as you do.

You continue with the martyrdom personal attack thing, while you refuse to listen to people, tell us we're all uncooperative, and pretend that you're on some Blues Brothers mission from God.

You sent a PM because you're disgruntled and you can't find the damned ignore button. I have a right to think that's in turns pathetic and funny. Also ironically I can't ignore you right now because I'll miss the poll. I RESENT THIS.

I don't really care about you very much and I've never had much of an impression of you other than "Why isn't anybody listening to me!?" which is exactly what I'm seeing here.

You have my sympathy and I'm sorry that the universe put you in a bad mood and you're crabby.

But I think you should grow up.

That is not a personal "attack" - that is my opinion of how you're behaving. If you don't want to hear it or you can't deal with that in any mature manner, and so far all I see you doing is stomping your foot and saying we're NOT LISTENING! (again)

This is not new. This is not news. You being oversensitive is not new.

But I'll be damned if you whine so much that the AH changes because YOU take everything personally and can't distance yourself from a forum.

Clearer?

If you stop your ears and don't give a damn about what I say, GREAT. Ignore me. But do not, under any circumstances, put on any airs as if you speak for any majority, speak for me, or have the slightest bit of any authority other than Laurel gave you some damned busy work.

You've written off everything constructive I've tried to say and passed it off as if I'm just a big MEANIE.

So deal with your immaturity and if you want to BE a grownup, or be treated like one, ACT like one.

Damn.
 
And yet I've said repeatedly you are entitled to your opinion just like I am entitled to mine. I'm not doing this just for me, but everyone has focused their ranting at me because I'm the one who sent the pm and started the discussion. I know where the ignore button is, and I've used it and will continue to do so. And yes, there have been personal attacks on ME, not just my opinion. I'm not stupid. I can read.

You started off constructively, but you ended up being a bully. Your entire tirade just now is a good example of pot meet kettle. The only negative thing I said to YOU was that you were being ridiculous when you started with the one liners about stuff in the yard (or whatever the reference was to the homeowners situation.) The entire thread went off track, and I attempted to get it back on-track. You want to take that to mean that I feel like I'm on a mission from God, go ahead. I am not putting on any airs. Again, if you think I am, good for you. I.Don't.Care.

I know who I am, what kind of person I am, and YOU DON'T HAVE A CLUE. So render all the judgments you want about me and my behavior. Makes no never mind to me.
 
I believe that the “Authors’ Hangout” should be reserved for actual authors. There are plenty of other forums available where everyone else can post. Other than that, I don’t much care what my fellow authors want to talk about.

That being said, I sincerely doubt that TPTB will ever take the trouble to restrict posting on this particular forum to actual authors. But, now that I’m aware that some of the prolific posters here are not actually authors, I’ll take the time to check out the credentials of the other “Authors’ Hangout” posters that are unknown to me. If they don’t belong on this forum, I’ll simply ignore their threads and posts.
 
Tell me which one of these will make James the maddest and I'll vote for that one.
 
And yet I've said repeatedly you are entitled to your opinion just like I am entitled to mine. I'm not doing this just for me, but everyone has focused their ranting at me because I'm the one who sent the pm and started the discussion. I know where the ignore button is, and I've used it and will continue to do so. And yes, there have been personal attacks on ME, not just my opinion. I'm not stupid. I can read.

You started off constructively, but you ended up being a bully. Your entire tirade just now is a good example of pot meet kettle. The only negative thing I said to YOU was that you were being ridiculous when you started with the one liners about stuff in the yard (or whatever the reference was to the homeowners situation.) The entire thread went off track, and I attempted to get it back on-track. You want to take that to mean that I feel like I'm on a mission from God, go ahead. I am not putting on any airs. Again, if you think I am, good for you. I.Don't.Care.

I know who I am, what kind of person I am, and YOU DON'T HAVE A CLUE. So render all the judgments you want about me and my behavior. Makes no never mind to me.

Yes, you've had some personal attacks. And you've engaged in some of your own attacks on other people's judgment and character. While behaving like someone's hard-put upon mother.

But on the whole you have also entirely ignored anything you didn't want to hear.

I started off and continued the same way I always do. You didn't respond to my sub-forum comment or any of my serious contributions.

So if I'm clear and you understand that when I discuss my opinion about your proposed changes, they're about their effect on me.

This really is not about you. I stated what I did think about you so you're clear I'm not being timid or holding back, I'm not shy. I will tell you when you ask.

But these changes ARE as I characterize them in my world. And you have no respect in that or interest in that and you simply wish to be the martyred authority.

You want to make it be your way while pretending it's what Laurel wants. Laurel didn't approach you and ask you to do anything.

You've taken this upon yourself, so if you want to be an authority, I am disagreeing that you are qualified to do so.

You can think that's because I hate you or target you or we just spontaneously decided to do this because we're mean.

You might consider that in the middle of your not caring and being brave, and oh so strong, that some people do not care enough about YOU to attack you.

We care about what you're proposing.

So again, you can quit with how put upon you are and either listen and respond without some shrill mantra, dealing with people's concerns and issues, or you can do what you're doing and appear to be controlling and deaf to anybody else.

Your choice. But don't expect respect unless you earn it by behaving as a leader should.

I'm just rabble. I don't have to be responsible. But then I didn't send Laurel a PM either and take on some role I don't deserve.
 
I believe that the “Authors’ Hangout” should be reserved for actual authors. There are plenty of other forums available where everyone else can post. Other than that, I don’t much care what my fellow authors want to talk about.

That being said, I sincerely doubt that TPTB will ever take the trouble to restrict posting on this particular forum to actual authors. But, now that I’m aware that some of the prolific posters here are not actually authors, I’ll take the time to check out the credentials of the other “Authors’ Hangout” posters that are unknown to me. If they don’t belong on this forum, I’ll simply ignore their threads and posts.

I thought about that for a bit, having a place where only people who post stories can talk. But then lollipops will just make some 750 word nonsense submission and they'll have to be let in.
 
I thought about that for a bit, having a place where only people who post stories can talk. But then lollipops will just make some 750 word nonsense submission and they'll have to be let in.
True. But, at least, they'll have to do that much to get in. And, some of them will be too lazy to do even that.
 
Last edited:
I believe that the “Authors’ Hangout” should be reserved for actual authors. There are plenty of other forums available where everyone else can post. Other than that, I don’t much care what my fellow authors want to talk about.

That being said, I sincerely doubt that TPTB will ever take the trouble to restrict posting on this particular forum to actual authors. But, now that I’m aware that some of the prolific posters here are not actually authors, I’ll take the time to check out the credentials of the other “Authors’ Hangout” posters that are unknown to me. If they don’t belong on this forum, I’ll simply ignore their threads and posts.

Problem is that some prolific writers here post under and 'alt' to keep their story voting clean of writer/troll sabotage.
 
YOU think it's fair. Why doesn't someone else get to start a poll then on what they think is fair? Maybe we can have everyone make up a poll based on what they think is fair. We can flood AH with polls, but the position wasn't yours to take. Personally, I wish this whole fucking mess would just stop, so we can get back to reading and posting comments on issues we're really interested in.
LOL! You should really bottle what you're taking and sell it on ebay.
 
Problem is that some prolific writers here post under and 'alt' to keep their story voting clean of writer/troll sabotage.

Then that is a different posting personality altogether. Can't have it both ways. (And, besides, most who say they do that are lying. If they wanted to be seen as a writer in their forum personality, they'd post a few stories to that name.)
 
Problem is that some prolific writers here post under and 'alt' to keep their story voting clean of writer/troll sabotage.
I wish I'd thought of that!

It was so obvious that my scores were based on what I said in the forums-- that I just removed my work.
 
Then that is a different posting personality altogether. Can't have it both ways. (And, besides, most who say they do that are lying. If they wanted to be seen as a writer in their forum personality, they'd post a few stories to that name.)

I agree, that's the biggest lie: "Oh, I post stories on a different name or on a different site." No they don't, because people want their stories to be read.
 
I've voted.

Jeanne D'Artois, even though she has posted stories here, will NOT be voting.

Fag-Ash Lil won't be voting. She requires bribing with cigarettes and doesn't post stories.

Og
 
Then that is a different posting personality altogether. Can't have it both ways. (And, besides, most who say they do that are lying. If they wanted to be seen as a writer in their forum personality, they'd post a few stories to that name.)

:D I almost put your opinion of that in my post, but decided you could speak for yourself. :rose: I do actually know a couple and they're quite prolific. As for others, I don't know.
 
I've voted.

Jeanne D'Artois, even though she has posted stories here, will NOT be voting.

Fag-Ash Lil won't be voting. She requires bribing with cigarettes and doesn't post stories.

Og

Wait, votes from a different name that posts stories should count too. I posted a bunch of stories under another name like seven years ago, those stories could just as well be from a different author.
 
I agree, that's the biggest lie: "Oh, I post stories on a different name or on a different site." No they don't, because people want their stories to be read.

Not true. Most of the readership doesn't hang out here, and they want good votes, not votes driven by rage over a forum flame-war.
 
Wait, votes from a different name that posts stories should count too. I posted a bunch of stories under another name like seven years ago, those stories could just as well be from a different author.
<evil on> That wouldn't be a "recent" story poster alt then, would it?</kinda off>
 
Back
Top