AIDS and priorities

Ishmael

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Posts
84,005
Former president Clinton, speaking at the PUSH-Rainbow Convention in Chicago stated that America is not doing it's fair share with regard to the "War on AIDS". He called for a increase in funding from $1 billion/year to $2.5 billion/year. While that sort of pandering with other peoples monies sounds good to the activists, and looks good on paper, I have a real problem here.

First of all AIDS is wholely preventable. Using reasonable precautions and common sense, the odds of anyone contracting the disease are astronomical.

But more importantly, statements such as these demonstrate a total lack of reasoned prioritization for the health of the nation in general. AIDS is NOT an epidemic in the United States. There was actually a recorded drop in new cases last year. It appears that the educational programs, of all sorts, are begining to work. Heart disease, cancer, diabetes, and other maladies are far more likely to kill the average citizen than AIDS. But this is how our money is being spent.

Research Dollars Spent per Death

$1,129 per heart disease death

$723 per stroke death

$4,995 per diabetes death

$4,525 per cancer death

$31,381 per HIV/AIDS death

(Source, National Institutes for Health)

Does anyone else see a problem with this? Should the former presidents proposal be taken seriously, we would be funding research at the rate of $75,000 per HIV/AIDS death.

Given the statistical cause of deaths in this country, the money spent is already a gross mis-appropriation and mis-allocation of funds. This is just plain wrong.

Ishmael
 
Diabetes is slowly increasing in cases and deaths. Spending must increase not only in research but in lifestyle prevention to combat its rampant reach.

The Rainbow-PUSH Coalition is one of the least respected 'do-gooder' organizations ever. Its almost totally a front.

AIDS research money is important though. The implications of similar viruses, which have shown up in animal populations, are staggering. Its the type of virus that concerns those who follow these things, not just HIV.

Its also worth noting that heart disease, cancer, diabetes are not due toa single factor, and thus are not as likely to be eliminated but rather prevented. AIDS, on the other hand, has a singular cause so R & D money could potentially eliminate it. Similar to what we now feel about smallpox, cowpox, etc.
 
No problem, as long as you are a liberal spending other peoples money on a special group championed by the liberals. I wish the CDC would separate out the cases caused by irresponsible sexual acts and IV drug use so we could truely see what each case costs that isn't an attempt at suicide.

Rhumb:rolleyes:

Zipping up my asbestos suit!
 
modest mouse said:
Diabetes is slowly increasing in cases and deaths. Spending must increase not only in research but in lifestyle prevention to combat its rampant reach.

The Rainbow-PUSH Coalition is one of the least respected 'do-gooder' organizations ever. Its almost totally a front.

AIDS research money is important though. The implications of similar viruses, which have shown up in animal populations, are staggering. Its the type of virus that concerns those who follow these things, not just HIV.

Its also worth noting that heart disease, cancer, diabetes are not due toa single factor, and thus are not as likely to be eliminated but rather prevented. AIDS, on the other hand, has a singular cause so R & D money could potentially eliminate it. Similar to what we now feel about smallpox, cowpox, etc.

Your points are well taken MM.

Trans-species virus' are all of concern. The 'flu' being one of many. Retro-viral agents tend to be controllable by means other than innoculation. They demonstrate a high degree of specificity and fragility.

I do agree that research should continue. The retro-viral agents, because of their cellular specificity, may actually hold a cure for certain cancers. (Being given a modified virus that only attacks the tumor for example.) So there are many potential benefits to the research.

Spinoff's from research occur from all research. This is always a possibility. But focused research has always yeilded better results. The other problem with spinoffs is in their recognition. Many have gone unrecognized for years until a later researcher happens across the root paper and the "Eureka" syndrome sets in.

My concern is that the spending is far out of line with the real threat to the general population. And that is the point.

Ishmael
 
RhumbRunner13 said:
No problem, as long as you are a liberal spending other peoples money on a special group championed by the liberals. I wish the CDC would separate out the cases caused by irresponsible sexual acts and IV drug use so we could truely see what each case costs that isn't an attempt at suicide.

Rhumb:rolleyes:

Zipping up my asbestos suit!

Be interesting to see if you do get flamed rhumb.

Most of the clinically induced (transfusions, medically adminstered blood products, etc.) HIV/AIDS victims are now dead. Serious screening is taking place and the cases you speak of are a thing of the past for the most part.

99.9% of the extant cases are sexually or drug related.

Ishmael
 
I've said it before, I'll say it again. AIDS is an invention of government, a myth, and a malpractice cover-up.

It is on a par with the global warming hysteria and as easy to find as UFO's over Washington.

Of course, we've decided on a course of action so right or wrong, we'll bleed away precious resources from real, meaningful research in order to chase yet another fear, another tactic, another re-distribution of wealth scheme.
 
Ishmael said:
My concern is that the spending is far out of line with the real threat to the general population. And that is the point.

At some point I'll be talking from my ass because this is not a topic I know a great deal about.

I would agree with your above sentence, with that exact wording. For most, cancer and diabetes and heart disease have a more significant affect on the lives of themselves and family and freinds.

Part of the reason for the massive amount of money thrown at AIDS is the long delay it took to begin significant research. Its a bit of catch up on the part of the Govt.

Its also easier to sell, in many regards, in so much as it is scarier than your uncles heart attack. Its more sudden and it could happen tomorrow, to many. regardless of precautions.

Even if getting AIDS tomorrow doesnt seem likely to you, it does have an implication that getting cancer when you are 65 does not.

Not sure I am making my point or not.

I think AIDS research is important but I would probably agree that it is highly funded compared to other diseases. It would be nice to be able to throw gads of money at them all.

The next one to step up and gobble up R & D money is Alzheimer's Disease.
 
In a way yes.

Have you read Dr. Peter Duesburg's book?

To paraphrase Napolean, "Never assign to malice what can be explained by incompetence." It stems from the war on cancer, the need for funds, and something to research with those funds.

I expounded in the last AIDS thread. Right now I'm relaxing and having a drink, so I won't go too much into depth. Look up the old thread, It's less than a month old...
 
Ishmael said:


Be interesting to see if you do get flamed rhumb.

Most of the clinically induced (transfusions, medically adminstered blood products, etc.) HIV/AIDS victims are now dead. Serious screening is taking place and the cases you speak of are a thing of the past for the most part.

99.9% of the extant cases are sexually or drug related.

Ishmael

I agree! But the liberal rant is usually that if you question any part of the AIDS program, you are a "homophobe"! Doesn't seem to matter that for a long time new cases dropped in the gay community as tainted blood products infiltrated our blood banks and created infections in the heterosexual community. The disease now, what ever it is, once again seems to be impacting only the gay community and IV drug users (statistically, I know some heterosexuals and babies contract it).

I have never been able to understand why AIDS couldn't have been treated as TB was? I don't know, but even today do we allow active TB carriers to walk around in public?

Rhumb:confused:
 
modest mouse said:


At some point I'll be talking from my ass because this is not a topic I know a great deal about.

I would agree with your above sentence, with that exact wording. For most, cancer and diabetes and heart disease have a more significant affect on the lives of themselves and family and freinds.

Part of the reason for the massive amount of money thrown at AIDS is the long delay it took to begin significant research. Its a bit of catch up on the part of the Govt.

Its also easier to sell, in many regards, in so much as it is scarier than your uncles heart attack. Its more sudden and it could happen tomorrow, to many. regardless of precautions.

Even if getting AIDS tomorrow doesnt seem likely to you, it does have an implication that getting cancer when you are 65 does not.

Not sure I am making my point or not.

I think AIDS research is important but I would probably agree that it is highly funded compared to other diseases. It would be nice to be able to throw gads of money at them all.

The next one to step up and gobble up R & D money is Alzheimer's Disease.

You are making sense. It has emotional appeal because it's associated with sex. To the young that is a far stronger percieved threat than the other disease's (diabetes and asthma being exceptions).

But the "catch up" theory is weak. The fact that one woman can have a child in nine months is not grounds for the supposition that nine women can have a child in one month. And there is another issue. It appears that there are far more researchers working in the field than there are qualified researchers and that serves no ones purpose. (Except the researchers benefiting financially that is.) There is also a high degree of duplication of research, and that isn't good for anyone either.

Alzheimers? Perhaps, but the core constituent group keeps forgetting to complain and protest. (Sorry, couldn't resist that.)

Ishmael
 
RhumbRunner13 said:


I agree! But the liberal rant is usually that if you question any part of the AIDS program, you are a "homophobe"! Doesn't seem to matter that for a long time new cases dropped in the gay community as tainted blood products infiltrated our blood banks and created infections in the heterosexual community. The disease now, what ever it is, once again seems to be impacting only the gay community and IV drug users (statistically, I know some heterosexuals and babies contract it).

I have never been able to understand why AIDS couldn't have been treated as TB was? I don't know, but even today do we allow active TB carriers to walk around in public?

Rhumb:confused:

Your point is well taken as well.

Man has NEVER cured a virus. That day may come, but the technology and knowledge are not ours. We aren't even close. A vaccine is the best that can be hoped for. The researchers that intone 'cure' are for the most part snake oil salesmen preying on the fears of the victims. Damn shame too.

The only known way to 100% contain an epidemic is isolation (quarantine). No one has the balls to go there.

The TB thing was under control with pharmaceuticals for a while but a new strain has come up that is not only resistant, but particularly virulent. The victims of the resistant strain are quarantined.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
Research Dollars Spent per Death

$1,129 per heart disease death

$723 per stroke death

$4,995 per diabetes death

$4,525 per cancer death

$31,381 per HIV/AIDS death

(Source, National Institutes for Health)

I wonder how the money spent on research is being identified as directed at a specific condition?

Just as one example: I'm sure that there are numerous dollars spent on diseases of the circulatory system that apply to preventing deaths by heart attack, stroke, and diabetes that isn't attributed to research dollars for those diseases.

As others have noted, part of the $31K for HIV research is also research into cures for cancer and gene-therapy for other diseases.

I do tend to agree that funding for HIV/AIDS research seems to be disproportionate to the risk. But numbers don't tell the whole story.

What is the spending rate vs number of cases (not just deaths)?

What is the spending rate vs cures/survivals?

What other funding categories apply to each disease -- or more than one disease?

Using a very limited and biased set of numbers to prove a point is a tried and true method of raising unwarranted ire against a policy. Where is "the Rest of the story?" Without it, there's no way to determine whether funding is sufficent or excessive.
 
"The next one to step up and gobble up R & D money is Alzheimer's Disease."

I hope you are wrong, Modest. Not because I don't care about old people, I are one, but because the cost/benefit just doesn't make sense. I would rather see money spent on some of the orphan diseases that could improve the lives of young people than extend some old farts life from 89 to 91 years old! I know it is a horrible disease, if that is what it is but spending billions just doesn't make sense.

Rhumb:cool:
 
Zero is being spent on the opposing argument.

Center of Universe. Flat Earth. AIDS.
 
Re: Re: AIDS and priorities

Weird Harold said:




What is the spending rate vs number of cases (not just deaths)?

What is the spending rate vs cures/survivals?


Come on WH, I know that your better than that.

Cancer will afflict over 25% of the population, and the number is climbing. Heart related disease's will affect over 50%. You don't even want to roll the numbers that way and combine HIV/AIDS into the mix. Hell, I was being kind.

HIV/AIDS survival rate is 0%. Prevention is the only known way to survive the disease.

HIV/AIDS is 100% preventable, the other diseases can only have the statistical risks reduced.

Vaccine related research is the only research that will have any meaningful effect. Most of the other research is just so much snake oil, or experimental knowledge expanding. (This is not evil in and of itself, but does not require the level of funding that we're seeing.)

Pharmaceutical related therapies are fine. Reducing the suffering is not a bad thing. But it is much like in the days of Polio. Investing in the research of a better iron lung when the true hope laid elsewhere.

This also begs the question. Once contracted, HIV/AIDS is fatal. Are we doing society a favor by prolonging the lives of the victims, risking the chance that they will infect others?

Ishmael
 
Re: Re: Re: AIDS and priorities

Ishmael said:


Come on WH, I know that your better than that.

Cancer will afflict over 25% of the population, and the number is climbing. Heart related disease's will affect over 50%. You don't even want to roll the numbers that way and combine HIV/AIDS into the mix. Hell, I was being kind.

No, I'm not better than that.

Do your numbers on "Cancer deaths" include money dedicated to specific "cancers" like malignant melanoma, non-hodgkins lymphoma, etc?

Do your numbers include money NOT spent on prior research?


You're waving one puzzle piece at us and declaring that it proves the picture is obscene.

You raise an interesting point, but you also raise many other questions in the process -- questions that cast serious doubt on the validity of your proposistion.
 
RhumbRunner13 said:


I agree! But the liberal rant is usually that if you question any part of the AIDS program, you are a "homophobe"! Doesn't seem to matter that for a long time new cases dropped in the gay community as tainted blood products infiltrated our blood banks and created infections in the heterosexual community. The disease now, what ever it is, once again seems to be impacting only the gay community and IV drug users (statistically, I know some heterosexuals and babies contract it).

I have never been able to understand why AIDS couldn't have been treated as TB was? I don't know, but even today do we allow active TB carriers to walk around in public?

Rhumb:confused:

Actually, for quite a while now, the largest-growing population of HIV infected folk have been heterosexual women, particularly those of non-Caucasian heritage.

Unfortunately, it is starting to rise again in the gay community, mostly because the preventative measures aren't being taken as strongly anymore due to the success of the drug cocktails and people's misconceptions about transmission.

Hopefully disease research funding will not be determined based on what people think about how someone got the disease. Looking at some of the other afflictions mentioned in the original post, several are induced by unhealthy lifestyles, especially diabetes and cardiac disorders. If folks want to start chopping money because someone got a disease through unprotected sex or IV drug use, might as well put it all up on the block; less funding because you ate yourself into diabetes, or smoked your way to coronary artery disease at an early age, etc...
 
Re: Re: Re: AIDS and priorities

Ishmael said:

Cancer will afflict over 25% of the population, and the number is climbing.

I think we need to do some more research on the exact causes of cancer. 25% is an awful lot and everyone seems to be at risk.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: AIDS and priorities

Weird Harold said:


No, I'm not better than that.

Do your numbers on "Cancer deaths" include money dedicated to specific "cancers" like malignant melanoma, non-hodgkins lymphoma, etc?

Do your numbers include money NOT spent on prior research?


You're waving one puzzle piece at us and declaring that it proves the picture is obscene.

You raise an interesting point, but you also raise many other questions in the process -- questions that cast serious doubt on the validity of your proposistion.

Actually a more meaningful number might be dollars per survival rate.

As a clarification (but most should have realized anyway) those numbers are only tax dollars spent on research. The numbers do not include private monies. The categories also cover all included illness's. For example, the dollars spent on cancer research include ALL cancer types. Breaking it down to specific cancers would further dilute the pool. Same is true for heart disease.

Regardless, we are still looking at a 7 1/2 to 1 differential in spending of tax monies. And that will produce little, proportionately, to society in general. Education and prevention have had a noticable effect. No research to date can claim the same.

Now, Polio was associated with a specific type of behavior. (Swimming in certain types of waters.) Likewise, HIV/AIDS is associated with certain types of behaviors, at least in the US.

I still contend that to continue spending at taht rate on a disease that is 100% preventable with behavior modification is unjustifiable.

Don't read that as I'm not in favor of further and continued research. Do read that as I believe that the issue has become more political than scientific and that there are diseases of significantly more importance to the average citizen that deserve equal or greater attention.

(For the record, I have spent over twenty years in cancer research. The instrumentation end of the business (medical electronics), but research all the same. PM me if you want and I'll refer you to one of the giants in the field and let him answer your questions. He'll be more than happy to expound, but asking the good Dr. questions is roughly akin to taking a drink from a fire hydrant, so beware. :D )

Ishmael
 
Mae13 said:


Actually, for quite a while now, the largest-growing population of HIV infected folk have been heterosexual women, particularly those of non-Caucasian heritage.

Unfortunately, it is starting to rise again in the gay community, mostly because the preventative measures aren't being taken as strongly anymore due to the success of the drug cocktails and people's misconceptions about transmission.

Hopefully disease research funding will not be determined based on what people think about how someone got the disease. Looking at some of the other afflictions mentioned in the original post, several are induced by unhealthy lifestyles, especially diabetes and cardiac disorders. If folks want to start chopping money because someone got a disease through unprotected sex or IV drug use, might as well put it all up on the block; less funding because you ate yourself into diabetes, or smoked your way to coronary artery disease at an early age, etc...

What you say is true Mae. But the fact remains that we are warned about the smoking et al yet there are many people that do not engage in these risky behaviors that still contract the disease's. The same cannot, for the most part, be said of HIV/AIDS.

HIV/AIDS has been identified with two specific forms of behavior. Both of which are high risk by nature. Especially the IV drug use. There are 'innocent' victims in the sexual behavior category. But once again, prudence and self control would have prevented these occurrances. The single most damning incident would be a married man that gave the disease to his wife because of his infidelity (or vice versa, it's a two way street), but once again the infected party could not have been said to have excersized good judgment, let alone moral judgement.

Ishmael

PS. You still do some of the best photo stuff on the boards. Peace
 
Ish, I'm drinkin', but when you say AIDS is 100% fatal, that is only true because we are all going to die.

Hell, being a drunken petard is 100% fatal!
 
SINthysist said:
Ish, I'm drinkin', but when you say AIDS is 100% fatal, that is only true because we are all going to die.

Hell, being a drunken petard is 100% fatal!

Fucking Indians. Should never let them near "fire water". :D

Do NOT start a fire in the living room, don't dance, and for God's sake, don't sing. :p

Ishamel
 
modest mouse said:
SYN,

AIDS is a Govt conspiracy?

Everthing thats sends US dollars overseas is a govt conspiracy to Sin.

There was a very long and drawn out AIDS discussion a little while ago when you were gone.

Here is one from Bill

http://www.literotica.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=96798&highlight=AIDS

here is the other from LC

http://www.literotica.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=96767&highlight=AIDS

I don't ahve any of my AIDS research papers with me but PPman, Celestial Boday and uhh damn someone else who I can't remember cause they don't come here very often anymore all have copies.
 
Have you read the book or are you content to let others tell you what to believe?
 
Back
Top