gotsnowgotslush
skates like Eck
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2007
- Posts
- 25,720
Charge and convict the Defendant for the crime of nothing.
The prosecutor accuses a Defendant of being in violation of a law, but doesn't allege that the Defendant actually did anything that violates that law.
After a trial on the allegation of the crime of nothing, the judge says, "I enter a finding of guilty," but not guilty of doing anything in particular.
Then, when the Defendant complains to the judge, "I didn't do anything that violates the law. I wasn't even accused of doing anything that
violates the law, and you haven't found me guilty of doing anything which violates the law. So, just what, exactly, is it that you found me
guilty of doing that violates the law?"
To which the judge responds, "You don't understand, sir. Now that I've entered a finding of guilty, you have lost your presumption of innocence.
Therefore, you have to tell the Court what it is that you did that violated the law, rather than the other way around."
The prosecutor accuses a Defendant of being in violation of a law, but doesn't allege that the Defendant actually did anything that violates that law.
After a trial on the allegation of the crime of nothing, the judge says, "I enter a finding of guilty," but not guilty of doing anything in particular.
Then, when the Defendant complains to the judge, "I didn't do anything that violates the law. I wasn't even accused of doing anything that
violates the law, and you haven't found me guilty of doing anything which violates the law. So, just what, exactly, is it that you found me
guilty of doing that violates the law?"
To which the judge responds, "You don't understand, sir. Now that I've entered a finding of guilty, you have lost your presumption of innocence.
Therefore, you have to tell the Court what it is that you did that violated the law, rather than the other way around."