Auxillary Verbs

BRONZEAGE

Thank God you werent around when Lincoln wrote his Gettysburg Address.

From what I read about it, writers with real awards and real successes believe prose should be as lean or fat as necessary. Tolstoy said in 1100 pages what e.e.cummings said in a poem. A bicycle will take you as far as a Mercedes.

When you use precise verbs and nouns you dont need tons of modifiers (see Lincoln, Abe).

Always, as necessary and with missionary zeal.

It follows, a writer with little to say and little meaning in what he says, needs less words.
 
My intent is not to polish the paragraphs, my intent is to remove the helping verbs and fix the grammatical errors.

Besides, I spoke to the author about his paragraph; he gets it that he can keep his style AND improve his prose. He prefers lush over lean, and thats okay cuz he also knows that his paragraph has 13 grammatical errors. I fixed 11 of them.
 
My intent is not to polish the paragraphs, my intent is to remove the helping verbs and fix the grammatical errors.

Besides, I spoke to the author about his paragraph; he gets it that he can keep his style AND improve his prose. He prefers lush over lean, and thats okay cuz he also knows that his paragraph has 13 grammatical errors. I fixed 11 of them.

You finally found a writer who doesn't demand you tell him his work is perfect?

Be sure to tell him about e. e. cummings and War and Peace.
 
I applaud your (JBJ) intent. Obviously there is some disagreement, but there always is.

I find that people don't understand the written word as well as they understand conversation, because there are many verbal clues in speech. I think trysail was right when he said there should be a font for sarcasm. :D

Then too, it appears the lots of people that react to threads, irrationally. Some run out on the right/left wing and consider everything political. I think because either, the point you try to make gores one of their pet oxen, or they are just contrary.

Then again, when you get paid by the word, axillary words and long paragraphs put beer in the cooler.
 
JACK

Its hard to argue against writers with multiple Pulitzers, but people do. As I told one writer earlier, WHEN EVERYTHING YOU WRITE IS WEAK AND PASSIVE ITS KINDA HARD FOR YOUR WEAK & PASSIVE CHARACTER TO STANDOUT IN THE CROWD.
 
JACK

Its hard to argue against writers with multiple Pulitzers, but people do. As I told one writer earlier, WHEN EVERYTHING YOU WRITE IS WEAK AND PASSIVE ITS KINDA HARD FOR YOUR WEAK & PASSIVE CHARACTER TO STANDOUT IN THE CROWD.

Yet if you write all action, there can be little characterization. That's not always bad because the action keeps the readers attention and they imagine the character in far more personalized way, than if you "List her/his Attributes" in excruciating detail.

By putting the character in a situation and describing his reactions, you can provide the mental characterization which draws the reader into the story.

"Show don't tell."


It's fine line to make it all come together, and there is no accounting for authorial purpose.
 
Last edited:
Yet if you write all action, there can be little characterization. That's not always bad because the action keeps the readers attention and they imagine the character in far more personalized way, than if you "List her/his Attributes" in excruciating detail.

By putting the character in a situation and describing his reactions, you can provide the mental characterization which draws the reader into the story.

"Show don't tell."


It's fine line to make it all come together, and there is no accounting for authorial purpose.

Its less obtrusive. When I did psychotherapy couples used to come in, sit together on the sofa, and the female would spread her legs...the husband clueless of the show I was watching. Now! I'm not sure what that means, but if I put it in a story someone would recognize it and know! They'd think I'm a genius and I dont have an effing clue.
 
I ran a grammar review of original and revision. The original has 13 grammar problems, the revision has 2 errors.


ORIGINAL
One might think that the marble floors should be cold however, when considering the Summerhouse as a respite from the build-up of summer heat in the main house then it's understandable that the owners wanted a cool and tranquil environment. And yet, as I stood in the centre of that room I could feel not only a comfort of well being I could also feel, strangely, an inner strength that I hadn't experienced in years. The latter of those feelings had me confused until I realised it was one of quiet confidence that one gets when you feel you are not alone. I glanced around but, of course, the room was empty. As my eyes scanned the open empty space, I started to retrace my troubled history.

REVISION
The Summerhome's marble floor tiles enhanced its cool and tranquil ambience. But, standing in the center of that room (unspecified referential indices), I felt comfort and, strangely, stamina from long ago, plus confused until I recognized my feelings as the quiet confidence I experience in a group of friends. I looked around the empty room and pondered my troubled history.

Like Jack, I also applaud JBJ for making writing threads...

But you are doing more than simply removing passive voice. Here is my re-write removing the axillary verbs - it's more active voice but leaves the style more intact. I did leave in a "hadn't" as it fits well and doesn't detract.

"Marble floors are cold however, considering the Summerhouse as a respite from the build-up of summer heat in the main house, it's understandable the owners wanted a cool and tranquil environment. And yet, as I stood in the centre of that room I felt not only a comfort of well being I also felt, strangely, an inner strength that I hadn't experienced in years. The latter of those feelings confused me until I realized it was one of quiet confidence one gets when you feel you are not alone. I glanced around but, of course, the room was empty. As I scanned the open empty space, I started to retrace my troubled history."

The text does need editing, which you did along with the verb removal (as well as change meaning - e.g. inserting stamina for quiet confidence). For example, the second sentence doesn't make much sense following the first, though maybe it's not awkward in context...the "that room..." as well. And "The latter of those...", the "one feels when one..." needs work too.

ETA: I reread after doing this and mine is similar to bronzeage's.
 
Last edited:
Its less obtrusive. When I did psychotherapy couples used to come in, sit together on the sofa, and the female would spread her legs...the husband clueless of the show I was watching. Now! I'm not sure what that means, but if I put it in a story someone would recognize it and know! They'd think I'm a genius and I dont have an effing clue.

I never thought you did. :D

Hump, I tried to write a novel about a guy who spends one year in a place, I didn't describe everything in detail and just tried to describe the clash of divergent societal norms between the two related but different cultures. Oh, and there was a lot of intercourse, of course. 40 chapters later, I'm only a 1/3 the way through in tour of duty and finally, finally figured out what I was talking about in the first place.

Now I've got about forty characters and poor Josh's dick is starting to scab over.
I figure to finish it off at the forth of July party and then, in the sequel shift to a third person voice to let "everyone" put in their two cents. Then in the third part of the Trilogy, move back to first person and let Josh show the moral character he has to have to exist in a world of 10 women for each man.
 
JOMAR

Plenty in the original paragraph makes no sense. WHAT ROOM? 'Inner strength' is stamina. If the owners desired a 'cool and traquil' place the floor tiles are cool NOT cold. 'The quiet confidence that one gets when you feel you are not alone' makes no sense cuz YOU ARE NOT ALONE isnt a feeling: mad, sad, glad, afraid, sleepy, hungry are feelings. and I have no idea whom or what the writer is referring to...a rat in his pocket? his mother? the Manson Gang? Dubya? A UNICORN? The 2nd sentence makes no sense cuz its an unspecified referential indices, WHAT EFFING ROOM?

If you write like BRONZEAGE, uh...are you bragging or complaining?

When I started work for the state I had like one paragraph of text to distill a client's situation. Like, 'Five minutes after Mizzz Stella Omega came for her appointment I wanted to stab her thru the heart with my pencil.' In 1993 they gave us 85 lines of text, and I thought I could write WAR & PEACE! By 2005 we had 40 pages to play with, and 95% of the reports were incoherent babble.
 
JOMAR

Plenty in the original paragraph makes no sense. WHAT ROOM? 'Inner strength' is stamina. If the owners desired a 'cool and traquil' place the floor tiles are cool NOT cold. 'The quiet confidence that one gets when you feel you are not alone' makes no sense cuz YOU ARE NOT ALONE isnt a feeling: mad, sad, glad, afraid, sleepy, hungry are feelings. and I have no idea whom or what the writer is referring to...a rat in his pocket? his mother? the Manson Gang? Dubya? A UNICORN? The 2nd sentence makes no sense cuz its an unspecified referential indices, WHAT EFFING ROOM?

Agreed, which is why I commented on it. But your exercise, as I took it, was to remove auxiliary verbs, not do a total edit/rewrite/distillation.

If you write like BRONZEAGE, uh...are you bragging or complaining?

...

Ha! No, just pointing out that removing the passive voice results in consistency.
 
JOMAR

I dont want to leave you folks with schizophrenic word salad.

I'm even tempted to edit one of my stories on here, so newbies can observe a story change for the better?
 
JOMAR

I dont want to leave you folks with schizophrenic word salad.

I'm even tempted to edit one of my stories on here, so newbies can observe a story change for the better?

That's fine, but you started the thread talking about removing auxiliary verbs then rewrote completely, so the end result was different than the exercise.

Yeah, go ahead and do that. People would like to see your writing. Have you taken a look into the story feedback forum and the story discussion circle (slow moving) to see what you can offer there?
 
JOMAR

Yes, the end result is almost guaranteed to be different; I mean, what do you expect? If the offending sentence is, say JOMAR IS BEAUTIFUL, I suppose I can yankout 'is' and substitute, say, ' invented.' JOMAR INVENTED BEAUTIFUL. But I still think such easy substitutions are one empty chamber in a cylinder with 5 live rounds.

I stopped volunteer editing cuz people pretty much want a hug and skin for their efforts.
 
I don't know whether to be amused or appalled. I have noticed in my editing that we are losing the subtle tenses -- the difference between 'I began to go' or 'I was going' or 'I had gone' all simply collapsing to 'I went'. Those little helper verbs are there for a reason, and if you don't understand what or why your are missing much of the beauty and power the language has to offer.

As for stories being about action -- if that's what your looking for, stick to car chase movies.

I thought there could be nothing more idiotic than JB's political fulminations but I realize now that was only the tip of the iceberg.
 
One well-quoted piece of advice for short stories is to edit again and again cutting out everything unnecessary for telling the story.

Removing auxiliary verbs could be a way of doing that.

But it is not necessarily good advice for a novel which has scope to give a broader picture, to develop the characters, to introduce sub-plots and to set the scenes in more detail.

If you are going to be economical with auxiliary and descriptive words in a novel then you need a very strong and complicated plot with plenty of action that the readers can follow.

Og
 
One well-quoted piece of advice for short stories is to edit again and again cutting out everything unnecessary for telling the story.

Removing auxiliary verbs could be a way of doing that.

But it is not necessarily good advice for a novel which has scope to give a broader picture, to develop the characters, to introduce sub-plots and to set the scenes in more detail.

If you are going to be economical with auxiliary and descriptive words in a novel then you need a very strong and complicated plot with plenty of action that the readers can follow.

Og

And a good vocabulary.

Here's what I think: Robert Gunning says we use the 50 most common words 50% of the time; and use 3000 common words 98% of the time. I think Rudolph Fleisher made the same conclusion. So the lion's share of our vocabulary are auxillary verbs, static linking verbs, and weak-simple verbs.
 
JOMAR

Yes, the end result is almost guaranteed to be different; I mean, what do you expect? If the offending sentence is, say JOMAR IS BEAUTIFUL, I suppose I can yankout 'is' and substitute, say, ' invented.' JOMAR INVENTED BEAUTIFUL. But I still think such easy substitutions are one empty chamber in a cylinder with 5 live rounds.

I stopped volunteer editing cuz people pretty much want a hug and skin for their efforts.

If the exercise is to remove auxiliary verbs from a piece of text you will get a fairly consistent result among participants. But you're doing something different - a complete rewrite and distillation, which is fine, but different than simply removing auxiliary verbs.

I dunno, when I was active in the SDC folks took plenty of beat downs on their writing, myself included.
 
If the exercise is to remove auxiliary verbs from a piece of text you will get a fairly consistent result among participants. But you're doing something different - a complete rewrite and distillation, which is fine, but different than simply removing auxiliary verbs.

I dunno, when I was active in the SDC folks took plenty of beat downs on their writing, myself included.

Help me out, JOMAR. What exactly do you think oughta happen once the auxillary verb is removed? Fill the space with BONDO and sand it?
 
Auxillary verbs are the bane of good writing and siphon gas from the tank of action.

Correcting the problem means finding the right verb to express the action and removing clutter from the stream of prose.

AUXILLARY VERBS: is am are was were be being been have has had do does did shall will should would may might must can could.

[/B]


Help me out, JOMAR. What exactly do you think oughta happen once the auxillary verb is removed? Fill the space with BONDO and sand it?

Okay, I went back and looked at your OP. With all the talk about removing auxiliary verbs I overlooked the your "clutter" line. So perhaps I misunderstood the intent of your exercise - which was not simply to make passive active, but to edit more heavily...two different things

No, I agree that the text you picked definitely needed editing, not just changing auxiliary verbs. But if a text is otherwise tight and right you can probably change passive to active and are good to go.
 
Dear Penthouse Letters,

Its less obtrusive. When I did psychotherapy couples used to come in, sit together on the sofa, and the female would spread her legs...the husband clueless of the show I was watching. Now! I'm not sure what that means, but if I put it in a story someone would recognize it and know! They'd think I'm a genius and I dont have an effing clue.
 
After reading this thread, I'll say this. While its good advice in general to reduce the amount of auxillary verbs in favor of action verbs, you can't get rid of them entirely because they are a natural part of speaking and english. Afterall, the word "be" in all its forms is one of the first parts of english your taught.

My friend said it best "Those who win awards show that they've the skill and style to get the job done. Note, however, that not everyone's actually READ some of these award winning novels."
 
By golly everyone on planet Earth reads each and every LIT story, and everyone knows that Pulitzers are another name for 'affirmative action!'.

I mean, there's not a writing manual in America that doesnt include a chapter on how to change pesky, concrete action verbs into tepid, weak, static, abstract, 90 pound little cocksuckers that do nothing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top