brithright citizenship

Should there be 'birthright citizenship'? (born on the soil, you're a citizen)

  • don't know, don't care, held hostage by illegals.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    30
  • Poll closed .
Undocumented foreign nationals aren't necessarily "illegal" in the sense that, if caught, they would be tried and convicted and sentenced to prison. Entering the country without going through proper channels is a misdemeanor, unless done repeatedly. They may be deported and fined, but it's not as if they're going to wind up in jail unless they've committed some other crime(s) while in the US. I'm not sure even working here is a crime, although hiring undocumented workers is.

The economic problems facing this country would not be solved by deporting all the "illegals", and government services wouldn't suddenly come into balance with tax revenues if they weren't here.

a crime is still a crime whether misdemeanor or felony. and it is a crime to be here illegally and work without a green card. yet again the executive branch and justice are unwilling to enforce the laws on the books.

no the economic problems would not be completely solved but it would be a start and would reduce the burden on hospital emergency rooms, schools, police and social welfare programs.
 
no the economic problems would not be completely solved but it would be a start and would reduce the burden on hospital emergency rooms, schools, police and social welfare programs.

Which would probably be grossly offset by the loss of staff across the most-needed services in society.

I don't support just turning a blind eye to illegal immigrants--but I don't pretend it's an easy tradeoff just to find and expell them all either.
 
being in the US w/o proper papers is not a criminal matter, it's neither a felony nor misdemeanor (though the AZ law sought to make it the latter).

it's an infraction (of immigration law) that leaves you open to being apprehended and deported. analogy: shooting a deer w/o a hunting license.

however, the fate of that person is not the thread topic. supposing w/o papers she lives in the US for five years, and then has a child. i see no reason why the CHILD should not be a citizen or at least eligible to become one (say, at 18), by simple application. ESPECIALLY, let's further assume that the CHILD has lived from birth, five years (or more) in the US, gone to kindergarten here, etc. the child knows no other country than the US.

it's well to remember that the 'birthright' law is NOT an act of charity, as in welcoming refugees. it's stark national interest, and that's why it's found in US, approximately in Canada, and very close in Australia. new people are needed to replenish the population, pay taxes and so on.

again your semantics are crap. an infraction of the law, is still a crime, in most cases a misdemeanor but can be escalated to a felony depending on the value of the object and/or property. and as with most crimes jail time is just one of the punishments, whereas for misdemeanors a fine is imposed in place of or sometimes in conjunction to jail time.
 
Birthright citzenship (jus soli). Are you in favor? The immediate case is US, where Senator Kyl and others on the right are talking about revising/repealing the 14 th amendment that gave native borns--at that time, many slaves--full US citzenship rights.

I'm not a European, but a Canadian and I believe that there are other amendments that should be changed before this one. Let's look at the second amendment. At the time it was important, but the right to bear arms is insignificant now and makes no sense. America is a country, like Canada, built by immigrants. Do away with immigrants and you essentially do away with everything the forefathers meant to build and negate the meaning of being American in the New World. Everyone in North America is an immigrant. To do away with birthrights is to lessen the strength of what it means to be free in the Americas.
 
I'm not a European, but a Canadian and I believe that there are other amendments that should be changed before this one. Let's look at the second amendment. At the time it was important, but the right to bear arms is insignificant now and makes no sense. America is a country, like Canada, built by immigrants. Do away with immigrants and you essentially do away with everything the forefathers meant to build and negate the meaning of being American in the New World. Everyone in North America is an immigrant. To do away with birthrights is to lessen the strength of what it means to be free in the Americas.

more canadian logic at work. yes, without "legal" immigrants neither nation would be what it is today.
 
more canadian logic at work. yes, without "legal" immigrants neither nation would be what it is today.

Wrong. I don't even know where to start, it's so wrong. Get your diploma from one of those ads in the back of comic books, did you?
 
The 14th Amendment was ratified in 1868 to permit former slaves to gain citizenship.

Not one European country permits, 'Anchor Babies', to have citizenship in their countries.

Babies born to illegal aliens are illegal aliens.

Bite me.

Amicus
 
Bite me.

Amicus

No thanks. I don't want your rabies. Any one can see from the way you foam at the mouth you have rabies.

My suggestion to others, Stay far away from it. It can hurt or kill ya.
 
a crime is still a crime whether misdemeanor or felony. and it is a crime to be here illegally and work without a green card. yet again the executive branch and justice are unwilling to enforce the laws on the books.

no the economic problems would not be completely solved but it would be a start and would reduce the burden on hospital emergency rooms, schools, police and social welfare programs
.

~~~

Hello and welcome to the Hangout; your thoughts are appreciated, at least by me.

The Left do not deal in absolutes, everything is relative, transitional, uncertain and without definition...keep that in mind as you swat at the fog of what passes for liberal thinking.

Does a sovreign nation have the right to control its' borders? Yes.

Does a sovereign nation have the right to determine who immigrates to the country? Yes.

Does illegal really mean illegal? Yes.

To the progressive weenies here, none of the above answers are absolute.

:)

Amicus
 
bronzeage said:
I suppose US law has some provision for this problem, just so long as the child did not ever want to run for President.

Here's how you do it. You go to your consulate and apply for a certificate for the birth of an American born abroad. I know because that's what I did when my daughter was daughter was born in Iran. I am, and always have been, an American citizen, although I had Iranian citizenship as well; her father was an Iranian citizen. By this time the marriage was on the rocks and I wanted to make absolutely sure there was as little hassle about getting her into the states as possible. I wasn't sure how legal it was when I did it but the people at the consulate helped me and that's what I did. For the past couple of years my daughter has been old enough to run for President, but has zero interest in doing so.

I understand that in most European countries, a family of, say, Turkish origin can have three or four generations born, live, work and die in that European country, and they will never be viewed as anything but Turks--even if they are immersed in the culture and know the language as well as, or better than, the natives. I think this is unfortunate and is probably contributing to the trouble the Europeans are having with the Muslims in their midst, which is more than what we're having, 9/11 notwithstanding.
 
A Turkish family living in the UK for generations would be able to claim British Citizenship - see explanation of law below.

Part of the UK's problem with legal immigrants is that some do not want to become British but to live in Britain as if they were still in their parents' and grandparents' country. That can cause conflict between generations and sometimes with UK laws. You can be Something-Hyphenated British, recognising your ancestral culture, but if you remain Something and are not willing to recognise British laws and customs, then there will be conflict with the authorities at some time.

The UK has adapted gradually to assist with religious and cultural differences, probably not as fast as it should have, and certainly not as fast as some new citizens would have liked, but it has changed.

Og

British citizenship by birth in the United Kingdom
Under the law in effect from 1 January 1983, a child born in the UK to a parent who is a British citizen or 'settled' in the UK is automatically a British citizen by birth.

Only one parent needs to meet this requirement, either the father or the mother.

"Settled" status in this context usually means the parent is resident in the United Kingdom and has the right of abode, holds Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR), or is the citizen of an EU/EEA country and has permanent residence. Irish citizens in the UK are also deemed to be settled for this purpose.
Special rules exist for cases where a parent of a child is a citizen of a European Union or European Economic Area member state, or Switzerland. The law in this respect was changed on 2 October 2000 and again on 30 April 2006. See below for details.

For children born before 1 July 2006, if only the father meets this requirement, the parents must be married. Marriage subsequent to the birth is normally enough to confer British citizenship from that point.
Where the father is not married to the mother, the Home Office will usually register the child as British provided an application is made and the child would have been British otherwise. The child must be aged under 18 on the date of application.

Where a parent subsequently acquires British citizenship or "settled" status, the child can be registered as British provided he or she is still aged under 18.
If the child lives in the UK until age 10 there is a lifetime entitlement to register as a British citizen. The immigration status of the child and his/her parents is irrelevant.

Special provisions may apply for the child to acquire British citizenship if a parent is a British Overseas citizen or British subject, or if the child is stateless.

Before 1983, birth in the UK was sufficient in itself to confer British nationality irrespective of the status of parents, with an exception only for children of diplomats and enemy aliens. This exception did not apply to most visiting forces, so, in general, children born in the UK before 1983 to visiting military personnel (e.g. US forces stationed in the UK) are British citizens by birth.
 
Here's how you do it. You go to your consulate and apply for a certificate for the birth of an American born abroad. I know because that's what I did when my daughter was daughter was born in Iran. I am, and always have been, an American citizen, although I had Iranian citizenship as well; her father was an Iranian citizen. By this time the marriage was on the rocks and I wanted to make absolutely sure there was as little hassle about getting her into the states as possible. I wasn't sure how legal it was when I did it but the people at the consulate helped me and that's what I did. For the past couple of years my daughter has been old enough to run for President, but has zero interest in doing so.

I understand that in most European countries, a family of, say, Turkish origin can have three or four generations born, live, work and die in that European country, and they will never be viewed as anything but Turks--even if they are immersed in the culture and know the language as well as, or better than, the natives. I think this is unfortunate and is probably contributing to the trouble the Europeans are having with the Muslims in their midst, which is more than what we're having, 9/11 notwithstanding.

That is very interesting.

In many US states, especially in the south, there were miscegenation laws on the books. It was illegal for a white person to marry a black person. The same laws determined how much black heritage made one black. In most cases, a single black great grand parent made one black, regardless of the rest of the mix.

I imagine the Turkish family having the same dilemma. If a 3rd generation Turk marries a born French citizen, and have a child, how is this new resident of France defined?
 
That is very interesting.


I imagine the Turkish family having the same dilemma. If a 3rd generation Turk marries a born French citizen, and have a child, how is this new resident of France defined?

The President of France is a 2nd generation Frenchman of impeccable Hungarian Jewish ancestry yet he has no problems with denying citizenship or social acceptance to moslems who may have lived under French rule far longer than his family.
 
they are, thanks for admitting it. it take a big man to admit his mistakes.

It 'take' a bigger brain than yours to joust here - AmiCoot excluded (he's an intellectual pussy - won't debate anyone smarter than a republican - everyone here) - read the response again you poor retarded twit.............
 
~~~

Hello and welcome to the Hangout; your thoughts are appreciated, at least by me.

The Left do not deal in absolutes, everything is relative, transitional, uncertain and without definition...keep that in mind as you swat at the fog of what passes for liberal thinking.

Does a sovreign nation have the right to control its' borders? Yes.

Does a sovereign nation have the right to determine who immigrates to the country? Yes.

Does illegal really mean illegal? Yes.

To the progressive weenies here, none of the above answers are absolute.

:)

Amicus

You haven't the guts to debate or meaningfully engage anyone here....just spew your racist, inbred crap.........
 
a crime is still a crime whether misdemeanor or felony. and it is a crime to be here illegally and work without a green card. yet again the executive branch and justice are unwilling to enforce the laws on the books.

no the economic problems would not be completely solved but it would be a start and would reduce the burden on hospital emergency rooms, schools, police and social welfare programs.

DAMN YORE A DUM SHIT! BUT RIGHT SMART FER YER AGE.....
 
It 'take' a bigger brain than yours to joust here - AmiCoot excluded (he's an intellectual pussy - won't debate anyone smarter than a republican - everyone here) - read the response again you poor retarded twit.............

You haven't the guts to debate or meaningfully engage anyone here....just spew your racist, inbred crap.........

and it would seem to me the only thing you get pleasure from is calling people names. it must be very sad to be you. i piety your poor soul for it is sure that it will burn forever in that place 'you' call hell.
 
and it would seem to me the only thing you get pleasure from is calling people names. it must be very sad to be you. i piety your poor soul for it is sure that it will burn forever in that place 'you' call hell.

Jeez, yore dummer than I thawt: yew kneed to git a dickshunery an lurn haw to uz itt.

Piety? Piety will allow me to roast some marshmallows while you and your racist buddies burn crosses forever.............................but that's heaven for you, right?
What a twit.......
Piety? indeed, piety..................
 
Jeez, yore dummer than I thawt: yew kneed to git a dickshunery an lurn haw to uz itt.

Piety? Piety will allow me to roast some marshmallows while you and your racist buddies burn crosses forever.............................but that's heaven for you, right?
What a twit.......
Piety? indeed, piety..................

I wish someone would "piety" my poor soul. *sigh*

ah, so you don't make any mistakes when typing? talk about the kettle calling the pot black.

@dragon again shows his superior debating skills with his foul, hateful words.
 
Back
Top