brutal honesty...

G

Guest

Guest
do you admire those who tell it like it is or get angry because they dont think the way you want them to?
What issues do you feel are b&w?
 
There's brutal honesty and then there's tact and consideration. I think the world needs some of each in order to get the proper balance. Myself, I prefer to be a little more diplomatic when dealing with people and difficult situations.
 
hmmm, wonder what inspired this thread?

First there would have to be some kind of consenus on what "it is" that is being told brutally honestly. You might think you are 'just being honest' and someone else might think you're being manipulative, and yet someone else might think you've just got your head up your ass, and someone else might think you're just being naive, and someone else still might think you're almost right but not quite, etc etc etc.
 
It depends on the issue.. If it is going to end up hurting someone's feelings then tact needs to be employed.
 
Yes, being honest is a very good thing, but in being honest, there is often a cost.

Of course, there is a lot to be said for tact and manners. You may have something to say, but none of us should discount other's points of views based only on the fact that they are different.

B and W issues?

There are none, or almost none.

Rape is wrong.

Murder is wrong.

Theft is wrong, but udnerstandable in certain circumstances.

Ohh now I am already slipping into gray areas!
 
peachykeen said:
hmmm, wonder what inspired this thread?

assuming is not constructive.
Anyway, I have realized that most people can not handle the truth so its better for everyone to sugarcoat your opinions.
 
I think I'm a brutal honesty type of poster, I'm not into sugar coating. I leave room for other opinions and choices, but when mine or those like mine are judged under the mores of a sheep society, I have no problem standing up for what I believe in.

If a sheep in a flock decides to stand up for his or her beliefs, I totally support their choice to do so. That doesn't mean I can't debate with them or tell them they're a sheep. That's brutally honest.
 
I think in serious situations brutal honesty is sometimes needed. If you know it's going to hurt the person's feelings however one should practice a little tact. Sometimes people who practice brutal honesty on a regular basis are just assholes using brutal honesty as an excuse for their being assholes.
 
Last edited:
De Sade said:
do you admire those who tell it like it is or get angry because they dont think the way you want them to?
What issues do you feel are b&w?

I started a thread much like this earlier tonight, then edited it and hit the back button on my browser. It hit me that it wouldn't make much difference; people are going to behave the way they choose to.

I admire those that can speak their mind *without* attacking, making it personal, and resorting to name calling when met with opposing views.
What is black and white to me are the very things I won't debate, there is no point in doing so. When I choose to debate/discuss, it has to be with an open mind.
 
De Sade said:
do you admire those who tell it like it is or get angry because they dont think the way you want them to?
What issues do you feel are b&w?

Very few issues in life are black or white, to many opinions, wants, beliefs, feelings involved to be anything but grey. Now if someone shows anger, then that is probably a sign of compassion or conviction to it.
 
Is being tactful, sugar coating?

Is being respectful of other's views, sugar coating?

Does an opinion carry more weight if it is punctuated by "fucktard" or :rolleyes:?

Just wondering....

Now, in another direction:
There are times when our friends, who love us, must be brutally honest and it may feel hurtful. Getting beyond this is a sign of true freindship.
 
Is being tactful, sugar coating? yes, in a way

Is being respectful of other's views, sugar coating? what constitutes disrespect?
 
Maybe this will answer this question.

I am probably the most brutally honest person in the world.
And.

If I could, I would slit my voice box.

People dont want to hear the truth....Period, end of story.

Its about apathy, and rose colored glasses folks.
 
I find that most people's 'brutal honesty' is heavy on the brutal and light on the honesty.
 
If I respect your views concerning abortion, for example. It simply means that I am likely to udnerstand how you developed those views and will not judge you as a person because your opinion is different from mine.

I don't agree that tact equates to sugar coating.

People who simply state an opinion without passing judgement over others or showing inconsideration of others or their views are being tactful. Not using name calling or other slurs is being tactful.

I am not suggesting that tact means one must request permission to opine and doesn't take a stand one way or another.

Here, those who quietly express themselves generally, aren't as invovled in the lengthy threads that hash and rehash issues over and again.

However, this is just my opinion. :D:D:D
 
Killswitch said:
Maybe this will answer this question.

I am probably the most brutally honest person in the world.
And.

If I could, I would slit my voice box.

People dont want to hear the truth....Period, end of story.

Its about apathy, and rose colored glasses folks.

To some degree, you are correct.
There are many people who just dont' want to know.

They don't want to hear the truth about how their hair looks, the new dress or their job performance.

Then, others, perhaps fewer, really want to know so as to use criticism in a positive manner. In this respect, "brutal" honesty isn't even necessary.

So, I guess those who want honesty, don't need to "brutality" of it. It is enough to just say what you think.

Accepting and honest and open POV is a hard lesson to learn and many never do.
 
Honesty has no need to be brutal. Usually it is lies that need that extra boost of brutality to make them believable. Truth is secure. Truth will attach itself rather effortlessly to any who are searching for it.
 
perky_baby said:
I think I'm a brutal honesty type of poster, I'm not into sugar coating. I leave room for other opinions and choices, but when mine or those like mine are judged under the mores of a sheep society, I have no problem standing up for what I believe in.

If a sheep in a flock decides to stand up for his or her beliefs, I totally support their choice to do so. That doesn't mean I can't debate with them or tell them they're a sheep. That's brutally honest.
What's all this about sheep?
 
erosman said:
Honesty has no need to be brutal. Usually it is lies that need that extra boost of brutality to make them believable. Truth is secure. Truth will attach itself rather effortlessly to any who are searching for it.



Can I just say that I :heart: your ass????



Is that brutal enough???


:kiss:
 
Never said:
I find that most people's 'brutal honesty' is heavy on the brutal and light on the honesty.


busy body is a fan of being brutally honest i think
 
De Sade said:
do you admire those who tell it like it is or get angry because they dont think the way you want them to?
What issues do you feel are b&w?

Honesty is a virtue probably the only one I have, lol. That said, I will not lie to save someone's feelings, but I will try to be as gentle as possible.

As to black and white issues. I think, for me, most things are right or wrong, I find as I get older that changes though. Name an issue and I'll tell you what I think. There are way too many to list.
 
Re: Re: brutal honesty...

lost said:
Name an issue and I'll tell you what I think. There are way too many to list.
euthanasia?
cloning?
welfare?
 
Back
Top