Capitalism's collapse continues

Re: Heavy Stick had a prick,

p_p_man said:
A penis thin and small,
But Heavy Stick being thick,
Couldn't see its size at all...

(with apologies to the emperor and his clothes)

ppman


No, no it isn't my idiotic inebriated assclown.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: OC & SIN

p_p_man said:
See what I meant about a shallow thinker?

ppman

Homer wrote shallow poetry? What's so hot about that?

Which Simpson's character is your favorite, pp?
 
Of course it has problems, Red! I've never said that it didn't. But nothing that incremental change within this existing system won't fix. No need to "throw the baby out with the bathwater" (as my grandfather used to say).

I don't see society as being potentially perfectable, just improvable. So, I'm on board for lots of reforms of capitalism, including limiting corporate contributions to elected officials and campaigns and making corporate executives more accountable by stiffening punishments for misbehavior (and actually enforcing them - imagine that).

The problem I have with Marxism is its idea that humanity is perfectable. "the alteration of men on a mass scale is necessary" is what Marx said. Hitler also wrote of "the will to create mankind anew. Both sought to perfect societies. I don't think it's possible and I think just attempting to perfect it is what lead to the Stalinist purges, the holocaust, the gulags, the Khmer Rouge, Mao's horrendous cultural revolution, and the rest of the record attributed to fascism and communism. I'm not a "capitalist". I'm a person who believes that capitalism happens to be the least harmful system to individual liberties and the general public good.

I'm intensely distrustful of anyone with a strong ideology, because of Solzhenitsyn said in the Gulag Archepelago, (comparing the Communist leaders to Shakespearian villains): "MacBeth's justifications were feeble - and his conscience devoured him. Yes, even Iago was a little lamb too. The imagination and the spiritual strength of Shakespeare's evildoers stopped short at a dozen corpses. Because they had no ideology."

Radicalism always leads to tyranny and suffering.
 
Re: Re: Re: OC & SIN

p_p_man said:
I said at the time it was first posted, anyone who didn't admit watching over and over again, fascinated, as the jets flew into the two towers, is probably lying and...

From which perspective is the poem written? An American or a terrorist? If a terrorist then REDWAVE has written a classic on par with Homer but...ppman

Of course the footage was gripping, peepee. But isn't there just a bit of difference between your eyes being glued to the screen in horror and believing the attack to be "the coolest thing I've seen since 1992" and asking "to have that everyday now"?

And comparing Red to Homer?

Come on, Peeps. That's silly, even for you.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: OC & SIN

Oliver Clozoff said:
now"?

And comparing Red to Homer?

Come on, Peeps. That's silly, even for you.

There's nobody named red on the Simpsons.
 
Thanks, p p man!

A classic on par with Homer? You flatterer, you!
Even Homer Simpson is pretty classic, in its own way. I definitely identify with Bart to some extent. Eat my shorts, inches & HeavyStink!
:p

OK, Oliver, now that you've acknowledged there are problems, maybe we can proceed to a genuine dialogue. The problem I have with the idea of incremental reforms is-- they always get rolled back later. There were a lot of reforms made in the 1960's, which have all been reversed since then in the post-'60's reaction. What hope is there for a system which couldn't even pass a lousy extension of unemployment benefits, at a time when many millions of Americans are out of work, through no fault of their own?

Where does Marxism say humanity is perfectable? I've read a lot of Marx, but I've never come across that quote you gave. Where is it from? It seems to me that rather than dealing with what Marxism really has to say, you're constructing a straw man. How about this proposition: "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles." Agree or disagree, and why?

BTW, despite the frequent invitations I've received to leave, there is a lot I like about living in America: that there's a Trader Joe's not far from where I live, for instance.
 
Re: Thanks, p p man!

REDWAVE said:
OK, Oliver, now that you've acknowledged there are problems, maybe we can proceed to a genuine dialogue. The problem I have with the idea of incremental reforms is-- they always get rolled back later.

I agree to an extent. The course of progress isn't ever straight and smooth. It's usually "two steps forward and one step back", but even with that kind of motion, progress gets made. And for the examples you cited (I assume you meant the reforms of LBJ's Great Society), I'd argue that those "reforms" were more of a "step back" than two steps forward. They never reduced poverty and instead created a sense of entitlement among poor Americans.

I confess that I don't know a whole lot of Marxist theory in depth, but my BA was in history and I know the devastation Marxism wrought in the places where it was implemented wholesale - Cambodia, the USSR, China, North Korea, Viet Nam. You've blamed these failures on the West, but Stalin, Mao, and Pot were worse to Communism than America ever was. Together they killed over 30 million people. Hitler would be envious.

My Marx quote comes from a book called "Ten Theories of Human Nature" by Haberman and Stevenson (1998), page 146. It doesn't give an exact citation to Marx.

How about this proposition: "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles." Agree or disagree, and why?

I think Marx's observations about the struggles between the classes were very astute and allow us to explain a lot about society we might not be able to otherwise. But I disagree that class is somehow the fundamental struggle in human existence.

Homo sapiens have been on this planet about 300,000 years and we've been millions of years in the making. It's individual conflict that's shaped us. We're only here because each of us is the product of a collection of genes that has been ruthless in beating out other genes for survival. In that sense, Hobbes had a better idea of human nature and society than Marx. It's not class that defines human society and relationships, it's selfishness. We're all doing what we're built to do - survive and deliver our genetic payload to the next generation.

If history is just a struggle of class against class then your revolution is indeed inevitable. But is such a revolution really necessary. How about this alternative. Let's say your worst nightmare comes true and the United States colonizes the world. What's to say there couldn't be established a "United States of Earth" with hundreds more stars on the Star-spangled banner? What would be so bad about that? It could conceivably done without a bloody revolution (which your revolution would be, judging from the way revolutions usually turn out). It would eliminate the evil US wielding its power against the rest of the world, because the US would be the world. All humans would be entitled to Constitutional protections and would have a say in government.

Not such a bad thing, I'd say.
 
Re: Heavy Stick had a prick,

p_p_man said:
A penis thin and small,
But Heavy Stick being thick,
Couldn't see its size at all...

(with apologies to the emperor and his clothes) ppman

Hwere . . . let me try ppman . . . after all, I just got called in . . . ( to the rhythm of "Little Jack Horner"

Hugely Smuck,
Tried to f*ck
With a penis the size of a pimple,
He shook it about,
Then let out a shout -
He'd popped it in a cheek dimple!

:D :) :p :) :D
 
Last edited:
Sounds Good . . . How Will You Do It??

Oliver Clozoff said:
Of course it has problems, Red! I've never said that it didn't. But nothing that incremental change within this existing system won't fix. No need to "throw the baby out with the bathwater" (as my grandfather used to say).

I don't see society as being potentially perfectable, just improvable. So, I'm on board for lots of reforms of capitalism, including limiting corporate contributions to elected officials and campaigns and making corporate executives more accountable by stiffening punishments for misbehavior (and actually enforcing them - imagine that).

The problem I have with Marxism is its idea that humanity is perfectable. "the alteration of men on a mass scale is necessary" is what Marx said. Hitler also wrote of "the will to create mankind anew. Both sought to perfect societies. I don't think it's possible and I think just attempting to perfect it is what lead to the Stalinist purges, the holocaust, the gulags, the Khmer Rouge, Mao's horrendous cultural revolution, and the rest of the record attributed to fascism and communism. I'm not a "capitalist". I'm a person who believes that capitalism happens to be the least harmful system to individual liberties and the general public good.

I'm intensely distrustful of anyone with a strong ideology, because of Solzhenitsyn said in the Gulag Archepelago, (comparing the Communist leaders to Shakespearian villains): "MacBeth's justifications were feeble - and his conscience devoured him. Yes, even Iago was a little lamb too. The imagination and the spiritual strength of Shakespeare's evildoers stopped short at a dozen corpses. Because they had no ideology."

Radicalism always leads to tyranny and suffering.

Interesting post, OC . . . social change to inflict accountability on the captains of capitalism . . . in Oz Corporations Law the corporate directors are responsible to themselves and NOT the shareholders . . . consequently, any expenditure that can be invoiced is legitimate expenditure, including unearned consultant's fees for politicians . . . as the leader of the State Opposition was exposed recently . . . normally his behaviour would be called "selling political influence", but because it was invoiced it was called "a business expense" and so a legitimate business tax deduction . . .

I would be interested to now how you propose to amend the Corporations legislation to effect these very necessary accountability reforms . . . and especially how you would overcome the vested corporate executive interest in maintaining the present unfettered status quo. :)
 
Re: Re: Thanks, p p man!

Oliver Clozoff said:
I agree to an extent. The course of progress isn't ever straight and smooth. It's usually "two steps forward and one step back", but even with that kind of motion, progress gets made. And for the examples you cited (I assume you meant the reforms of LBJ's Great Society), I'd argue that those "reforms" were more of a "step back" than two steps forward. They never reduced poverty and instead created a sense of entitlement among poor Americans.

I confess that I don't know a whole lot of Marxist theory in depth, but my BA was in history and I know the devastation Marxism wrought in the places where it was implemented wholesale - Cambodia, the USSR, China, North Korea, Viet Nam. You've blamed these failures on the West, but Stalin, Mao, and Pot were worse to Communism than America ever was. Together they killed over 30 million people. Hitler would be envious.

My Marx quote comes from a book called "Ten Theories of Human Nature" by Haberman and Stevenson (1998), page 146. It doesn't give an exact citation to Marx.



I think Marx's observations about the struggles between the classes were very astute and allow us to explain a lot about society we might not be able to otherwise. But I disagree that class is somehow the fundamental struggle in human existence.

Homo sapiens have been on this planet about 300,000 years and we've been millions of years in the making. It's individual conflict that's shaped us. We're only here because each of us is the product of a collection of genes that has been ruthless in beating out other genes for survival. In that sense, Hobbes had a better idea of human nature and society than Marx. It's not class that defines human society and relationships, it's selfishness. We're all doing what we're built to do - survive and deliver our genetic payload to the next generation.

If history is just a struggle of class against class then your revolution is indeed inevitable. But is such a revolution really necessary. How about this alternative. Let's say your worst nightmare comes true and the United States colonizes the world. What's to say there couldn't be established a "United States of Earth" with hundreds more stars on the Star-spangled banner? What would be so bad about that? It could conceivably done without a bloody revolution (which your revolution would be, judging from the way revolutions usually turn out). It would eliminate the evil US wielding its power against the rest of the world, because the US would be the world. All humans would be entitled to Constitutional protections and would have a say in government.

Not such a bad thing, I'd say.

Another challenging post, OC . . .

Doesn't your proposition sound a little like the George Senior "One World Government" speech of 1991??

The U$ is more likely to asset-strip than colonise . . . that way the elite get the benefits without all the hassles of actually moving house . . . you know, just ship the natural resources to the U$ controlled factories where the indoctrinated slave class will process the raw materials into manufactured goods for sale at enormous profit to a world clamouring for more U$ cultural imperialism and materialism . . . leaving the proprietor and managerial classes to reap the benefits of the slave class labours . . .

Don't get me wrong . . . I tend to agree with you that capitalism is better than socialism . . . but there is a third, middle way, as was practised in Oz under the Whitlam Labor government, whereby corporations were encouraged to be socially responsible and, together with government put the best interests of ALL the people ahead of the interests of the few influencial groups of corporate executives wielding the political party funding . . .

Idealism, you say . . . and I agree . . . but in my defence, I say that the Gordon Ghecko "Greed is Good" philosophy is demonstrably bad for both individuals and society alike . . . just look at the present parlous state of the U$ economy . . . and Dubyah Shrub has shot the messengers rather than fix the problems . . . :)
 
OC

No, you don't know much about Marxist theory at all, as I can tell from your post. For one thing, I'm a Trotskyist (as I've stated numerous times), not a Stalinist. The crimes of Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot (killer Cambodian weed) don't touch what I'm saying at all. Trotsky fought against Stalin just as hard as he fought against capitalism. Yet you're quick to condemn Marxism without even knowing much about it. Gee, you'd think an intelligent, fair-minded person would at least want to understand a theory before rejecting it, wouldn't you?

And let me get this straight-- you based your notion on Marxism on a book which apparently only mentions Marx's theory in passing, and which doesn't even give a citation to Marx? That's an incredible statement coming from someone who claims to have an M.D. Are such shoddy standards of scholarship taught in medical school? Before you form an opinion on Marxism, don't you think you should read Marx first-- not some book by someone else which talks about Marx?

And I don't even want to get into your imperialist fantasy about a "United States of Earth." Bush is trying to dominate the entire world, but not so he can bring other countries freedoms traditionally enjoyed here. Don't you follow current events at all? Instead, he's trying to take away our freedom, and reduce us to the status of "Third World" peoples who live under despotic governments. And the really frightening thing is, he's very close to succeeding.

But the most interesting part of your post was your endorsement of a Hobbesian worldwiew. Do you really think the life of humanity, in a state of nature, was "nasty, short, solitary, and brutish"?
Hobbes is an interesting and important thinker, and your reference to him opens up a whole new can of worms. More on him later.
 
Most Important Writers

Off topic, I know . . . Redwave how about PMing me the three/five authors and titles that you think have influenced the modern Western World and its thinking? Thanks. :)
 
Re: Sounds Good . . . How Will You Do It??

Don K Dyck said:
I would be interested to now how you propose to amend the Corporations legislation to effect these very necessary accountability reforms . . . and especially how you would overcome the vested corporate executive interest in maintaining the present unfettered status quo. :)

Well, I admit I don't have a whole lot of answers on this topic. I spend most of my days thinking about neurotransmitters, synapses, and other psych stuff, but I would definitely start with making examples of the higher-ups who were responsible for the fiascos at Enron, WorldCom, Arthur Anderson and other crooked corporations. There has to be a unequivocal message sent that deceiving shareholders, employees, and the general public won't be tolerated. The health of our society depends on public confidence in our institutions and if we can't trust corporations, we won't invest in them. If we don't invest in them, they can't provide us jobs or the services we desire. Without jobs, obviously we can't pay for the other goods and services we want and this effects the abilities of other companies to provide jobs and thus a vicious cycle is begun.

We have to interrupt that cycle by cracking down on lawbreakers like Kenneth Lay and the rest of the Enron crew. Without accountability, people will act in their own self-interest to the exclusion of the interests of others and we've seen what that can produce.

I'd also require corporations to undergo independent auditing. It seems that the way things are done now makes deception for accountants as profitable as for the corporations themselves. The auditors cook the corporation's books, sell the public on the financial health of the corporation, and then the corporation passes on some of the the ill-gotten gains back to the accounting firm. An independent 3rd party needs to be required to take a look at corporations' books.

Your second question, though, is much more difficult. The problem of corporate influence over government is tough. Corporations aren't going to give up their control without a bitter fight. The answer to all questions of major reform usually comes down to public will, but in this case corporations also have a large influence over the media which are where the public derives its information.

I generally reject the premise, though, that the power of corporations is necessarily at odds with the general welfare of our people. Corporations have been a vital part of the high standard of living that we enjoy here.

Bottom line is, I don't know.

P.S. Yes, I'm in favor of a world government, like Papa Bush. It's a loooonng way off, but we seem headed in that direction (EU, NAFTA, etc.) I think it would be the ideal answer to an incredible number of problems.

How to assure everyone representation in such a government is the rub, of course.
 
Trust corporations?

I don't trust corporations. Never have, never will. Bunch of crooks.

I would like to meet someone who does trust corporations, though. Anyone that naive should be easy to take advantage of.
:p
 
Last edited:
My view of Socialism is not one of world management...

as I've said many times before. Centralisation is not workable without incentive and how do you have that when the system is centralised.

No, I see the ideal world as a vertical line of Socialism with horizontal lines of capitalism...

Like a Christmas tree. The central trunk is there but the implementation is carried out through sensible fiscal policies based on world markets...

ppman
 
Re: OC

REDWAVE said:
No, you don't know much about Marxist theory at all, as I can tell from your post. For one thing, I'm a Trotskyist (as I've stated numerous times), not a Stalinist. The crimes of Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot (killer Cambodian weed) don't touch what I'm saying at all. Trotsky fought against Stalin just as hard as he fought against capitalism. Yet you're quick to condemn Marxism without even knowing much about it. Gee, you'd think an intelligent, fair-minded person would at least want to understand a theory before rejecting it, wouldn't you?

I keep hearing you make this "Trotskyist" distinction, but to me it just seems like a convenient way for you to shrug off the obvious failures of communism - and should be pretty obvious that it's been a failure everywhere it's been tried?

Capitalism, on the other hand, has a pretty fair track record strictly based on results. One doesn't have to understand technical marxist theory to understand "all animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others". In the end, both systems have to be judge on results

And let me get this straight-- you based your notion on Marxism on a book which apparently only mentions Marx's theory in passing, and which doesn't even give a citation to Marx?

No, sillyhead. I based that one observation on that book. But you're absolutely right that I ought to know more about Marx before I critique his philosophy in depth. Unfortunately, I work 70+ hours a week and have to keep up with the latest psych literature, so politics is just a hobby. It's on my list to learn more.

But I'm much more well-informed about history and the history of communism in practice is pretty damned sorry.

And I don't even want to get into your imperialist fantasy about a "United States of Earth."

And why not? We indulge your fantasy of the coming worldwide workers revolution almost daily. It wouldn't have to be called the USE if you find that distasteful. In fact, it would probably end up being an outgrowth of the UN. Think about it - if every person on earth had political representation in a single government, so much of the bullshit we now endure would disappear.

Disappear.

And we wouldn't even need to storm the Bastille or push the bougoisie off the land. It could come relatively smoothly.

Now that would be revolutionary.

But the most interesting part of your post was your endorsement of a Hobbesian worldwiew. Do you really think the life of humanity, in a state of nature, was "nasty, short, solitary, and brutish"? Hobbes is an interesting and important thinker, and your reference to him opens up a whole new can of worms. More on him later.

Absolutely. Take a look at the anthropological literature of the last 30 years. Primative societies are far more violent than even the worst inner cities. And look no further than the US-Soviet arms race to see a classic Hobbesian trap - two societies deadly fearful of the other. Hobbes was the most astute judge of human nature I've come across. He rightly judged that the 3 prime human motivators are greed, fear, and desire for social status/reputation. Virtually all human conflict is born of one or more of these. Our laws and governments are formed to minimize this inevitable conflict.

Where Hobbes messed up was positing an unchecked leviathan. We Americans learned pretty fast that the leviathan needs a leash. That's where my other favorite philosopher - Locke - comes in.

But that's another story. Ollie needs sleepie.
 
Last edited:
Amazing!

You work 70+ hours a week, and you still have all this time to post on Lit. Infuckingcredible!
;)

I'd like to continue this discussion further, OC, but I don't have the energy to respond to your postfully right now. My bedtime approaches also.

I'll get back to you tomorrow, OK?
 
You know, those aren't even the REVISED numbers...

That will be out in two or three weeks.

What was it RED? .3 of 1%? Were you even alive when Jimmy Carter was president?
 
Yes

Yes,SIN, I was alive when Jimmy Carter was President. I also remember 1968, the turning point year, very well.
 
Hey there, ppman!

So as far as I can teel, you want a hybrid Socap tree, with a socialist trunk and capitalist branches and twigs.

"Sound fiscal policy" is a euphemism for "screw the workers." And "market socialism" is a contradiction in terms.
 
Back
Top