Define "Fairness" for us.

I cannot deal with it unless you define it.

If you accuse me of mistreating my wife, when I don't, is my denial then proof of my guilty conscience?

I think, in this case, your logic may fail; I would submit that their concern with the word fairness (as I quoted in my first post) is that is is being furled as a battle standard in a culture war aimed at ending their way of life by the Left with its parade of unassailable victims.

My point is one step more meta than yours. The interesting thing isn't the battle over the precise meaning of the word "fairness" (ie "equality of outcomes vs equality of opportunity" or whatever). It's the fact that the political battle you speak of is being fought on this ground at all. Your "classical liberalism" or classical libertarianism as i call it, was once the ideology of "the left". Left and right are not fixed concepts.
 
It's interesting that modern conservatives feel plagued by the word "fairness" and related notions. There's a "guilty conscience" thing going on, probably because "the right" today is just the conservative-leaning side of what was formerly "the left" (going back several hundred years of course).

My "sig" is old-school conservatism.

Actually I often wonder why they don't laugh and point at the socialists that use the word in virtually every possible situation.

Invariably when the socialist begins to yap about 'Fairness' he/she is talking about outcome, not a level playing field or equality of access. Outcomes can never be fair in a free society because the results are quite often tied to the incremental decisions made by the individual. In order to have 'fair', or equal, outcomes the ability for individuals to make decisions must be removed. That's been tried too and not with very good results.

Ishmael
 
My point is one step more meta than yours. The interesting thing isn't the battle over the precise meaning of the word "fairness" (ie "equality of outcomes vs equality of opportunity" or whatever). It's the fact that the political battle you speak of is being fought on this ground at all. Your "classical liberalism" or classical libertarianism as i call it, was once the ideology of "the left". Left and right are not fixed concepts.

Nice tangent.

We didn't begin the battle over fairness, but we must fight where battle is brought.

I would rather fight the battle over ample opportunity which government severely retards as it seeks to create "equal" opportunity but then measures the result in terms of outcome and then declares outcomes "unfair."
 
What gets left outta the Green debate is government regulations.

A local company manufactures golf carts and other electric vehicles, mostly utility. The company wanted to build electric cars for the local market. They cant.

The US Government prohibits any company from selling electric cars if their production is less than 5000 vehicles per year.
 
Fairness, according to Obama from his 2012 Stat of the Union Address:

Quote:
"where everyone gets a fair shot, everyone does their fair share, and everyone plays by the same set of rules. What’s at stake are not Democratic values or Republican values, but American values"


There is a problem with this reasoning, and he is not the only Pol that thinks this way... politicians believe "fairness" is a level playing field by taking/taxing those that have it, and giving to those that do not currently have it. That's my interpretation.
 
Actually I often wonder why they don't laugh and point at the socialists that use the word in virtually every possible situation.

Exactly my point. Why don't they point and laugh?

You can point and laugh at a concept that has no currency, no traction, that's outside the mainstream of discourse.

They can't point and laugh because people care about fairness, however defined.

Every ideology, as manifested in a living, talking, interacting human being, has two aspects: the "hard wired" emotional background and the learned cultural aspect. I think the "hard wiring" of conservatism is at odds with the troublesome fact that our culture values fairness, unlike other, more honor- or warrior-oriented cultures in the past.

At bottom, the conservative soul says "what I have is mine because I took it by means fair or foul, I took it because I possessed the strength, cunning, excellence, luck, to do so." Once "the divine right of kings" supposedly bestowed these qualities upon the aristocracy, now "the market" supposedly recognizes them.
 
Nice tangent.

We didn't begin the battle over fairness, but we must fight where battle is brought.

I would rather fight the battle over ample opportunity which government severely retards as it seeks to create "equal" opportunity but then measures the result in terms of outcome and then declares outcomes "unfair."

Tangents and "the big picture" are my stock in trade.
 
"At bottom, the conservative soul says "what I have is mine because I took it by means fair or foul, I took it because I possessed the strength, cunning, excellence, luck, to do so." Once "the divine right of kings" supposedly bestowed these qualities upon the aristocracy, now "the market" supposedly recognizes them."

Horseshit.

No conservative wants to gain by harm. That's a roundabout slander.

The Leftist (nonconservative) steals because he has armed himself with a morality that convinces him his theft is moral because he did not perpetrate the theft but rather enabled his government to do it in the name of fairness, charity, or equality.

"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that justifies it."

"Sometimes the law defends plunder and participates in it. Sometimes the law places the whole apparatus of judges, police, prisons and gendarmes at the service of the plunderers, and treats the victim - when he defends himself - as a criminal.”
Frédéric Bastiat
 
To the best of your ability anyway. When a politician throws out the word 'Fair' what is the mental image that word conjures for you?

Ishmael



for democrats - fair means "make the rich pay taxes so that I don't have to"

for the union terrorist afl-cio - fair means "stick it to the man and lets bankrupt this company"

for Republicans - get everyone working and everyone paying the same % of income tax and END WELFARE as a career choice
 
"A
No conservative wants to gain by harm. That's a roundabout slander.

Again, you're fighting the battle on "liberal" ground. That's my whole point. Richard ll didn't care if you thought his methods were harmful or not.

Roots of ideology.
 
for democrats - fair means "make the rich pay taxes so that I don't have to"

for the union terrorist afl-cio - fair means "stick it to the man and lets bankrupt this company"

for Republicans - get everyone working and everyone paying the same % of income tax and END WELFARE as a career choice

Simplistic thiinking like this is destructive as well as ...just plain fucking dumb.
Oh, btw...do you vote Republican ?
 
Again, you're fighting the battle on "liberal" ground. That's my whole point. Richard ll didn't care if you thought his methods were harmful or not.

Roots of ideology.

Again, I fight where I am forced to.

If I yield the ground to them, then they win and again begin using my words in creative new ways to force me to fight the battle on their ground; that's why I can't even tell the truth, that I'm a liberal without making myself look like a Socialist.

;) ;)

Now they don't talk about raising taxes, they talk about investments. Where then am I to pick battle ground when they're the "investment" class as well as the owners of the phrase "trickle-down?"

Later, I have to go finish my chicken coop.

Prepping...
 
Again, I fight where I am forced to.

If I yield the ground to them, then they win and again begin using my words in creative new ways to force me to fight the battle on their ground; that's why I can't even tell the truth, that I'm a liberal without making myself look like a Socialist.

;) ;)

Now they don't talk about raising taxes, they talk about investments. Where then am I to pick battle ground when they're the "investment" class as well as the owners of the phrase "trickle-down?"

Later, I have to go finish my chicken coop.

Prepping...

I never noticed that substitution of "investment" for "goverment spending", but you're right. Sly dogs those corporate-welfare-state liberals.
 
Simplistic thiinking like this is destructive as well as ...just plain fucking dumb.
Oh, btw...do you vote Republican ?

obama, pelsoi and the other mentally challenge fucktards force me to vote to the right.

Simplistic thinking? hell no, that is the truth. Democrats are fucking up America with their socialist sickness, while the afl-cio has been given a second to fuck up GM.

I only speak the truth. if you are too fucking stupid to see that, well that is your issue
 
Actually I often wonder why they don't laugh and point at the socialists that use the word in virtually every possible situation.

Invariably when the socialist begins to yap about 'Fairness' he/she is talking about outcome, not a level playing field or equality of access. Outcomes can never be fair in a free society because the results are quite often tied to the incremental decisions made by the individual. In order to have 'fair', or equal, outcomes the ability for individuals to make decisions must be removed. That's been tried too and not with very good results.

Ishmael

Bullshit, and typical straw man. "Sociacialist begins to yap".

Socialism is about equality of opportunity. When Marx spoke about "each according to his means" he wasn't just talking about economics.
 
Bullshit, and typical straw man. "Sociacialist begins to yap".

Socialism is about equality of opportunity. When Marx spoke about "each according to his means" he wasn't just talking about economics.

and that worked out just fine didn't it.
 
Fair is easy to define.

Every individual person pays 10% of their pay for taxes. Every company pays 10% of what they pull in for taxes.
 
Fair is easy to define.

Every individual person pays 10% of their pay for taxes. Every company pays 10% of what they pull in for taxes.

Hard to argue about this. Unless you are a liberal, a tax lawyer, an accountant, an employee of the IRS, or an owner or employee of a tax service.
 
Obama poured hundreds of billions of dollars into the solar industry? Citation is needed oh great Ish. Last I checked he only poured eight hundred billion into the economy as a whole.
 
Back
Top