Do it?

Should Kybele Put Her Dog Down?


  • Total voters
    20
Kybele, by the time there is an obvious answer to this question, it will feel too late. All ways that the timing is clear-cut will happen quite far into any end-of-life condition. That means the two choices are wait for that point, or choose one that is varying degrees of "too early."

Neither choice is very palatable. You'll feel guilty for doing it 'too early' and guilty for waiting until it's too late.

If the question is whether to do it now or in two miserable months, I personally don't think you have a question. Giving a dog two months of misery is not a gift.

If it's a choice of whether to do it now or in three difficult years, that's a different story. In that case, since it is untenable to have dog shit all over your house every day for the next three years, I would suggest giving him away rather than keeping or killing him.

None of the choices are going to be easy, including the the choice NOT to put him down. Since you're at the point of considering it, I think it's time to have the dog any more, one way or the other.

Sorry, and hang in.
 
I had to put my 7 year old Golden down about a month ago. He started limping, took him to the vets, cancer diagnosed, couldn't move three weeks later. I had to carry him into the vets (he weighed 110 pounds) and put him on the table. It was one of the hardest things I've ever done.
 
I also think that the pacing and whining at night isn't neccesarily a sign of pain but more of dementia. I've been there with the every 2 hours thing.

Still, how much longer really has he got? Even in the best of circumstances? I've never been one for heroics when it comes to these things. I've experienced it both ways...

Euthanasia is a gift. One I wish were allowed with humans. It's easy and painless and dignified for the animal if done properly...

I think it's time :rose:


Kybele, by the time there is an obvious answer to this question, it will feel too late. All ways that the timing is clear-cut will happen quite far into any end-of-life condition. That means the two choices are wait for that point, or choose one that is varying degrees of "too early."

Neither choice is very palatable. You'll feel guilty for doing it 'too early' and guilty for waiting until it's too late.

If the question is whether to do it now or in two miserable months, I personally don't think you have a question. Giving a dog two months of misery is not a gift.

If it's a choice of whether to do it now or in three difficult years, that's a different story. In that case, since it is untenable to have dog shit all over your house every day for the next three years, I would suggest giving him away rather than keeping or killing him.

None of the choices are going to be easy, including the the choice NOT to put him down. Since you're at the point of considering it, I think it's time to have the dog any more, one way or the other.

Sorry, and hang in.

This is it. We don't know how much longer he could have and the thought of living with little sleep and shit everywhere for even another 6 months is pretty dreadful. He could also just die suddenly.

How would you persuade someone to take on an old dog who needs pretty much 24/7 care? Few people take on healthy adult dogs, let alone geriatrics like my guy.


Selfish pet owner!!! Now that the dog has gotten older and you have to care a little more for it, you want to put it down.

Grandparents frequently suffer from the same kind of aliments, should they be put down too? :mad:

It's an animal, not a person. I'm perfectly willing to devote myself to providing 24/7 personal to another human being, even one I'm not related to, but not to an animal.
 
As I said, incontinence is one of the things that to me, starts making it a mercy to put them down. Dogs have pride and a healthy dog does not wish to shite himself every day and lie crusted in filth.

One of my best friends is now coping with a dog who wears diapers and eats a $300 a week diet despite being unable to walk more than 50 yards a day. Every time I see that dog, I wish I had a firearm and privacy.

Do what you must, but do it for the dog, not for yourself.

Thank you LadyFairfax.

The O/P has to be responsible to take care of any animals brought in to the home. In the wild the pack would have abandoned him long ago or he would have wandered off to die by himself.

Honestly when I get in that kind of condition and I can't get the doctors to help me I pray some one gives me a pistol and I'll damn sure do it myself.

Kybele take him to the vet and have him put down. When you do, do not just tell the vet put him down and walk away. You owe him a safe and loving way to go. Go in with them and hold him and comfort him as he is injected and make him feel safe as he gos.. He is your dog and you OWE him that last small comfort.

He gave you years of unconditional love now it is pay back time. Put him down and do it right.

Mike
 
I had to put my 7 year old Golden down about a month ago. He started limping, took him to the vets, cancer diagnosed, couldn't move three weeks later. I had to carry him into the vets (he weighed 110 pounds) and put him on the table. It was one of the hardest things I've ever done.

The vet told us he was just really old. It would be easier if we knew he had something like cancer. When the time comes I'm getting the vet out here. To stressful taking him to the vets, he hates the place.
 
dementia, incontinence, stiff, tires easily, can't sleep at night? Kybele, the time has come. Most dogs I have been around don't live to old age. There have been exceptions, and if you think it may be time- It is time.

Don't mean to sound cruel. Everyone can hate me if they want. I would be making a trip to the vet & sharpening my spade.
 

cute dog.

Thank you LadyFairfax.

The O/P has to be responsible to take care of any animals brought in to the home. In the wild the pack would have abandoned him long ago or he would have wandered off to die by himself.

Honestly when I get in that kind of condition and I can't get the doctors to help me I pray some one gives me a pistol and I'll damn sure do it myself.

Kybele take him to the vet and have him put down. When you do, do not just tell the vet put him down and walk away. You owe him a safe and loving way to go. Go in with them and hold him and comfort him as he is injected and make him feel safe as he gos.. He is your dog and you OWE him that last small comfort.

He gave you years of unconditional love now it is pay back time. Put him down and do it right.

Mike

like I said in another post, I'll get the vet to my home when the time comes. We did it with my mum's dog and they have no idea. It's very peaceful.
 
The vet told us he was just really old. It would be easier if we knew he had something like cancer. When the time comes I'm getting the vet out here. To stressful taking him to the vets, he hates the place.
When I brought our big cat in, I asked the vet if I could do the injection myself, alone in the room with the cat (which is against the law). I wasn't about to hand him over and put his last seconds in someone else's hands after all those years.

He let me.
 
The dog put up with you all these years you can at least extend him some freakn courtesy now that he is at the end of his.
 
dementia, incontinence, stiff, tires easily, can't sleep at night? Kybele, the time has come. Most dogs I have been around don't live to old age. There have been exceptions, and if you think it may be time- It is time.

Don't mean to sound cruel. Everyone can hate me if they want. I would be making a trip to the vet & sharpening my spade.

I thought about having him cremated. Unless you mean that you were going to use the spade to save on vet's bills.

When I brought our big cat in, I asked the vet if I could do the injection myself, alone in the room with the cat (which is against the law). I wasn't about to hand him over and put his last seconds in someone else's hands after all those years.

He let me.

Do vets not do house calls in the USA?:confused:

The dog put up with you all these years you can at least extend him some freakn courtesy now that he is at the end of his.
you are all heart.
 
When I brought our big cat in, I asked the vet if I could do the injection myself, alone in the room with the cat (which is against the law). I wasn't about to hand him over and put his last seconds in someone else's hands after all those years.

He let me.

I O. D.'d my dog with pills. It broke my heart to do it but I thought it the most humane way. He went to sleep and didn't wake up. Or maybe he woke up in another body, as a bird or a human.
 
The spade is to give the dog a proper burial.

Yes, my vet makes house calls but it's a lot cheaper to take the dog into his office than paying the extra $75 trip charge. I even haul cattle to him if there is less than 6 to treat.
 
Do vets not do house calls in the USA?:confused:

Some do; we had one in Brooklyn who did. We didn't have one out here in CA yet, and the time differential between finding out how sick he was and putting him down was one (1) long, sleepless weekend of lying on the kitchen floor with him all night. Vet wanted to put him down at the initial visit, I told him we needed the two days to come to grips with it, and if he died along the way, so be it.
 
Selfish pet owner!!! Now that the dog has gotten older and you have to care a little more for it, you want to put it down.

Grandparents frequently suffer from the same kind of aliments, should they be put down too? :mad:

Well, somebody has to do something, if they don't want to go on the cart. It won't be back 'til Thursday.
 
You mean British vets really are like the way they're portrayed in All Creatures Great and Small? That's kinda cool.

Things int' countryside are not allus as pleasant as thee meight a' fust seem. Eur sheep wi' t' liva fluke is nowt ta be ignored, it needs ta be seen ta reet away theur norrz.
 
just do it.
the old ''i'm waiting for him to be in enough pain that i don't feel guilty'' line is shite. don't wait for the pain to come. he's on his last legs.
 
if it were family it wouldn 't be an issue :(

Sorry, had to laugh...some pets are more beloved than human family and they'd pull the plug on their mom but not the cat... Was a time when pets were pets, not people.

Okay, has his quality of life dropped below 10%?

If his world has gotten small and is overwhelming yours, put him gently to sleep if there isn't a doggy retirement home or respite care.

Hell, when our own parents get senile we eventually put them in a home in order to stay sane.

Perspective, people.
 
I sympathize completely with you. I have had the vet out to my house several times to put my old girl down but had her talk me out of it each time.

Bailey is a sixteen-year-old sweetheart black lab who has been in the family for fourteen years. She has hip dysplasia which causes her legs to give out on her sometimes. Her liver failed a year ago, and she had no bladder or bowel control at all. The vet brought her back from that and she eats, shits and pees normally now. She clearly has some form of dementia and paces A LOT, especially at night.

My judgement is based on quality of life and since she still has "puppy moments" I'm going to hang on even though if we are gone for more than four hours (ie work) we probably have a mess to clean up by the back door. As long as my vet tells me she is not in pain and can show me that she still has moments of joy, hang on I say.
 
Back
Top