Do you go to hell if you commit suicide?

well i was going to read the replys to this but, felt no need too.
i would probably come across to many to argue with *L* all though i will give a answer. in romans the good book tells us whosoever call upon the name of the lord shall be saved an have eternal life. look at the first part of this. WHOSOEVER that means anyone an everyone the second part tells us to do what to get saved? call upon the name of the Lord. then the third part is of course the salvation an eternal life. you can take this like you want an claim its just some sorta parable but the bible does have parables (Sp) it also has absolute truths. so i belive if there saved they go to heaven if there not of course they go to hell.
no passing go no 200 dollars.
 
Well then at least call a helpline and talk to someone. Think about your kids. They need you and you need to be there for them.

How much psychological scarring do you think it would inflict on them for you to do this?

Would it not be better to have a family member or your partner (if there is one) take the kids until you sort yourself out?

Asking for help and doing the right thing is better than doing what you're contemplating and leaving your kids to suffer. If it means putting your kids in care while you straighten your problems out, so be it. Better that you're still around for them in some way.
 
Re: Re: Do you go to hell if you commit suicide?

*bratcat* said:


One thing that people don't realize is that if you are taken to the Emergency Dept. from a suicide attempt...the only thing they can do is pump your stomach...suicide attempts do not qualify for CPR or any other lifesaving therapies even if you change your mind and want to live once you are there.

It's been so long since I've quoted someone, not sure if I've done it correctly. Cat, is that a canadian thing? We attempt to save anyone who comes into the E.R., whether it's an accident or suicide attempt. I can't even begin to tell you how many self-inflicted gunshot wound cases we have taken care of. They are then sent to the ICU and considered a full code. We then consult for a Psychiatric evaluation, and treatment for that persons mental status begins. I am baffled by what you have written.

A person is not allowed to die, simply because they wanted to. They are not considered to be in their right frame of mind, therefore for us not to treat them would be neglect on our part.

Am I the only one who is gasping at this?
 
It must be in B.C. only, because here in Ontario, they would try and save the person always. Unless they have a non-rescusitation (sp?) thing in their wallet or have made their wishes regarding same known.
 
There is no such thing as ''metaphysical hell''. All the hells are here on Earth. No. you won't go to ''metaphysical hell''. That's just silly.
 
Unregistered said:
Certainly not a joke or an attempt to get attention. I am truly in pain and I'm so sick of it. I understand why you might think that but it's no joke.

yes i'm bloody selfish because i have children and i know they would suffer as a result, but would it be worse than living with a mother who is unstable and depressed. i would rather die than lose my kids and if i seek help and say i'm suicidal my kids will be taken, so round and round we go.

i'm not so morbid that i can't see the humor in some of your replies and i thank you all.it's natural human desire to reach out to help others even if you don't know them. the point is i have thought so much about this for many years and then it goes away for awhile. but it always comes back and each time worse.

it's cowardly and pathetic. i may not do anything tonight, i'm thinking i can't go thru with it yet.

i will not pm anyone and reveal myself,, that would push me over the edge, thank you anyway.

PLease...please let me talk to you, please? I honestly think I can help you, but you have to let me, first? please talk with me?
 
Looking at this from both sides, I can understand how you feel but I also know what it's like to have a family member commit suicide. My cousin committed suicide when he was 18, 5 years ago and his mother, sisters, and my grandmother (who found him after he shot himself) are still having difficulty dealing with his death. When someone kills him/herself you blame yourself. You wonder why you didn't notice they were depressed and why you couldn't help them. You wonder why you weren't enough for them to live for, that your love didn't mean anything. The question here is, do you want your kids to grow up feeling guilty? Do you want them to blame themselves regardless of whether you leave a note saying it's not their fault? Whether you admit you have a problem or not you will lose your kids. If they are taken away from you, it could be only temporarily, if you commit suicide it's forever.

And in answer to your original question, I don't believe in heaven or hell but I do believe in life after death. According to mediums like John Edward people who commit suicide are no happier when they are dead than when they were alive.
 
Unregistered said:
Even if the pain is unbearable? Is emotional pain and hopelessness worth less than physical pain? (thinking of kevorkian where assisted suicides are justified).

I have a plan for later but I'm not sure because I really don't want to go to hell and suffer even more. No one knows I guess so it's a chance I'll have to take. It couldn't be worse than the hell on this earth.

Sorry this is really grim. Not interested in lectures, sympathy, anyone telling me how selfish and stupid I am. I know all that. It's really too late for pep talks.

Also anyone know if over the counter sleeping pills taken with alcohol will do it? I'd really hate to just fuck up my brain yet still be alive.

I know too many people who have tried and failed....and always want to again...it never leaves them .....

I might not know you but I don't want to see you hurting....I will always listen..I might not have the best advice to give you...but I will atleast listen....
I don't believe that you will go to hell though, personally I think there might be a place for you....of healing and renewal...but maybe not a painless place....*hard to explain* My Significant Other has been battling this issue as well...I worry about them...*sighs* Point is, there might be a place for you, but I don't think it would be painless....
 
Unregistered said:
Certainly not a joke or an attempt to get attention. I am truly in pain and I'm so sick of it. I understand why you might think that but it's no joke.

yes i'm bloody selfish because i have children and i know they would suffer as a result, but would it be worse than living with a mother who is unstable and depressed. i would rather die than lose my kids and if i seek help and say i'm suicidal my kids will be taken, so round and round we go.

Who are you to say that not having their mother in their lives, knowing for the rest of their lives that she preferred dying to being with them is better than having you in their lives trying to get help. Yes, you're right - you are VERY selfish if you are not at least willing to try to get help before offing yourself. At least if you are trying to get help, your children will know that it's a temporary loss of their mom. One of my co-workers did this to her children - 2 years later they are still depressed and angry about it, probably always will be.


i'm not so morbid that i can't see the humor in some of your replies and i thank you all.it's natural human desire to reach out to help others even if you don't know them. the point is i have thought so much about this for many years and then it goes away for awhile. but it always comes back and each time worse.

it's cowardly and pathetic. i may not do anything tonight, i'm thinking i can't go thru with it yet.

i will not pm anyone and reveal myself,, that would push me over the edge, thank you anyway.

I don't know what it is that you're dealing with and if you don't want to share, I understand. It was hard dealing with all of the crap that I've been trying to work through and I have realized a lot of things about myself - including that I've been fighting major depression for a lot of years AND that I've been this way since I was a child. I know what it's like to not want to live BUT if you have even one tiny iota of feelings for your children, please don't do this. Call a hotline and find another way to get help. If you do this, it will get better. There will be a time you will look back on this and wonder what the heck you were thinking. Trust me. I'm sorry if I have come across as angry or bitchy but please think about what you are doing.

Oh, and to answer your question - I don't know. I've been questioning my faith lately so I don't have an answer. I guess it depends on your idea of hell based on your faith. I will say that, if your physical family can be angry that you value your life so little that you can take it, then I would think that your heavenly father would be just as hurt and angry. Since life is a precious gift, yes I believe this is something you could be 'punished' for.
 
Unregistered

Look around......yes yes look around. You have lots of people here who care about you. Enough to look into their own past and pull up thoughts and feelings...when most would rather forget. Why are they doing this? Might I suggest that they believe that sharing their hurt helps....Think about it , eh? Perhaps also they see you as someone who is hurting and just might want to help you deal with this....

People care. We just might not always show it....but deep down we do.

I'm thinking about you. :rose:
 
Unregistered said:
Even if the pain is unbearable? Is emotional pain and hopelessness worth less than physical pain? (thinking of kevorkian where assisted suicides are justified).

I have a plan for later but I'm not sure because I really don't want to go to hell and suffer even more. No one knows I guess so it's a chance I'll have to take. It couldn't be worse than the hell on this earth.

Sorry this is really grim. Not interested in lectures, sympathy, anyone telling me how selfish and stupid I am. I know all that. It's really too late for pep talks.

Also anyone know if over the counter sleeping pills taken with alcohol will do it? I'd really hate to just fuck up my brain yet still be alive.

As a Catholic, I am certain that Hell awaits those who take their own life. I have always been taught this.

I pray you are not considering doing it. It is a very bad thing that likely will impact others. Think about those whom you are thinking of leaving behind.

I speak with some knowlege of this subject. My father took his life in 1975 with a 38 calibre handgun.
 
Please stop!

Go to your community outreach center, call the village or county you live in and get the number now. Tell them you are going through a difficult time, nd need some help to care for your children while you get some counseling.

Even if the kids have to go to state or Foster care temporarily, it is a much better solution than never having a mother/father again.

Please, please take time out and reapproach your problems after you've gotten some help. No one has to be alone.
 
As someone who has thought about suicide a lot and does not see it as necessarily a bad thing, I will say this: Don't commit suicide if only for your kids. You should have responsible attitude towards suicide. I am not going to kill myself while in debt, for example. You shouldn't allow your kids to experience this.

Having a mother that is stressed is probably less traumatic than a mother that killed herself when they were just kids.

I think that if you have someone who depends on you (whether it be an elderly mother or young kids) you shouldn't take your life. Just think of the pain you'll cause.

Plus, you'll feel good again. Guarenteed. There are days where the chemicals in your brain make you sad. This is probably one of those days for you. They're bad for me, too. But maybe in a few days or a week, you'll feel really good for no reason. Focus on those days. Unless you have some condition I'm unaware of.

Truth is, years later, you won't look back and think how silly your suicidal feelings are. You'll think, "Damn, that was bad, but I'm glad I got through it." You will be a survivor. Feel free to PM me as well. I don't know how good I'd be over the phone though.
 
LadyGuinivere said:
Oh, I'm sorry to hear that Laurel. That must be hell on the family. That's why I agree that suicide or attempts are selfish because they wreck havoc on families and friends.

Oh I do agree with this very much!! Suicide is the ultimate selfish act.
 
LadyGuinivere said:
Oh, I'm sorry to hear that Laurel. That must be hell on the family. That's why I agree that suicide or attempts are selfish because they wreck havoc on families and friends.

Well, she's a schizophrenic, so her suicide attempts are very spur-of-the-moment and happen when she's not on her meds. She also acts out violently. From what I read, schizos have the highest suicide rate of any mental illness. It's a weird, compulsive act. She doesn't brood on it - she just suddenly does it. Last year, she drove her car over a 50 foot embankment at Palomar Mountain. It's hard to deal with because it's not something that can be reasoned with. Manu and I spent a lot of time & effort trying to help her, but she refuses to do what she needs to do. My sister would rather self-medicate with pot & alcohol (which worsen things) than take her meds and try to work toward being healthy.

What do you do? Selfishly, I've opted to keep her out of my life. There's nothing I can do to help her, and I'm sick of her showing up on my doorstep either totally weird or violent or however. It may sound cold, but there's not a thing I can do for her. It's a hopeless situation, not unlike many faced by families of schizophrenics.

It's very different from this guy, who sounds like a healthy, stable person who (as we all do sometimes) feels trapped by his life, who has a chance to be happy. He just needs to be strong and do the right thing, not the easy thing.

For your sake and your kids' sake, you need to either get help for your wife or get yourself and your kids out of that unhealthy situation. I know killing yourself sounds easier, but nothing in life worthwhile is easy. You brought those children into the world. If nothing else, you have a responsibility to them to get them out of that bad situation. If you kill yourself and leave them with an unstable mother, then you deserve a hell. No offense, but that's how I feel.
 
Laurel:

Your last post made reminded me of this: the real suicide victims are those who are left behind wondering "why?"

And I agree with everything you wrote! (I did not quote it as it was rather long). Very well done!!!
 
Actually Laurel I am the mother (perceiving myself as unstable because i feel this way).

I like what you said Mechablade, I'm going to repeat this to myself a thousand times a day if I have to "having a mother that's stressed is less traumatic than a mother who killed herself".

I do have ptsd, if that means anything. It seems so shallow in light of the anniversary of sept 11 when those survivors must be in a lot of pain. I feel so guilty for 'navel-gazing' when so many others suffer unbearable traumas.

Thank you all.I really didn't expect an outpouring of support.

I may pm you one day intrigued if I get my nerve up or am feeling low again. Thank you, you're very kind and classy.

One question though... how does it even get to the point of the stomach pumping? Does someone find them before they're dead?
 
JazzManJim said:

I happen to believe it a rather cowardly way out of doing some truly hard, human, work.


Rhys said:
I am probably gonna get flamed for this. I don't care.

Suicide is the ultimate act of pure selfishness. Its the most dramatic act of pure attention getting and ingratitude. Life is a gift, an extremely precious gift, and to piss it away by offing yourself is an act of total cowardice.


I'm sorry, but that is not always the case. Until you are suffering from life-shattering mental disorders you have no right to pass that kind of judgement on a person who is at all suicidal.

You have no idea the anguish and suffering someone with a condition such as Bi-Polar disorder goes through, especially before they are diagnosed and begin treatment for something that fucks up any chance of having a normal life without spending the rest of their life on Medication. Assuming a person is being selfish or a coward is a horrible thing to pin on a person that could have a severe problem and needs treatment.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Do you go to hell if you commit suicide?

*bratcat* said:


IF their body goes into cardiac arrest...there is some sort of policy that does not allow them to be revived. It shocked the hell out of me when I first heard it as well. Tragedies have happened when teens change their minds...

If they survive their suicide attempt...THEN they are given full psych assessments, etc.

Count me as someone who is gasping. I don't believe "some sort of policy" like that exists. Even in Canada.
 
Quiet_Cool said:
Don't quote me, cause religion is clearly not my thing, but I'd bet if there's a God and Hell and all that, you're pretty much screwed if you try it.
In all honesty, see a counselor. No lecture of accusation. people have problems.
Just see a counselor.

Why would you say that? You would think that if there were a God (and assuming he is benevolent), he would have mercy for a person who was in such pain.

Unregistered, I don't think anyone here has any better idea than you do about what, if anything, happens after we die (or die by suicide). But honestly, shouldn't you just be a little more patient? I mean, you're gonna die eventually, but eternity is forever.
 
Last edited:
It must only be in B.C. because I asked family here in the medical field and they were stunned.

Angel, I hear what you're saying, I have someone in my life with BiPolar problems and have gone through a lot with them. The mood swings, the feelings of worthlessness and hopelessness. It's not fun.

However, people who tell others they are planning to commit suicide and then start asking questions about how you get your stomach pumped are obviously either crying out for help or , well, you know.
 
Back
Top