Doomed From The Start.

J

JAMESBJOHNSON

Guest
THESIS: What you learn in college is obsolete/outdated within 5 years of graduation.

I read the above thesis this morning. Based on my life of work and leisure I agree with the thesis. But not completely. Reading, writing, and math pretty much stay in fashion over time.

So whats the benefit of learning stuff that has the shelf life of bananas?

Why not school kids in the basics, and polish it in college? Then let them serve an apprenticeship in their particular profession and trade?
 
THESIS: What you learn in college is obsolete/outdated within 5 years of graduation.

I read the above thesis this morning. Based on my life of work and leisure I agree with the thesis. But not completely. Reading, writing, and math pretty much stay in fashion over time.

So whats the benefit of learning stuff that has the shelf life of bananas?

Why not school kids in the basics, and polish it in college? Then let them serve an apprenticeship in their particular profession and trade?

You mean like doctors who do a residency? Or engineers do do the EIT before becoming a PE? Or accountants who need a minimum amount of experience before becoming a CPA? Or any of the trades who work as apprentices before being allowed to do important stuff?

That's a great idea!
 
You mean like doctors who do a residency? Or engineers do do the EIT before becoming a PE? Or accountants who need a minimum amount of experience before becoming a CPA? Or any of the trades who work as apprentices before being allowed to do important stuff?

That's a great idea!

Some people come out of college as dumb as when they went in, and need an excuse.
 
I learned how to study really efficiently. This comes in handy quite often, actually.

Plus, a lot of what I learned in college will never become obsolete. Plato won't change his opinions in the next 5 years, yaknow?
 
I learned how to study really efficiently. This comes in handy quite often, actually.

Plus, a lot of what I learned in college will never become obsolete. Plato won't change his opinions in the next 5 years, yaknow?

Plato keeps expensive perfessers employed but otherwise he wont help you change a flat tire. Plato is entertainment, like Tom Clancy. That is, Plato takes the place of learning that will help you be useful.
 
No, Plato does not take the place of learning. Plato teaches one how to learn, which is the purpose of all schooling. You are not there to learn a trade, you are there to learn how to think - so that you might advance the trade you choose.

If you believe you will graduate university qualified for an entire lifetime of useful work, you probably were not fit to go to university in the first place.

If you want to learn a trade, go do it as an apprentice, if you want learn to think, so that you might invent a trade - go to university.
 
The thesis assumes that you cease to learn when you qualify and that the process of learning has no value.

It also assumes that your acquired knowledge has a shelf-life. That might be true in the Sciences, but is not necessarily true in the Arts.
 
No, Plato does not take the place of learning. Plato teaches one how to learn, which is the purpose of all schooling. You are not there to learn a trade, you are there to learn how to think - so that you might advance the trade you choose.

If you believe you will graduate university qualified for an entire lifetime of useful work, you probably were not fit to go to university in the first place.

If you want to learn a trade, go do it as an apprentice, if you want learn to think, so that you might invent a trade - go to university.

There's not much evidence university teaches trades or critical thinking. I mean, what do you really understand of Plato from a survey course? I assert that teacher colleges fail to graduate pupils with much grasp of how people learn. If they did larval teachers would come to school prepared to buckle their tool belts on and go to work.
 
Jimbo, if you think bananas have a shelf life of five years, I'm surprised you've lived this long.
 
The thesis assumes that you cease to learn when you qualify and that the process of learning has no value.

It also assumes that your acquired knowledge has a shelf-life. That might be true in the Sciences, but is not necessarily true in the Arts.

No. I'm questioning the utility of education as it now exists.

Earlier today I read an economics article and the writer contends that modern education qualifies students to do squat after graduation. The test determines if the student is 'qualified' NOT demonstrable competence.
 
Back
Top