EPA over reach

They're totally out of control...a bunch of good for nothing bureaucrats who have nothing to do other than justify their useless jobs.

Pathetic.
 
The following excerpt reads as though the reporter's agenda doesn't mesh with Mr. Johnson's position. If he followed "the rules", then logically the government can tell him what to do on his land.

That being said, I hope Mr. Johnson gets to stick a trout up the EPA's ass.



Johnson plans to fight. “This goes a lot further than a pond,” he said. “It’s about a person’s rights. I have three little kids. I am not going to roll over and let [the government] tell me what I can do on my land. I followed the rules.”
 
They're totally out of control...a bunch of good for nothing bureaucrats who have nothing to do other than justify their useless jobs.

Pathetic.

Power crazed zealots. 400 years ago they would have lived in Salem MA.

Ishmael
 
seriously, there is not enough information in this news article to judge either way. There is enough information to make one wonder if he did indeed follow the rules. If he actually built a "stock pond" then there would be no water flowing through it. Trout won't survive in stagnant water. I doubt if there is any "8 acre" piece of ground in Wyoming where he could collect enough rainwater to maintain a pond without blocking a flowing stream.
State agencies issue permits but did they actually inspect the pond to see if it complied with the rules?
 
seriously, there is not enough information in this news article to judge either way. There is enough information to make one wonder if he did indeed follow the rules. If he actually built a "stock pond" then there would be no water flowing through it. Trout won't survive in stagnant water. I doubt if there is any "8 acre" piece of ground in Wyoming where he could collect enough rainwater to maintain a pond without blocking a flowing stream.
State agencies issue permits but did they actually inspect the pond to see if it complied with the rules?

You have to love how the Internet can shed light on a situation and bring knowledge to bear.

Kudos on your post.
 
At first glance, it would appear the EPA might've overstepped it's boundaries. Keep in mind, though, that Fox News always has an agenda. Therefore, I'd like to see an objective account of this affair before proclaimin' my outrage.
 
seriously, there is not enough information in this news article to judge either way. There is enough information to make one wonder if he did indeed follow the rules. If he actually built a "stock pond" then there would be no water flowing through it. Trout won't survive in stagnant water. I doubt if there is any "8 acre" piece of ground in Wyoming where he could collect enough rainwater to maintain a pond without blocking a flowing stream.
State agencies issue permits but did they actually inspect the pond to see if it complied with the rules?

You have to love how the Internet can shed light on a situation and bring knowledge to bear.

Kudos on your post.

Let's start with the fact that he had a sign off by the state engineers at every stage.

My buddy has a cabin in the mtn's of New Mexico. His title confers to him all mineral and water rights. On the property is a spring that runs 24/7/365. He's build a spring house over the head of the spring and then runs the spring into a 300 gal cistern the over flow of which feed a pond he built on the property, which overflows into a creek that feeds a lake that feeds a river that feeds another river that feed the Mississippi.

According to the new waterway reg.s the EPA is rolling out he too is subject to severe federal intervention on his property. Technically speaking both the cistern and the pond represent "dams." And I suppose that the pond represents a source of pollution because leaves and shit fall in it and the elk use it to water and piss and shit in it too, the odd deer and bear as well, not to mention the smaller critters.

The western states are extraordinarily sensitive about interference with natural waterways. Men killed one another of those issues in days gone by. We don't know the method the individual used, but the fact that the state signed off speaks volumes as to how he went about it. It appears that the EPA has redefined, or broadened, the definition of what constitutes a 'dam.'

Ishmael
 
If he built a dam on a stream that flows into a navigable waterway, it looks like he has an uphill battle.

Not all "stock ponds" are exempt:

The exemption applies as long as the activity purpose is NOT to bring an area of the navigable waters into a use to which it was not previously subject (i.e., the flow or circulation of navigable waters may not be impaired or the reach of such waters may not be reduced). If the activity performed results in bringing an area of the navigable waters into a new use, then a Section 404 permit is required for your construction project. See Section 404 at http://www.epa.gov/OWOW/wetlands/regs/sec404.html for further details on the exemptions.

http://www.epa.gov/compliance/resou...ectors/constructmyer/myer1c_dredgeandfill.pdf

It looks like he needed a permit if that area was not used for stock-pond purposes beforehand.

And his reliance on a Wyoming state agency's determination--as opposed to the Corp of Engineer's--looks like it will do little to insulate him.

In most states, you must obtain a Section 404 permit or verify coverage under a general permit from your COE District Office. A list of COE district offices is available at: http://www.usace.army.mil/inet/functions/cw/cecwo/reg/district.htm.
Currently, two states (Michigan and New Jersey) have assumed the role of the COE to issue Section 404 permits;

Based on the little information provided in the article, it looks like he put himself in harm's way by ignoring the permitting process.
 
Let's start with the fact that he had a sign off by the state engineers at every stage.

As HellBentto noted, let's also allow for the fact that the state could have been wrong in granting approval. Or that, as he again noted, trout need running water and not a non-moving pond.


The western states are extraordinarily sensitive about interference with natural waterways.

Bet no one saw that coming when they decided to grow water-intensive alfalfa in California.
 
If he built a dam on a stream that flows into a navigable waterway, it looks like he has an uphill battle.

Not all "stock ponds" are exempt:



http://www.epa.gov/compliance/resou...ectors/constructmyer/myer1c_dredgeandfill.pdf

It looks like he needed a permit if that area was not used for stock-pond purposes beforehand.

And his reliance on a Wyoming state agency's determination--as opposed to the Corp of Engineer's--looks like it will do little to insulate him.



Based on the little information provided in the article, it looks like he put himself in harm's way by ignoring the permitting process.

CJ, think about that for a minute. All water, even the water that runs off your lawn during a rain ultimately ends up in some navigable waterway. (In Corps of Engineer and EPA speak that is any waterway that is, or can be, over 1 ft deep.)

Ishmael
 
Oh yeah, let us not err on the side of liberty. Let's wade through buildings full of government regulatory tomes to find that obscure passage that cancels all his property rights, civil rights, and state laws except ours, cuz he has to be guilty if Fox News is reporting the story.

Actually, what people here are saying is that Fox is probably guilty of mis-representing the story (what a surprise, right?). Mr. Johnson just wants a fucking pond.
 
CJ, think about that for a minute. All water, even the water that runs off your lawn during a rain ultimately ends up in some navigable waterway. (In Corps of Engineer and EPA speak that is any waterway that is, or can be, over 1 ft deep.)

Ishmael

That's been litigated right and left. I'm no expert on the matter and don't care to be. Scalia's plurality opinion in Rapanos v. United States, though, seems to set the scope of the EPA's jurisdiction.

Here's how the EPA summarizes the opinion:

The plurality concluded that the agencies' regulatory authority should extend only to "relatively permanent, standing or continuously flowing bodies of water" connected to traditional navigable waters, and to "wetlands with a continuous surface connection to "such relatively permanent waters.

Seems to me the connection to interstate--navigable--waterways is reasonable.
 
If everybody in Colorado built their own damns Vegas would be drinking dirt.

I think Ish's point about western states being sensitive to interference with natural waterways would indicate that Las Vegas is of the opinion that it should have an abundance of golf courses and manicured lawns despite the fact that it sits in the middle of a fucking desert.
 
Back
Top