Eric Holder should resign

The very first Cabinet member to be held in contempt by either chamber of Congress...
 
After being publicly exposed as an exchange of guns to drug cartels in exchange for support of anti-gun legislation, how anyone could support killing a US law enforcement official to undermine the Constitution is beyond anyones ability to support, and steps firmly into a treasonable act. There's simply no way anyone can make a case for a defense.
 
House could arrest Holder with inherent contempt power

Despite voting to hold Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. in contempt of Congress, there’s little House Republicans can do in the short term to compel him to turn over documents — unless it wanted to revisit a long-dormant power and arrest him.

The thought is shocking, and conjures up a Hollywood-ready standoff scene between House police and the FBI agents who protect the attorney general. It’s a dramatic and unlikely possibility not least because Congress doesn’t even have a jail any longer. But in theory it could happen.

Republicans say it’s not even under consideration, with House Speaker John A. Boehner’s spokesman flatly ruling it out.

But the process, known as inherent contempt, is well-established by precedent, has been confirmed by multiple Supreme Court rulings, and is available to any Congress willing to force such a confrontation.

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/jun/28/house-could-arrest-holder-with-inherent-contempt-p/
 

In order to buy that explanation you have to buy the premise, in this case, by implication, it was the laws of AZ. that were to fault. (One of the others I've heard is that the AZ offices of BATFE were 'under-funded.)

First of all the laws regarding 'straw' purchases of firearms are federal in nature, felonies, and rigorously enforced. What the author of the article fails to mention is that the sellers ALL notified BATFE of the unusual purchases and were instructed to go forward anyway. (The reason that NONE of the dealers have been indicted. You see under federal law the dealers are culpable as well if the purchase is suspected of being a 'straw' purchase.)

Once those purchases were consummated the BATFE could have moved in at the time the second transfer of possession was made. They didn't do that either and they weren't hamstrung by any AZ. law on the subject.

The statements para-phrased by the BATFE agents on the scene that the author refers to are mandatory 'cover your ass' statements. They are, in effect, attempting to blame AZ. law for their failure to follow federal law. And most folks know, or should know, that federal law trumps state law in every case. That was one of the first significant rulings by the SCOTUS shortly after the nation was founded.

Regardless, I reject the authors premise and in doing so have rendered all following explanations as nothing more than a waste of words. And I'm far from being alone in that opinion.

Holder has been found to be both civilly and criminally in contempt of congress. Obama has stepped forth to try to give Holder cover via executive privilege, a privilege that does NOT exist as far as the DOJ's internal documents are concerned. I don't know why Obama has taken this unprecedented step and neither do you. But Obama's action makes me even more curious as to why this unprecedented action is seen as necessary by the administration.

Ishmael
 
In order to buy that explanation you have to buy the premise, in this case, by implication, it was the laws of AZ. that were to fault. (One of the others I've heard is that the AZ offices of BATFE were 'under-funded.)

First of all the laws regarding 'straw' purchases of firearms are federal in nature, felonies, and rigorously enforced. What the author of the article fails to mention is that the sellers ALL notified BATFE of the unusual purchases and were instructed to go forward anyway. (The reason that NONE of the dealers have been indicted. You see under federal law the dealers are culpable as well if the purchase is suspected of being a 'straw' purchase.)

Once those purchases were consummated the BATFE could have moved in at the time the second transfer of possession was made. They didn't do that either and they weren't hamstrung by any AZ. law on the subject.

The statements para-phrased by the BATFE agents on the scene that the author refers to are mandatory 'cover your ass' statements. They are, in effect, attempting to blame AZ. law for their failure to follow federal law. And most folks know, or should know, that federal law trumps state law in every case. That was one of the first significant rulings by the SCOTUS shortly after the nation was founded.

Regardless, I reject the authors premise and in doing so have rendered all following explanations as nothing more than a waste of words. And I'm far from being alone in that opinion.

Holder has been found to be both civilly and criminally in contempt of congress. Obama has stepped forth to try to give Holder cover via executive privilege, a privilege that does NOT exist as far as the DOJ's internal documents are concerned. I don't know why Obama has taken this unprecedented step and neither do you. But Obama's action makes me even more curious as to why this unprecedented action is seen as necessary by the administration.

Ishmael

The last and only time we have seen such an action taken, it was Richard Nixon, and that didn't work out too well for him either. I think this is even more egregious, seeing that it was an attempt to subvert the Constitution resulting in the murder of two US officials, and at least 200 Mexican citizens. Watergate resulted in an office burglary.
 
Probably because Axelrod's been managing the politics in the Justice Department in violation of law.

When the law is no longer followed, there is no love among thieves, and it won't be long before they start eating their own. Holder vs Axelrod is likely only the beginning of the piranha-esque self destruction in Obama's administration.
 
How's the taste of spam in your mouth , Daryl?
 
Holder is guilty of nothing. The President, his boss, has declared Executive Privilege. End of story. Contempt of Congress is shameful grandstanding by the republican party and has no teeth.
 
Holder is guilty of nothing. The President, his boss, has declared Executive Privilege. End of story. Contempt of Congress is shameful grandstanding by the republican party and has no teeth.

You get shit.

I disagree with you on things.

When I disagree with you, I reexamine why.

That is a compliment.
 
Holder is guilty of nothing. The President, his boss, has declared Executive Privilege. End of story. Contempt of Congress is shameful grandstanding by the republican party and has no teeth.

Holder is guilty as an accessory to murder, and obstruction of justice. If Holder is not guilty, then neither were Haldemann and Erlichman, who were also declared innocent by Richard Nxon's executive privilege.
 
Holder is guilty as an accessory to murder, and obstruction of justice. If Holder is not guilty, then neither were Haldemann and Erlichman, who were also declared innocent by Richard Nxon's executive privilege.

I don't pay you much attention.

Now I realize it's because you literally talk out your ass.
 
Holder is guilty of nothing. The President, his boss, has declared Executive Privilege. End of story. Contempt of Congress is shameful grandstanding by the republican party and has no teeth.

What is there about "executive privilege cannot be asserted beyond the executive branch" that you fail to grasp? The DOJ is NOT part of the executive branch. It is a functionary department administered by the executive branch under the oversight of congress and the courts.

Further, his "Boss" is the congress, not the president. The congress makes the laws and authorizes the expenditures. The presidents job is to see that those laws are faithfully carried out and to ensure that those expenditures are made in the public's interest. If officials, such as the Attorney General, were solely employees of the president, congressional approval of the appointment would NOT be required.

Ishmael
 
What is there about "executive privilege cannot be asserted beyond the executive branch" that you fail to grasp? The DOJ is NOT part of the executive branch. It is a functionary department administered by the executive branch under the oversight of congress and the courts.

Further, his "Boss" is the congress, not the president. The congress makes the laws and authorizes the expenditures. The presidents job is to see that those laws are faithfully carried out and to ensure that those expenditures are made in the public's interest. If officials, such as the Attorney General, were solely employees of the president, congressional approval of the appointment would NOT be required.

Ishmael

WRONG

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Attorney_General

The attorney general is nominated by the President of the United States and takes office after confirmation by the United States Senate. He or she serves at the pleasure of the president and can be removed by the president at any time; the attorney general is also subject to impeachment by the House of Representatives and trial in the Senate for "treason, bribery, and other high crimes and misdemeanors."

Go back to school
 
Actually...

...it most definitely does demonstrate who his practical bosses are.

They can impeach the president and they are not his boss.

It's called checks and balances.

For a bunch of guys who pretend to be the great government and legal experts you guys really are woefully ignorant of how this shit works.

My job is done here.

You have been schooled.
 
They can impeach the president and they are not his boss.

It's called checks and balances.

For a bunch of guys who pretend to be the great government and legal experts you guys really are woefully ignorant of how this shit works.

My job is done here.

You have been schooled.

House impeachment, as proven in Clinton's case, carries no who's-the-boss proof at all...

...that fact is asserted when the Senate convicts and the President is Constitutionally removed from the Office of the Presidency.

So the Congress is, indeed, enumerated the Constitutional power to get rid of any President or Attorney General;...

...unfortunately for your perception of "checks and balances", though, the President has no power whatsoever to expel a single member of Congress.
 
Back
Top