Ethical Question


There's a very large and distinct difference between using such information to try to hurt your competition and using it to try to protect the innocent.

"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."
Edmund Burke



Comshaw

Like Bronze pointed out. I am not the only one who knows this for christ's sake. Fuck. I get what you're saying.

What started as a myopic business coup has turned into something more.
 
No, but seriously, real easy for us to tell you what you need to do, man. But you know what's right. You know.
I suspect from your OP that this was in the back of your mind.
it won't be easy or pretty, but it is right.
Think of even one person's life you might be sparing.

It's right. It's worth that moment of "ick" and discomfort.

It is.

You will be doing the right thing, and helping others. That is never wrong!
 
Fuck it. Fine. My wife is a union rep in her district. I will make sure every district within 50 miles knows.

Do it!!! Be proud for doing it.

Think of this: with you disseminating the information that you know, a young girl will grow up to be a success.

You spared her from quite possibly a life of self abuse, drug addiction, depression, maybe even suicide.

You clearly don't know any victims of abuse. Understand this: they often lead tortured lives and many of them become the underbelly of society. That meth head you see walking down the street? She might have been that bright and shiny 14-year-old who was approached by that 37-year-old fuckwit in the hall at school. Predators destroy people.

If you can save but one child from experiencing that, you should.
 
I would just like to point out that the majority of you thought I was the asshole if I used the information....until I mentioned schools.
 
Do it!!! Be proud for doing it.

Think of this: with you disseminating the information that you know, a young girl will grow up to be a success.

You spared her from quite possibly a life of self abuse, drug addiction, depression, maybe even suicide.

You clearly don't know any victims of abuse. Understand this: they often lead tortured lives and many of them become the underbelly of society. That meth head you see walking down the street? She might have been that bright and shiny 14-year-old who was approached by that 37-year-old fuckwit in the hall at school. Predators destroy people.

If you can save but one child from experiencing that, you should.

You're right. I don't know any victims of abuse. This is something that I never would consider doing. When I heard this information I was visually upset and disgusted.
 
I would just like to point out that the majority of you thought I was the asshole if I used the information....until I mentioned schools.

until you mentioned both his crimes and the school bids.
...i was unsure and was about to ask about what he'd done.

there are guys on that megan's law list for boning their 15y/o girlfriend when they were 15 1/2, and using that would be big time shitty.

but this is a mature predator who is targeting schools. BIG difference.
 
until you mentioned both his crimes and the school bids.
...i was unsure and was about to ask about what he'd done.

there are guys on that megan's law list for boning their 15y/o girlfriend when they were 15 1/2, and using that would be big time shitty.

but this is a mature predator who is targeting schools. BIG difference.

Okay, forget schools. Knowing he was 37 assaulting a 14 year old girl, would it be any less assholish if he was bidding on convalescent homes?

To me, he is a dirtbag regardless if he is on a high school campus, city hall or grocery store.
 
Okay, forget schools. Knowing he was 37 assaulting a 14 year old girl, would it be any less assholish if he was bidding on convalescent homes?

To me, he is a dirtbag regardless if he is on a high school campus, city hall or grocery store.

he's a dirtbag whatever.
but there's a difference between a dirtbag just getting on with life and a dirtbag deliberately seeking out places to be around potential victims.

he needs to be kept away from the vulnerable.
 
he's a dirtbag whatever.
but there's a difference between a dirtbag just getting on with life and a dirtbag deliberately seeking out places to be around potential victims.

he needs to be kept away from the vulnerable.

Perfectly said.
 
he's a dirtbag whatever.
but there's a difference between a dirtbag just getting on with life and a dirtbag deliberately seeking out places to be around potential victims.

he needs to be kept away from the vulnerable.

I can't believe that I am being devil's advocate for this guy but here it goes. The types of jobs he would bid at schools are common to our industry and are not the only jobs we (he) would bid on.

So, how can you say he is deliberately seeking out places to be around kids? District jobs would be a small percentage of jobs we bid on. Funnily enough, he beats the shit out of me in one particular city on jobs paid for by the city and the city chamber jobs.
 
Isn't it the courts job to keep him away? I'm sure it states in his probation to keep so many feet away from schools.
they can only enforce what they know about. they can't afford to track the movements of every criminal who gets released.
 
Isn't it the courts job to keep him away? I'm sure it states in his probation to keep so many feet away from schools.

The courts don't enforce until the tail end after they've already been caught. It's the duty of the police to monitor and enforce, and they're overburdened. That's why people like you are so critical to prevent abuse. The more people who report, the better it is for everyone. It may be difficult, it may make you feel terribly, you may feel it's not your responsibility... but it's the RIGHT thing to do.
 
they can only enforce what they know about. they can't afford to track the movements of every criminal who gets released.

And here lies personal responsibility. Anyone who is contracting out work should know if they are dealing with someone licensed, bonded, insured, convicted etc...

This information isn't hard to come by.
 
And here lies personal responsibility. Anyone who is contracting out work should know if they are dealing with someone licensed, bonded, insured, convicted etc...

This information isn't hard to come by.

and if they're lapse,
do we all sit back and ignore it?
wait for a kid to get raped,
then smugly say that we could see it coming?
 
The courts don't enforce until the tail end after they've already been caught. It's the duty of the police to monitor and enforce, and they're overburdened. That's why people like you are so critical to prevent abuse. The more people who report, the better it is for everyone. It may be difficult, it may make you feel terribly, you may feel it's not your responsibility... but it's the RIGHT thing to do.

How about this. I only say something if he is bidding or doing work where he is around young girls.
 
How about this. I only say something if he is bidding or doing work where he is around young girls.

Well, duh. You absolutely should do that.

It's not the problem that he's making a living, it's the notion that he HAS ACCESS to school children; and he also may have access to kids elsewhere. You have that knowledge, you have the power to do something about it.
 
Well, duh. You absolutely should do that.

It's not the problem that he's making a living, it's the notion that he HAS ACCESS to school children; and he also may have access to kids elsewhere. You have that knowledge, you have the power to do something about it.

I get this. I really do. But what I can't wrap my head around is that shouldn't everybody be made aware?

I just find that because he is around schools is a cop out. Kids are everywhere.
 
For the most part, isn't that what we do?
i hope not.

when my kid got a letter, accidentally handed to her when a church group was in her school, it set off some deafening alarm bells. i went to the school, to the police, told every parent i knew about the issue.
nothing had happened to my kid. she was fine. she never even met the man. you could say it wasn't my business or my problem.
but the kids who went to that church were around a man who had no business being around children.
i kicked up a stink.
eventually something came of it.

the other church members were lapse. they didn't see what they didn't want to see. had i not minded being scowled at as a trouble maker, nothing may have been done.
 
I get this. I really do. But what I can't wrap my head around is that shouldn't everybody be made aware?

I just find that because he is around schools is a cop out. Kids are everywhere.

it tends not to be a kid snatched up off the street.
it's usually the child of a friend/relation,
or a kid they get to spend time with at work/clubs.

any small steps you can take to reduce his chances are worth it.
 
i hope not.

when my kid got a letter, accidentally handed to her when a church group was in her school, it set off some deafening alarm bells. i went to the school, to the police, told every parent i knew about the issue.
nothing had happened to my kid. she was fine. she never even met the man. you could say it wasn't my business or my problem.
but the kids who went to that church were around a man who had no business being around children.
i kicked up a stink.
eventually something came of it.

the other church members were lapse. they didn't see what they didn't want to see. had i not minded being scowled at as a trouble maker, nothing may have been done.

You are probably going to think I'm a terrible person, if you already don't. But that was your child. Of course you would do that. I don't have kids. I am not directly involved.
 
You are probably going to think I'm a terrible person, if you already don't. But that was your child. Of course you would do that. I don't have kids. I am not directly involved.

i would do the same for any child.
my kid picked up a piece of paper and forgot it's contents within days.
my concern wasn't for my kid. my anger was that he was around other people's kids.
 
I found out a competitor is on Megan's Law. He is a total asshole and talks shit about me all the time.

I just recently found out this info. I have had beers with him before I knew.

Would you use this as a competitive edge? I haven't, yet.

you will look like a total shit, but if he gets the bid for the school then you are morally obliged to inform the school that he is a known sex offender. If he loses the contract then tough.
 
Back
Top