Euthanasia. What are your thoughts?

I have also believed if people want to die, they should have a right to take their own lives or have somebody else do it for them.
 
I spend a fair amount of time at the pointy end of watching people die. all too often they are frightened and, despite medication, in distress. i'll spare you all the details.

our societies need a complete rethink on how we deal with death. fear of death causes far too much suffering, and the fear and denial of the families & carers of the dying increases that suffering greatly.

if a person is facing months suffering, with no quality of life, distressed and in pain, how can any civilised society deny them a dignified end? they're still going to die either way.
 
Yeah. She died alone.

It's ... Heartbreaking.

http://forum.literotica.com/showpost.php?p=49371573&postcount=294783

"It is an awful thing to die alone," said Dr Edelman. For Mr Cordover, 24, memories came flooding back of his father's death in June 2009. Robert Cordover was a marine biologist who spoke seven languages. He was also stricken by motor neurone disease and ended his life with Nembutal. Mr Cordover was anxious for Ms Ranke.

"The fact that she was alone really kept me awake all night. It really felt unfair, unjust, that somebody who deserves such a good passing at the most vulnerable time of their life should be denied it against her will."
 
Controversial subject

Aruna Shanbaug is a former nurse from Haldipur, Uttar Kannada, Karnataka in India. In 1973, while working as a junior nurse at King Edward Memorial Hospital, Parel, Mumbai, she was sexually assaulted by a ward boy, Sohanlal Bhartha Walmiki and has been in a vegetative state since the assault. On 24 January 2011, after she had been in this status for 37 years, the Supreme Court of India responded to the plea for euthanasia filed by Aruna's friend journalist Pinki Virani, by setting up a medical panel to examine her. The court turned down the mercy killing petition on 7 March 2011.
 
Back in 1999, at Christmas, my grandmother announced that life was no longer fun and she died 3 days later. She was 90 and had lived alone, in her home forever. My aunt prepared her meals and saw her every day, to check on her and take her to appointments, shopping. But the old lady fell and broke her hip, and hadda go in a nursing home. She hated it, and disliked people. So she checked out.

I usta visit her and bring McDonalds to share. She never hinted to anyone her real sentiments and curiosities, but saved them for me as I never kiss and tell. So we discussed sexual curiosities and sexual things she didn't understand, and would never talk to her daughters about. She trusted me.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back in 1999, at Christmas, my grandmother announced that life was no longer fun and she died 3 days later. She was 90 and had lived alone, in her home forever. My aunt prepared her meals and saw her every day, to check on her and take her to appointments, shopping. But the old lady fell and broke her hip, and hadda go in a nursing home. She hated it, and disliked people. So she checked out.

Sounds like a plan.
 
For me it is an act of mercy. Is it really better for the person or more convenient for the family? The law prefers to err on the side of caution. I get the reasoning, but some cases (like Aruna) just cry out for mercy.
 
I spend a fair amount of time at the pointy end of watching people die. all too often they are frightened and, despite medication, in distress. i'll spare you all the details.

our societies need a complete rethink on how we deal with death. fear of death causes far too much suffering, and the fear and denial of the families & carers of the dying increases that suffering greatly.

if a person is facing months suffering, with no quality of life, distressed and in pain, how can any civilised society deny them a dignified end? they're still going to die either way.

^^^^^^^^This

On a personal note, my grandfather was so afraid to die, he hung on long after he should have passed. I watched him become less than he was and my last memory of him is not a good one.

It would be nice to think that one day people wouldn't be so afraid to die. If the fear (usually based in some kind of religious teaching about hell or punishment or karmic debt) was gone, then maybe choosing to take your own life in a dignified, safe manner would finally be legally sanctioned.

Also, just a thought - most people seem to think it's ok to put down an animal that has very poor health / low quality of life. It's seen as the the 'humane' thing to do.

So why is it we deny our sick and broken beyond repair people we supposedly love the dignity of a peaceful, painless death?

Everyone in my immediate family has a living will that includes power of attorny to 'euthanise under x conditions if legal to do so or transport to a country where euthansia is legal'.
 
There are many things worse than death. Chronic physical or emotional pain lower the quality of life to not worth living for many people.

However, the taboo is in place for good reasons. People also shouldn't have to feel that for a variety of social reasons that they are a burden on others and that their "time is up" even if they'd like to hang around a while longer.

So in reality the taboo should stay for obvious reasons, to protect those who have a chance at "it gets better" and who can bear up under their burdens and appreciate their own life or the community of others.

For those who don't have a chance, it might redouble their grief, but many people and doctors find ways of mercy that aren't subject to the law and that should continue and be recognized as a compassionate act, and not murder. If the death is consensual, there shouldn't be any legal burden for compassion.

Determining consensuality over social coercion or free will is left to those up close and personal. It is complicated by actual murder being framed as suicide. How can you tell what really happened? Investigation without prejudice. Yeah, I think that someone who kills someone and frames it as a suicide deserves the death penalty. Do I want to let the murderer go out of compassion for the possible victim? No. So I have to keep investigative techniques in place, but I would like an extra part to the law that if consensuality and free will are involved, the stigma is removed and compassion is considered to be the motive.
 
^^^^^^^^This

On a personal note, my grandfather was so afraid to die, he hung on long after he should have passed. I watched him become less than he was and my last memory of him is not a good one.

It would be nice to think that one day people wouldn't be so afraid to die. If the fear (usually based in some kind of religious teaching about hell or punishment or karmic debt) was gone, then maybe choosing to take your own life in a dignified, safe manner would finally be legally sanctioned.

Also, just a thought - most people seem to think it's ok to put down an animal that has very poor health / low quality of life. It's seen as the the 'humane' thing to do.

So why is it we deny our sick and broken beyond repair people we supposedly love the dignity of a peaceful, painless death?

Everyone in my immediate family has a living will that includes power of attorny to 'euthanise under x conditions if legal to do so or transport to a country where euthansia is legal'.

People fear death when they feel unloved and unhappy.
 
Isn't it mostly the fear of the unknown; not knowing what comes next?

A non-really-suicidal person fears death. A really-suicidal person fears life. I am the really suicidal person. Death sounds like an amazing deal on some days. It is a comforting thought, a refuge, a meditation, an inevitability to embrace. I will eventually get what I want, I just have to wait.

There is a genuine difference and an important distinction. Why do I fear living, why would I not fear dying.
 
Isn't it mostly the fear of the unknown; not knowing what comes next?

Not from what I've seen.

My mother in law opted to die surrounded by all her kids and grandkids, when the celebration of her life was completed the MD pulled the plug and she drifted away. It wasn't sad at all, she had been loved and cherished for 80 plus years, and she didn't want to remain tied to a machine. So the big day was picked, everyone came from all over the planet, folks said what they wanted to say to her, she said what she wanted to say to us, and that was it.
 
A non-really-suicidal person fears death. A really-suicidal person fears life. I am the really suicidal person. Death sounds like an amazing deal on some days. It is a comforting thought, a refuge, a meditation, an inevitability to embrace. I will eventually get what I want, I just have to wait.

There is a genuine difference and an important distinction. Why do I fear living, why would I not fear dying.

I agree.

The point I was trying to make was how some people hang on simply because they are afraid to let go. Uncertain of what comes next they'd rather hold on to their miserable lives.

(I'm not talking about suicidal folks, just the terminal variety where everyone is sitting around waiting because everyone knows the person is past the expiry date)
 
I agree.

The point I was trying to make was how some people hang on simply because they are afraid to let go. Uncertain of what comes next they'd rather hold on to their miserable lives.

(I'm not talking about suicidal folks, just the terminal variety where everyone is sitting around waiting because everyone knows the person is past the expiry date)

Yeah, that's why I'm drawing a distinction. All the taboos are in place to rescue those who might want to fight to live.

There's genuinely...nothing you can do for those who want to fight to die. It's up to them, you can't actually prevent it.

I would compare it to having a great deal of treatment for something that can be cured, even if it's a long shot, like cancer. Thinking you need to die but you're terrified of dying is more like cancer. With the right therapy and heroic measures, you might pull through. People can choose between metaphoric chemo and metaphoric radiation or just slipping away.

There is no treatment for the other kind. So that's why I'd say the taboo has real benefits. It has drawbacks...and I'd like to see the religious taboo disappear as it's doing more harm than good to surviving families who are tortured by the idea of their loved one being denied salvation. If someone is driven to that point, regardless of cause or reason or lack thereof, I'd like to limit the collateral damage to the living.

For best social results, treat every case as if it were curable. Don't relax the taboo because that's going to result in a lot of needless suicide as a result of unintended consequences of relaxation of a required taboo.
 
There are two aspects to this question. The legal and the moral.

Looking at it legally, I fear the legalization of euthanasia (I'm referring to actual mercy killing and not passive euthanasia) can easily be exploited.

Looking at it from a moral standpoint I see it as an act of compassion.

The real trick though is establishing that the situation really called for it.

For me Aruna's case has always been pretty clear cut, but the SC didn't see it that way. Who then qualifies for mercy?
 
Its hard to defeat a life that wants to live.

In Vietnam I experienced a head injury that fractured my skull and broke most of my teeth. I was knocked senseless (couldn't see, hear, speak, or move) but was aware of my thoughts. So I decided FUCK THIS, I AINT GONNA DIE. And I came back from a dark place. No brilliant white light or 71 virgins.
 
There are two aspects to this question. The legal and the moral.

Looking at it legally, I fear the legalization of euthanasia (I'm referring to actual mercy killing and not passive euthanasia) can easily be exploited.

Looking at it from a moral standpoint I see it as an act of compassion.

The real trick though is establishing that the situation really called for it.

For me Aruna's case has always been pretty clear cut, but the SC didn't see it that way. Who then qualifies for mercy?

Lawyers always find a way to change the definitions of words. Its never wise to open the door to them.
 
Lawyers always find a way to change the definitions of words. Its never wise to open the door to them.

Yeah, and law is not about justice, it is about law.

It is supposed to be a deterrent and when it isn't, it can simply make things more unjust.

I'm not sure there is a viable legal option, particularly with many religions and philosophies opposed to suicide for genuinely good reasons.
 
Its hard to defeat a life that wants to live.

Nicely put. :rose:



In Vietnam I experienced a head injury that fractured my skull and broke most of my teeth. I was knocked senseless (couldn't see, hear, speak, or move) but was aware of my thoughts. So I decided FUCK THIS, I AINT GONNA DIE. And I came back from a dark place. No brilliant white light or 71 virgins.

I've been in that kind of situation (won't get into any details here). Our will is the most powerful tool we own.
 
Yeah, and law is not about justice, it is about law.

It is supposed to be a deterrent and when it isn't, it can simply make things more unjust.

I'm not sure there is a viable legal option, particularly with many religions and philosophies opposed to suicide for genuinely good reasons.

Attempted Suicide is illegal here. So if you are unsuccessful in your attempt you have the cops waiting for you at your bedside.
 
Back
Top