Exploring sexuality

Re: Is it socialization, or is it hereditary?

Ramlick said:
The opinion so far is that women are more apt to try homosexuality (although this is far from scientific). I'm sure there is data on the subject. But if it's true, I'm not so sure it's socialization only. I'm sure there's something biological about it too. Something in the nature of women vs. men. I'm reading a fascinating book on the subject of human nature right now called "The Blank Slate" by Steven Pinker. His hypothesis is that hereditary plays a larger role in who we turn out to be than many are comfortable with accepting.

I'd like to agree that heredity/genetics plays a part. I tend to reflect on relationship issues, and I once tried to see things from a homosexual man's point of view, and looked for any feature of a man that I found exciting. It didn't work; men don't turn me on at all.

That having been said, I think socialization plays a tremendous and far more important part in reinforcing fear/reluctance of homosexuality. I've been involved in multiple guy/multiple girl scenes, and I've noticed that the ladies have no problem touching each other, even doing so deliberately, whereas men leap away from the slightest contact with each other, even getting upset over accidental non-sexual brushes. I doubt that biology can entirely account for that kind of behavior. But, I'm no scientist...

2¢.
 
I dont think it is fair to generalize. It may be harder for younger women to experiment because there is MUCH STRONGER pressure from their parents and the expectations but on young women are sooooo unfair. Men are expected to break free and find themselves, sew their wild oats and then capture a woman. A woman is expected to be "passed" from her father and his family to another man... so where men have time to figure themselves out without the watchful eye of their parents, women find themselves always being watched. I wish it was easier for all of us. I know that when I came out three years ago as bisexual that it was easy for me to find guys who were out and who had parents who knew, while the women I knew at the time who were out did not usually have the ability to tell their parents out of fear of loosing them and/or their support. I think women have it harder on this one.
 
Re: Re: Exploring sexuality

perky_baby said:
more likely? I don't think it's more prevalent than female experimentation, I just think it is more hidden.

i blow more married men that way.
 
Re: Re: Re: Exploring sexuality

glamorilla said:
i blow more married men that way.
I'm sure. I've done my homework. <grinning>
 
I am a straight man that in my distant thought that my liking of anal play must have made me bi. I tried it out and found that though I still loved anal play, men did very little for my in terms of turning me on.
A recent gf had some trouble adjusting to the fact that a straight guy could enjoy anal play so much without being gay or bi. I took a while but she learned that it was just something I found to be pleasurable without affecting my sexuallity.
Just my 2 cents worth.
Take Care and Lust Always,
Ezarc
 
My two cents

Ezarc said:

A recent gf had some trouble adjusting to the fact that a straight guy could enjoy anal play so much without being gay or bi. I took a while but she learned that it was just something I found to be pleasurable without affecting my sexuallity.

Guess who! For someone so open about my sexuality, it was a new experience to be with a man who enjoyed anal stimulation. My ex was so phobic about it he would literally go soft if I got to near his ass. It is a lesson I am glad I learned, it gives so many new ways to pleasure someone to feel that closeness of knowing every inch of their body and its responses. and that is just my two cents.
 
Nature vs. Nurture

I think the sexually enlightened group who have contributed to this thread would be in agreement that homosexuality is something that one has no control over. In other words, that one is born a homosexual. The vast majority of homosexuals claim this to be true, especially when defending their rights or fighting discrimination. So there is a slight contradiction I'm finding in the arguments that socialization has such a great role in this matter of experimentation. I for one, am a male who has absolutely no desire to experiment with homosexuality. It just wouldn't turn me on. Porn isn't socially acceptable , yet nobody has a problem feeding that craving in a secretive manner. If men were turned on by other men, they'd have clandestine affairs, just as they feed their other kinky, socially unnacceptable desires. No, I don't think the socialization arguments are valid. People will satisfy their desires. But they won't try something that they innately find a turn-off.
 
Re: Nature vs. Nurture

Ramlick said:
I think the sexually enlightened group who have contributed to this thread would be in agreement that homosexuality is something that one has no control over. In other words, that one is born a homosexual. The vast majority of homosexuals claim this to be true, especially when defending their rights or fighting discrimination.

I think that to frame sexual enlightenment in terms of agreement with you is more than a bit presumptuous.

I do not agree that homosexuality is exclusively biological. Or, perhaps I should say that I'm not convinced one way or the other. I'm bisexual, and though I feel that I've always been that way, it would have been very easy for me to never explore my attraction to women, had the currents of my life not taken me in that direction. But ultimately, I chose to explore my attraction to women, after much thought, and research. I did not follow my clit wantonly to the first set of tits and pussy that it magnetically pulled me to, as a biological determinism argument would imply. I maintain that all of sexuality is based on choice-- that is why celibacy remains an option. If heterosexuals are "born that way" just as you claim homosexuals are, then does that mean that a heterosexual person who chooses to be celibate is not heterosexual?

So there is a slight contradiction I'm finding in the arguments that socialization has such a great role in this matter of experimentation. I for one, am a male who has absolutely no desire to experiment with homosexuality. It just wouldn't turn me on.

If it's innately biological, then how do you explain the phenomenon of closeting? Or of people who never explore their "biological urges" because of religious and socially induced shame and stigma? If it were as cut and dry as biological determinism, it would be just another accepted thing. But socialization works to thwart just as much as it does to assist. We will never be able to remove the human animal from the environment that molds it. There are societal factors that affect us regardless of biology. There are too many variables in the human experiment to say that socialization plays no role.

Porn isn't socially acceptable , yet nobody has a problem feeding that craving in a secretive manner. If men were turned on by other men, they'd have clandestine affairs, just as they feed their other kinky, socially unnacceptable desires. No, I don't think the socialization arguments are valid. People will satisfy their desires. But they won't try something that they innately find a turn-off.

Men do have clandestine affairs that encompass homosexual activity. They do not call themselves homosexual, perhaps, but it does happen. Men who consider themselves heterosexual still have glory hole sex, and all other manner of homosexual dalliances. Not all, but certainly more than a few. Do they admit it out loud, to themselves and others? No, because that would make their homosexual tendencies more real. It's not a matter of biological determinism, as much as it is a matter of self-labeling and statistical inaccuracy. Now, I don't doubt that you, personally are 100% straight with no desires for other men. You have no reason to mislead me. I do think, however, that it is a bit naive of you to think that your experience as a straight man represents all mens' experience (as straight men). Many men who call themselves straight simply haven't been as stringent with their straightness as you have. No survey on the subject will ever be perfect, because there is too much stigma and shame involved.

And that all comes right back to, you guessed it....socialization.
 
But ultimately, I chose to explore my attraction to women, after much thought, and research.

My point had to do with having the desirre, or attraction as you put it, in the first place. Are you claiming that the desire you feel toward women isn't innate?

If heterosexuals are "born that way" just as you claim homosexuals are, then does that mean that a heterosexual person who chooses to be celibate is not heterosexual?

Whether a person chooses to be celibate or not isn't germaine to my argument because whether one chooses to act on a desire doesn't mean they don't have the desire. My only concern is whether they in fact have a particular desire. The sex desire, just like the desire to eat or sleep, is biological.

If it's innately biological, then how do you explain the phenomenon of closeting? Or of people who never explore their "biological urges" because of religious and socially induced shame and stigma?

Again, I'm talking about whether the desire itself is inborn. Whether one acts on their desire isn't material.

But socialization works to thwart just as much as it does to assist. We will never be able to remove the human animal from the environment that molds it. There are societal factors that affect us regardless of biology. There are too many variables in the human experiment to say that socialization plays no role.

Unless you are saying that socialization can actually mute a desire for sex (not the zeal to which one goes about satisfying that desire), then this point is irrelevent.

No, because that would make their homosexual tendencies more real. It's not a matter of biological determinism, as much as it is a matter of self-labeling and statistical inaccuracy.

So you're saying that the desire that otherwise heterosexual man have to have sex with men is not biological. If that's true, why would they find it pleasurable? And how do you know they're not homosexual, or bi-sexual, anyway?

I do think, however, that it is a bit naive of you to think that your experience as a straight man represents all mens' experience (as straight men). Many men who call themselves straight simply haven't been as stringent with their straightness as you have.

I never said that I represent all men. I'm not being "stringent" with my straightness. I have no homosexual proclivities. I'm sure many men do and don't act on them, and I'm sure many do. How they behave may in fact be partly influenced by socialization, I would never deny that. But the desire is biological.
 
Last edited:
Ramlick said:
My point had to do with having the desirre, or attraction as you put it, in the first place. Are you claiming that the desire you feel toward women isn't innate?

I think I understand what you're getting at now. Yes, it is true that the desire I feel for women is a physical thing. It is certainly not something that popped into my head one day after I saw a lesbian-chic advertisement in a magazine, or saw two girls kissing in a nightclub.

Whether a person chooses to be celibate or not isn't germaine to my argument because whether one chooses to act on a desire doesn't mean they don't have the desire. My only concern is whether they in fact have a particular desire. The sex desire, just like the desire to eat or sleep, is biological.

I think that it is relevant, because your initial query was about a tendency toward experimentation. When you establish heterosexuality as the default mode from which same-sex experimentation departs, you must include all degrees of heterosexuality along the spectrum. Your initial query focused on choice, essentially, and my point with celibacy is that humans are able to rationally choose to overcome or displace the biological urge that you argue is so compelling. If a heterosexual is able to choose celibacy, then how does that speak for other sexual choices? It does remain, also, that there are people who experiment with same-sex activities, yet stick primarily to a heterosexual lifestyle. Same sex activities do not equate biologically determined homosexuality. If your question was about biologically determined sexual drives, then why did you frame your initial query as one of experimentation? Experimentation is, essentially, an exercise of choice. It is not a means to the end of sexual identity formation, in all cases.

Again, I'm talking about whether the desire itself is inborn. Whether one acts on their desire isn't material.

All sexual desire is inborn, to a degree. The primary biological function of sex is reproduction. Socially, though, sexuality means much, much more than simple duplication. If we were arguing this point from a strictly reproductive POV, I could see the validity of your argument. But sexuality manifests itself as a very broad spectrum of activities, not all of which are copulatory, even. Every sex act is not a copulatory act, with the intent to make a baby. To exclude socialization from your understanding of human sexuality, regardless of orientation, misses a huge point.

Unless you are saying that socialization can actually mute a desire for sex (not the zeal to which one goes about satisfying that desire), then this point is irrelevent.

I think you're extrapolating a little broadly here.

So you're saying that the desire that otherwise heterosexual man have to have sex with men is not biological. If that's true, why would they find it pleasurable? And how do you know they're not homosexual, or bi-sexual, anyway?

First off, please do not paraphrase me incorrectly. I did not make a definative statement, I simply said there was no way for me to separate the social from the biological.

You're straying from your initial argument, here. If the initial question was about something as amorphous as 'tendency to experimentation' and now you're getting concrete, it doesn't make much sense. If your mind was already made up, then why did you initiate a discussion on the topic?

And the question of what men find pleasurable is as mystifying to me as it is anyone. Men find it pleasurable to get drunk and have sex with women they would never fuck sober, and they do the same thing with men, and sheep, and other random holes. I don't think the issue of pleasure is as complex as you're making it. People like to get off. The way they choose to get off doesn't necessarily make them one thing or another.

I never said that I represent all men. I'm not being "stringent" with my straightness. I have no homosexual proclivities. I'm sure many men do and don't act on them, and I'm sure many do. How they behave may in fact be partly influenced by socialization, I would never deny that. But the desire is biological.

You may not have said that you represent all men in actual words, but the strength of your assertions implied that you were. If you're just throwing out ideas, take care to use language that would imply such a thing.

And you're waffling on your argument, ultimately.

Say what you mean, and mean what you say.
 
Last edited:
I'm going to fall somewhere in between you two (Ramlick & SLG) on this. I don't think you're directly disagreeing with each other, though.

I'm not especially swayed either way by the arguments that sexual orientation is wholly genetic or choice. Despite my 3-year-old brain that likes things black & white, I think it's incorrect to try to fit much of anything human into a dichotomy.

I've heard of studies saying that, if one identical twin is homosexual, there's a 50% chance the other will be. Or a study that a homosexual is so many times more likely to have a sibling who is a homosexual. How would you control out that correlation being just as much a result of a social environment these family members shared rather than genetics?

And I don't think the easy quotes on other mammals that exhibit homosexual behaviors give enough credit to those animals abilities to learn. And, despite being a staunch biological evolutionist, I don't think what we observe in animals always holds true for the human animal.

As for the original question of the thread - the bell curve probably applies well if you put 100% heterosexual on one end and 100% homosexual on the other. I'd suspect the curves for men and women, at least in Western culture, wouldn't match each other well. The curve for men would be slanted more toward the hetero side, and that has little to do with genetics. Intolerance seems to be in our genes more than sexuality.
 
Well said, WaxNWane. I too, am undecided on the issue. I do believe that sexuality is very much a biological thing, but I am hesitant to place any definitive labels on such a slippery thing. I don't think we are disagreeing directly either-- I just got all huffy because I didn't agree with some assertions that were made blanketly. You just said, oh-so-much more eloquently, what I wish I had said.

OK, panties are out of knot mode. At least for the time being..... :D


WaxNWane said:
I'm going to fall somewhere in between you two (Ramlick & SLG) on this. I don't think you're directly disagreeing with each other, though.

I'm not especially swayed either way by the arguments that sexual orientation is wholly genetic or choice. Despite my 3-year-old brain that likes things black & white, I think it's incorrect to try to fit much of anything human into a dichotomy.

I've heard of studies saying that, if one identical twin is homosexual, there's a 50% chance the other will be. Or a study that a homosexual is so many times more likely to have a sibling who is a homosexual. How would you control out that correlation being just as much a result of a social environment these family members shared rather than genetics?

And I don't think the easy quotes on other mammals that exhibit homosexual behaviors give enough credit to those animals abilities to learn. And, despite being a staunch biological evolutionist, I don't think what we observe in animals always holds true for the human animal.

As for the original question of the thread - the bell curve probably applies well if you put 100% heterosexual on one end and 100% homosexual on the other. I'd suspect the curves for men and women, at least in Western culture, wouldn't match each other well. The curve for men would be slanted more toward the hetero side, and that has little to do with genetics. Intolerance seems to be in our genes more than sexuality.
 
Ramlick said:
So you're saying that the desire that otherwise heterosexual man have to have sex with men is not biological. If that's true, why would they find it pleasurable? And how do you know they're not homosexual, or bi-sexual, anyway?

So, from the other direction, would a 100% heterosexual male (if such a thing existed), be biologically incapable of finding any sexual contact with another man pleasurable?
 
Assumptions are Dangerous

Superlittlegirl, you make excellent points but sometimes fall into the trap of assuming more meaning in my words than what is really there. For example I started the thread with this:
Are women more likely than men to try having sex with someone of the same sex? My sense is that women might be more likely to experiment with homosexuality. Any thoughts?
My intent here is to find out whether women are more likely to have homosexual sex than men. I don't think that it matters whether the men or women identify themselves has homosexual or heterosexual. I'm just interested in whether women are more inclined toward homosexual sex. The consensus of the posters seems to believe that women are more likely to try homosexual sex. I don't think that the word "experimentation" is anything to get hung up on because I believe people know before they experiment with sex that they're going to like it. I don't think it's typical for someone to say to themselves "I think I'll try sex with a member of my own sex just to see if I like it" out of the blue. I think they feel a desire first, then decide whether to act on it or not.

So the point of my question is to find out first if people here agree that women are more inclined to have sex with other women than men are with other men.

My next point is to find out why, if in fact women are more inclined to try homosexuality, that this is true. Some here have offered theories of socialization. I lean toward biology. If in fact women are more likely than men to have homosexual sex, I feel there is a strong possibility that there is a genetic, or biological reason. That's not to say that our environment plays no role. I'm sure it does. But I would be extremely surprised if there weren't a biological explanation.

The next step after determining that there is a genetic factor is to find out what the possible reason nature might have for implanting a greater desire for same sex coupling in females than in males. In other words, why did men and women evolve as they did? This is ultimately where I am interested in going with this thread. There still may be room for debate on the nature vs. nurture argument, however. I think I've presented some good points for the nature argument. Please review them and let me know what you think.
 
Last edited:
*clapping*

Kudos!

Now see??? This is a excellent example of a debate/discussion the way it should be...this is it in it's finest form.
Heck, I think I'm wet.:)
 
To borrow a good friend's phrase....

"Boys are stupid and someone should throw rocks at them."


Did that answer the question?"
 
i can only go by personal experiences.

i actually think it must be tough these days to be a straight,normal man. so many pressures and expectations coming in from all angles.
 
Ramlick said:
Here's a question for you:

Are women more likely than men to try having sex with someone of the same sex? My sense is that women might be more likely to experiment with homosexuality. Any thoughts?

I'd like to offer my opinion on why later...
Yes I believe you are right. Men are less likely to try being with another man simply because they have a basic animal instinct to destroy or divert their attention from anything that society deems unnatural.
 
I've got the sign-up sheet right here, baby. ;)


Minkey Boodle said:
I'd be willing to try it.

Is there some sheet I need to sign, or something?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top