Gender reassignment? Is it really reassignment??

Gender reassignment??

  • A guy with breasts and a vagina is still a guy

    Votes: 4 57.1%
  • A guy with breasts and a vagina is still now a woman

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 1 14.3%
  • A woman with a penis is now a guy

    Votes: 1 14.3%
  • A woman with a penis is still a woman

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 1 14.3%

  • Total voters
    7
Shy Tall Guy said:
What I did state was that I consider gender to be more than genetalia, and that, to me, such operations as merely cosmetic with regards to gender.
Herein lies your answer. Transgendered people are not "becoming" the other gender through the operation. They already feel like the other gender, and are simply attempting to match their outsides with the innate feelings of their gender on the inside.

I'm sure someone can find the studies that support the contention, but I vaguely remember reading how the brain functions of transgendered people differ to a statistically significant degree from their birth gender (not just the rat study - but one on humans). The feelings do not happen overnight - these people have never felt "right" in their skin, and such feelings are indicative of what their actual gender really is.

Though most people neatly fit within the dominant male and female categories, not everyone does. For scientific purposes, I would place transgendered people into a third category that crosses the traditional pysiological gender lines. For social purposes, however, I would treat them as their chosen gender.
 
EvilBrat74 said:
Doing everything you can to prove yourself right above everybody else aren't you? :)
LOL
:devil:
Above? An interesting choice of words. Those few times I am right about somehting it doesn't make me a better person than everyone else; everyone is right and wrong about something.

If you ahd been around for more than a month you would know that I am opinionated, and that I am not wishy washy about what I think or believe. I do go out and gather evidence for my viewpoint and I am not shy about presenting that evidence or my viewpoint.

You are welcome to provide your own evidence and arguments to prove me wrong if you wish. Comments about my motivations are ad hominem arguments and do nothing to further your point of view among intelligent people. :rolleyes:
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Gender reassignment? Is it really reassignment??

seXieleXie said:
your idea of the difference between male and female brains seems to be vastly inflated. the main difference is size... men are typically larger, they have larger heads and slightly (~5%) larger brains. the only other difference scientists have found is nerve density in a few select areas. however, they have not been able to relate these structural differences to functional differences.
From my classes on biopsychology, I recall a few studies on the corpus callosum, the bridge between the two hemispheres of the brain. In women, the bridge was thicker, and conducted far more activity back and forth between the hemispheres. In men, the bridge experienced faster deterioration with age, and less activity spanned the bridge.

The conclusion: Women are more likely to depend equally on both hemispheres (be middle brainers). Men are more likely to rely on one hemisphere over the other (resulting in more extreme right or left brainers). Strokes disportionately affect men because if they strike the hemisphere that the man dominantly relies upon, he cannot as easily switch to the other half. Women are less effected because if a stroke damages a portion of one hemisphere, they can more easily transfer the functions to the corresponding section in the other hemisphere.

I'm not sure how this relates to transgendered people, but I really liked the subject and it tangentially related to seXieleXie's post. :)
 
Mischka said:
I'm sure someone can find the studies that support the contention, but I vaguely remember reading how the brain functions of transgendered people differ to a statistically significant degree from their birth gender (not just the rat study - but one on humans). The feelings do not happen overnight - these people have never felt "right" in their skin, and such feelings are indicative of what their actual gender really is.

Though most people neatly fit within the dominant male and female categories, not everyone does. For scientific purposes, I would place transgendered people into a third category that crosses the traditional pysiological gender lines. For social purposes, however, I would treat them as their chosen gender.
An interesting POV - one I would like to see evidence for if somebody knows of any. It does muddy up the waters.
 
Internet studies - worth the paper they aint printed on. Show my references from Nature, Biologist, Trends in Neurobiology and I might give weight to them.
 
Astro said:
Internet studies - worth the paper they aint printed on. Show my references from Nature, Biologist, Trends in Neurobiology and I might give weight to them.
Paper or bits floating in the ether, which is more valid? Answer: neither.

Sure anybody can put up anything, but if you look at the people behind some of the URLs I posted, you will see institutions such as John Hopkins and the University of Washington. Several of those URLs referenced studies by researchers at these institutions one was an abstract by the researcher himself IIRC.

I was not so much presenting these URLs as proof of my assertions, but providing references that others could read. I don't know if you read any of them, but many supported your statements and Mischka's rather than my POV.

So, before you summarily dismiss them as trivial, maybe you should consider the fact that just about anything that appears in print is now also appearing on the internet.

You might also consider the fact that many printed peer review journals have been known to print articles without any peer review, and have had their share of hogwash, faked results, etc.

You are of course free to laboriously hand copy any article you wish - but I would also like a URL with the same text so I can read it in context.
 
So women in general tend to use both hemispheres more?

So men in general tend to be better at mathematics due to brain structure?

What about the millions of men who use both hemispheres more than the average woman? Are these men actually women due to their brain structure?

What about the millions of women who are better at mathematics than the average man? Are these women actually men due to their brain structure?

As for X and Y chromosomes, there are people born with a Y chromosome, no penis, and a perfectly formed vagina. Are they male or female?

I think the root of the problem is a weakness of our Western culture ... a propensity for dualism. But too often dualism becomes an intellectual crutch, that gets in the way of our adopting more useful models of reality.

We could see race as Black and White, or we could see a spectrum of hues, with billions of unique individuals.

Similarly, we could see gender as Male and Female, or we could see a gender spectrum ... once again with billions of unique individuals.

Comments are welcome.;)
 
Call me narrow minded but.............................A guy with breasts and a vagina is still a guy



You my thought...
 
Re: I'll admit I skipped

CelestialBody said:
The intersex community consists not only of people who have opted to have surgery, but also those who were born that way. What do you think of them? The women who have wombs and breasts-but no vagina. Common medical practice is to Create a vagina for them - but today, this practice is being challanged, that the surgery is inhumane and the psychological and emotional stress incurred is immeasurable, from what I understand. What of those people-who had no choice?
I believe in the past, and still in the present to some degree, that they created a vagina for intersexuals regardless of their actual gender because it was a lot easier than creating a penis. This went for both males and females. I don't believe Intersexuals consider it cruel to give them the appropriate genetalia, but they do consider it cruel to give males a vagina, and to remove a clitoris that seems to large by the arbitrary standards of the medical profession.

A simple ultrasound and some DNA testing should be able to determine the gender of most intersexuals as most do actually have the correct internal reproductive organs and the correct chromosomes.

If there is any question then let the baby grow a little - these operations do not have to happen right away in most cases.
 
EthiopianPrince said:
So women in general tend to use both hemispheres more?

So men in general tend to be better at mathematics due to brain structure?
Those are the indications so far.

What about the millions of men who use both hemispheres more than the average woman? Are these men actually women due to their brain structure?

What about the millions of women who are better at mathematics than the average man? Are these women actually men due to their brain structure?
By itself, probably not, but that was not my assertion - my assertions were that, generally, male and female brains are different, and that adding or removing genetalia to a person of one gender does not in and of itself transform them into another gender.

As for X and Y chromosomes, there are people born with a Y chromosome, no penis, and a perfectly formed vagina. Are they male or female?
What are their internal reproductive organs? Do they have ovaries and/or a womb?
 
Shy Tall Guy,

I feel like you are side-stepping by main point that considering gender a spectrum would be a more useful model than considering gender dualistically. Could you adress that point from my earlier post?

Thanks.

EP
 
EthiopianPrince said:
Shy Tall Guy,

I feel like you are side-stepping by main point that considering gender a spectrum would be a more useful model than considering gender dualistically. Could you adress that point from my earlier post?
I am not sidestepping it; I don't have any real input on that assertion. In principle I would be inclined to agree with it - to a point. However, OTOH, there is in general a recognized dividing line with regards to the male and female genders. What I am saying, is that for most people on earth, it is fairly clear what gender they are.

I don't think this is unique to western culture either. Indeed, quite a number of eastern cultures have a much more stark delineation of what they consider to be male and female.

Indeed, it is ingrained into some eastern philosophies where almost everything in the universe is considered to be either male or female.

Where does this leave transgender persons? That depends on their individual situations. They could be in the middle of that spectrum, or not. My original assertion still holds though - gender reassignment is probably not reassignment at all, but merely "cosmetic surgery" to make someone with gender dysphoria feel better about themselves.

If that works for them then more power to them.
 
CelestialBody said:
I see your argument, but the case I argued was that the surgeries were not necessary-yes to have a normal body, the person would have to have surgery, but at the same time, thats not naturally how they were born-and that the surgery itself leaves the child with the indication that they are somehow lessthan human. THe arguement being made would be that the sugeries are inhumane-regardless of the sex assigned (or chosen) but the doctor/parents.
The same could be said of a number of cosmetic surgeries used to relieve birth defects such as facial deformities, etc.

Think of it this way; if transgenders have problems with their gender and their bodies, and their bodies seem normal in all outward appearances, what kind of problems is little Suzie going to have with a 5 inch clitoris when she dresses down for gym class, or little Bobby when he dresses down and has no recognizable penis?

If kids make fun of other kids for relatively minor things and people grow up with emotional scarring from that, how much more scarring will they grow up with for something like ambiguous genetalia?

I am not arguing for the way things have been done in the past - there were way too many arbitrary decisions and criteria thrown about, but you can see the problem parents face.
 
I know a little girl who insists she is a boy and will correct you if you say anything about her being a girl. She hates dresses, wants to dress as a boy. She loves "boy" toys and refuses to touch dolls. She knows she is a girl, really, but she still insists she is a boy, even to other children who get mad when she does it. Her daycare caregivers were concerned. The psychologist said she could be just going through a phase, or she could end up as a lesbian. OR, she really could feel like a boy trapped in a girl's body. The psychologist said those types of people often claim they just "knew" when they were very young that they had been born as the incorrect sex. In all honesty, I'm hoping it is a phase.
 
Warning: philosophy ahead

I think this thread tackles a question very few people (including myself) are fully prepared to handle. Understanding what constitutes the biological basis of gender itself is a subtle and complex task. Without a background in biological ontogeny, embryology and endocrinology, most people aren't equipped to give a meaningful answer.

When it comes to brain science and our perception of gender identity, though, I don't think even top neuroscientists only more than vague notions of what is responsible for "feeling" male or female.

Also, for most people, the question of what gender really is extends beyond science (or at least seems to, as even a scientist would concede). I can demonstrate this with some speculative questions that occured to me reading this thread and particularly Mischka's post:

Mischka argues that the perhaps there's already some biological diathesis responsible for the odd intuition that occurs in some people that they've been assigned the wrong gender, that "they" are "really" the opposite gender.

If this idea is true, wouldn't we be doing right to attempt to correct this misperception of being wrongly gendered rather than shuffle genitalia and hormones? If there's a particular neurological cause for the intuition of "being a woman trapped in a man's body" shouldn't we correct this belief, rather than cater to the whims of what is essentially a diseased brain? In simple terms, shouldn't we treat the belief as being pathological rather than the natural gender assignment being wrong?

In one sense, there's nothing radical or controversial about this. No one would think twice before discounting the bizarre and paranoid delusions found in a schizophrenic. Neither would most people criticize medicating him against his will to eradicate his delusions. This is accepted because schizophrenia is well-accepted as a condition of disordered thought and perception with recognized areas with the brain with hyperactive dopaminergic activity. We apply the standard notion of "disease" to this phenomenon and it's only a short next step to argue that as beliefs are created by brains, diseased brains create diseased beliefs. From this we can say justify discounting the beliefs of the mentally ill, allowing us who are mentally healthy to hold the patient against his will, medicate him, and attempt to restore him to mental wholeness, not until which time we will again recognize his competency to make decisions for himself.

Imagine that tomorrow I confirm Mischka's suspicion by locating the specific neurological anomaly responsible for "feeling wrongly gendered". Imagine also that I discover a "cure" for this condition, a technique by which I can eliminate this intuition, causing everyone who had perceived themselves as being the opposite gender to suddenly become satisfied with their given gender, eliminating the need to sex reassignment surgery and hormones.

Would requiring these people to undergo this treatment be ethical? Would allowing them to go on and have major surgery be ethical when a simple neurological correction would obviate their desire for sex change? It seems to me that many people would object to the idea of "curing a belief" that harms no one, but this particular belief could be seen as cause of unnecessary surgery (especially when its considered that surgically created genitalia are never as good as the real thing.)

This is the kind of difficulty that's caused by the odd nature of the human condition: our minds are strange and unique features of our brains. Brains are 3 pounds lumps of matter which seemingly must conform to the same laws of physics as all other matter, yet somehow they create the subjective notion of self, as well as our thoughts, ideas, beliefs, and emotions.

Once we begin to reduce each successive element of our mental lives to purely physical processes though, our common-sense notions of the sanctity of the individual beliefs come into question. We call bizarre delusions caused by a particular brain disorder schizophrenia and we find it appropriate to intervene to alter these delusions. Analogously, might we then reduce other odd, unpopular, or socially unacceptable belief into a disease? For instance, if I isolated the neurologic basis of religious belief, might I then argue that we alter this brain process given the intolerance and war long associated with religion? Might I do the same for particular troublesome political beliefs? Sexual orientations?

I'd better stop before I talk myself out of my future career. ;)
 
Re: Warning: philosophy ahead

Originally posted by Oliver Clozoff
. . . Mischka argues that the perhaps there's already some biological diathesis responsible for the odd intuition that occurs in some people that they've been assigned the wrong gender, that "they" are "really" the opposite gender.

If this idea is true, wouldn't we be doing right to attempt to correct this misperception of being wrongly gendered rather than shuffle genitalia and hormones? . . .
Interesting thread. I was particularly intrigued by your post, Ollie. You do present some interesting ideas.

As I read through the posts, what kept coming to mind was a hypothesis presented by Dr. Laura regarding a potential explanation for the origins of homosexuality and I can see her hypothesis applying equally well to the anomaly addressed here.

For those unfamiliar, her hypothesis was offered as a possible explanation since geneticists have pretty well dismissed the idea of a gene or series of genes which correlate to homosexuality. The hypothesis is essentially that during the developmental process of the zygote/blastocyst/embryo/fetus, a biochemical error occurs which results in the final organism lacking the normal sexual response to its opposite gender.

Considering the degree of change and the complexity of the process that occurs between the union of the gametes and the final organism's formation, this to me seems a thoroughly reasonable explanation lacking conclusive evidence to the contrary and lacking a better explanation.

I can easily see that a biochemical error of a slightly different nature in that developmental process could well result in the condition of gender dysphoria.

That being the case, I can readily appreciate Ollie's idea that treatment of the brain malady to correct the problem would potentially be a better treatment because it has the potential to render the person normal, i. e., both physical and psychological identities match. And the chemical treatment would leave the person with their reproductive ability intact, i. e., functional which surgery does not unless my information is outdated.

In answer to the question about present treatment using surgery to correct the situation, that is within the capability and understanding of the medical community right now. Also, surgery is a bigger money maker than drug prescriptions, so perhaps there's an incentive to continue the present means of treatment. :)

And for another related potentiality, should chemical treatment of the brain provide a remedy for gender dysphoria, might it not also provide a mechanism to correct the condition that resulted in homosexuality?

Oops! Missed your last question, there Ollie. Must read more carefully!
 
Last edited:
You've presented an interesting perspective, Oliver. I had never thought of it in this light before (admittedly I am unfamiliar with the success of treating schizophrenia and other abnormal thoughts of the mind). I'll have to think further about this. Certainly changing a person's mindset would have a less dramatic effect on that person than mutilating a part of their body.

Since our last conversation, Uncle Bill, I've clarified what bothers me about Dr. Laura's views on homosexuality. I agree that homosexuality has a biological basis rather than a genetic one (have you read the study of the blitzkreig's effect on pregnant women in London?). Given the inability of a homosexual person to change such characteristics - without Oliver's intrusive brain operations, of course - how then can she pass moral judgment on such a person? Why is a such a person condemned as a sinner? I cannot reconcile finding a biological basis for a behavior and then declaring that same behavior a moral sin. A person is free to choose to commit or not commit most of the laundry list of sins in the Old and New Testaments. If sexual orientation is not chosen; why then is the exercise of that orientation a sin?
 
Originally posted by Mischka
Since our last conversation, Uncle Bill, I've clarified what bothers me about Dr. Laura's views on homosexuality. I agree that homosexuality has a biological basis rather than a genetic one (have you read the study of the blitzkreig's effect on pregnant women in London?). Given the inability of a homosexual person to change such characteristics - without Oliver's intrusive brain operations, of course - how then can she pass moral judgment on such a person? Why is a such a person condemned as a sinner? I cannot reconcile finding a biological basis for a behavior and then declaring that same behavior a moral sin. A person is free to choose to commit or not commit most of the laundry list of sins in the Old and New Testaments. If sexual orientation is not chosen; why then is the exercise of that orientation a sin?
First, I think Oliver's idea was not brain surgery (intrusive brain operations) but chemical (drug) therapy.

As to condemning the homosexual lifestyle as a sin, very easy: Religious Dogma. Her intellect, science and religion produce some interesting contrasts, don't you think?

On one broadcast, I heard her say that one contributing factor to her embracing religion was her unwillingness or inability (I forget which) to deal with the idea that there is no ultimate justice, i. e., a person can live a life of crime an earth and die never having been convicted and punished.
 
Back
Top