Hot Butter Rum

I want someone to make me some hot buttered rum tonight.
 
I found a recipe on a google search since no one was forth coming with their secret Hot Buttered Rum recipe.

I adapted a couple of them together. It is quite delicious.

! cup of brown sugar, firmly packed.
! long, thick cinnamon stick
3 whole cloves.
A piece of nutmeg.
1 quart water.
1/4 cup butter.
1 pinch of salt.
Bring to boil on stovetop, turn down and simmer for approx 1 hour. (That is what I did.)

Put 1 scoop of vanilla ice cream into your very large, clear glass mug. Add 2 ounces of rum. Hot mixture to fill. Fold together gently with a spoon. Sprinkle with ground nutmeg to make pretty.

Yum.

On the next one I am going to substitute lightly whipped cream and vanilla instead of the ice cream. I let you know which tantalizes my taste buds more.

Join me, lavy?
 
Last edited:
I saw your request earlier, but it's not something I've ever made. My friend and I killed the last half an hour at work sorta bastardizing a few recipes and put this one together (it's mostly an Emeril recipe, but we substituted cider for the water) and we're both going to probably try it tonight. I guess it's more a grog than a hot buttered rum, but it still looks good *grin*

1 stick unsalted butter, softened
2 cups light brown sugar
1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon grated nutmeg
Pinch ground cloves
Pinch salt
Bottle dark rum
Boiling cider

In a bowl, cream together the butter, sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, and salt. Refrigerate until almost firm. Spoon about 2 tablespoons of the butter mixture into 12 small mugs. Pour about 3 ounces of rum into each mug (filling about halfway). Top with boiling cider (to fill the remaining half), stir well, and serve immediately.
 
The cider sounds enticing. I don't have any cider. ..Let me know how it tastes.
 
ksmybuttons said:
The cider sounds enticing. I don't have any cider. ..Let me know how it tastes.

Will do. I just sent hubby to the store for the cider. :D
 
Okay. Now having the one with whipped cream. Unsweetened with vanilla. Not whipped to hold shape but just to help it float better. The brown sugar and spice mixture has simmered longer. The flavor is incredible. The unsweetened cream helps to filter the sugar in the first mixture.

I have a winner here.
 
I want to taste hot butter rum on someone else's tongue. :)
 
ksmybuttons said:
I want the best Hot Buttered Rum tonight. Anyone have an excepional recipe?

LOL several. Kick ass drink. Vicious hangover though.

Ishmael
 
ksmybuttons said:
I found a recipe on a google search since no one was forth coming with their secret Hot Buttered Rum recipe.

I adapted a couple of them together. It is quite delicious.

! cup of brown sugar, firmly packed.
! long, thick cinnamon stick
3 whole cloves.
A piece of nutmeg.
1 quart water.
1/4 cup butter.
1 pinch of salt.
Bring to boil on stovetop, turn down and simmer for approx 1 hour. (That is what I did.)

Put 1 scoop of vanilla ice cream into your very large, clear glass mug. Add 2 ounces of rum. Hot mixture to fill. Fold together gently with a spoon. Sprinkle with ground nutmeg to make pretty.

Yum.

On the next one I am going to substitute lightly whipped cream and vanilla instead of the ice cream. I let you know which tantalizes my taste buds more.

Join me, lavy?

Oh this just sounds SO yummy.
 
2 cups firmly packed brown sugar
1/2 cup butter or margarine
1 pinch salt
3 sticks cinnamon
6 whole cloves
1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
2 cups rum
heavy cream -- whipped
ground nutmeg -- for topping

Put all ingredients, except rum and cream, and nutmeg into crockpot.
Add
2 quarts hot water. Stir well. Cover pot and cook on LOW for 5 hours.
Add
rum; stir to blend. Serve from pot in warm mugs with a scoop of whipped cream and a dusting of nutmeg.

But that receipe will probably take too long.

;)

Ishmael
 
Re: Re: Hot Butter Rum

Ishmael said:
LOL several. Kick ass drink. Vicious hangover though.

Ishmael

I'm planning on it. :)

This is so heaven! The slight whipped cream mustache and the smooth lick over the lips. Yes!
 
Ishmael said:
2 cups firmly packed brown sugar
1/2 cup butter or margarine
1 pinch salt
3 sticks cinnamon
6 whole cloves
1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
2 cups rum
heavy cream -- whipped
ground nutmeg -- for topping

Put all ingredients, except rum and cream, and nutmeg into crockpot.
Add
2 quarts hot water. Stir well. Cover pot and cook on LOW for 5 hours.
Add
rum; stir to blend. Serve from pot in warm mugs with a scoop of whipped cream and a dusting of nutmeg.

But that receipe will probably take too long.

;)

Ishmael

Actually, that is one of the one's I adapted from my google search. Since I didn't use the crockpot I could infuse the spices at a more rapid rate. I made half a recipe. Done in an hour, exceptional at two.
 
Hope yours turned out well. Mine is *incredible*
 
Well the test of a truly delicious Hot Buttered Rum is how you feel the next day and it is okay!

I will store this recipe as a keeper for the next time I want Hot Buttered Rums. I think the last time was in about 1980...
 
lavender said:
I want to taste hot butter rum on someone else's tongue. :)
I was looking on this thread in despair, wondering what had become of the world that nobody at lit could come up with the simple, standard recipe. Now my faith is restored by a seemingly tangential post. What a cool forum.
 
I nearly started a thread on this a couple weeks ago. I got hooked on this drink when I lived in Annapolis Maryland in another lifetime. There's really nothing like a hot buttered rum on a cold wet icky winter day/night. I don't get as elaborate as the above recipes, which sound like they're more for a crowd.

I keep a bottle of rum in my cabinet just for times when I crave this beverage. I cream a couple spoonfulls of brown sugar with butter in a large mug, toss in a dash of cinnamon and nutmeg, a generous jigger of rum and fill the mug with near boiling water. Top with a dollop of whipped cream, if there's any in the frige. Yummmmmmmmmm.
 
Last edited:
Ah, Someplace, that is the easiest way, yet. :) I'll keep it on hand through the cold, wet, winter ahead of me.

I am definately on to coffee this morning. Hot, black coffee. Ymmm.

I was looking on this thread in despair, wondering what had become of the world that nobody at lit could come up with the simple, standard recipe. Now my faith is restored by a seemingly tangential post. What a cool forum.

Yes, Sir Lukky, the forum truly is cool! I was thinking of Lavender's post and hoping she got the taste she wanted. What a great way to welcome the new year!
 
Yeah, lav had a great notion.

Hot, buttered rum is medicinal elixir unlike any other, and there is no more bone-chilling cold than the damp near-winters of the mid-Atlantic coast of the U.S. of A. 20 years I lived in and around Washington DC, and my feet were almost always cold. Now in the presumed polar climate of Minneapolis/St.Paul I have no trouble keeping my extremities comfortable (nor my feet, for that matter.)
 
Re: Yeah, lav had a great notion.

LukkyKnight said:
Hot, buttered rum is medicinal elixir unlike any other, and there is no more bone-chilling cold than the damp near-winters of the mid-Atlantic coast of the U.S. of A. 20 years I lived in and around Washington DC, and my feet were almost always cold. Now in the presumed polar climate of Minneapolis/St.Paul I have no trouble keeping my extremities comfortable (nor my feet, for that matter.)

Oh, you too, LK? I thought it was just me. I was never more miserably cold in my life than when we moved to DC from Los Angeles. For awhile I thought I'd never be warm again in my life! I guess I got used to it and you're right: When I spent a few years in the snowbelt outside Cleveland Ohio, it was a drier cold that was much more manageable. There is something to be said for the Gulf Coast this time of year, however. Can you believe Kitte told me "Kiss My Ass!" last week when I told her our temp was in the mid 70s?
 
Last edited:
This is not rocket surgery, someplace.

Of course I can believe it. She was angling for an invitation so you could do just that.
 
Well, to both of you, come and join us here in the Pacific Northwest if you want a great excuse for Hot Butter Rum.
 
Re: This is not rocket surgery, someplace.

LukkyKnight said:
Of course I can believe it. She was angling for an invitation so you could do just that.

Oh contrare, Good Knight....Kitte KNOWS she has a standing invitation and even gets the middle if she can ever get her pretty ass down here to warmer climes.
 
Back
Top