How and when will the shutdown end?

Kirkrapine

Literotica Guru
Joined
Sep 24, 2018
Posts
5,538
Trump has expressed his determination to keep it going for months or even years if he doesn't get his wall funding. Can that really happen?
 
You've now got two GOP Senators pushing for Trump to give in.

But enough of the GOP has to be convinced that not helping Trump get his wall won't severely cut into their votes.

All of the Republicans I know who support Trump say there's no wiggle room on the wall (the "it's okay; he meant a fence" crowd isn't taken seriously). For these folks, no wall = no 2020 vote for Trump or the GOP who forsake him.

That's why it's such good news for the Dems; they have all the power, thanks to Donny's brain-dead promise. :cool:

Except for the power to end the shutdown! :(
 
It should end with Republicans trying to save their own bacon with constituents by adding enough votes to the reopening bills to override Trump's veto. It may be Republicans' last chance to exhibit as Americans.

If Trump persists, there's no need to look for other grounds to impeach him and remove him. His job is governing. If he won't do it, he should be quickly removed in favor of someone who will run a functioning government.
 
It should end with Republicans trying to save their own bacon with constituents by adding enough votes to the reopening bills to override Trump's veto. It may be Republicans' last chance to exhibit as Americans.

If Trump persists, there's no need to look for other grounds to impeach him and remove him. His job is governing. If he won't do it, he should be quickly removed in favor of someone who will run a functioning government.

An early draft of the Constitution provided officials could be impeached for "maladministration." For some reason, they took that out.
 
You've now got two GOP Senators pushing for Trump to give in.

But enough of the GOP has to be convinced that not helping Trump get his wall won't severely cut into their votes.

All of the Republicans I know who support Trump say there's no wiggle room on the wall (the "it's okay; he meant a fence" crowd isn't taken seriously). For these folks, no wall = no 2020 vote for Trump or the GOP who forsake him.

That's why it's such good news for the Dems; they have all the power, thanks to Donny's brain-dead promise. :cool:

The longer it goes on the more pressure there will be on McConnell and senate republicans to end it.

Trump has no idea how to negotiate - this is all he knows how to do. It will fail and weaken him.
 
It should end with Republicans trying to save their own bacon with constituents by adding enough votes to the reopening bills to override Trump's veto. It may be Republicans' last chance to exhibit as Americans.

If Trump persists, there's no need to look for other grounds to impeach him and remove him. His job is governing. If he won't do it, he should be quickly removed in favor of someone who will run a functioning government.

Your stupidity rivals that of the President himself, and that's saying quite a bit.

In your world, the actual Constitutional act of a President vetoing a piece of Congressional legislation constitutes "high crimes and misdemeanors" constituting grounds for impeachment.

Given rationalizations like that, it's a wonder he hasn't asked your genetically mutated ass to be Attorney General.
 
Your stupidity rivals that of the President himself, and that's saying quite a bit.

In your world, the actual Constitutional act of a President vetoing a piece of Congressional legislation constitutes "high crimes and misdemeanors" constituting grounds for impeachment.

Given rationalizations like that, it's a wonder he hasn't asked your genetically mutated ass to be Attorney General.

You seem upset.
 
Republicans will start to defect, and Trump will be forced to cave. The only question is, what will be the face saving measure?
 
In your world, the actual Constitutional act of a President vetoing a piece of Congressional legislation constitutes "high crimes and misdemeanors" constituting grounds for impeachment.

Which are whatever the HoR decides they are. That is intended by the Constitution to be a political, not a judicial decision, and is not reviewable in any court of law.
 
You seem upset.

Nope. Just gobsmacked by the stupidity of someone that would actually suggest that the exercise of an elected official doing his Constitutional mandated duty of either signing legislation or vetoing it would be guilty of actually VIOLATING the Constitutional standards of "high crimes and misdemeanors" that would thus expose that person to impeachment if he chose the latter course.

And anyone subscribing to such a asinine theory would have to hold any member of Congress voting against a funding resolution to reopen the government guilty of an impeachable offense as well. Why focus only on the actions of the President?
 
Why focus only on the actions of the President?

Because those are the ones over which the HoR has impeachment jurisdiction. Misconduct by a member of the House is dealt with by expulsion, a much simpler process.
 
Last edited:
Which are whatever the HoR decides they are. That is intended by the Constitution to be a political, not a judicial decision, and is not reviewable in any court of law.

Call Keith and see if you can carpool. Whatever the lack of judicial review attendant to the political question of impeachment it was never the "intent" of the Constitutional language "OTHER high crimes and misdemeanors" (which, if you read Section 4 of Article Two, was a direct analogous reference to treason and bribery) to expose a President or Vice President to removal from office for exercising powers specifically authorized by other Constitutional language in Article One, Section 7.

Only an idiot such as yourself (which clearly includes Keith) would believe the document was written with the INTENT of the giving the House of Representatives that authority.
 
I would give the GOP 5 billion...for something like...health care :D
 
Because those are the ones over which the HoR has impeachment jurisdiction. Misconduct by a member of the House is dealt with by expulsion, a much simpler process.

Fine. So by YOUR logic with regard to the appropriate sanctions against a President and/or a member of the House for failing to "responsibly govern," if the members of the House were to judge that a Presidential veto of a funding bill to reopen the government was an impeachable offense under the Constitution, is it actually your argument that they would be on an equally logically sound footing NOT to expel a member from membership who essentially commits the same act by voting AGAINST the very funding bill that the President vetoed?

You actually wish to argue that the Constitution INTENDED to allow for this contradictory possibility?

Really?
 
Because those are the ones over which the HoR has impeachment jurisdiction. Misconduct by a member of the House is dealt with by expulsion, a much simpler process.

Article 2, Section 4

The President, Vice President and all Civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.

(Bold mine.)

Constitutional impeachment covers all "Civil Officers of the United States," including, obviously, U.S. Representatives, U. S. Senators and all federal judges.
 
Your stupidity rivals that of the President himself, and that's saying quite a bit.

In your world, the actual Constitutional act of a President vetoing a piece of Congressional legislation constitutes "high crimes and misdemeanors" constituting grounds for impeachment.

Given rationalizations like that, it's a wonder he hasn't asked your genetically mutated ass to be Attorney General.

What has he vetoed? Exactly....nothing...so try a new tactic numb nuts
 
Call Keith and see if you can carpool. Whatever the lack of judicial review attendant to the political question of impeachment it was never the "intent" of the Constitutional language "OTHER high crimes and misdemeanors" (which, if you read Section 4 of Article Two, was a direct analogous reference to treason and bribery) to expose a President or Vice President to removal from office for exercising powers specifically authorized by other Constitutional language in Article One, Section 7.

Only an idiot such as yourself (which clearly includes Keith) would believe the document was written with the INTENT of the giving the House of Representatives that authority.

Of course the Constitution was written with the intent of giving the HoR that authority. No other authority is provided. Impeachment decisions are strictly political, and not reviewable in any court of law.
 
The "art of the deal" maker...isnt a very good deal maker.
 
An early draft of the Constitution provided officials could be impeached for "maladministration." For some reason, they took that out.

But the House could use that as a reason anyway, even more solidly by pairing it with the obvious truth that Donald Trump is a blackmailed asset of the Russian government and, as such, is purposely undermining the functions of government.

He spouted a new Russian propaganda line just yesterday (that Russia went into Afghanistan all those years ago because of terrorism against Russia--the Soviet Union at the time). This is a brand new Russian propaganda piece. Very few Americans have ever heard this lie, but yet, know-nothing Trump is spouting it in the Oval Office already.
 
Back
Top