Intentional writing style

Clod has no style.


Why do people go to machines to find out about thinking and creativity?
I don't want to derail things with another AI thread, but...

The single biggest issue with using AI for research is that AI doesn't know when it is wrong.

That is the reality that we all live with. AI can provide information, but is it always the correct information?
 
Life is short, time is limited and I am going to enjoy writing whatever I can whenever I can. I have no one to impress and no reason to turn fun into annoying work because I want to sound like someone else.
I suppose it's only annoying if it's not something you enjoy doing. I enjoy varying styles and experimentation, but I'm well aware not everyone is like that, and this is true both in amateur and professional writing. Readers are similarly split — some love the predictability and comfort of knowing exactly what they're going to get, and others love seeing shifts in style and how it impacts the vibe, interpretation, viscerality, etc.

I know some people who make a big deal out of their style and go out of their way for the "look at me, I'm so clever, bow to my genius" style, and those people tend to write fairly dull, uninteresting stories with little regard for the actual reader, and in fact tend to have great disdain for their readers unless said reader is neck-deep kissing their ass. It's ego, and they care not for how it fits with the story so long as they can show off their massive prowess with the written word, and then get incredibly defensive when people point it out to them and label them ignorants who aren't deserving of their story in the first place.

I've never been like that. I like a more understated style that isn't immediately obvious, because, like you, I think it's better to give the reader an experience than a self-congratulatory splooge onto paper. I don't want them to stop and marvel at my genius, my genius (or lack thereof) is irrelevant, because all I care about is making sure the story gives the reader the best possible experience. I want to immerse them in it, and yes, I spend a decent chunk of time tweaking the most minute details to go about that, but I am, at heart, a massive fucking craft nerd who very much enjoys employing subliminal techniques to make the story hit just a tiny bit better.

You hit on something that I think is probably why your stories are so successful:
I get the idea, I sit, I write and I try to put something in the story more than sex and to make the characters relatable real people and not just bodies in a bed.
I think that matters a great deal toward elevating something from hot, but forgettable and not very compelling, to something relatable and able to grab someone and pull them in. The best writing isn't always the most literary, literate, or even well-written, it's the stuff that's visceral and makes us feel something, and you seem to have that down pretty well.
 
You illustrated the single biggest differentiator for me where my own writing style is concerned, and that is the POV.

Who is telling the story dictates my style.

I'm glad you mentioned this, because this is a valuable skill for an author. There's a tendency of some authors (me to some degree) to write characters as though they all see things the same way. It gets monotonous. And when you work at this, you grow as an author.
 
I recently read something recently where the writing style stayed the same, but the 1P POV changed between characters. At times I had to go back and see who's head I was supposed to be in while reading.
I'm glad you mentioned this, because this is a valuable skill for an author. There's a tendency of some authors (me to some degree) to write characters as though they all see things the same way. It gets monotonous. And when you work at this, you grow as an author.
There are few things more annoying and immersion-ruining than dual first-person POV stories where both characters are written exactly the same, even if they're wildly different in dialogue. Even third-person close, if the style is exactly the same, I get a little irked, but it's less of a problem than 1P. With 3P close, the differences are more subtle, but they should exist unless the characters are very similar.
 
Who is telling the story dictates my style.
Do you write in 3°p?

It's a little bit harder to say "who" the narrator is, in that situation (compared to a 1°p narrator). It could just be "me, the writer." It could be an in-universe character. Often it's a figure who is neither the author nor a character but is a figure which has a particular voice and personality.

It isn't even harder, really. It's just that figuring it out or making the decision takes an extra step, compared to 1°p. Sometimes people don't take that step.
 
With 3P close, the differences are more subtle, but they should exist unless the characters are very similar.
I only agree with this to the extent that the narrators of the different close POVs are for some reason predicated on being different observers and narrators. Why shouldn't they be taken to be all one "person" with their own consistent voice?

Just because the characters being followed are different doesn't necessarily call for different narrative voices. That is a thing an author can do, but there isn't always a reason to.

Especially if / when: This could create the same difficulty or pitfall which multiple 1°p narrators can fall into. Now you have multiple voices all telling parts of a larger story, but are they aware of each others' storytelling? Are they cooperating, counter-operating, or totally independent and unaware? An author who doesn't think about that question, decide consciously on an answer, and compose the overall work accordingly, can plink readers.
 
Last edited:
Now you have multiple voices all telling parts of a larger story, but are they aware of each others' storytelling? Are they cooperating, counter-operating, or totally independent and unaware? An author who doesn't think about that question, decide consciously on an answer, and compose the overall work accordingly, can plink readers.

This is why, as a matter of principle, I disagree with writers who use that head-hopping 1P technique. I think of it as cheating. If you want to write in 1P, I think that carries with it an obligation to stay in one POV, with all the pitfalls and disadvantages that entails. That's why it's challenging.
 
I only agree with this to the extent that the narrators of the different close POVs are for some reason predicated on being different observers and narrators. Why shouldn't they be taken to be all one "person" with their own consistent voice?

Just because the characters being followed are different doesn't necessarily call for different narrative voices. That is a thing an author can do, but there isn't always a reason to.

Especially if / when: This could create the same difficulty or pitfall which multiple 1°p narrators can fall into. Now you have multiple voices all telling parts of a larger story, but are they aware of each others' storytelling? Are they cooperating, counter-operating, or totally independent and unaware? An author who doesn't think about that question, decide consciously on an answer, and compose the overall work accordingly, can plink readers.
I agree that if we're radically shifting voice between 3P POV characters, I think that would give rise to the question of who's telling the story, but that's not what I mean when I'm talking about stylistic shifts. Voice and style are separate things in my mind. Style helps shape voice, and voice shapes style, but they aren't synonymous. I wouldn't by default change voice in 3P POV shifts too much (unless I had good reason to), certainly not where the voice and style are radically different from someone else. That would be indicative of either a separate narrator, or narrator who's really trying to jam the reader as close as possible by emulating 1P voice with 3P, which, at that point, why aren't you just using 1P?

But like I said, I tend to keep it more subtle for 3P than I would for a 1P dual-story. I think of it like an audiobook where the person is doing different voices for different characters. It's still the same person, but there's a shift to help get you more in tune with the character. It's little things, like calling someone by a more or less formal name than the other POV character (first name when doing 3P close for that character vs. Dr. Smith for 3P close with a different character who doesn't know him as well). I wouldn't necessarily massively shift styles between POVs, the changes would be bigger when coming to styling the vibe: more languid for soft, emotional, slow moments, and short, clipped for action/horror/tension, and chaotic and disjointed when vibing for confusion, etc. Changing how the story is told stylistically is a common technique with oral storytellers. Dramatic pauses, punctuated words, literally shifting their voice, all in service of providing atmosphere for the reader, and writing isn't that different, it just uses different techniques to accomplish that.

I also think most people's default assumption with 3P is that it's the author, not an in-universe character. I don't often hear people talk about who the narrator is in relation to how they're connected to the story so much as who is the narrator in terms of what style and voice are they using. But I think you could get into a position for some people where having very different voices makes them wonder why the voice is so different. At that point, I'd start to wonder if it is someone else telling the story, and that could be an incredibly effective tool if you want to get dualing narrators and unreliability, one almost rooting for one side, the other rooting for the other side type deal.
 
This is why, as a matter of principle, I disagree with writers who use that head-hopping 1P technique. I think of it as cheating. If you want to write in 1P, I think that carries with it an obligation to stay in one POV, with all the pitfalls and disadvantages that entails. That's why it's challenging.
I think there needs to be a good reason to have multiple 1P POVs, and reason that should be part of the story, not simply, "I can't think of how to get this info to the reader." I would want someone to have a specific reason why they choose that dual POV. I believe POV should be a major consideration when deciding how to tell the story, because you get different effects with each one, and that can change how the reader interacts with the story and characters, not just when deciding whether to add a second 1P POV.

Dual 1P POV has its purposes, though. Think something like unreliable narrators, where you get conflicting views on how the story is unfolding, or each POV is adding a new perspective on events, or getting to a point where they're converging on each other, and seeing both paths helps heighten the expectation of what's going to happen when they meet, things of that nature. But "Um, just 'cause?" is not a good reason for any POV choice. Every POV character needs to add something to the story, and you frequently see totally unnecessary POV characters to get across one particular piece of information, or you learn nothing new from having them, and that's focus that would've been better spent on building rapport with your other POV character(s).

Then again, I like being very intentional about these things, and other people don't have the same considerations and philosophy about this, and that's fine. People should write what they want to write, I merely encourage more thoughtfulness when it comes to story framing, and POV is one of the biggest frames of the story. I frequently see a story and think that it would've been better with different POV characters, or a different POV style altogether, but at the end of the day, I'm not lord of all writing, and no one is obligated to bend to my will.* It'd be damn dull if people were obligated to write a certain way, because for the 99 stories where that new thing didn't work, there's one where it did, and finding those is incredibly satisfying.

*Yet. I'm working on it though.
 
<snip>

Dual 1P POV has its purposes, though. Think something like unreliable narrators, where you get conflicting views on how the story is unfolding, or each POV is adding a new perspective on events, or getting to a point where they're converging on each other, and seeing both paths helps heighten the expectation of what's going to happen when they meet, things of that nature.<snip>
The one time I did alternating 1P POV's was exactly that, I wanted to show the reactions to the same event, which where very different between the two MCs (one was freaked out, thinking they'd done something inappropriate and 'wrong' the other was conflicted but turned on).

I could have done it after, with a 'Oh I didn't realize that...' discussion, but was going for something different. It worked OK, but I'd do a lot different if I wrote that story today*
*Yet. I'm working on it though.
Lord help us.

*but I bet many (most?) of us have said that.
 
Back
Top