Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
christcat69 said:If morality and religion are intertwined than why aren't more military men catholic? This way they can kill people as long as they ask for forgiveness.
Seriously though, I believe morals are independent not religious. You know in your heart what is right or wrong. You don't need to go to church so some priest can tell you what to do like he's so f***ing pious. Say you study the bible your whole life, you have no fun, only to find out on your death bed that your priest was unable to come pray for you because he was in jail for molesting a child. Now I say, as long as you know to draw the line at hurting others or yourself, then do it and have fun.
perky_baby said:how do you know the difference? who told you? what taught you that one thing was right and the other wasn't?
theGatsby said:Should morals be seperate from state?
Well can you legislate morals? At some point don't you have to? Legislate people's choices as right or wrong. Isn't it concievable that someone thinks that murder is morally acceptable? If so then isn't having a law against murder legislating morals?
perky_baby said:if you know in your heart what is right and wrong, why are there debates on abortion?
curious2c said:Law are made to protect the innocent and give society a way to live together in groups. Morality is that which each individual has (or doesnt have), that little voice that says...no, don't do this or...yes this is right. That voice is a combination of inherent knowledge and then tempered with learned or taught rules on top of it all.
theGatsby said:But what is the method of teaching? Religion?
perky_baby said:didn't need an abortion lesson.
I'm prochoice, thanks.
theGatsby said:And so are laws based on the teaching of religion?
Oscuridad said:Oh I give up.
Sort it out for yourselves.
Oscuridad said:Law is an outgrwoth of property, sad but nonetheless true.
It might be more complex now with hate crimes and all, but let's not delude ourselves that religion defines law. If that were true, Roe v. Wade could never have happened.
No religion ever had a monopoly on morals anyway. If most of us were Buddhists than going to McDonalds would be far less morally neutral than it currently is.
Tx Belle was on the right track when speaking about that little piece of brain. You don't get denied it for lack of a religion.
Further, I think that religion tends to lull it to sleep, as somebody else is takin' care of all that. (unabashed opinion)
Can I do my primal scream therapy now?
perky_baby said:I'll try to be a bit more coherent.
I'm saying that morality has a huge base in religion. People decide what is morale and what isn't according to what they're taught according to lots of Judeo-Christian dogma.
I'm wondering how people differentiate between a religious morality issue and just a morality issue.
If there is no difference, then religion is morality and there should be a seperation of morality and state.
I believe, that the immorality of politics proves just that.
perky_baby said:excellent, and yes. Thank you very much. That's what I was looking for. I just couldn't figure it out in my head. That works for me.
I'm trying to figure out what I believe and why I believe. I was stuck on morality vs. religion. You helped me mucho.
Thanks, oscuridad.