Is Obamacare imploding?

The math never lies, but you sure do!

You're assuming a static market. We have x amount of doctors today, we'll have x amount of doctors tomorrow, and the day after, and so on.

This is wrong. There may be a temporary imbalance as the market adjusts, but in a capitalistic society supply almost always catches up with demand.

Of course, folks like you will revel in the temporary imbalance as evidence of "failure".

Think about when the automobile became popular 100 or so years ago....conservatives probably clung to the notion that there'd never be a demand for autos surpassing horses because there simply weren't enough gas stations to service these jalopies.


I never said anything about a static market, and I'm not assuming one, hell I don't even know what a static market would be. I'm the one that said supply would meet demand, and if you will re-read the post carefully you'll note that the primary subject of my post is price. If you don't think that the distortions created in the healthcare marketplace by government isn't effecting price, then God help us all.

In the 70's when the government set price controls for gasoline it led to rationing. That my friend is exactly what is going to happen with our healthcare, just as it has everywhere when price controls are put into place.
 
Last edited:
I never said anything about a static market, and I'm not assuming one, hell I don't even know what a static market would be. I'm the one that said supply would meet demand, and if you will re-read the post carefully you'll note that the primary subject of my post is price. If you don't think that the distortions created in the healthcare marketplace by government isn't effecting price, then God help us all.

In the 70's when the government set price controls for gasoline it led to rationing. That my friend is exactly what is going to happen with out healthcare, just as it has everywhere when price controls are put into place.



You are making far too much sense
 
No such animal as a market with no distortions exists for starters. And no the market will not always drive prices down. You're basing your entire opinion off a faulty premise.

Of course a market can exist without distortions. A market is simply when demand for a product is met by supply.

Me: Do you want to buy a clue? It cost 25 cents

You: Yes

A market free of distortion
 
Oh finally we are back to my supply question and this is where the train wreck jumps the tracks and falls off the trestle. Your assumption is that there will be enough established doctors that will continue to practice when they are told who to see, when to see them and for how long. You suggest that if there is a "temporary imbalance" the market will adjust. How many years does it take for the average doctor to complete schooling and residency requirements? Its not like learning to flip burgers.

Also who in their right mind is going to want to work that hard for 6 plus years to be told who, what, where and how much they can make in their practice. What doctor is going to work to become that specialist that can do the brain or heart surgery that takes years to perfect?

Demand for health care (the product) is one thing... supply is yet another.


Oh yes.....and on top of that.......as if that were not bad enough.....

if anyone is interested, please do a bit of research into Common Core. This national "education" agenda will make becoming a doctor near impossible as they completely dumb down the next and future generations of children.

If one does do research....might want to go to youtube and search Common Core and see what is actually being taught in schools (45 states actually)...though some are pushing back now.

Also, might want to google Anti-Common Core......there you will see the actual concerns....not the "party-line" rhetoric that is being shared by those who think this is a good idea. It is linked to the ability to apply Federal Funding through Race To The Top.

...just a little FYI if people are interested in children's education.
 
I never said anything about a static market, and I'm not assuming one, hell I don't even know what a static market would be. I'm the one that said supply would meet demand, and if you will re-read the post carefully you'll note that the primary subject of my post is price. If you don't think that the distortions created in the healthcare marketplace by government isn't effecting price, then God help us all.

In the 70's when the government set price controls for gasoline it led to rationing. That my friend is exactly what is going to happen with out healthcare, just as it has everywhere when price controls are put into place.

Absolutely!
 
Then there was Onan son of Judah, whom God killed because he didn't want to be fruitful. Great way to value life there, God.

I would think it is best not to question God......like it or not He knows much more than you.....and your criticism of Him is of no significance.......

(and if you actually read it, you can read that God killed him for not obeying.....)
 
Last edited:
I would think it is best not to question God......like it or not He knows much more than you.....and your criticism of Him is of no significance.......
And your assumption that God opposes abortion is just as worthless.
 
Of course a market can exist without distortions. A market is simply when demand for a product is met by supply.

Me: Do you want to buy a clue? It cost 25 cents

You: Yes

A market free of distortion

Yeah and that only occurs in hypotheticals and fantasies. In reality there are always distortions and a lot of them.
 
Oh yes.....and on top of that.......as if that were not bad enough.....

if anyone is interested, please do a bit of research into Common Core. This national "education" agenda will make becoming a doctor near impossible as they completely dumb down the next and future generations of children.

If one does do research....might want to go to youtube and search Common Core and see what is actually being taught in schools (45 states actually)...though some are pushing back now.

Also, might want to google Anti-Common Core......there you will see the actual concerns....not the "party-line" rhetoric that is being shared by those who think this is a good idea. It is linked to the ability to apply Federal Funding through Race To The Top.

...just a little FYI if people are interested in children's education.

I'm willing to bet that you understand "Common Core" almost as well as you do Insurance. Which is to say, not at all. But have been told that it's a "Bad Thing™" to have a national standard for what schools are supposed to teach our children instead of having every state decide what should be taught.
 
I never said anything about a static market, and I'm not assuming one, hell I don't even know what a static market would be. I'm the one that said supply would meet demand, and if you will re-read the post carefully you'll note that the primary subject of my post is price. If you don't think that the distortions created in the healthcare marketplace by government isn't effecting price, then God help us all.

In the 70's when the government set price controls for gasoline it led to rationing. That my friend is exactly what is going to happen with our healthcare, just as it has everywhere when price controls are put into place.

Your assumption was that the number of health care providers would remain the same, ergo "static market". That's simply not true in a capitalistic system.

We can already see signs of the system adjusting, for example, Walgreens drug stores here in the US retrofitting their larger pharmacies to include a staff physician's assistant. This will alleviate some of the minor aches and pains that heretofore were limited to the emergency room for the uninsured.

And nobody is talking about government price controls, that's a red herring.
 
Yeah and that only occurs in hypotheticals and fantasies. In reality there are always distortions and a lot of them.

Seriously? Look I get it, you're pro ACA, and you are completely entitled to that opinion, but even today in our over-regulated economy markets can and do exist free of distortions.

I'll let you have the last word
 
I would think it is best not to question God......like it or not He knows much more than you.....and your criticism of Him is of no significance.......

(and if you actually read it, you can read that God killed him for not obeying.....)

You warn against questioning God, but have no problem telling others how He would feel about something that was never once mentioned. Presuming to speak for God puts you in a rather precarious position.
 
Seriously? Look I get it, you're pro ACA, and you are completely entitled to that opinion, but even today in our over-regulated economy markets can and do exist free of distortions.

I'll let you have the last word

OPEC limits crude oil production and laughs at your "free of distortion" conjecture.
 
Seriously? Look I get it, you're pro ACA, and you are completely entitled to that opinion, but even today in our over-regulated economy markets can and do exist free of distortions.

I'll let you have the last word

Do you think the regulations on who can practice medicine distort the free market? If so (which obviously, they keep Doctors as the highest compensated professionals in the US), are you in favor of those restrictions?

Why can't I just open up a medical office? I'll charge less than people with MD's and let's let the market decide if I stay in business.
 
Seriously? Look I get it, you're pro ACA, and you are completely entitled to that opinion, but even today in our over-regulated economy markets can and do exist free of distortions.

I'll let you have the last word

The final word is simply that you're wrong. You made up an imaginary product in an imaginary world and found it free of distortions. However reality very rarely works that way. This isn't about being pro or anti ACA this is about the fact that free markets are not only a myth but something that no large group has ever truly supported in modern history. Even the Founding Fathers were against such a plan because it's not a plan that's conductive for a conductive economy.
 
Do you think the regulations on who can practice medicine distort the free market? If so (which obviously, they keep Doctors as the highest compensated professionals in the US), are you in favor of those restrictions?

Why can't I just open up a medical office? I'll charge less than people with MD's and let's let the market decide if I stay in business.

I see the point he's making, the ease of entry into the market is probably the highest of anything in America, but it is not insurmountable (i.e. open more med schools, hire more foreign doctors) and there are alternatives (physician's assistants, etc).

That is what I meant by a temporary market imbalance earlier.
 
I see the point he's making, the ease of entry into the market is probably the highest of anything in America, but it is not insurmountable (i.e. open more med schools, hire more foreign doctors) and there are alternatives (physician's assistants, etc).

That is what I meant by a temporary market imbalance earlier.

Presumably he accepts some government involvement in his heath care. I was just trying to define what he's ok with. Sometimes these guys can be slippery.
 
Your assumption was that the number of health care providers would remain the same, ergo "static market". That's simply not true in a capitalistic system.

We can already see signs of the system adjusting, for example, Walgreens drug stores here in the US retrofitting their larger pharmacies to include a staff physician's assistant. This will alleviate some of the minor aches and pains that heretofore were limited to the emergency room for the uninsured.

And nobody is talking about government price controls, that's a red herring.


What?

I was not assuming that the number of healthcare providers would stay the same. I have no idea about how many health care providers there will be.

What I did say, and will guarantee that the distortion in the healthcare marketplace is going to lead to price controls, followed by rationing.

And whatever Walgreen's does, someone is going to pay for the additional staff they have to hire, which is going to lead to more cost shifting, followed by even more rationing.
 
Do you think the regulations on who can practice medicine distort the free market? If so (which obviously, they keep Doctors as the highest compensated professionals in the US), are you in favor of those restrictions?

Why can't I just open up a medical office? I'll charge less than people with MD's and let's let the market decide if I stay in business.


Thanks for making my point, assuming you are good enough to satisfy your customers demand, then that is exactly what should happen. Notice in your little premise that you charged less for your service....competition will always exert downward pressure on price.

(edited to add a period at the end of a sentence)
 
I'm curious how he addresses things like copyrights and trademarks. I mean correct me if I'm wrong but the mantra of the free market goes a little something like this.

Person A offers a product, if they charge too much Person B will come along and offer the product at a lower price and take your business.

However trademarks and copyrights make it illegal for Person B to offer the same product. They can offer a similar product but wouldn't a free market allow me to buy an Ipod, take it apart send it to my guys in. . .okay they are already made in China but that's beside the point for the moment. . .and mass produce them and sell them at a lower price because I'm a big company and can sell at a loss, have the infrastructure in place to create unites cheaper, spent a lot less on R&D than Person A and quite possibly I have a Brand name that simply by slapping it on the product increases it's 'value'?
 
Thanks for making my point, assuming you are good enough to satisfy your customers demand, then that is exactly what should happen. Notice in your little premise that you charged less for your service....competition will always exert downward pressure on price

Exactly.

So where is the rationing coming in? If there is a product or service that someone wants, someone else will step in and fill the need.

So what if doctors have competition? They are, by far, the highest paid of any occupation and boo hoo if they are forced to accept less.

Obamacare will create MORE customers for the doctors, no less. That demand will force an increase in supply.
 
I'm curious how he addresses things like copyrights and trademarks. I mean correct me if I'm wrong but the mantra of the free market goes a little something like this.

Person A offers a product, if they charge too much Person B will come along and offer the product at a lower price and take your business.

However trademarks and copyrights make it illegal for Person B to offer the same product. They can offer a similar product but wouldn't a free market allow me to buy an Ipod, take it apart send it to my guys in. . .okay they are already made in China but that's beside the point for the moment. . .and mass produce them and sell them at a lower price because I'm a big company and can sell at a loss, have the infrastructure in place to create unites cheaper, spent a lot less on R&D than Person A and quite possibly I have a Brand name that simply by slapping it on the product increases it's 'value'?

I never said all distortions were bad, merely that they effect supply and demand, and usually in a way that is not beneficial to the consumer. Now, I do think there is too much government regulation, but that's another topic entirely.
 
Back
Top