Jury Nullification

Dillinger

Guerrilla Ontologist
Joined
Sep 19, 2000
Posts
26,152
Every jury in the land is tampered with and falsely instructed by the judge when it is told that it must accept as the law that which has been given to them, or that they can decide only the facts of the case.

-- Lord Denham O'Connell v Rex (1884)
 
The jury has the power to bring in a verdict in the teeth of both the law and the facts.

-- Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.
-- Homing v District of Columbia, 138 (1920)
 
What does that mean?

It means that the jury - NOT THE JUDGE - is the final arbiter of BOTH the facts and the law. Thus, if a jury believes that a law is unjust (either in general or in a particular case), it may find the defendent not guilty, DESPITE THE LAW (and despite judicial instructions to the contrary). This doctrine is known as "Jury Nullification."

For more information refer to The Fully Informed Jury Association - http://www.fija.org
 
ok not to hijack but this is along those lines when it comes to juries....


(first off i am not a legal expert..)

In houston a judge ruled to let CourtTV inside the jury deliberations room...the room where I understood you were to be weighed and measured anonamously (spelling?...without people knowing who said what and so on)

I just cannot understand why that "judge" would let that happen...

Ok back to your regularly scheduled thread!!
 
I'm curious - a question for you lawyers and law students here - do they teach you this in law school? Have you ever had a jury that knew they had this power?

Why is this astonishing to most people? Why doesn't everyone know about this?

For all of you here - did any of you know about this?

Some bottom line stuff here...

Say you're on a jury that is deciding a case against someone who was arrested for possession of marijuana. You may very well smoke or may have smoked pot sometime in your life. The odds are you have at least some friends who indulge. You sympathize with the defendent BUT the judge tells you that possession of marijuana is against the law and that you MUST decide this case on the facts.

The judge is wrong.

You CAN choose to find the defendent not guilty because you think the fucking law is wrong. Period.
 
Dillinger said:
What does that mean?

It means that the jury - NOT THE JUDGE - is the final arbiter of BOTH the facts and the law. Thus, if a jury believes that a law is unjust (either in general or in a particular case), it may find the defendent not guilty, DESPITE THE LAW (and despite judicial instructions to the contrary). This doctrine is known as "Jury Nullification."

For more information refer to The Fully Informed Jury Association - http://www.fija.org

Indeed that is the interpretation of our right to be tried by a jury or our peers. That the defendants fate is in the hands of (theoretcially) other "common" people instead of at the mercy of the aristocracy (judges). Thus for example a jury can decide that although murder is and should be against the law, not all murder should be punished in the same manner or even punished at all.
 
I actually was part of a jury that was "hung" once in a case where myself and two other members disagreed with the way the law was written. Fortunately the Defense Lawyer did an excellent job in his closing remarks to point this right out to the jury.
 
theGatsby - exactly right!

"If a juror accepts as the law that which the judge states, then that juror has accepted the exercise of absolute authority of a government employee and has surrendered a power and a right that once was the citizen's safeguard of liberty."

-- Bancroft, History of the Constitution
 
I had jury duty alst august and can i tell you it is the worst form of torture known to man.

In my state you have to serve twice a week for a month on as many trials you are picked for. You arrive every tuesday and thursday or monday and wednesday at 8:30am. They do not start calling people upstairs until 11am unless it is a murder trial. I found this out on the second day and started arriving at 10:30am to avoind being picked for a murder trial. I saw two drug possession and one robbery case. You then go upstairs and mill around and answer questions until you are told that you are not on the jury then you go back downstairs and start the process all over again. Unless they tell you to go home.
I cannot speak for other states but I don't think juries are tampered with as much as frustrated and bored and just want to go home as quickly as possible.
On the 3 trials I served on my only thought was that this is boring, I can't pay attention and will this lady please stop trying to make us stay late enough to order dinner.
 
"It is not only the juror's right, but his duty, to find the verdict according to his own best understanding, judgement and conscience, though in direct opposition to the directions of the court."

-- John Adams
 
The burden of proof lies with the prosecution. Not only does the prosecutor have to prove guilt, but in some cases may also have to prove the legitimacy of the law itself. Especially if the defense team questions the law.
 
"If the jury feels the law is unjust, we recognize the undisputed power of the jury to acquit, even if its verdict is contrary to the law as given by a judge, and contrary to evidence."

-- 4th Circuit Court of Appeals, U.S. v Moylan, 1969
 
Dillinger said:
What does that mean?

It means that the jury - NOT THE JUDGE - is the final arbiter of BOTH the facts and the law. Thus, if a jury believes that a law is unjust (either in general or in a particular case), it may find the defendent not guilty, DESPITE THE LAW (and despite judicial instructions to the contrary). This doctrine is known as "Jury Nullification."

For more information refer to The Fully Informed Jury Association - http://www.fija.org

This is disputed.
 
"When a jury acquits a defendent even though he or she clearly appears to be guilty, the acquittal conveys significant information about community attitudes and provides a guideline for future prosecutorial discretion.

Because of the high acquittal rate in prohibition cases in the 1920's and early 1930's, prohibition laws could not be enforced. The repeal of these laws is traceable to the refusal of juries to convict those accused of alcohol traffic."

-- Sheflin and Van Dyke, Law and Contemporary Problems, No. 4, 1980
 
TWB said:
This is disputed.

Disputed by who? By people who don't like the idea of trial by peers? By the citizenry having the final say?
 
I've served on two juries, one for assault and battery, the other for medical malpractice. In both situations, the judges read to us what the law involved in the cases was - very dry. Then told us that it was up to us to determine how that law was interpreted for the cases, and if there had been wrong doing.

In my unique situations, and with my fellow jurors, we were more concerned about doing what was right, rather than making some sort of political stance against laws. If some one isn't happy with a particular law there are ways to go about changing laws in our country. To let some one who is guiltly of a crime free (or charge some one) simply because people don't like how the law is worded, to me, is simply selfish indignation. Most jurors do not have the legal background or understanding to fully comprehend all the intricacies of a particular law. The judge does his or her best to interpret it in layman's terms, yes. But to say something like, "Well, I smoked pot in high school, and I'm okay, so I'm gonna let this drug dealer go 'cuz I feel sorry for him", just speaks of some one who isn't fully comprehending the possible full impact of the person's actions.

For me, when I sit on a jury, I try to collect the facts, sort them through with my fellow juror, and place my decision on what I feel is right, within the bounds of the law. And I think that the majority of jurys do the same thing.
 
Peers of the vicinage

Very interesting thread, Dillinger. Jury nullification is a fascinating topic. Judges tend to hate it, because it limits their power. Also, note it's a double edged sword: it may be used for malign as well as laudable purposes. For instance, all-white juries in the South have acquitted whites who murdered blacks, despite overwhelming evidence of their guilt.

In a very early case, Chief Justice John Jay (the first C.J.) said to the jury: "you have . . . a right to take upon yourselves to judge of both, and to determine the law as well as the fact in controversy." Brailsford v. Georgia, 3 U.S. 1 (1794).
 
SexyChele said:
I've served on two juries, one for assault and battery, the other for medical malpractice. In both situations, the judges read to us what the law involved in the cases was - very dry. Then told us that it was up to us to determine how that law was interpreted for the cases, and if there had been wrong doing.

In my unique situations, and with my fellow jurors, we were more concerned about doing what was right, rather than making some sort of political stance against laws. If some one isn't happy with a particular law there are ways to go about changing laws in our country. To let some one who is guiltly of a crime free (or charge some one) simply because people don't like how the law is worded, to me, is simply selfish indignation. Most jurors do not have the legal background or understanding to fully comprehend all the intricacies of a particular law. The judge does his or her best to interpret it in layman's terms, yes. But to say something like, "Well, I smoked pot in high school, and I'm okay, so I'm gonna let this drug dealer go 'cuz I feel sorry for him", just speaks of some one who isn't fully comprehending the possible full impact of the person's actions.

For me, when I sit on a jury, I try to collect the facts, sort them through with my fellow juror, and place my decision on what I feel is right, within the bounds of the law. And I think that the majority of jurys do the same thing.

I disagree - If I don't believe something is a crime, whether someone else does or not, I should be able to base my decision on MY conscience - not on what some "arbitrary" law says. This is directly related to the Constitution and Bill of Rights and not the thousands upon thousands of outdated and potetentially harmful laws.

Now I'm not talking about murder or robbery here. I talking about allowing people to do things for themselves that don't harm anyone else. I consider the marijuana laws to be ridiculous. How about Rowe vs Wade? If that's overturned in the future and someone is brought to trial for having an abortion and you think its their right to have an abortion (I don't know if you do or not, I'm just using this as an example) then will you convict that person just because the law says its wrong?
 
BTW - this is NOT a political stance against laws. Its about doing what's right rather than what someone else has told you is right.
 
Dillinger said:
I disagree - If I don't believe something is a crime, whether someone else does or not, I should be able to base my decision on MY conscience - not on what some "arbitrary" law says. This is directly related to the Constitution and Bill of Rights and not the thousands upon thousands of outdated and potetentially harmful laws.

Now I'm not talking about murder or robbery here. I talking about allowing people to do things for themselves that don't harm anyone else. I consider the marijuana laws to be ridiculous. How about Rowe vs Wade? If that's overturned in the future and someone is brought to trial for having an abortion and you think its their right to have an abortion (I don't know if you do or not, I'm just using this as an example) then will you convict that person just because the law says its wrong?


Why shouldn't it include murder or robery??? Some jurors might feel that murder or robery are...what about drunk driving.....?...if you don't kill anyone then it should be OK ...right?...you have just brought us to a slippery slope...

you claim that some laws are "arbitrary"....what is to keep people from saying all the laws are arbitrary?

who would decide what laws should be enforced by juries?...the jurists themselves....?

as someone once said, "Idon't want someone who couldn't figure out how to get out of Jury duty to judge me."
 
Mountain Man:

Jury Nullification IS a basic constitutional right that supercedes any law. When a judge tells you that you have to base your decision on the law instead of your conscience he/she is either ignorant of your rights or outright lying to you.

And, btw, if you you think that someone had every right to murder someone else you do not have to find that person guilty. That is your right.
 
Dillinger said:
Disputed by who? By people who don't like the idea of trial by peers? By the citizenry having the final say?

There are many courts which hold differently than the cases you have cited. For example:

State v. Spyker, The court decides on questions of law, and the jury on questions of fact.

State v. Strong, ,1902 It is the duty of the jury to receive and apply the law as given by the court.

Montgomery v. State, Ohio,1842 While juries are judges of the law as well as of the facts, they should accept the law as laid down and expounded to them by the presiding judge.

However, there is not much a judge can do if there is just an up or down not guilty verdict. There are often exceptions carved out in the law which allow a Jury to come to the right decision. For example, there is the necessity doctrine, whcih basically says that if you technically break a law but it makes no sense for you to refrain from doing it, you should not be found guilty. In criminal cases it becomes important for a jury to have this latitude, but it also can often be explained by competing doctrines of law which the jury can hear from the judge.

It is a very interesting topic.
 
Dillinger said:
Mountain Man:

Jury Nullification IS a basic constitutional right that supercedes any law. When a judge tells you that you have to base your decision on the law instead of your conscience he/she is either ignorant of your rights or outright lying to you.

And, btw, if you you think that someone had every right to murder someone else you do not have to find that person guilty. That is your right.

I would have a hard time if there was a jury interrogatory wherein jurors were asked 1. whether defendant killed the victim (answers, yes) 2. whether there was any legal defense (answers no) = Not Guilty.
 
Dillinger said:
I disagree - If I don't believe something is a crime, whether someone else does or not, I should be able to base my decision on MY conscience - not on what some "arbitrary" law says. This is directly related to the Constitution and Bill of Rights and not the thousands upon thousands of outdated and potetentially harmful laws.

Now I'm not talking about murder or robbery here. I talking about allowing people to do things for themselves that don't harm anyone else. I consider the marijuana laws to be ridiculous. How about Rowe vs Wade? If that's overturned in the future and someone is brought to trial for having an abortion and you think its their right to have an abortion (I don't know if you do or not, I'm just using this as an example) then will you convict that person just because the law says its wrong?


See, I would have to go along with Mountain on the murder and robbery thing as well. If a mother had starving children and she stole to feed them, she has committed the crime but my conscience might feel she was in the right.

In each jury I've sat on, it was explained to the potential jury selection what type of trial it would be and what it would encompass. In each, I had to seriously search my mind and heart to determine if I could be fair and impartial. (One was a father assaulting his grown daughter, the other a doctor being accused of wrongful death) If I had felt that my morals would be compromised in any way, I would have argued my point to the judge to be excused.

As for the abortion example, most people have an opinion one way or the other. If that scenario were to become actuality for me, I would have seriously search within me to see if I could set aside my personal convictions to give fair and unpartial hearing to the facts of the case. If not, I would argue for my own dismissal from the jury.

As a juror, I consider my job to listen to the facts of a case as they are presented to me and come to a decision based on the evidence. If I come into the trial with a notion to "take a stance" against a particular law, then I have no business being a juror, as I cannot look neither the plaintiff nor the defendent in the eye and tell them I will listen to each equally. I would already have an agenda in my own heart, and while that might be true for some jurors, it is simply not something that I would want to base my decision on. I don't think it fair to the either party involved in the case. (Even if one side is a government entity)
 
TWB said:
There are many courts which hold differently than the cases you have cited. For example:

State v. Spyker, The court decides on questions of law, and the jury on questions of fact.

State v. Strong, ,1902 It is the duty of the jury to receive and apply the law as given by the court.

Montgomery v. State, Ohio,1842 While juries are judges of the law as well as of the facts, they should accept the law as laid down and expounded to them by the presiding judge.

However, there is not much a judge can do if there is just an up or down not guilty verdict. There are often exceptions carved out in the law which allow a Jury to come to the right decision. For example, there is the necessity doctrine, whcih basically says that if you technically break a law but it makes no sense for you to refrain from doing it, you should not be found guilty. In criminal cases it becomes important for a jury to have this latitude, but it also can often be explained by competing doctrines of law which the jury can hear from the judge.

It is a very interesting topic.

Quite an interesting topic.

The cases you cite are all lower court. My citations include Supreme Court Justices (not to mention John Adams), which I think would hold more weight?
 
Back
Top