Kennedy assassination

We went to the Sixth Floor Museum this past winter, and Dealey Plaza was a little bit of a circus even then. I'll pay my respects in my own way, and not give the exploitative element any more attention than it deserves.
 
I've been watching some of the TV coverage from the weekend of the assassination. Not sure why I find this so fascinating.

I'm not pushing any particular conspiracy theories over the assassination, but there sure are a lot of unanswered questions.
 
Last edited:
I've been watching some of the TV coverage from the weekend of the assassination. Not sure why I find this so fascinating.

I'm not pushing any particular conspiracy theories over the assassination, but there sure are a lot of unanswered questions.
No, there aren't. The people who want you to think that there are unanswered questions just want to sell you something.
 
No, there aren't. The people who want you to think that there are unanswered questions just want to sell you something.

I guess you don't know much about it, do you?

Let's start with:

1. Oswald being able to fire three shots in such a short timeframe.

2. Oswald's accuracy being remarkable

3. The fact he just happened to work at a building which the motorcade travelled past

4. Ruby killing Oswald, we're supposed to accept that he just loved JFK so much that he went and did in Oswald for idealistic reasons?

On and on, the whole thing is strange enough that it can definitely rise to the level of reasonable doubt regarding the lone gunman theory.
 
I guess you don't know much about it, do you?

Let's start with:

1. Oswald being able to fire three shots in such a short timeframe.

2. Oswald's accuracy being remarkable

3. The fact he just happened to work at a building which the motorcade travelled past

4. Ruby killing Oswald, we're supposed to accept that he just loved JFK so much that he went and did in Oswald for idealistic reasons?

On and on, the whole thing is strange enough that it can definitely rise to the level of reasonable doubt regarding the lone gunman theory.

All of those questions have been asked and answered for years now. A book called Case Closed will provide you with all the conspiracy destroying evidence you need:

The assassination of John F. Kennedy on November 22, 1963, continues to inspire interest ranging from well-meaning speculation to bizarre conspiracy theories and controversial filmmaking. But in this landmark book, reissued with a new afterword for the 40th anniversary of the assassination, Gerald Posner examines all of the available evidence and reaches the only possible conclusion: Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone. There was no second gunman on the grassy knoll. The CIA was not involved. And although more than four million pages of documents have been released since Posner first made his case, they have served only to corroborate his findings. Case Closed remains the classic account against which all books about JFK’s death must be measured.
 
All of those questions have been asked and answered for years now. A book called Case Closed will provide you with all the conspiracy destroying evidence you need:

The assassination of John F. Kennedy on November 22, 1963, continues to inspire interest ranging from well-meaning speculation to bizarre conspiracy theories and controversial filmmaking. But in this landmark book, reissued with a new afterword for the 40th anniversary of the assassination, Gerald Posner examines all of the available evidence and reaches the only possible conclusion: Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone. There was no second gunman on the grassy knoll. The CIA was not involved. And although more than four million pages of documents have been released since Posner first made his case, they have served only to corroborate his findings. Case Closed remains the classic account against which all books about JFK’s death must be measured.

Case Closed actually is considered my most assasination conspiracy theorists to be riddled with factual inaccuaricies....then again the author has been discovered to be a serial plagiarist. so what can ya do
 
I guess you don't know much about it, do you?

Let's start with:

1. Oswald being able to fire three shots in such a short timeframe.

2. Oswald's accuracy being remarkable

3. The fact he just happened to work at a building which the motorcade travelled past

4. Ruby killing Oswald, we're supposed to accept that he just loved JFK so much that he went and did in Oswald for idealistic reasons?

On and on, the whole thing is strange enough that it can definitely rise to the level of reasonable doubt regarding the lone gunman theory.

Here's what's always blown my mind wide open:

How the hell did Oswald defect from this country in the thick of the Cold War and then not only just waltz right back into the US unimpeded a relatively short time later, but also get to bring his Soviet citizen wife with him with essentially no questions asked?

WTF was that? People just didn't do that as easily as he - a man we're supposed to believe was a lone nutbar - seemed to have done.

And I agree - somehow I don't think Jack Ruby just shot Oswald out of a deep love and respect for Jackie Kennedy.

The whole thing is too pat and just fits together too neatly (on the surface, anyway) for me. I'm not always looking for the conspiracy theory, but there are far too many holes in the Warren Commission's story for me to just buy it hook, line, and sinker.

Speaking of Dealey Plaza, does anyone else who's been there find it very odd that the plaque on the sidewalk near the location of the fatal shot doesn't even mention what actually happened there? I think that's so bizarre.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand why everyone says Kennedy was a "young man" when he was killed. Dude was 46.
 
I don't understand why everyone says Kennedy was a "young man" when he was killed. Dude was 46.

Young by presidential standards. Younger than Ike, younger than LBJ, and more importantly "a new generation" younger than theirs, but somehow theirs managed to grab "the torch" back, until Nixon and that weren't no improvement.
 
Last edited:
The older I get, the younger JFK gets.

My SO is the same age JFK was when he died. I'm not far behind. I don't consider either of us old by any stretch of the imagination.

Yes, Jack Kennedy was a young man when he was killed. I might not have seen that in my teens or even my early twenties but I certainly see it now. I have too many things to do that I see myself doing far beyond the age of 46. It's more than many get, yes, but it's so much less than so many more have gotten. Age has made me see and feel that side of the tragedy even more: for whatever he was or wasn't, he was a father of two young children and someone's husband, someone's son, and a brother to many.

46 is young to die, and I think that, since we expect to live even longer now than we did in the 1960s, it 'seems' even younger.
 
I guess you don't know much about it, do you?

Let's start with:

1. Oswald being able to fire three shots in such a short timeframe.

2. Oswald's accuracy being remarkable

3. The fact he just happened to work at a building which the motorcade travelled past

4. Ruby killing Oswald, we're supposed to accept that he just loved JFK so much that he went and did in Oswald for idealistic reasons?

On and on, the whole thing is strange enough that it can definitely rise to the level of reasonable doubt regarding the lone gunman theory.



1. It wasn't, if you know what you're doing.

2. Not really. His first shot missed. And if you've seen the site, the closeness of the sixth floor to street level is one of the things that strikes you.

3. Oswald got the job at the book depository before it was announced where the motorcade would be traveling, possibly even before it was known that Kennedy was going to Dallas at all.

4. I don't know why he did it -- but unlike the shooting of the president, there's no plausible conspiracy here; everyone saw Ruby kill Oswald. The absence of a logical reason for why Ruby shot him does not by itself serve as proof for whatever theory one might propose.
 
1. It wasn't, if you know what you're doing.

2. Not really. His first shot missed. And if you've seen the site, the closeness of the sixth floor to street level is one of the things that strikes you.

3. Oswald got the job at the book depository before it was announced where the motorcade would be traveling, possibly even before it was known that Kennedy was going to Dallas at all.

4. I don't know why he did it -- but unlike the shooting of the president, there's no plausible conspiracy here; everyone saw Ruby kill Oswald. The absence of a logical reason for why Ruby shot him does not by itself serve as proof for whatever theory one might propose.

So, let me guess you're a "conspiracyphobe"? Regarding 1. and 2. (but especially 1.), plenty of people disagree with you including the House Committee that investigated. Regarding 3., I'd say this provides support for the conspiracy argument rather than detracts from it.
 
The Kennedy assassination is the perfect-storm conspiracy-theory material! It has something for everybody! Oswald was a Comsymp, the CIA/MIC might be implicated, Jack Ruby had Mob connections, and, just to give anti-Semitic conspiracy theorists something to work with, he was a Jew who shortened his name from Rubenstein! :)
 
Read these two books:

Best Evidence by David Lifton - the biggest pile of bullshit.

and

Reclaiming History by Vincent Bugliosi - the most comprehensive book on the case.

Plus Wrong Element's answers to the four questions are spot on.
 
So, let me guess you're a "conspiracyphobe"? Regarding 1. and 2. (but especially 1.), plenty of people disagree with you including the House Committee that investigated. Regarding 3., I'd say this provides support for the conspiracy argument rather than detracts from it.
With no clear account of exactly how fast the shots were fired, there's no reason to question Oswald's firing speed. As for his accuracy, it is completely unremarkable that he could hit a relatively stationary target less than 90 yards away.

And as for #3, are you claiming that the motorcade route was specifically chosen to line up with Oswald?
 
Anyone seriously wanting to properly evaluate the likelihood of President Kennedy's assassination being the product of a conspiracy would do themselves a tremendous favor by viewing the prospective conspiracy from two perspectives.

1. Acts of the conspirators to affect the assassination itself. This involves such obvious considerations as attempting to decide which of the various "usual suspects" having the means, motive and opportunity to commit the crime actually did so. Too many conspiracy buffs spend an enormous amount of time trying to prove a "generic" conspiracy by flagellating the mistakes of the Warren Commission or arguing about what Oswald could or could not have possibly done. Many of these arm-chair sleuths never get anywhere near making a solid, evidentiary-based case against flesh and blood criminals. They appear sufficiently thrilled to merely raise more unanswered questions and discovering what they believe are untied "loose ends."

Hopefully, you will do better. As you contemplate the conspiratorial plot, put yourself in the shoes of the architects. If you really want to pull this off and get away with it, how many gunmen will you use? Where will you place them? How will they escape detection and capture? In other words, assume that the conspirators have the common sense to make decisions that, superficially at least, INCREASE the chances for their success rather than make it more difficult or introduce unnecessary risks.

As you encounter the cherished evidence advanced by others, hold it up to that standard. Does this make sense from the conspiratorial viewpoint? Is it what you would do if YOU were hoping to stay out of prison for the rest of your life?

2. Acts of the conspirators after the fact. This is what I call the "second conspiracy." Others simply call it the coverup. Fifty years after the assassination, it still occupies the vast majority of attention and heated discussion. Here again, assuming the mindset of the conspirator is highly recommended. What will best serve your objective? Blow town or try to frame a "patsy"? Steal the body? Medically alter the wounds and commit an obstruction of justice? And why the hell did you create wounds that you would feel the need to alter or obscure? What made you think you could get unfettered access to the body of a dead President? Kill witnesses five years or more after the crime? Is this really the way to keep a low profile?

Hopefully you see where I'm going with this. I never cease to be amazed at people who don't.

Above all, remember that the objective of your research is not merely to construct a scenario that is plausible. The objective is to compile evidence that proves what actually happened. The field already has more than enough theories. If you can't improve on what is already out there, there's little reason to play.
 
Last edited:
So, let me guess you're a "conspiracyphobe"? Regarding 1. and 2. (but especially 1.), plenty of people disagree with you including the House Committee that investigated. Regarding 3., I'd say this provides support for the conspiracy argument rather than detracts from it.

I don't know about being a "conspiracyphobe," but Occam's Razor is a good rule of thumb generally.

The burden of proof is on those who believe the Kennedy assassination was the product of a multifaceted conspiracy involving most of the important people in the country not named "Kennedy;" and those who believe the moon landings were faked in a Hollywood backlot; and those who believe that Jews were warned to stay away from the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001; and those who believe that Ann Dunham concocted a nonexistent Hawaiian birthplace because she thought it was important, in the summer of 1961, when Jim Crow was still in existence in large parts of America, to preserve the possibility that her black son could become President someday.


Re #3: Oswald was a loser who was fully aware of his loserness, and wanted to feel significant. Since he was an American, this led him inexorably to the idea of shooting someone important. This was why he preceded his murder of Kennedy with an earlier assassination attempt, against Gen. Walker of John Birch Society infamy. That he targeted both JFK and JFK's most vocal hater in the city of Dallas is a sign that he wasn't the most coherent son of a bitch who ever lived. (Oswald wasn't the only would-be assassin of the era who was just waiting around for someone, anyone to kill: Arthur Bremer was stalking Nixon before he shot George Wallace.)

Had Walker been killed, and it came pretty close to happening, Oswald either would have been arrested in short order; or a visit to Dallas likely would have been off the table for the President, given the recent unsolved murder of a public figure in the city.
 
Back
Top