Let's Hear It for the First Amendment!!

He broke the dress code.

No, he didn't. His school's dress code forbids images that promote violence, and an NRA logo that included an image of a rifle doesn't do that.

That's why he wore the shirt to five classes without comment or incident until the teacher of the sixth decided to have a problem with it.

That's why, when the boy was suspended and other students wore gun-depicting tees in protest, none of them was disciplined or made to change, let alone arrested.

That's why no school official has responded to any request for comment about the incident or the attire policy at all, let alone offered a defense of it. They know that the teacher abused his authority.

But let's visit la-la land and pretend that the teacher is right about the policy (and the only one of the boy's teachers who apparently felt it should be applied to him). If the school means for its students to know that wearing anything depicting guns is considered promotion of violence, it's incumbent on them to make that explicitly clear in the rules. Because as it stands now, it's not clear at all that that's what they meant, and the boy was right to disagree. What would've been wrong is if he'd just rolled over and gone along with it. But he didn't - and he didn't even raise his voice.

And he gets arrested and now has a criminal record because of their crappily-worded policy?

*ahem* Fuck that noise.

Jumping to Joliet,
Ellie
 
The fact that several teachers didn't call him on it just means several teachers didn't call him on it. Unfortunately what does and doesn't promote violence is subjective.

He could have turned his shirt inside out or changed into gym cloths at any time. He has a criminal record because, as you put it, he didn't roll over. That's the price you pay for not rolling over for authority. That's the price you are supposed to pay. The school decided not to escalate things by pushing against the people who wore shirts afterwards in protest. Perhaps the policy gets changed, perhaps not.

That doesn't change the fact that the boy broke the rules and was punished for doing so.
 
The fact that several teachers didn't call him on it just means several teachers didn't call him on it. Unfortunately what does and doesn't promote violence is subjective.

He could have turned his shirt inside out or changed into gym cloths at any time. He has a criminal record because, as you put it, he didn't roll over. That's the price you pay for not rolling over for authority. That's the price you are supposed to pay. The school decided not to escalate things by pushing against the people who wore shirts afterwards in protest. Perhaps the policy gets changed, perhaps not.

That doesn't change the fact that the boy broke the rules and was punished for doing so.

The fact is, he didn't break the rules, and it's wrong to roll over for those who are abusing their authority.

Certain in Cyprus,
Ellie
 
The fact is, he didn't break the rules, and it's wrong to roll over for those who are abusing their authority.

Certain in Cyprus,
Ellie

He didn't break the rules yet none of the teachers came to this conclusion and the police arrested him on no charges?

We can debate whether or not it's right or wrong to roll over for those abusing their authority. The fact is that civil-disobedience has a price and that price in his case is a criminal record. According to you for no charge since he didn't break any rule. So no criminal record because he clearly wasn't arrested. If he was however that's the price you pay for standing up for your rights. I hope that whatever difficulties this kid goes through trying to get a job in a few years is worth being able to say he refused to turn his shirt inside out.
 
He didn't break the rules yet none of the teachers came to this conclusion and the police arrested him on no charges?

The police didn't arrest him for wearing the shirt. The police were called because the teacher decided the child was creating a "disturbance" by having the temerity to disagree with him (even though the kid wasn't vulgar, rude, trying to attract attention, or even raising his voice).


We can debate whether or not it's right or wrong to roll over for those abusing their authority. The fact is that civil-disobedience has a price and that price in his case is a criminal record. According to you for no charge since he didn't break any rule. So no criminal record because he clearly wasn't arrested.

Oh, he was arrested alright. Unjustly. It happens, in case you haven't noticed.

You might as well face it. This was a case of a teacher abusing his authority and interpreting a policy according to his own personal ideology, not what the policy actually stated. The kid was in the right.

I hope that whatever difficulties this kid goes through trying to get a job in a few years is worth being able to say he refused to turn his shirt inside out.

His rights were completely run over. He was arrested, essentially, because the teacher was a sanctimonious, overbearing dufus who couldn't abide being contradicted and shown to be wrong.

It's the boy who should be defended, not the teacher.

Which is why every school official has become mute on the subject.

Deal.


Reader in Redmond,
Ellie
 
The police didn't arrest him for wearing the shirt. The police were called because the teacher decided the child was creating a "disturbance" by having the temerity to disagree with him (even though the kid wasn't vulgar, rude, trying to attract attention, or even raising his voice).

He could have rolled over at any point. He chose not to and thus was creating a disturbance. It's not complicated.

Oh, he was arrested alright. Unjustly. It happens, in case you haven't noticed.

So the cops are in on it to?

You might as well face it. This was a case of a teacher abusing his authority and interpreting a policy according to his own personal ideology, not what the policy actually stated. The kid was in the right.

Lets say for the sake of argument that the teacher was abusing their authority and interpreting a policy to his own personal ideology. Doesn't matter. Authority figure. You deal with it later by going to their superiors or you accept the price you pay.

His rights were completely run over. He was arrested, essentially, because the teacher was a sanctimonious, overbearing dufus who couldn't abide being contradicted and shown to be wrong.

And he's got a criminal record and the teacher has at worst a bad rep at the school. Maybe this will change but right now there is a winner and a loser and the kid don't seem to be on top.

It's the boy who should be defended, not the teacher.

Which is why every school official has become mute on the subject.

Deal.


Reader in Redmond,
Ellie

The school faculty could have stepped in prior to this step. They didn't because they agreed. Which ultimately lets again say your right and they're deeply ashamed. Is that going to expunge the kids record? If it isn't the kid still has to deal with the decision that he made. As I already said, I hope this doesn't come back to bite him when he graduates but if it does it should be a lesson.

If blacks had to endure arrests, hoses, attack dogs, and general brutality simply to be treated as humans I'm not sure why people are suddenly up in arms about someone having to go through less than a tenth of that abuse for something as trivial as what kind of shirt he chose to wear to school. Civil disobedience has a price. If you aren't willing to pay it you might want to consider rolling over like a good boy.

I guess the kid is ultimately lucky that he lives in an era when kid's talking back to teachers is acceptable. My parents would have beat me black and blue for this kind of bullshit. The correct answer would have been change your shirt, turn it inside out, whatever. Come home, tell parents, let adults deal with it. So I guess he's lucky not to be me.
 
Sean,

You've got a great narrative. No law, though.

Apply Tinker to these facts. Why does this merit regulation of the student's speech but the facts in Tinker did not?
 
Oh... and according to recent reports, the kid has returned to school - wearing the same shirt - and the principal reportedly expressed regrets to him over what happened.

And the local prosectutor has yet to decide to move forward with the charges.

*smile*
 
Sean,

You've got a great narrative. No law, though.

Apply Tinker to these facts. Why does this merit regulation of the student's speech but the facts in Tinker did not?

Sorry, had to google that one.

Personally they made the wrong call in Tinker.

Those kids still got suspended until their protest was over. They paid the cost. Kudos to them.
 
It was the teacher who created the disturbance, not the other way around. Evidently there's video that will back that up.

http://abcnews.go.com/US/west-virgi...a-shirt-school/story?id=19017896#.UXXVYb1wTMg

Linkin' in Lincoln,
Ellie

From your link: Logan county schools' dress code, which is posted online, prohibits clothing and accessories that display profanity, violence, discriminatory messages or sexual language, along with ads for alcohol, tobacco or drugs. There is no mention of the NRA or guns.

Unless you're going to pull that same BS the right tried in 2010 with Sharon Angle's "We might need to try 2nd Amendment solutions if I don't win this election" isn't actually promoting violence then it is right there.

I don't see the video in question, but how you think standing on the tables isn't causing a scene is beyond me.

The final lining shows just how out of touch they are. Teachers are (or at least were when I was still in school) prohibited from debating with students. Apparently that's indoctrination.

Oh well though.
 
Sorry, had to google that one.

Personally they made the wrong call in Tinker.

Those kids still got suspended until their protest was over. They paid the cost. Kudos to them.

I think Tinker got it right.

We rightly assume trial courts and appeals courts get it right. They usually do. When they get it wrong, though, the petitioner is vindicated.

You wouldn't suggest those who are convicted of a crime and were later deemed innocent received their just deserts, would you?
 
He didn't break the rules yet none of the teachers came to this conclusion and the police arrested him on no charges?

We can debate whether or not it's right or wrong to roll over for those abusing their authority. The fact is that civil-disobedience has a price and that price in his case is a criminal record. According to you for no charge since he didn't break any rule. So no criminal record because he clearly wasn't arrested. If he was however that's the price you pay for standing up for your rights. I hope that whatever difficulties this kid goes through trying to get a job in a few years is worth being able to say he refused to turn his shirt inside out.
It sounds like he's aiming for the military.

Let's hope he doesn't choose an inopportune moment to make himself conspicuous.
 
I think Tinker got it right.

We rightly assume trial courts and appeals courts get it right. They usually do. When they get it wrong, though, the petitioner is vindicated.

You wouldn't suggest those who are convicted of a crime and were later deemed innocent received their just deserts, would you?

That's a different argument though. This kid wasn't wrongly accused. He did exactly what he was accused of. It's a question of if it was justified or not.

As I've been saying since the beginning of this thread I'd feel a little differently if the First Amendment had been a thing for any of a few dozen other offenses. Where was Tallie's rightious rage when the cops were pepper spraying students a few years back?
 
From your link: Logan county schools' dress code, which is posted online, prohibits clothing and accessories that display profanity, violence, discriminatory messages or sexual language, along with ads for alcohol, tobacco or drugs. There is no mention of the NRA or guns.

Unless you're going to pull that same BS the right tried in 2010 with Sharon Angle's "We might need to try 2nd Amendment solutions if I don't win this election" isn't actually promoting violence then it is right there.

As rhetoric that's grand, but as a valid comparison? Completely bogus, as is your bringing it up from the article as if it hasn't already been pointed out, many times, that the school's dress code merely prohibits images of violence.

Wearing a National Rifle Association t-shirt with a rifle on it is not a display of, or an incitement to, violence.

I don't see the video in question, but how you think standing on the tables isn't causing a scene is beyond me.

I see you deliberately missed the part that goes over what they did when they were told to get down (they got down). Edited to add: and it wasn't the kid in question who stood on a table.

The final lining shows just how out of touch they are. Teachers are (or at least were when I was still in school) prohibited from debating with students. Apparently that's indoctrination.

The kid wasn't arguing about gun control. He was pointing out that the teacher was wrong about the school's policy.

Oh well though.

You're just wrong on this one, dude.

Shake it off. It happens.

Rolling Eyes in Rockford,
Ellie
 
Last edited:
That's a different argument though. This kid wasn't wrongly accused. He did exactly what he was accused of. It's a question of if it was justified or not.

As I've been saying since the beginning of this thread I'd feel a little differently if the First Amendment had been a thing for any of a few dozen other offenses. Where was Tallie's rightious rage when the cops were pepper spraying students a few years back?

Tinker violated the rules too.

The court found the rules unconstitutional.

What if the rules said only Christians can attend public school.

Does the fact that a school decided that is the rule decide its constitutionality?
 
As rhetoric that's grand, but as a valid comparison? Completely bogus, as is your bringing it up from the article as if it hasn't already been pointed out, many times, that the school's dress code merely prohibits images of violence.

Wearing a National Rifle Association t-shirt with a rifle on it is not a display of, or an incitement to, violence.

That's a matter of opinion.



I see you deliberately missed the part that goes over what they did when they were told to get down (they got down).

So? The scene was made or do you not understand how that works?


The kid wasn't arguing about gun control. He was pointing out that the teacher was wrong about the school's policy.

It doesn't actually matter. Teachers are not allowed, per policy (least last time I was in school), to engage students.

You're just wrong on this one, dude.

Shake it off. It happens.

Rolling Eyes in Rockford,
Ellie

I'm not wrong. The facts are simple. The kid stood up for what he thought was right, got punished, maybe he wins maybe he doesn't. Encase you haven't figured it out, I'm not against the kid. I hope this works out for him that doesn't change anything.

I do find it hilarious though that all the people who are constantly talking about how freedom isn't free are the first to start complaining when freedom has to be defended with something so minor as a bit of inconvenience.

I hope you guys start showing up when kids get suspended for dying their hair, or when the next girl shows up to prom in a Tux. Though I know good and damn well that you won't because this isn't about freedom of speech. That's your cover. This is about your perceived threat of guns being taken away.
 
Little update on the situation, maybe.

It seems there are many videos of the altercation and they all seem to indicate that the teacher was the one out of control. Further, the following day many of his classmates wore NRA T-shirts to school in a show of solidarity and the article doesn't mention ANY of them being confronted, which kinda throws a prejudicial element into the discussion that will surely appear before the court. And all of this occurred in W.Va????? What in the fuck was going through that teachers mind?

Just a guess here but I suspect when the dust settles there is going to be a teacher looking for employment.

Ishmael
 
That's a matter of opinion.

Not really. If someone is incited to violence by the sight of a rifle on an NRA shirt, then they're insane.

Besides, the teacher doesn't get to enforce his opinion. He gets to enforce school policy, and the kid's shirt doesn't violate school policy. Which is why other students are currently being allowed to wear that shirt in that school.


So? The scene was made or do you not understand how that works?

Yes, I do understand how that works. And since it was the teacher who was yelling, and other kids who were creating the disturbance, maybe they're the ones who should have been arrested.

Or maybe NO ONE should have been arrested and the kid should have been free to go on his merry and policy-abiding way.

It doesn't actually matter. Teachers are not allowed, per policy (least last time I was in school), to engage students.

Odd, because that's exactly what that teacher did. In a very volatile way.

I'm not wrong. The facts are simple. The kid stood up for what he thought was right, got punished, maybe he wins maybe he doesn't.

And it's looking more and more like he will win - because the facts are on his side.

Encase you haven't figured it out, I'm not against the kid. I hope this works out for him that doesn't change anything.

Then why are you so busily defending the teacher and trying to tell us the kid deserved what he got for breaking rules (that he didn't even break)?

I hope you guys start showing up when kids get suspended for dying their hair, or when the next girl shows up to prom in a Tux. Though I know good and damn well that you won't because this isn't about freedom of speech. That's your cover. This is about your perceived threat of guns being taken away.

Think that all you want, but that's not the case, at least as far as I'm cconcerned. If a kid was arrested for calmly objecting to being yelled at and commanded to change their hair when their hairstyle isn't even forbidden by the dress code, I'd say that stinks, too.

And I'd say the same thing if the situation was completely, politically reversed, and the kid was wearing a shirt that simply expressed solidarity with a pro-gun control group, and the teacher had created a scene and gotten the kid arrested on the pretext that the shirt incited violence because it brought up a controversial subject.

Really, get the polarizing stick out of your butt. Some of us really do just care about rights.


Dining in Denmark,
Ellie
 
Many CUNTries have weapon bans but is not stop the wholesale slaughter of innocent people. Mexico is one such CUNTry.

Talk to Canadians, they have very strict gun laws and their murder rate is a fraction of ours. The Mexicans have a strict laws, but they also have redneck states at their border where you can fill up a trunk with guns and come back down into Mexico, since people there don't think selling guns wholesale is anything but good business.The canadians have strict border crossing inspections and also severe penalties for those who traffic guns there.

Every study of where the guns comes from in Mexico highlights the fact they come from Texas and other border states with lax gun laws.
 
Not really. If someone is incited to violence by the sight of a rifle on an NRA shirt, then they're insane.

If someone isn't incited to violence by the words "Protect your rights" in conjunction with a rifle they clearly don't understand the connection. If a bunch of blacks showed up in Malcolm X shirts with the phrase "By any Means Necessary" again they either know the meaning of their shirt or they don't. If they do they are inciting violence, if they don't they don't have any business wearing that shirt.

Besides, the teacher doesn't get to enforce his opinion. He gets to enforce school policy, and the kid's shirt doesn't violate school policy. Which is why other students are currently being allowed to wear that shirt in that school.

Here the difference between opinion and policy is negligible. The current students are either getting a pass for the same reason he did for five classes (according to you) which is nobody cared or B, the school thinks they stepped in it and would rather not go any farther down that road. That doesn't mean they aren't wrong. Just that nobody intends to take them to task for it.


Yes, I do understand how that works. And since it was the teacher who was yelling, and other kids who were creating the disturbance, maybe they're the ones who should have been arrested.

The teacher is the authority figure. By not following instructions you are the instigator even if all you're doing is sitting silently while all hell breaks loose around you.


Or maybe NO ONE should have been arrested and the kid should have been free to go on his merry and policy-abiding way.

Perhaps. However that's not what happened. Something about bulls and horns comes to mind here.

Odd, because that's exactly what that teacher did. In a very volatile way.

Sorry, in debate. That should have been clear.



And it's looking more and more like he will win - because the facts are on his side.

Good for him.


Then why are you so busily defending the teacher and trying to tell us the kid deserved what he got for breaking rules (that he didn't even break)?

The student did break the rules. I didn't defend the teacher, I merely pointed out that the student paid the price for his disobedience. No defense of the teacher or police is necessary.

Think that all you want, but that's not the case, at least as far as I'm cconcerned. If a kid was arrested for calmly objecting to being yelled at and commanded to change their hair when their hairstyle isn't even forbidden by the dress code, I'd say that stinks, too.

And I'd say the same thing if the situation was completely, politically reversed, and the kid was wearing a shirt that simply expressed solidarity with a pro-gun control group, and the teacher had created a scene and gotten the kid arrested on the pretext that the shirt incited violence because it brought up a controversial subject.

Really, get the polarizing stick out of your butt. Some of us really do just care about rights.


Dining in Denmark,
Ellie

You however aren't one of them Ellie. Which is why you didn't say shit when any of the other stories broke and they break on a fairly regular basis. Again, why don't I remember you from the Occupy time? It's because you were silent then and you'll be silent the next time this comes up.
 
I wonder what would have happened if a kid came in wearing a T shirt that said Jesus was a myth and anyone who believed it was a moronic child...anyone wanna bet Ishmael and the rest of Fox News crowd would be yelling and screaming that the kid had no right to wear that, the Jesus is enshrined in our country and all the other drivel the morons who watch that believe?

I don't know what school policy in west virginia is, given the fact that the state only ranks educationally because arkansas and Mississippi are so low no one could go lower, but in many states they forbid T shirts with messages of any kind, liberal or conservative, pro or anti anything. Freedom of speech does not exist in the schools, the schools have the right to suppress anything that is disruptive or offensive, to maintain an orderly environment.If my hypothetical kid wore a t shirt with the Jesus is myth thing, you would hear a squalin' and yellin' that it is offensive to the snake handlers, and want it removed. The easiest way to maintain the piece is not allow t shirts at all with messages. If the school allows any kind of messages, that would be legal, if ill advised; if all they allow is for example pro gun and not anti gun messages, it is a violation, since it would be the school taking sides.

But schools are not bound by the first amendment and have not been, and courts have upheld it time and again. Likewise, schools censor school newspapers, but they can get in trouble if they censor let's say liberal points of view while allowing junior Rush Limbaughs to spout off. They either can sensor everything they consider controversial, or allow everything, no middle ground. I would bet if some kid came in with his anti jesus t shirt the school would tell him to take it off or reverse it, while letting NRA kids wear their t shirts, and in court they would be ripped to shreds.
 
<snip>

But schools are not bound by the first amendment and have not been, and courts have upheld it time and again. Likewise, schools censor school newspapers, but they can get in trouble if they censor let's say liberal points of view while allowing junior Rush Limbaughs to spout off. They either can sensor everything they consider controversial, or allow everything, no middle ground. I would bet if some kid came in with his anti jesus t shirt the school would tell him to take it off or reverse it, while letting NRA kids wear their t shirts, and in court they would be ripped to shreds.

So when was Tinker v. Des Moines Independent School District overruled?
 
Last edited:
I wonder what would have happened if a kid came in wearing a T shirt that said Jesus was a myth and anyone who believed it was a moronic child...anyone wanna bet Ishmael and the rest of Fox News crowd would be yelling and screaming that the kid had no right to wear that, the Jesus is enshrined in our country and all the other drivel the morons who watch that believe?

I don't know what school policy in west virginia is, given the fact that the state only ranks educationally because arkansas and Mississippi are so low no one could go lower, but in many states they forbid T shirts with messages of any kind, liberal or conservative, pro or anti anything. Freedom of speech does not exist in the schools, the schools have the right to suppress anything that is disruptive or offensive, to maintain an orderly environment.If my hypothetical kid wore a t shirt with the Jesus is myth thing, you would hear a squalin' and yellin' that it is offensive to the snake handlers, and want it removed. The easiest way to maintain the piece is not allow t shirts at all with messages. If the school allows any kind of messages, that would be legal, if ill advised; if all they allow is for example pro gun and not anti gun messages, it is a violation, since it would be the school taking sides.

But schools are not bound by the first amendment and have not been, and courts have upheld it time and again. Likewise, schools censor school newspapers, but they can get in trouble if they censor let's say liberal points of view while allowing junior Rush Limbaughs to spout off. They either can sensor everything they consider controversial, or allow everything, no middle ground. I would bet if some kid came in with his anti jesus t shirt the school would tell him to take it off or reverse it, while letting NRA kids wear their t shirts, and in court they would be ripped to shreds.

You really suck at reading minds, don't ya?

The schools can make all the rules they want, but in the end they answer to the people of the community. Logan W. Va. is so far back in the sticks they probably have to import sunlight. The main road is Old US Highway 319, implying that the 'new' US highway bypassed them. You can pretty well count on almost every member of the community being members of the UMWA Union and NRA members as well. Regardless of how the case turns out you can count on the fact that that teacher is no longer a respected member of the community. He or she may as well pack their shit and move now.

That being said, there is NO pending disciplinary action contemplated by the school for his breaking any rule. I take from that that the powers that be in the school don't believe he broke any rules whatsoever. And there was no mention of any disciplinary action being taken for standing up to the teacher either. (Another reason the teacher should be packing their shit and moving on.)

Apparently the only outstanding issue is the arrest for disruption of the school and I'm betting every kid with a cell phone has a video of exactly what went on there. And if those videos show that it was indeed the teacher that was getting out of hand, well, buh bye teacher.

Ishmael
 
If someone isn't incited to violence by the words "Protect your rights" in conjunction with a rifle they clearly don't understand the connection.

All it means is protect your second amendment rights. That's all. There's always been a rifle on the National Rifle Association's logo, as far as I know, and the phrase "protect your rights" means only that.

And keep in mind - the teacher told him (wrongly) that any image of a gun was prohibited by the dress code.

You're the one trying to concoct a connection to incitement to violence by the phrase "protect your rights" being on the shirt. It never even came up during the incident.

Here the difference between opinion and policy is negligible.

No, it's not. Obviously.

The current students are either getting a pass for the same reason he did for five classes (according to you) which is nobody cared or B, the school thinks they stepped in it and would rather not go any farther down that road. That doesn't mean they aren't wrong. Just that nobody intends to take them to task for it.

Or the truth of the matter, which is that it doesn't breach the dress code.

The teacher is the authority figure.

And authority figures can be wrong, as he was, and it's perfectly okay to point out their mistakes.

By not following instructions you are the instigator even if all you're doing is sitting silently while all hell breaks loose around you.

And yet, quite rightly, no one blames Gandhi for all the riots and killing perpetrated by his followers.


As in, for sure.

The student did break the rules.

No, he didn't.

You however aren't one of them Ellie. Which is why you didn't say shit when any of the other stories broke and they break on a fairly regular basis. Again, why don't I remember you from the Occupy time? It's because you were silent then and you'll be silent the next time this comes up.

Huh? What are you even talking about? I'm not even around here most of the time. If the only way I can be fair in your eyes is to show up with bells on every time someone here posts about an injustice, well... it's never going to happen. Even when I'm here I don't click on every thread.

I clicked on this one because it was new, and the title indicated it concerned the first amendment (not the second, please note), and then I saw what the subject was, and I happened to know about the case in question, so I commented.

Jerk. :mad:

Offended in Oman,
Ellie
 
Back
Top