Liberal democracy's final hour?

Ishmael

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Posts
84,005
http://www.townhall.com/columnists/paulcraigroberts/

Paul Craig Roberts
November 20, 2002

Liberal democracy's final hour?

When the Soviet Union collapsed a decade ago, neoconservatives proclaimed "the end of history," by which they meant the emergence of an ecumenical world organized by liberal democracy.

Noting China's ambitions and the re-emergence of Islam, skeptics regard the neoconservative thesis as little more than an expression of hope. China and Islam aside, powerful developments within the West itself are leading away from liberal democracy.

These developments are both intellectual and political. For example, multiculturalism and the emergence of group rights based on victim status are eroding equality in law, freedom of conscience and free speech. As these are the historic achievements of liberal democracy, how can the future belong to a system that is undergoing meltdown at its core?

Both the United States and Europe now have crimes of opinion, a defining feature of Oceania in George Orwell's "1984." Americans and Europeans are subject to arrest and imprisonment for words judged offensive by the therapeutic state. This frightening departure from Western tradition is justified in the name of curtailing hate and
advancing human rights.

While the Western identity is melting down intellectually, it is being dissolved politically. The historic identities of European nationalities are being replaced by an abstraction. Briton, Frenchman, German, Italian, Swede, Czech, Greek, Austrian, Dane, Spaniard and Dutchman are to become "European" citizens of a new bureaucratic state created by edicts and without a history.

These are not promising developments for liberal democracy. Differences of opinion within homogeneous nation-states have often challenged consensual government, with bitter divisions erupting in national strikes and political violence. Imagine these differences multiplied by aggregating many nationalities into one state.

The politics of the European Union will have to deal not only with the differences of opinion within the separate nationalities, but also with the differences between the different nationalities that comprise the new superstate. Will not consent be more difficult to obtain, thus enhancing the scope for coercion? Will liberal democracy be the model, or will the model be bureaucratic coercion ruling through the same unaccountable edicts that are being used to create the European Union?

Large-scale immigration of people from different cultures is turning the United States as well into a multi-nationalities state. The political emergence of disparate and hyphenated identities reduces the range of issues that can be resolved by persuasion and consent. Coercive regulations already exist to enforce victim-group rights and to regulate speech.

Other developments are eating away at the foundations of liberal democracy. Having lost its national identity to hyphenated populations, the United States can only respond to terrorism with constitutionally suspect legislation, which permits officials to set aside civil liberties, and by empowering a Department of Homeland Security to keep a dossier on every citizen. Only illegal immigrants will have privacy.

Multicultural populations do not possess the comity among citizens that flows from a national identity. Having discarded national identities, the United States and the European Union are multicultural empires. Empires have poor records of self-government and tend to rely on coercion. Liberal democracy is a creation of the nation-state and is unlikely to persist in the emerging multicultural empires.

It was America's unique achievement to create a national identity out of European ethnicities. When immigration worked for America, all the incentives were for an immigrant to make himself into an American.

Today, the incentives are for immigrants to retain the privileges of preferred minorityhood. A few states go so far as to grant special advantages, such as in-state tuition, to illegal immigrants. This is not a policy that promotes comity. What is the meaning of citizenship when the rewards to the illegal immigrant trump the penalties of his illegal presence and give him financial advantages over citizens?

Western governments are undermining themselves by creating populations of disparate peoples with disparate rights. The resulting antagonisms are inconsistent with liberal democracy. The clash of civilizations is upon us from within our own borders. If China and Islam only bide their time, the world is theirs. It is not the end of history; it is the end of the West.

--------------------------------------------------

Ishmael
 
Don't forget to add - "Coservatives truly aren't concerned with what you think or want anyways...they're out for special interests."
 
Ishmael said:
http://www.townhall.com/columnists/paulcraigroberts/

Paul Craig Roberts
November 20, 2002

Liberal democracy's final hour?


It was America's unique achievement to create a national identity out of European ethnicities. When immigration worked for America, all the incentives were for an immigrant to make himself into an American.

Today, the incentives are for immigrants to retain the privileges of preferred minorityhood. A few states go so far as to grant special advantages, such as in-state tuition, to illegal immigrants. This is not a policy that promotes comity. What is the meaning of citizenship when the rewards to the illegal immigrant trump the penalties of his illegal presence and give him financial advantages over citizens?

These two paragraphs really hit home with me. My father's parents immigrated here from Naples in 1910. They had 9 children of which only 5 lived to adulthood. It was stressed to those children, by their parents, to become "American."

My grandparents became American citizens. My father and his brother fought in WWII. Italian was still spoken at home but never in front of company. It was the dream of my grandparents for their children to be Americans or they would never have left Italy.

Thanksgiving's at my nona's (grandma) consisted of a traditional American feast, with ravioli included. We never forgot where we came from but we never lost sight of fact that we are Americans, not Italians.

No longer do immigrants to America feel like this. Somehow, somewhere this philosophy has been lost. This is a sad and somewhat scary essay that has been posted here. But seems to be very true. *Where* is the incentive to be a citizen? There seems to no longer be one, as stated in this essay.
 
All due respect to Mr. Roberts. BULLSHIT.

For one thing, Islam and CHina might enjoy temporary resurgence for the beliefs that they espouse, but since they also both like to trash freedom of the individuals and the ability to think for one's self...I highly douobt that either Islam or China will survive in the end. Islam, while a great religion, has too many suffering enslaved people to fully enjoy the greatness it once held and China, North Korea, and other countries like them have so many ways of trying to control their people they will not be able to keep up with it in the end either.

Humans were naturally created FREE. They were also given a thought process unlike any other creature on earth. Due to this natural ability, we as humans have a need to remain free from opression. The West will fall when it tries to join with those who would take our freedoms and enslave us. That is a fact of life that will always be. There will always be a struggle for freedoms and rights. We enjoy as a country the most free country in the world, bar none. We as American citizens need to guard these freedoms firmly and sharply in order to keep them for our decendants.
 
curious2c said:
All due respect to Mr. Roberts. BULLSHIT.

For one thing, Islam and CHina might enjoy temporary resurgence for the beliefs that they espouse, but since they also both like to trash freedom of the individuals and the ability to think for one's self...I highly douobt that either Islam or China will survive in the end. Islam, while a great religion, has too many suffering enslaved people to fully enjoy the greatness it once held and China, North Korea, and other countries like them have so many ways of trying to control their people they will not be able to keep up with it in the end either.

Humans were naturally created FREE. They were also given a thought process unlike any other creature on earth. Due to this natural ability, we as humans have a need to remain free from opression. The West will fall when it tries to join with those who would take our freedoms and enslave us. That is a fact of life that will always be. There will always be a struggle for freedoms and rights. We enjoy as a country the most free country in the world, bar none. We as American citizens need to guard these freedoms firmly and sharply in order to keep them for our decendants.

Hmmmmmmmm, you call the article "bull shit" then go on to say the very same thing the article said.

That's strange, don't you think?

Ishmael
 
I called bullshit because there are enough people out there in the US of A that feel strongly like I do and we will work to keep us free. As long as there are people here that feel taht way, we still have some influence on keeping the US free and on its constitutional path.
 
curious2c said:
I called bullshit because there are enough people out there in the US of A that feel strongly like I do and we will work to keep us free. As long as there are people here that feel taht way, we still have some influence on keeping the US free and on its constitutional path.

But the article points out the very real erosions that we are enacting on ourselves that are leading us away from "Liberal Democracy."

One small bite at a time in the name of multi-culturalism, security (financial and physical), and tolerance. The very steps that are taken are forms of imposed thought. With prescribed punishments for not agreeing with those thoughts.

I just don't see enough people concerned with the 'vigilence' that you describe.

Look at PC's thread on the "Homeland Security" and LionessInWinters thread on the "European Union".

Ishmael
 
Part of the problem is that some people, like me, when we get 'fired up' tend to point out the constitutional issues that are being eroded and before you know it we are being pointed at as 'those conspiracy weirdo's'. Fact is I see the constitution being eroded daily and the press is right there pushing to end all rights except of course theirs in the first amendmant, however, without the others the first has no back, no teeth, and no protection.

Factually, he is correct. Spiritually, I will fight to the bitter end to preserve our way of life and the constitution of the United States of America.
 
Ishmael said:
http://www.townhall.com/columnists/paulcraigroberts/

Paul Craig Roberts
November 20, 2002

Liberal democracy's final hour?

When the Soviet Union collapsed a decade ago, neoconservatives proclaimed "the end of history," by which they meant the emergence of an ecumenical world organized by liberal democracy.

Noting China's ambitions and the re-emergence of Islam, skeptics regard the neoconservative thesis as little more than an expression of hope. China and Islam aside, powerful developments within the West itself are leading away from liberal democracy.

These developments are both intellectual and political. For example, multiculturalism and the emergence of group rights based on victim status are eroding equality in law, freedom of conscience and free speech. As these are the historic achievements of liberal democracy, how can the future belong to a system that is undergoing meltdown at its core?

Both the United States and Europe now have crimes of opinion, a defining feature of Oceania in George Orwell's "1984." Americans and Europeans are subject to arrest and imprisonment for words judged offensive by the therapeutic state. This frightening departure from Western tradition is justified in the name of curtailing hate and
advancing human rights.

While the Western identity is melting down intellectually, it is being dissolved politically. The historic identities of European nationalities are being replaced by an abstraction. Briton, Frenchman, German, Italian, Swede, Czech, Greek, Austrian, Dane, Spaniard and Dutchman are to become "European" citizens of a new bureaucratic state created by edicts and without a history.

These are not promising developments for liberal democracy. Differences of opinion within homogeneous nation-states have often challenged consensual government, with bitter divisions erupting in national strikes and political violence. Imagine these differences multiplied by aggregating many nationalities into one state.

The politics of the European Union will have to deal not only with the differences of opinion within the separate nationalities, but also with the differences between the different nationalities that comprise the new superstate. Will not consent be more difficult to obtain, thus enhancing the scope for coercion? Will liberal democracy be the model, or will the model be bureaucratic coercion ruling through the same unaccountable edicts that are being used to create the European Union?

Large-scale immigration of people from different cultures is turning the United States as well into a multi-nationalities state. The political emergence of disparate and hyphenated identities reduces the range of issues that can be resolved by persuasion and consent. Coercive regulations already exist to enforce victim-group rights and to regulate speech.

Other developments are eating away at the foundations of liberal democracy. Having lost its national identity to hyphenated populations, the United States can only respond to terrorism with constitutionally suspect legislation, which permits officials to set aside civil liberties, and by empowering a Department of Homeland Security to keep a dossier on every citizen. Only illegal immigrants will have privacy.

Multicultural populations do not possess the comity among citizens that flows from a national identity. Having discarded national identities, the United States and the European Union are multicultural empires. Empires have poor records of self-government and tend to rely on coercion. Liberal democracy is a creation of the nation-state and is unlikely to persist in the emerging multicultural empires.

It was America's unique achievement to create a national identity out of European ethnicities. When immigration worked for America, all the incentives were for an immigrant to make himself into an American.

Today, the incentives are for immigrants to retain the privileges of preferred minorityhood. A few states go so far as to grant special advantages, such as in-state tuition, to illegal immigrants. This is not a policy that promotes comity. What is the meaning of citizenship when the rewards to the illegal immigrant trump the penalties of his illegal presence and give him financial advantages over citizens?

Western governments are undermining themselves by creating populations of disparate peoples with disparate rights. The resulting antagonisms are inconsistent with liberal democracy. The clash of civilizations is upon us from within our own borders. If China and Islam only bide their time, the world is theirs. It is not the end of history; it is the end of the West.

--------------------------------------------------

Ishmael

ABSOLUTE CRAP AND LIES!

Just kidding, I didn't read it.
 
lavender said:
Ish,

I think if you read your article, it's not bashing American liberal/ or Democrat party ideology.

Would you agree with this assessment?

That can't be said for certain now Lavy. But in general principle I agree. The author, to me, is espousing an erosion that the even the 'old line' liberals such as HHH, or J. Patrick, would have and do have deep concerns with. I believe that is of concern to all Americans, regardless of political bent.

Ishmael
 
curious2c said:
Part of the problem is that some people, like me, when we get 'fired up' tend to point out the constitutional issues that are being eroded and before you know it we are being pointed at as 'those conspiracy weirdo's'. Fact is I see the constitution being eroded daily and the press is right there pushing to end all rights except of course theirs in the first amendmant, however, without the others the first has no back, no teeth, and no protection.

Factually, he is correct. Spiritually, I will fight to the bitter end to preserve our way of life and the constitution of the United States of America.

I don't think he wrote the article because he's given up.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
. The author, to me, is espousing an erosion that the even the 'old line' liberals such as HHH, would have and do have deep concerns with.

KEEP RASSLIN' OUT OF POLITICS!
 
Whew boy...ummm...well i re-read the thing twice more. I know what he is saing is factual. It really gets me going though when I read something like this. sometimes my anger quotient runs wild before I stop to keep control and I angrily shout out my thoughts on the whole issue as a rant/rave

His assesment is close to accurate, and I really hate that he is correct. that is why I hollered bullshit. I keep thinking back to the constitution and how our founders wanted it set so we could reamin free and then see this shit happening all the time and the people, rather, sheeple let it go. Uncaring as to how much they are actually giving up for a tiny little bit of non protection that each theft of our rights gives in return.

My blood boils hot with the anger of loss. Loss of rights, loss of freedoms, loss of money to support these BS political actions with no end. It has happened so slowly so quietly, most people are fooled into bellieveing that there is no real loss. I blame the press in most ways since they have the power to be a whole lot less 'selective' in what they produce for the people to read and see. Perhaps since all the editors (senior ones) are members of the same clubs, drink and the same bars, go to the same places for entertainment, ther could be a corelation there, but we will never see it in print or on the tube since then it involves them. Then it becomes a 'freedom of the press' issue.
 
Re: Re: Liberal democracy's final hour?

A Desert Rose said:
These two paragraphs really hit home with me. My father's parents immigrated here from Naples in 1910. They had 9 children of which only 5 lived to adulthood. It was stressed to those children, by their parents, to become "American."

My grandparents became American citizens. My father and his brother fought in WWII. Italian was still spoken at home but never in front of company. It was the dream of my grandparents for their children to be Americans or they would never have left Italy.

Thanksgiving's at my nona's (grandma) consisted of a traditional American feast, with ravioli included. We never forgot where we came from but we never lost sight of fact that we are Americans, not Italians.

No longer do immigrants to America feel like this. Somehow, somewhere this philosophy has been lost. This is a sad and somewhat scary essay that has been posted here. But seems to be very true. *Where* is the incentive to be a citizen? There seems to no longer be one, as stated in this essay.

My family from my mothers side was second generation Welsh, language was not a problem. The desire to be "American" was deeply ingrained though. My father's side goes back to before the country was ever formed so no point in discussing that.

I do understand what you're saying and the tide started to turn in the 70's. That is when I began to notice the ghettos of illegals first.

Ishmael
 
This is one of those instances where the term Liberal isn't what it has come to mean over the last few election cycles.

It is to our detriment that we have gotten away from the melting pot.

At a time when Europe seeks to unite, determining from our example that it is better, we seek to Balkanize determining from the European model that that is better...
 
The decline of national identity walks hand in hand with the evolution of individualism which affects all generations alive today.

We tend to relate to more local issues than national. We are more active in our local community than in global affairs. It all started in the 60's, where modern individualism was born. Only now do we see the effects.

People may wave the national flag, but they don't line up around the block to enlist anymore. The national flag is rhetoric, the rising tax on, say, property in the local area is an issue we take seriously. Or getting that bank loan to build an extension. Or buy a boat. Or go on holiday.

The decline of a broad identity and, for argument's sake, religion, not to mention the rise of individual values is, indeed, dangerous when you consider the homogenous values of a religion like Islam.

The Chinese? Don't worry about them. There are now 60 million Chinese who are richer than you and I. When more of their countrymen join their ranks, they'll go down the same path as us.
 
Okay, so the melting pot is being shoved aside for something that more closely fits a "Seperate but equal" sort of system... Which has never seemed to work.

What are we meant to do about it? Vigilance? You mean watch it happening?

I am uncertain.

Like most I have the same immagrant ancestry, the same sorts of stories about making their way and becoming Americans. But at the same time they had kept their heritage. Hung onto the languages, the traditions, the silly folk-costumes. You name it.

What I do not understand is why these things that my family, and so many others, kept for hearth and home has now exploded all over the streets.

Perhaps I'm just running my mouth at this point, but it seems that the shift comes when immigrant populations (regardless of which) begin to see America like a sort of theme park. They become visitors or guests to be respected. Otherwise it's like a vending machine. A place to get what you need to send back home.

While I understand the pressures that cause this, it does sadden me to have become a sort of supermarket.

Have we brought this on ourselves though? We as a country have never been particularly happy to take in things that were not in keeping with a certain slice of euro-christianish thinking. Well, not openly anyway.

The real question being that could we ever have been wholly accepting of everything and NOT end up the way things are going now?I mean the thing that galvanized this country was conformity. Making one's way in THE WAY America did things.

Does it then inherently follow that relaxing conformity destroys liberal democracy? I'm to hazy to even voice a firm opinion.
 
Oscuridad said:

Have we brought this on ourselves though? We as a country have never been particularly happy to take in things that were not in keeping with a certain slice of euro-christianish thinking. Well, not openly anyway.

The real question being that could we ever have been wholly accepting of everything and NOT end up the way things are going now?I mean the thing that galvanized this country was conformity. Making one's way in THE WAY America did things.

Does it then inherently follow that relaxing conformity destroys liberal democracy? I'm to hazy to even voice a firm opinion.

Yes we did bring this on ourselves. It was a knee jerk reaction to discrimination. So instead of letting society mature naturally, we created statutes that created a permanent 'victim' class.

Being "American" is not what you wear, what church you go to, your favorite food. None of that. It's about being free and a philosophy concerning man's realtionship to the government. An attitude as it were. That is one of the reasons that we could assimilate so many diverse cultures and still end up with Americans.

That is no longer true. The 'seperate but equal' that you pointed out is quickly becoming the norm, with legal sanctions for those that do not approve of the new paradigm. Mind legislation as it were. Converting a thought to a criminal action. So much for the first amendment.

By providing 'protected and subsidized' status to ethnic sub-groups you are encouraging them NOT to join the mainstream population. And that is a prescription for disaster.

Ishmael
 
I find myself on-board with that assessment as stated...

But, and I know I'm going to regeret saying this, what about real discrimination by the assimilated vs new immigrant groups? We aren't going to say there is no discrimination are we?

I agree the situation has now been engineered, and poorly...
But what do we then do to curtail abuse of power in those few individuals who can and do abuse it?
 
Oscuridad said:
I find myself on-board with that assessment as stated...

But, and I know I'm going to regeret saying this, what about real discrimination by the assimilated vs new immigrant groups? We aren't going to say there is no discrimination are we?

I agree the situation has now been engineered, and poorly...
But what do we then do to curtail abuse of power in those few individuals who can and do abuse it?

Discrimination is real. It exists today, it existed yesterday, it will always exist. But is the answer to replace one form of discrimination with another?

It is a matter of time and education.

The American Black is quickly isolating themselves from mainstream society. Is this the path to integration and acceptance, or balkanization and class warfare?

To legislate thought is to engender anger, and eventually hatred. That will lead to a backlash.

Ishmael
 
This is the reason Ive always wondered why people dont call them selves americans instead of african-american asian-american german-american

etc.

they WANT to be different it seems.
 
I have always thought that adding to the title of American was a device given to people like me to replace other words we were using that they liked less...

Perhaps if one did not feel the need to call someone a name based on their differences then we would not have this problem.

*flips a page in Moore's "Utopia"*

But can one really expect that to happen anytime soon...
 
Oscuridad said:
I have always thought that adding to the title of American was a device given to people like me to replace other words we were using that they liked less...

Perhaps if one did not feel the need to call someone a name based on their differences then we would not have this problem.

*flips a page in Moore's "Utopia"*

But can one really expect that to happen anytime soon...

american

thats all
one word
 
Back
Top