Liberals out there...

The Preacher

Really Really Experienced
Joined
Jul 5, 2002
Posts
301
Do you support globalisation? I find this inconsistancy in liberal tradition a very interesting one...
 
What do you mean by globilization, Preacher man
 
There are no liberals at literotica. We make republicans look liberal by comparison. George Bush and his baby boy president are radical left-wingers bent on the destruction of our core values.
 
Liberal what?

Do you mean a Union member who lives in a trailer park , or the Republican that lives next to him ?

:cool:
 
i don't really consider myself a liberal, but i guess others see me like that. and i'm against the exploitation of third world nations due to globalization by large corporations
 
I am not strictly a liberal but have some left leanings.

Free trade implies the unrestricted movement of capital,
goods, and labour. Globalization as practiced, is the free
movement of capital and reduced restrictions on trading
of goods.

In the real world, I think this translates into companies
shifting production to other areas to eliminate requirements
of worker safety and environmental laws.

Free movement of labour implies the elimination of
emigration laws which will be a tough sell and may not
even be wise given the terrorism threat.

The results of "free trade" in the "new world order" include
permitting industrial pollution and abuse of labour in third
world countries that no industrialized or service economy
would permit. In addition, the middle and low class in
the US is being squeezed, creating an increased disparity
between the haves and the have-nots.

The world would be better off if we were more honest about
what is happening and the only way to do this is, I believe,
to implement campaign finance reform. The current system is
nothing more than legalized bribery. If you like what is
happening, vote for republicrats. If not vote for third party
candidates.
 
metal_minx said:
i don't really consider myself a liberal, but i guess others see me like that. and i'm against the exploitation of third world nations due to globalization by large corporations


Type Saint Gobain into your search. You will find it is a French Company that owns roughly half of what you call large corporations and was founded in the 1700's. So your vote here would have little effect on them. :eek:

:cool:
 
Here's the thing. In the USA, and all Western nations, you're dealing with a liberal democracy. Liberalism, stems from people such as Locke, Hobbes, Smith, etc. and Democracy from Ancient Athens. Now, these two, seemingly opposing values, are married in Western society.

Liberalism is all the stuff in the bill of rights. It's a strong focus on the individual, a wariness of the state, and most importantly, embodies civil and economic, rights. Now, this means, you're dealing with a relatively free market economy, as opposed to, say, a planned market. This is what the REAL bane with communism is, you take away peopels economic rights. All rights flow from capital and income. All your rights are dependant on your ability to exercise them at law. When you strive for "equality" (the democratic ideal, the individual as a utility for the state, I'll get to this in a mo), you FORCABLY remove economic, and thus, social rights. Liberalism allows you to set up a lemonade stand, as well as not be beaten down.

Democracy, on the other hand, sees the individual as a tool to be utilized in the best possible way (ie. voting, participation in the electorial and political system). The individual has no intrinsic value in itself (BIG difference). The philosophy is state focused. Democracy is often touted as allowing people to have rights, the truth is quite the opposite. Democracy, in it's classical form, would FORCE you to vote and participate, unwillingly or otherwise, in the political system. It is a system designed entirely to cater to the majority totally, no room for flexibility.

Now, this all gets mixed up in the wash, and liberalism is starting to mean "humanitarian". A humanitarian may well be a communist, it'd be a very short sighted view in my opinion, but should one think that all they need is a bed, food and a job, then yeah, it'd be a viable theory. "Liberal" has started to mean one who supports welfare, for instance, one who is anti-globalisation.

Now, what I am asking the new liberals here, is are you a classical, neo-economics liberal, or are you a social liberal, a closest communist? If you are a social liberal, you're essentially in support of a welfare state (in varying degrees) and disagree entirely with the founding principles of liberalism.
 
Stroll thru your home and look at the small print on the bottom of your stuff and count the number of items made in China. We already trade with countries that screw labor and the enviroment. Importing terrorists is an everyday occurance.

We may never bust the Saint Gobains but we can at least control how and on what terms we do business with them.
 
SaintPeter said:
Stroll thru your home and look at the small print on the bottom of your stuff and count the number of items made in China. We already trade with countries that screw labor and the enviroment. Importing terrorists is an everyday occurance.

We may never bust the Saint Gobains but we can at least control how and on what terms we do business with them.

Largest "UNION" constrution company in the world, Bechtel, is republican owned.

One of the largest "NON-UNION" is Brown and Root of Texas, started and owned by Lady Bird Johnson.

While you debate which party is best for what, both parties make money off your sweat and toil. They play both sides, does it make sense for you to stay on one only?

:cool:
 
So this is a drive in restaurant in Hollywood...
So this is a drive in restaurant in Hollywood...

So this is a drive in restaurant in Hollywood...
 
koalabear said:


Largest "UNION" constrution company in the world, Bechtel, is republican owned.

One of the largest "NON-UNION" is Brown and Root of Texas, started and owned by Lady Bird Johnson.

While you debate which party is best for what, both parties make money off your sweat and toil. They play both sides, does it make sense for you to stay on one only?

:cool:


The choice of political party does not keep one from choosing goods made by companies that show concern for the workers and enviroment. I do not think the guy that built the parts for my computer makes the money Lady Bird Johnson makes. As a consumer we can use our money to force big biz to treat the enviroment with respect.

The army will tell you "dont shit in your messkit." Good advice. The air, water, and earth are your messkit. Show how you want these assets treated with you dollar.

These changes may not occur overnight. It will cost you more for your computer doo-dads. Messkit companies may have to provide insurance and decent wages for the makers of the
messkits. Consider it an investment in your future.
 
koalabear said:


Largest "UNION" constrution company in the world, Bechtel, is republican owned.

One of the largest "NON-UNION" is Brown and Root of Texas, started and owned by Lady Bird Johnson.

While you debate which party is best for what, both parties make money off your sweat and toil. They play both sides, does it make sense for you to stay on one only?

:cool:

Koala, I think you have made this charge-claim before on the board. I won't make any claims concerning the party affiliation of the Bechtel family, I don't know them or how they vote. I do think individuals have the right to be in business for themselves and if the are diligent and successful enough to build that business into one of the largest most talented companies without going public, more power to them!

To imply that they are "Republican owned" is absurd!



www.bechtel.com/history.html

Rhumb:rolleyes:
 
RhumbRunner13 said:


Koala, I think you have made this charge-claim before on the board. I won't make any claims concerning the party affiliation of the Bechtel family, I don't know them or how they vote. I do think individuals have the right to be in business for themselves and if the are diligent and successful enough to build that business into one of the largest most talented companies without going public, more power to them!

To imply that they are "Republican owned" is absurd!



www.bechtel.com/history.html

Rhumb:rolleyes:


So is your useless link.

http://pages.prodigy.net/rogerlori1/emoticons/rolleyes1.gif
 
I really think that there is a big difference between "Liberal and Conservative" as a philosophy and "Democrat and Rebublican" as a political party. (Or in Canada, Liberals vs PC/Alliance.)

Let's face it, in reality the difference between the two parties is virtually nothing. Both are corrupt, niether has any real desire to change the status quo. Minor differences in policy make them appear different, but in reality, they are pretty much the same. Think of your life now, compared to when Clinton was in power. (Aside from events caused by Sept 11, which is outside the domestic political spectrum) how has your life changed as a result of a new Rebuplican president? Are your taxes lower, is the gov't really cutting spending, paying off the debt etc?

What is really needed is a complete change of the concept of the party system. Fresh people with fresh idea's, whether they ble liberal or conservative. People interested in actually making real change happen, instead of the stagnation that has been caused by professional politicians and the bureaucracy which really runs the country.
 
The Preacher said:
Do you support globalisation? I find this inconsistancy in liberal tradition a very interesting one...

Is "globalisation" European, or can conservatives just not spell correctly?
 
Dragon Dreamer said:
I really think that there is a big difference between "Liberal and Conservative" as a philosophy and "Democrat and Rebublican" as a political party. (Or in Canada, Liberals vs PC/Alliance.)

Let's face it, in reality the difference between the two parties is virtually nothing. Both are corrupt, niether has any real desire to change the status quo. Minor differences in policy make them appear different, but in reality, they are pretty much the same. Think of your life now, compared to when Clinton was in power. (Aside from events caused by Sept 11, which is outside the domestic political spectrum) how has your life changed as a result of a new Rebuplican president? Are your taxes lower, is the gov't really cutting spending, paying off the debt etc?

What is really needed is a complete change of the concept of the party system. Fresh people with fresh idea's, whether they ble liberal or conservative. People interested in actually making real change happen, instead of the stagnation that has been caused by professional politicians and the bureaucracy which really runs the country.

Well said. http://pages.prodigy.net/rogerlori1/emoticons/beer1.gif
 
The Preacher said:
Here's the thing. In the USA, and all Western nations, you're dealing with a liberal democracy. Liberalism, stems from people such as Locke, Hobbes, Smith, etc. and Democracy from Ancient Athens. Now, these two, seemingly opposing values, are married in Western society.

Liberalism is all the stuff in the bill of rights. It's a strong focus on the individual, a wariness of the state, and most importantly, embodies civil and economic, rights. Now, this means, you're dealing with a relatively free market economy, as opposed to, say, a planned market. This is what the REAL bane with communism is, you take away peopels economic rights. All rights flow from capital and income. All your rights are dependant on your ability to exercise them at law. When you strive for "equality" (the democratic ideal, the individual as a utility for the state, I'll get to this in a mo), you FORCABLY remove economic, and thus, social rights. Liberalism allows you to set up a lemonade stand, as well as not be beaten down.

Democracy, on the other hand, sees the individual as a tool to be utilized in the best possible way (ie. voting, participation in the electorial and political system). The individual has no intrinsic value in itself (BIG difference). The philosophy is state focused. Democracy is often touted as allowing people to have rights, the truth is quite the opposite. Democracy, in it's classical form, would FORCE you to vote and participate, unwillingly or otherwise, in the political system. It is a system designed entirely to cater to the majority totally, no room for flexibility.

Now, this all gets mixed up in the wash, and liberalism is starting to mean "humanitarian". A humanitarian may well be a communist, it'd be a very short sighted view in my opinion, but should one think that all they need is a bed, food and a job, then yeah, it'd be a viable theory. "Liberal" has started to mean one who supports welfare, for instance, one who is anti-globalisation.

Now, what I am asking the new liberals here, is are you a classical, neo-economics liberal, or are you a social liberal, a closest communist? If you are a social liberal, you're essentially in support of a welfare state (in varying degrees) and disagree entirely with the founding principles of liberalism.

Say WHAT?

The United States is not a democracy and was never designed to be one. The word isn't mentioned in the Constitution.

Go do your homework and report back on what form of government we have.
 
Re: Re: Liberals out there...

TWB, is America that insular that they don't realise other people spell correctly? :D

America is quite clearly a democracy, worded explicitly in the constitution or otherwise. Once a democracy becomes representative, it becomes a liberal democracy, away from classical notions of democracy, Athenian democracy. If this is the case, as you say, in regards to the American constitution then it because for most of political history, since the conception of classical liberalism, the two traditions have been seen as mutually exclusive. This is ESPECIALLY important as America has a Bill of Rights, Being that America was trying to marry these two concepts in a very innovative way, it's not surprising that the actual terms "liberalism" and "democracy" are not explicitly referenced. Nevertheless, I think it is self evident that America, along with Western society is a representative, modern, democracy.
 
Last edited:
Once a democracy becomes representative, it becomes a liberal democracy,

Well, that proves your point.

:rolleyes:
 
Miles, I just realised how TERRIBLY written my response was.

What I am trying to say is that you are right in a sense, America was never designed to be a classically democratic state, however, the social principles of democracy, which incorperate modern democracy, have been maintained. However America today is a more liberal society, lack of emphasis on welfare, for instance. My question in this thread, is that, if you consider yourself a liberal, do you equate that with humanitarian principles, or are you in favour of economic rationalism, and more classical liberal viewpoints.
 
The distinction you are trying to draw here is a good and useful one, preacher. Most people, I think, have no conception of the classical conceptions of conservatism and liberalism (and I don't mean that statement to be pointing fingers at anyone here), and so instead merely work from the more recent associations having to do with attitudes on humanitarian issues--which, as you rightly note, are often in conflict with the classical conceptions of those terms.

I would say that nearly all Americans are 'liberals' in the classic sense of the term, and that when we use the terms 'liberal' or 'conservative' today, we're using them in reference to attitudes on humanitarian issues.

As for 'globalization' . . . it's just "colonialism lite"--late modern capitalism's way of putting a smiley face on its exploitative and inequalitarian practices.
 
Back
Top