Melancholy Music

Couple of things, in last Sunday's episode of 'Torchwood' a guy had got killed and the story focussed around his ghost, about halfway through, the soundtrack was Antony and the Johnsons: Hope There's Someone.

Before I was married, so we're talking seventies here, I lived at home with my parents and younger brother and sister. One night my uncle came dowstairs in his dressing gown and my sister's fiancee made a remark about "Wee Willie Winkie" etc, we laughed, my uncle finished what ever he was doing in the kitchen (getting a drink of water or whatever) and eventually went back upstair.

After my parents arrived home my dad heard some sort of commotion going on upstairs, he went up to speak with him and my uncle was behaving as though he were drunk, singing loudly and recalling events from his youth on the farm in 'the old country'.

Everyone had a go at talking some sense into him but he was only speaking Lithuanian, throughout the episode we kept asking my dad what it was that his brother was talking about. He wouldn't say but decided to call an ambulance.

We got him to hospital where they did some tests, got him comfortable and bedded him down for the night. The family went home.

I couldn't sleep and stayed awake all night playing patience/solitaire with a real deck of cards (no PCs in those days)

Earlier that week (maybe months before, I can't remember now) my uncle had expressed his liking for a song by Neil Sedaka, and having only heard the song and not the singer's name, he thought that it was a female. I went out and bought him a copy (on vinyl).

Come two o'clock in the morning, my hands now slippery with residue from the deck, marked and reddened by their sharp edges I thought of the record I'd bought him and began singing it to myself, quietly so that I didn't wake anyone.

Days of devils, kings and crowns
Magic songs and birthday tunes
Sha lalas and doobie downs
The sounds to take away our blues

I continued playing and a while later the phone rang, someone wanting to speak to my dad.

The rest of that morning was spent in deep shock, my sister's fiancee drove me round to my older brother's house (he insisted that he drive) where we waited awhile until he came home from the night shift so that I could break the news. Our uncle had died at 2 o'clock.

This will be our last song together
Words will only make us cry
this will be our last song together
There's no other way, we can say goodbye.
 
Louis Armstrong
What A Wonderful World.



Or, Otis Reading
Sitting on the Dock of the Bay
 
gauchecritic said:
This will be our last song together
Words will only make us cry
this will be our last song together
There's no other way, we can say goodbye.


:rose:
 
Mahler's adagietto from his fifth symphony and Schubert's quintet in C (not the Trout). These pieces are sumptuously beautiful, so the melancholy's worth it.
 
Mozart's Magic Flute:
Aria, Pamina: "Ach, ich fühl's, es ist verschwunden" when she thinks she has been abandoned by Tamino.

Schubert's Song Cycle Swan Song performed by Fischer-Diskau accompanied by Gerald Moore

Og
 
CombiChrist - "Undertaker"
Fracture 4 - "Moon"

The first song is a song that basically has a synthetic pad plodding along on 2 chords with a harsh distorted industrial drum playing some unknown, abstract rhythm to the loop of a child laughing.

The second song is a blistering-paced song which has a alarm-melody with the general feel that you are on a spaceship disintegrating upon entry. Not a single voice sample is used throughout this piece.
 
Patsy Cline.

Beautiful voice.

She made many a juke box distributor rich, record companies too.

'Sweet Dreams'

'I Fall to Pieces'

'She's Got You'

The list goes on.

Great drinkin' music.

Peace.
 
vella_ms said:
sometimes the most melancholy music is silence.

'The Sound of Silence' by Simon and Garfunkel.

Whoops, sorry v_m.

I thought this was the Word Association thread (grin).

It is a sad song though.

And how about 'I Am A Rock' by S&G?

Peace.
 
Dr_Strabismus said:
The notorious 1930's song Gloomy Sunday is known as the "Suicide Song", so depressing is its mood and lyrics.

Leonard Cohen's songs have a deserved reputation for mawkishness.

For me, most of Joni Mitchell's "Blue" album is almost too sad for me to play.

And, even though its lyrics are maddenly obtuse, The Beach Boys "Surf's Up", (written by Bryan Wilson during his descent into psychosis) has an uncanny and overwhelming melancholy. The music itself, the cadences and harmonies alone, seem to do it. Surf's Up on YouTube.

So, what songs bring out the melancholia for you?

Harry Nilson's cover of "Can't Live." (See Perfect Christmas Song thread.) Lyricist Pete Ham hanged himself. If there's a competition for the title, "Suicide Song," there should be extra points for songs whose lyricists killed themselves.

For non-suicidal melancholy, my buttons are pushed by three songs performed by Judy Collins on the "Judith" album: "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress," a lullaby called "Pirate Ships," and "Houses," which ends on a high, pure note of such sweetness, it makes me weep and smile, sometimes at the same time:

You were always flying, nightingale of sorrow,
Singing bird with rainbows on your wings


Oddly, her more famous "Send in the Clowns" doesn't do a thing for me. Sad clowns are still clowns, right?


Edited to add: "Nessun Dorma," which used to make my dad cry; performed by Pavarotti, whom my dad nicknamed, "the fat guy with the great set of pipes."

Edited again to add: Phoebe Snow's classic "Poetry Man." Just because.
 
Last edited:
shereads said:
Harry Nilson's cover of "Can't Live." (See Perfect Christmas Song thread.) Lyricist Pete Ham hanged himself. If there's a competition for the title, "Suicide Song," there should be extra points for songs whose lyricists killed themselves.

For non-suicidal melancholy, my buttons are pushed by three songs performed by Judy Collins on the "Judith" album: "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress," a lullaby called "Pirate Ships," and "Houses," which ends on a high, pure note of such sweetness, it makes me weep and smile, sometimes at the same time:

You were always flying, nightingale of sorrow,
Singing bird with rainbows on your wings


Oddly, her more famous "Send in the Clowns" doesn't do a thing for me. Sad clowns are still clowns, right?

Clowns are scary.
 
TE999 said:
'The Sound of Silence' by Simon and Garfunkel.

Whoops, sorry v_m.

I thought this was the Word Association thread (grin).

It is a sad song though.

And how about 'I Am A Rock' by S&G?

Peace.

"4,33" by John Cage
 
Listen and weep.

(Pavarotti's Nessun Dorma videotaped at a live performance, and posted by some generous soul at YouTube.)

The first time I visited my father's grave alone, I brought along a set of mini-speakers and the Walkman I had given him one Christmas, and played his favorite aria. It was my private goodbye. What a sweet, infuriating, funny, angry, sad and affectionate little man he was. To anyone who didn't know him well, my dad's love of opera would have seemed ridiculously out of character. To me, it was proof that people are infinitely layered, beyond even their own understanding of themselves. Of all the ways I could remember my father, I choose the way he laughed with his whole body, red-faced, eyes watering, clutching his generous belly; and that he cried when he listened to "Nessun Dorma."
 
Mad World from the Donny Darko Soundtrack and Porcupine Tree - How is your Life Today.
 
"Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas"

"September Song"

Virtually any ballad by Eva Cassidy, such as her version of "Over the Rainbow" and Sting's "Field's Of Gold". If you've never heard her, this link should take you to a UK fan site with some audio clips including those two.

EVA CASSIDY

Rumple Foreskin :cool:
 
shereads said:
:uncontrolled sobbing:

Dammit, Rumple! Why did you have to bring that one up?
Quick. Go put on "Locomotion" by Grand Funk Railroad. Damn near impossible to stay down listening to that.

Rumple "Rx" Foreskin :cool:
 
Rumple Foreskin said:
Quick. Go put on "Locomotion" by Grand Funk Railroad. Damn near impossible to stay down listening to that.

Rumple "Rx" Foreskin :cool:

How did you find out that my childhood pet, a pony named Funky, was killed at a railroad crossing in Grand Rapids while pushing me out of the way of an oncoming locomotive?

I never expected this kind of cruelty from you, of all people.
 
shereads said:
How did you find out that my childhood pet, a pony named Funky, was killed at a railroad crossing in Grand Rapids while pushing me out of the way of an oncoming locomotive?

I never expected this kind of cruelty from you, of all people.
Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition.

Your tale of woe sounds a bit like lyrics from that country music classic, "You Never Called Me by My Name" by David Allen Coe.

I was drunk, the day my mom got out of prison,
And I went to pick her up in the rain.
But before I could get to the station in my pick-up truck,
She got runned over by a damned old train.


Rumple "redneck" Foreskin :cool:
 
Last edited:
Sarah McLachlan's "Fallen" gets me every time. I can't listen to it without starting to tear up. Also, Moonlight Sonata, but that happens to everyone, right?
 
Back
Top