Mental Illness

The insanity defense is backward. If you can't tell right from wrong, you'll always have the potential to commit the same crime again. If you CAN tell right from wrong--say, if you killed a cheating lover in a single, uncharacteristic fit of jealousy--prison is not going to "rehabilitate" you, because there's nothing to rehabilitate. It only serves to punish.

What we should have is a "sanity" defense: I know it was wrong, the circumstances are exceedingly unlikely every to arise again, and you're welcome to keep me under observation in a facility or on parole for as long as you need to convince yourself of it.

Most murderers will never kill again. A vast majority of them. I'm perfectly fine with them being held for observation, a court deciding it's highly unlikely to happen again and let them free but they can't not be punished. They did kill a person. At some point we have to allow for punishment.
 
The bastardex has bipolar ll, formerly called manic depression.
He sure as hell knows the difference between right and wrong - but his illness gives him the perfect excuse. Precisely because almost no-one who has never experienced it (from either side) can understand it.
It took me a couple of years of seeing him with it to begin to understand.

yeah, that' one's a bitch

when he's in a manic phase the concept of consequences for actions simply don't occur to them

medication can treat it, but if they go into a manic phase they dont feel the need for it..and this is when the shit hits the fan

treating someone for bpd who doesnt want to be treated is nightmarish.. but they are in control of their decision to not be treated...it's a very grey area for this disorder
 
Most murderers will never kill again. A vast majority of them. I'm perfectly fine with them being held for observation, a court deciding it's highly unlikely to happen again and let them free but they can't not be punished. They did kill a person. At some point we have to allow for punishment.
I don't know about the "have to" part. We like to, and we want to. If you're sane, you are being punished by your conscience either way.

I'm not saying send every "sane" killer back out the door after the trial is over. Hold them for a year to ensure that they have to live with what they did, determine their sanity, whatever. But the "have to be punished" part has not served our prison system well so far. Near as I can tell, it mostly just turns sane people into recidivists.
 
yeah, that' one's a bitch

when he's in a manic phase the concept of consequences for actions simply don't occur to them

medication can treat it, but if they go into a manic phase they dont feel the need for it..and this is when the shit hits the fan

treating someone for bpd who doesnt want to be treated is nightmarish.. but they are in control of their decision to not be treated...it's a very grey area for this disorder
The one person I know with bipolar (or the one whose bipolar I know about) is very clear about the effect on her: when she's manic, she acts out without conscience or control. Part of that acting out is deciding (as you say) not to bother with her medication. When she's medicated, she is able to discuss the lack of conscience and the rest. But it doesn't stop it from happening again.
 
yeah, that' one's a bitch

when he's in a manic phase the concept of consequences for actions simply don't occur to them

medication can treat it, but if they go into a manic phase they dont feel the need for it..and this is when the shit hits the fan

treating someone for bpd who doesnt want to be treated is nightmarish.. but they are in control of their decision to not be treated...it's a very grey area for this disorder

It took another year or two for me to realise that he was one who didn't want to be treated.
He waa comfortable not being well enough to work, not being reaponsible enough to look after the kids, not being able enough to do simple family outings, and not being sane enough to temper his behaviour.
The first time he really took control of his illness was when I left - but since he remarried, he's slid back again... because now he has someone to do those things for him again.
The perfect example is giving up his job here in Oz to go to Chicago and try and get a job in a jazz band playing harmonice. An instrument he first picked up less than 2 yrs ago, and by all accounts simply can't play well.
It also came to my attention that the new wife is very much an 'enabler', so he will be thinking she's perfect.
 
It took another year or two for me to realise that he was one who didn't want to be treated.
He waa comfortable not being well enough to work, not being reaponsible enough to look after the kids, not being able enough to do simple family outings, and not being sane enough to temper his behaviour.
The first time he really took control of his illness was when I left - but since he remarried, he's slid back again... because now he has someone to do those things for him again.
The perfect example is giving up his job here in Oz to go to Chicago and try and get a job in a jazz band playing harmonice. An instrument he first picked up less than 2 yrs ago, and by all accounts simply can't play well.
It also came to my attention that the new wife is very much an 'enabler', so he will be thinking she's perfect.
Christ are you stupid.
 
The brain is a very strange and not well understood organ, and with the variation from person to person it isn't likely that we'll ever understand it fully.
I have mental and neurological illness. My depression and.anxiety are medicated and so is my epilepsy. In the past I have stopped my antidepressants because I thought I was fine. I crash so badly I drive my husband to despair. I have promised him I will never stop taking my meds again. My epilepsy meds I've only been taking for a year but they actually help me in regards to remembering my antidepressants.
 
Politics, anecdotes, concepts. I thought a clearinghouse thread might be nice to have. I know there's a lot of experience on the GB from all perspectives.

Maybe as a start, the question, "Why do we treat mental illness differently from other illnesses?" would be worth discussing. One example: science is increasingly showing that addiction is an organic sickness of the brain. An organ is diseased, causing symptoms. Those symptoms, however, lead to prison, rather than treatment.

We treat mental illness differently because we cannot measure or quantify it. We can take a pulse rate, blood pressure, temperature. We can measure height, weight, strength, flexibility of limbs.

We don't know what mental illness IS. Where is the line between different, odd, eccentric, weird, mentally ill, insane, and batshit fruitloop?

They can't take a culture and look at it under a microscope.

It's all smoke and mirrors, with a strong conviction that there is actually something there somewhere, if only we knew where and how to look.

Like rehabilitation, it is a great field of study for people who are not really in a hurry to get results.
 
Bullshit. Over the 9 yrs I lived and dealt with the bastardex's illness, day and night, I cannot count the number of times he did something wrong and when someone (not always me) pointed it out, his answer was always 'Yes, I know - but I'm sick.'
He knew, alright.

If that's the case, I think he had more going on than bi-polar. Maybe some sociopathic or borderline tendencies.

Most people with bi-polar feel horrible about what they do during episodes.
 
The brain is a very strange and not well understood organ, and with the variation from person to person it isn't likely that we'll ever understand it fully.
I have mental and neurological illness. My depression and.anxiety are medicated and so is my epilepsy. In the past I have stopped my antidepressants because I thought I was fine. I crash so badly I drive my husband to despair. I have promised him I will never stop taking my meds again. My epilepsy meds I've only been taking for a year but they actually help me in regards to remembering my antidepressants.

:heart: :heart: :heart:

People tend to mock things they are afraid of and don't understand. There was a huge stigma about having seizures until it could be shown on testing the changes in the brain. Our brain is so mysterious yet. I always thought it was interesting as a physchiatric nurse that many of the medications that assist bipolar and schizophrenic people are anti-seizure medications. There is something in the brain that we will one day discover and people will see these disorders as the brain conditions that they are.

Yes. One of my very good friends is DON at a mental hospital here in Sydney. She says the exact same thing.
 
The hardest part about mental illness, the part people just don't understand, is that most of the messages are at 9000 hertz, but the black ones are only 7200 hertz, which they know makes them harder to chronicle in standard-size notebooks with the traditional selection of writing implements, since the implements are either pine, ash, or a range of industrial plastics, and they cannot be used for descriptions of sounds between 7000 and 7400 hertz, which I already told you once and don't understand why you keep asking about.
 
The hardest part about mental illness, the part people just don't understand, is that most of the messages are at 9000 hertz, but the black ones are only 7200 hertz, which they know makes them harder to chronicle in standard-size notebooks with the traditional selection of writing implements, since the implements are either pine, ash, or a range of industrial plastics, and they cannot be used for descriptions of sounds between 7000 and 7400 hertz, which I already told you once and don't understand why you keep asking about.

You didn't even.
 
You have to be careful with all medications.

A while back I used a popular OTC multi-vitamin, and it damned near killed me. Within a week I was using a cane, and couldn't get outta bed without help. I stopped taking the vitamin and the problems went away. I started the vitamins and the problems returned. My MD told me he has the same reaction to vitamins.

Plenty of medications have side-effects that make them useful for other ailments. I use a cheap anti-histamine for hay fever and a sleep aid. Alcohol puts me to sleep. Caffein sedates me.
 
People with addictions go to jail because they broke the law not because they are ill. Serial killers are ill but we don't let them roam free.

What if those laws are lobbied for by for-profit incarceration companies that have a vested interest in increasing the prison population?
 
We treat mental illness differently because we cannot measure or quantify it. We can take a pulse rate, blood pressure, temperature. We can measure height, weight, strength, flexibility of limbs.

We don't know what mental illness IS. Where is the line between different, odd, eccentric, weird, mentally ill, insane, and batshit fruitloop?

They can't take a culture and look at it under a microscope.

It's all smoke and mirrors, with a strong conviction that there is actually something there somewhere, if only we knew where and how to look.

Like rehabilitation, it is a great field of study for people who are not really in a hurry to get results.


did you know that in so called "primitive" societies, mental illness is almost unheard of?
 
When I first started working in mental health only folks with lotsa money and good insurance had the serious problems that need long periods of treatment, if you had no money or insurance we usually cured you in one visit.
 
did you know that in so called "primitive" societies, mental illness is almost unheard of?

ffs...

Mental illness is closely associated with age, and there aren't a lot of octogenarians among "primitive societies". They don't live long enough to develop any mental disease.

!!!
 
at the risk of sounding like LT... women are 40% more likely to be crazy. Or so the science says....

http://atlanta.cbslocal.com/2013/05...re-likely-to-develop-mental-illness-than-men/

there was a piece on this on radio 4 today.

if they test a random population they find equal numbers of men & women with bpd, but the official statistics record 3x as many women than men suffering bpd.
they put it down to two factors. 1, that women are more likely to seek medical help than men. 2, that men acting crazy are more likely to be arrested or just assumed to be an arsehole, whereas people are more likely to see a woman as ill.
 
Back
Top