Michelle Antoinette?

Ulaven_Demorte

Non-Prophet Organization
Joined
Apr 16, 2006
Posts
30,016
Could there be a more fitting meme coming from the "right"? But not for the reasons they might think.

The comparisons of Michelle Obama and Marie Antoinette being made by the "right" have been coming fast and furious in an attempt to smear her image in the eyes of the public. Little do they realize exactly how apropos this comparison is.

Remember the infamous lobster, caviar, and champagne lunch at the Waldorf - Astoria before the third Presidential debate? Yes, that's right, the one that never happened. Not that it mattered. Why let a little thing like the truth stand in the way of a good smear job?

This newest comparison to Marie Antoinette by the likes of Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck, echoed all over the right wing "news" sites is appropriate, but not for the reasons they think.

They're attempting to paint the First lady as not caring about the plight of those affected by the economic recession (brought on by conservative economic policies and deregulation) because she is currently on vacation in Spain. Comparing her attitude toward suffering Americans as the same as Marie Antoinette's toward the French who had no bread by allegedly saying "Let them eat cake."

The irony, of which the "right" is seemingly unaware, is that there is no evidence that the "Let them eat cake" incident is anything more than unsubstantiated rumor that was designed to enrage the hungry mobs of France against her. In fact, the phrase seems to have originated in the book "Confessions", by Jean- Jacques Rousseau, written when Marie Antoinette was only 13 years old and not even living in France.

Marie Antoinette was in fact a generous patron of charity and was moved by the plight of the poor when brought to her attention. Her true attitude differed greatly from that which her detractors would have everyone believe. Letters to her family in Austria paint a much different picture of her attitude toward the people of France.

"It is quite certain that in seeing the people who treat us so well despite their own misfortune, we are more obliged than ever to work hard for their happiness. The King seems to understand this truth." - Lettres de Marie-Antoinette, volume 1, p. 91

In using Marie Antoinette as a symbol of supposed uncaring extravagance to make the First Lady look bad they are forgetting that Marie Antoinette became that symbol due to the very same types of unsubstantiated rumors that the "right" has tried to use against Michelle Obama.

Perhaps Limbaugh, Beck, and the rest shouldn't worry about how the First Lady compares to Marie Antoinette and should instead worry about how they compare to the anti-royalist Libellists who, using exaggerations, fictitious accounts of events, and outright lies, encouraged and enraged the bloodthirsty French mobs who then demanded Antoinette's blood.

So yes, there is a definite similarity between Marie Antoinette and Michelle Obama. Both were harangued by liars, slanderers, and libellists in attempts to turn public opinion against them. In poor Marie Antoinette's case it worked famously but the American people are not French peasants and a lie doesn't get nearly as far as it once did before being confronted with truth.

It's said that ‘A lie is halfway round the world before the truth has got its boots on.’ But eventually truth gets booted and spurred, and the lie gets a good kicking.
 
Last edited:
Try as much as you can to convince people that the economic collapse is the result of conservative economic policies that have worked time and time again and not the crazy deficit spending to enrich and support the democratic special interests and the democrats desire to ensure that home loans are made to anyone who wants one whether they can afford it or not because to base loan approvals on objective factors such as credit scores and the ability to pay it back would be 'racist"

How much did Michelle's trip cost the American deficit?

It's interesting that she left her husband for this trip during his birthday. I wonder why she decided to leave at this particular time?

Nice that she got to hang out with the Spanish Royal family. Was she trying to pick up some behaviorial tips? Does she see herself as a modern American queen?

Rich.
 
Was no place in America good enough?





That's money that could have been spent in Las Vegas...

Oh, wait, we're NOT SUPPOSED to go to Vegas.
 
How many sanctuary cities needed the income?





Does she not WANT to be around "those" people of color?

Good enough for the lawn, but not for the vacation?

Let them eat tacos?
 
Could there be a more fitting meme coming from the "right"? But not for the reasons they might think.

The comparisons of Michelle Obama and Marie Antoinette being made by the "right" have been coming fast and furious in an attempt to smear her image in the eyes of the public. Little do they realize exactly how apropos this comparison is.

Remember the infamous lobster, caviar, and champagne lunch at the Waldorf - Astoria before the third Presidential debate? Yes, that's right, the one that never happened. Not that it mattered. Why let a little thing like the truth stand in the way of a good smear job?

This newest comparison to Marie Antoinette by the likes of Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck, echoed all over the right wing "news" sites is appropriate, but not for the reasons they think.

They're attempting to paint the First lady as not caring about the plight of those affected by the economic recession (brought on by conservative economic policies and deregulation) because she is currently on vacation in Spain. Comparing her attitude toward suffering Americans as the same as Marie Antoinette's toward the French who had no bread by allegedly saying "Let them eat cake."

The irony, of which the "right" is seemingly unaware, is that there is no evidence that the "Let them eat cake" incident is anything more than unsubstantiated rumor that was designed to enrage the hungry mobs of France against her. In fact, the phrase seems to have originated in the book "Confessions", by Jean- Jacques Rousseau, written when Marie Antoinette was only 13 years old and not even living in France.

Marie Antoinette was in fact a generous patron of charity and was moved by the plight of the poor when brought to her attention. Her true attitude differed greatly from that which her detractors would have everyone believe. Letters to her family in Austria paint a much different picture of her attitude toward the people of France.

"It is quite certain that in seeing the people who treat us so well despite their own misfortune, we are more obliged than ever to work hard for their happiness. The King seems to understand this truth." - Lettres de Marie-Antoinette, volume 1, p. 91

In using Marie Antoinette as a symbol of supposed uncaring extravagance to make the First Lady look bad they are forgetting that Marie Antoinette became that symbol due to the very same types of unsubstantiated rumors that the "right" has tried to use against Michelle Obama.

Perhaps Limbaugh, Beck, and the rest shouldn't worry about how the First Lady compares to Marie Antoinette and should instead worry about how they compare to the anti-royalist Libellists who, using exaggerations, fictitious accounts of events, and outright lies, encouraged and enraged the bloodthirsty French mobs who then demanded Antoinette's blood.

So yes, there is a definite similarity between Marie Antoinette and Michelle Obama. Both were harangued by liars, slanderers, and libellists in attempts to turn public opinion against them. In poor Marie Antoinette's case it worked famously but the American people are not French peasants and a lie doesn't get nearly as far as it once did before being confronted with truth.

It's said that ‘A lie is halfway round the world before the truth has got its boots on.’ But eventually truth gets booted and spurred, and the lie gets a good kicking.

It's even more ironic; because people on this board like busybody, aj, vman, ish, and the like... people who are middle class or poor are all screaming for greater wealth for the wealthy. Much like the French revolution, but in reverse...
 
It's even more ironic; because people on this board like busybody, aj, vman, ish, and the like... people who are middle class or poor are all screaming for greater wealth for the wealthy. Much like the French revolution, but in reverse...

We want sound economic principles to be exercised again to get us back to a growth economy. Out with these horrible liberal "experiments" in social engineering and lets get back to sound economic principles.
 
We want sound economic principles to be exercised again to get us back to a growth economy. Out with these horrible liberal "experiments" in social engineering and lets get back to sound economic principles.

Who's the last right wing president who had "sound economic principals"?
:rolleyes:
 
It's even more ironic; because people on this board like busybody, aj, vman, ish, and the like... people who are middle class or poor are all screaming for greater wealth for the wealthy. Much like the French revolution, but in reverse...



Yeah, we want the wealthy to get back to creating JOBS.

We want Democrats to stop creating poverty.

Altruism is horrible economics.
__________________
You loot the private sector, strip every dollar of 40¢ for overhead, and then give the other 60¢ to your political base in order to revitalize the looted.

What's not to like about that plan?

A_J, the Stupid
 
Well, I have a couple of things to say. First, I don't think that a current point of contention is fully qualified to be classified as a meme. I'd argue that instead specious and incorrect categorization could easily be considered more memetic. Haha. But that's just me being contrary for fun.

Next, I wouldn't paint Mme Antoinette in the same light as you. I'd say that the difference between French aristocracy and le proletariat was marked, despite her best and most sympathetic letters. Her words, false or not, pale in comparison to the ridiculous consumption of the noble class. Further, I'd think her notoriety would be more due to her role in the French Revolution than her misquoted opinions on baked goods. But that last bit's opinion-based. So. To be fair, we both win.

In regards to the overseas vaycay: did an obscene number of media outlets resort to exaggeration and overreaction? You betcha. Does Ms. O deserve a respite? I'm sure of it. Is the modern-day press sickeningly reactionary? Ja. Was it ill-advised to take such a jaunt in current political climes and times? Yeahhhh, probably.

I'm not saying you can't draw parallels here. It's just that mayhap the similarities between figureheads mightn't be the most damning or informative.
 
Last edited:
Well, I have a couple of things to say. First, I don't think that a current point of contention is fully qualified to be classified as a meme. I'd argue that instead specious and incorrect categorization could easily be considered more memetic. Haha. But that's just me being contrary for fun.

Next, I wouldn't paint Mme Antoinette in the same light as you. I'd say that the difference between French aristocracy and le proletariat was marked, despite her best and most sympathetic letters. Her words, false or not, pale in comparison to the ridiculous consumption of the noble class. Further, I'd think her notoriety would be more due to her role in the French Revolution than her misquoted opinions on baked goods. But that last bit's opinion-based. So. To be fair, we both win.

In regards to the overseas vaycay: did an obscene number of media outlets resort to exaggeration and overreaction? You betcha. Does Ms. O deserve a respite? I'm sure of it. Is the modern-day press sickeningly reactionary? Ja. Was it ill-advised to take such a jaunt in current political climes and times? Yeahhhh, probably.

I'm not saying you can't draw parallels here. It's just that mayhap the similarities between figureheads mightn't be the most damning or informative.

Skip Gates
Arizona
BP

Sherrod...
 
Well, I have a couple of things to say. First, I don't think that a current point of contention is fully qualified to be classified as a meme. I'd argue that instead specious and incorrect categorization could easily be considered more memetic. Haha. But that's just me being contrary for fun.

Next, I wouldn't paint Mme Antoinette in the same light as you. I'd say that the difference between French aristocracy and le proletariat was marked, despite her best and most sympathetic letters. Her words, false or not, pale in comparison to the ridiculous consumption of the noble class. Further, I'd think her notoriety would be more due to her role in the French Revolution than her misquoted opinions on baked goods. But that last bit's opinion-based. So. To be fair, we both win.

In regards to the overseas vaycay: did an obscene number of media outlets resort to exaggeration and overreaction? You betcha. Does Ms. O deserve a respite? I'm sure of it. Is the modern-day press sickeningly reactionary? Ja. Was it ill-advised to take such a jaunt in current political climes and times? Yeahhhh, probably.

I'm not saying you can't draw parallels here. It's just that mayhap the similarities between figureheads mightn't be the most damning or informative.

You are so fucking sexy.
 
You're made of win.

Can we play twister next?

Just tell me where the spinner lands and show me where to put my hands. I'm super flexible. Thanks, yogalates!

What are Health Care, Financial Reform, and things you have to pass to understand?

Congratulations! That was today's Daily Double. You get twice the eye-roll and two times the standard partisan selective listening. Join us tomorrow evening for more mediocre French Canadian pronunciation.
 
Funny thing is...




We don't compare civilian deaths in Afghanistan to the ones in Iraq.

I guess one was more valuable than the other to the press...

Even funnier is the new-found sensitivity to partisan.
 
Back
Top