Music Categorization

acitore_vuli said:
Al Dimeola - Category?
Coltrane - Category?
Wes Montgomery -
Chet Atkins-
Miles Davis -
Yellow Jackets-
Jeff Beck-

Coltrane and Davis I'd put in the Be-Bop Jazz cetegory. Wes Montgomery and Al Dimeola are tougher. I might leave them in something I'd call "straight jazz". The Yellow Jackets are definitely either Cool Jazz or Light Jazz. Chet Atkins goes in the Country/Bluegrass stack, IMO, and Beck in the Blues folder.
 
Re: Re: Re: Music Categorization

acitore_vuli said:
See, I put Dimeola and Yellow Jackets in a fusion category. Chet, while known for country, is more western swing (which is a jazz form). Beck, plays lots of styles, but listen to blow by blow and tell me that's not jazz.

True, but when I categorize, I go by what they've mostly done. You could argue Beck would go in a Rock category also. Perhaps you could put Beck and Atkins in a cetegory for Guitar Legends. That'd probably be just as easy to find them later, and be more suitable.

Well, fusion is a tough category to classify. You could go with the basic chronological dilineations for jazz, which did come in more or less distinct phases (with some overlap that might be tough), which would put then and Dimeola inthe Cool category.

It's not easy. But I think the Guitar Legends category wold work really well.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Music Categorization

acitore_vuli said:
Well, my point was that labels, while we feel the need to use them. are...well, labeling.

Tell me more about your thoughts on fusion. I'm really interested. I always thought that Spyro Gyra, yellow Jackets, Jean Luc Ponty, were considered fusion.

True, but without them, you can't find shit, as you've found. ;)

Well, the dictionary definition of fusion is mixing jazz with some other style of music, be it classical or pop or whatever. So, by that definition, everything you've mentioned is fusion.

ON the other hand, I prefer to keep fusion for the avant-garde types of artists like Ponty, and the Cool Jazz label for the groups you hear on the Light Jazz radio stations. I'm not necessarily a Cool Jazz fan, though.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Music Categorization

acitore_vuli said:
well, what I ended up doing was having a folder for each band/artist.

A short term fix

It's not a bad one either.

But you just know that at some point you'll be making bigger categories for them. You can't resist it. ;)
 
Al Dimeola - Instrumental Jazz/Fusion (Guitar)
Coltrane - Instrumental Jazz/Be Bop (Saxophone)
Wes Montgomery - Instrumental Jazz/Be Bop (Guitar)
Chet Atkins- Instrumental Country (some Jazz R&B) (Guitar)
Miles Davis - Instrumental Jazz/Be Bop/Cool/Hard Bop (Trumpet)
Yellow Jackets- Instrumental Jazz/Jazz Rock/Fusion/Mainstream (Instrumental group)
Jeff Beck- Insturmental Jazz/Fusion (best know for Rock) (Guitar)


That's my best go at it.
 
Why make it confusing?


Al Dimeola - D
Coltrane - C
Wes Montgomery - M
Chet Atkins- A
Miles Davis - D
Yellow Jackets- Y
Jeff Beck- B

Easy.

:cool:
 
I just alphabetize. Last name if a single artist, First name if it is a group or the last name of the group leader.

I'm lazy that way. I worked in a library shelving books for a few years in high school.

I find I alphabetize everything. I'm OCD that way.
 
Here, let me alphabetize for you:

Chet Atkins-
Jeff Beck-
Coltrane
Miles Davis
Al Dimeola - -
Wes Montgomery -
Yellow Jackets-

There you go.
 
Al Dimeola - Fusion
Coltrane - BeBop
Wes Montgomery - Instrumental Jazz
Chet Atkins - Country
Miles Davis - GOD
Yellow Jackets- Musak
Jeff Beck - Rock
 
Back
Top