Norquist says...

I'd say the Democrats actually gave up more than they needed to, but that's just their nature.

They really probably could have gotten capital gains higher. That used to be FAR higher and yet the stock market consistently went up. It's as if people don't understand that no one will ever decline to make money.
 
I suspect most of them want spending cut and government made smaller, not larger.

With no deal made by Christmas there was no fucking way that the spending cuts part of the cliff was going to be part of a deal. That can got kicked away for a few months.

Part of the reason of even getting just the tax shit dealt with was to restore SOME confidence in the markets. If both got kicked down the road again it would have undermined confidence in Congress even more.

Cuts WILL be dealt with. This deal didn't make them both agree to ignore them.
 
With no deal made by Christmas there was no fucking way that the spending cuts part of the cliff was going to be part of a deal. That can got kicked away for a few months.

Part of the reason of even getting just the tax shit dealt with was to restore SOME confidence in the markets. If both got kicked down the road again it would have undermined confidence in Congress even more.

Cuts WILL be dealt with. This deal didn't make them both agree to ignore them.

Your assignment is to monitor the situation and let us know when meaningful spending cuts kick in.

Looks like we'll never see you again.
 
Pubs got rolled by the Dems from the beginning. They'll cave on the debt ceiling too.

I think you and I agree that both sides felt some pain. But defaulting on the debt should never be up for debate, period. Any insistence on holding the American economy hostage for political gain is an abject failure to lead on the Republicans' part.

It's pure comedy though how Norquist insisted that his pledge signers follow it word-for-word but then he gets to turn around and say "Weeeell... it's the thought that counts, we shouldn't have to follow it word-for-word". :rolleyes:

Governing by pledges is absurd. Governing by rubber wish-washy pledges is abhorrent.
 
Which conservative here can help me understand this....

- Boehner took a plan to the Republican House which had $1.22 trillion in revenue (including interest savings) and $1.2 in Federal spending cuts and Republicans rejected it.

- The Democratic Senate sent the House a plan which had $640 billion in revenue and almost no cuts and the House passed it with 88 Republican votes.


What happened here?
 
Which conservative here can help me understand this....

- Boehner took a plan to the Republican House which had $1.22 trillion in revenue (including interest savings) and $1.2 in Federal spending cuts and Republicans rejected it.

- The Democratic Senate sent the House a plan which had $640 billion in revenue and almost no cuts and the House passed it with 88 Republican votes.


What happened here?

The Democrats put up a plan for 1/2 the revenue and the GOP took it, planning to use the CR and the debt ceiling to force 2-3T in spending cuts so that in the end the revenue to cuts is in the 1:3 to 1:5 range rather than take the 1:1.
 
The Democrats put up a plan for 1/2 the revenue and the GOP took it, planning to use the CR and the debt ceiling to force 2-3T in spending cuts so that in the end the revenue to cuts is in the 1:3 to 1:5 range rather than take the 1:1.

They wont be able to use the debt ceiling as a bargaining chip. "OMG we're going to destroy America unless you give us what we want Mr. President!". It's going to backfire and make them sound like idiots even more than it did last time. If conservatives want to go this route then they need to retract every last comment they've made about Obama creating uncertainty in the economy. Hypocrites.

By the way, it's not half the revenue. The $1.22 trillion revenue thing was actually only $930 billion if you don't count interest savings as cuts. So it's just under 70% of the revenue as the first deal and far less deficit reduction.

The Dems are going to push for further revenue in the next round of bargaining in the form of eliminating tax deductions for the rich (thank god)... ie why do people making $2.5 million dollars per year need a child care tax deduction?
 
Last edited:
The Tax Policy Center, a nonpartisan Washington research group, estimates that 77 percent of American households will face higher federal taxes in 2013 under the agreement negotiated between President Barack Obama and Senate Republicans. High-income families will feel the biggest tax increases, but many middle- and low-income families will pay higher taxes too.

Households making between $40,000 and $50,000 will face an average tax increase of $579 in 2013, according to the Tax Policy Center's analysis. Households making between $50,000 and $75,000 will face an average tax increase of $822.

"For most people, it's just the payroll tax," said Roberton Williams, a senior fellow at the Tax Policy Center.

http://money.msn.com/business-news/article.aspx?feed=AP&date=20130102&id=15949410
 
They wont be able to use the debt ceiling as a bargaining chip. "OMG we're going to destroy America unless you give us what we want Mr. President!". It's going to backfire and make them sound like idiots even more than it did last time. If conservatives want to go this route then they need to retract every last comment they've made about Obama creating uncertainty in the economy. Hypocrites.

By the way, it's not half the revenue. The $1.22 trillion revenue thing was actually only $930 billion if you don't count interest savings as cuts. So it's just under 70% of the revenue as the first deal and far less deficit reduction.

The Dems are going to push for further revenue in the next round of bargaining in the form of eliminating tax deductions for the rich (thank god)... ie why do people making $2.5 million dollars per year need a child care tax deduction?

I think the argument will be more like "OMG Mr. President we're not going to let you destroy America now that you got what you wanted. Washington always taxes first and then never cuts. Yada yada yada"

I think it would be smarter if the Dems spent more energy in cutting Defense than trying to eliminate a child care tax deduction.

The best possible thing to do would be for the Senate to take up and pass a bipartisan immigration reform bill that the House would also pass so that they would remember how to work together and then let them tackle the spending cuts. IMO anyway.
 
I think the argument will be more like "OMG Mr. President we're not going to let you destroy America now that you got what you wanted. Washington always taxes first and then never cuts. Yada yada yada"

I think it would be smarter if the Dems spent more energy in cutting Defense than trying to eliminate a child care tax deduction.

The best possible thing to do would be for the Senate to take up and pass a bipartisan immigration reform bill that the House would also pass so that they would remember how to work together and then let them tackle the spending cuts. IMO anyway.


Obama isn't spending anything. It's the expensive automatic Medicare/Medicaid congressional spending, pensions, and defense that are spending themselves. The president has no control over those things.

Republicans threatening to maliciously cause an economic catastrophe is the shittiest possible thing so-called leaders can do.
 
The Tax Policy Center, a nonpartisan Washington research group, estimates that 77 percent of American households will face higher federal taxes in 2013 under the agreement negotiated between President Barack Obama and Senate Republicans. High-income families will feel the biggest tax increases, but many middle- and low-income families will pay higher taxes too.

Households making between $40,000 and $50,000 will face an average tax increase of $579 in 2013, according to the Tax Policy Center's analysis. Households making between $50,000 and $75,000 will face an average tax increase of $822.

"For most people, it's just the payroll tax," said Roberton Williams, a senior fellow at the Tax Policy Center.

http://money.msn.com/business-news/article.aspx?feed=AP&date=20130102&id=15949410

Yes Koala, the compromise to protect unemployment, the EITC and get the increased rates on the $450K+, was to let the payroll tax cut expire and return back to its earlier rate.

I recognize that "compromise" is not a word in the Christian/TEA lexicon, but it is essential to governing.
 
Obama isn't spending anything. It's the expensive automatic Medicare/Medicaid congressional spending, pensions, and defense that are spending themselves. The president has no control over those things.

Republicans threatening to maliciously cause an economic catastrophe is the shittiest possible thing so-called leaders can do.

All I am saying is that thee are going to be the arguments and they are reasonably self-evident.

As I said, the Dems would be smart to make very targeted, surgical cuts in defense their top priority to shift the conversation in the right way. The GOP is fractured and on the defensive and a good hard push to eliminate spending that even the generals and the Pentagon do not want (Abrhams tanks) and that are foolishly expensive and behind schedule (Jt Strike Fighter) and that are complete pork barrel ( read the Sustainable Defense Task Force recommendations).

While it is true that the President does not actually spend, and that the debt ceiling limit needing to be raised is just the Congress paying for spending it has already authorized, the President has failed to make the Country understand it. And for that he is at fault. His interview this Sunday on Meet The Press was probably his best yet and if he can sustain it then I think he will make his case.
 
All I am saying is that thee are going to be the arguments and they are reasonably self-evident.

As I said, the Dems would be smart to make very targeted, surgical cuts in defense their top priority to shift the conversation in the right way. The GOP is fractured and on the defensive and a good hard push to eliminate spending that even the generals and the Pentagon do not want (Abrhams tanks) and that are foolishly expensive and behind schedule (Jt Strike Fighter) and that are complete pork barrel ( read the Sustainable Defense Task Force recommendations).

While it is true that the President does not actually spend, and that the debt ceiling limit needing to be raised is just the Congress paying for spending it has already authorized, the President has failed to make the Country understand it. And for that he is at fault. His interview this Sunday on Meet The Press was probably his best yet and if he can sustain it then I think he will make his case.

Obama can try harder to explain that but Republicans will just cancel it out with lies about how Obama is blaming other people. These are low-information people who want to believe Obama is the source of our problems...

I'm not sure what the value of targeted defense cuts would be. But Medicare is a much larger issue since it's snowballing fast with the baby boomer generation retiring and living to age 90.
 
Let's not get silly. It's already been shown that the debt ceiling can be lowered and the country's obligations can still be met. The government will just have to liquidate assets and structure to balance the books.

Wait what?
 


From your article:
If we do not raise it, the government's tax revenue will enable us to fund roughly two-thirds of projected expenditures, including interest payments. Without the ability to borrow the other third, spending cuts would be sudden and severe: Projects would be postponed, some vendor payments would be delayed, certain programs would be suspended, and many government employees might be furloughed. Default would easily be avoided, but these cuts would certainly be disruptive. That's why I hope we can avoid this scenario.


So what's your point again?
 
The last sentence. Nobody said it wouldn't be tough, but the main obligations will be met.


Senator Toomy's point was that obligations wouldn't be met. They would be met in the short term, but increasingly less with each passing day.

If 1/3 of obligations can't be met, military funding is going down the tubes as will Medicare. And VA care, military retirement pay, they'll all be whacked. If 1/3 of federal employees were laid off then unemployment would swell by +750,000 and unemployment benefits would get seriously costly. The social security trust fund will being to drain and... well, that's just during the first year.

What about the next 5 years?
 
Last edited:
The last sentence. Nobody said it wouldn't be tough, but the main obligations will be met.

What main obligations? Who decides what the main ones would be? And what happens as time goes on and 2/3 of obligations aren't met?

Or 3/3?
 
Back
Top