NSA Ruling

The New York Times has.

N.S.A. Phone Surveillance Is Lawful, Federal Judge Rules
By MICHAEL S. SCHMIDT and ADAM LIPTAK
December 27, 2013
WASHINGTON — A federal judge in New York on Friday ruled that the National Security Agency’s program that is systematically keeping phone records of all Americans is lawful, creating a conflict among lower courts and increasing the likelihood that the issue will be resolved by the Supreme Court.

In the ruling, Judge William H. Pauley III, of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, granted a motion filed by the federal government to dismiss a challenge to the program brought by the American Civil Liberties Union, which had tried to halt the program.

Judge Pauley said that protections under the Fourth Amendment do not apply to records held by third parties, like phone companies.

“This blunt tool only works because it collects everything,” Judge Pauley said in the ruling.

“While robust discussions are underway across the nation, in Congress and at the White House, the question for this court is whether the government’s bulk telephony metadata program is lawful. This court finds it is,” he added.

A spokesman for the Justice Department said, “We are pleased the court found the N.S.A.'s bulk telephony metadata collection program to be lawful.” He declined to comment further.

Jameel Jaffer, the A.C.L.U. deputy legal director, said the group intended to appeal. “We are extremely disappointed with this decision, which misinterprets the relevant statutes, understates the privacy implications of the government’s surveillance and misapplies a narrow and outdated precedent to read away core constitutional protections,” he said.

The ruling comes nearly two weeks after Judge Richard J. Leon of Federal District Court for the District of Columbia said the program most likely violated the Fourth Amendment. As part of that ruling, Judge Leon ordered the government to stop collecting data on two plaintiffs who brought the case against the government.

In his ruling, Judge Leon said that the program “infringes on ‘that degree of privacy’ that the founders enshrined in the Fourth Amendment,” which prohibits unreasonable searches and seizures.

While Judge Leon ordered the government to stop collecting data on the two plaintiffs, he stayed the ruling, giving the government time to appeal the decision.

Judge Pauley, whose courtroom is just blocks from where the World Trade Center towers stood, endorsed arguments made in recent months by senior government officials — including the former F.B.I. director Robert S. Mueller III — that the program may have caught the Sept. 11, 2001, hijackers had it been in place before the attacks.

In the months before Sept. 11, the N.S.A. had intercepted several calls made to an Al Qaeda safe house in Yemen. But because the N.S.A. was not tracking all phone calls made from the United States, it did not detect that the calls were coming from one of the hijackers who was living in San Diego.

“Telephony metadata would have furnished the missing information and might have permitted the N.S.A. to notify the Federal Bureau of Investigation of the fact that al-Mihdhar was calling the Yemeni safe house from inside the United States,” Judge Pauley said, referring to the hijacker, Khalid al-Mihdhar.

Judge Pauley said that the “government learned from its mistake and adapted to confront a new enemy: a terror network capable of orchestrating attacks across the world.”

The government, he added, “launched a number of countermeasures, including a bulk telephony metadata collection program — a wide net that could find and isolate gossamer contacts among suspected terrorists in an ocean of seemingly disconnected data.”

The main dispute between Judge Pauley and Judge Leon was over how to interpret a 1979 Supreme Court decision, Smith v. Maryland, in which the court said a robbery suspect had no reasonable expectation that his right to privacy extended to the numbers dialed from his phone.

“Smith’s bedrock holding is that an individual has no legitimate expectation of privacy in information provided to third parties,” Judge Pauley wrote.

But Judge Leon said in his ruling that advances in technology and suggestions in concurring opinions in later Supreme Court decisions had undermined Smith. The government’s ability to construct a mosaic of information from countless records, he said, called for a new analysis of how to apply the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition of unreasonable government searches.

Judge Pauley disagreed. “The collection of breathtaking amounts of information unprotected by the Fourth Amendment does not transform that sweep into a Fourth Amendment search,” he wrote.

He acknowledged that “five justices appeared to be grappling with how the Fourth Amendment applies to technological advances” in a pair of 2012 concurrences in United States v. Jones. In that decision, the court unanimously rejected the use of a GPS device to track the movements of a drug suspect over a month. The majority in the 2012 case said that attaching the device violated the defendant’s property rights.

In one of the concurrences, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that “it may be necessary to reconsider the premise that an individual has no reasonable expectation of privacy in information voluntarily disclosed to third parties.”

But Judge Pauley wrote that the 2012 decision did not overrule the one from 1979. “The Supreme Court,” he said, “has instructed lower courts not to predict whether it would overrule a precedent even if its reasoning has been supplanted by later cases.”

As for changes in technology, he wrote, customers’ “relationship with their telecommunications providers has not changed and is just as frustrating.”

http://mobile.nytimes.com/2013/12/28/us/nsa-phone-surveillance-is-lawful-federal-judge-rules.html
 
So, unless it is the lead, it is not covered.

Got it.
 
Doesn't the conflicting rulings set up a SCOTUS showdown?

Ishmael
 
Let see on NYT if it is the lead on NYT headline tomorow

Let see if it the lead story on the nightly news tonight.

Lets see if Meet the Press devotes over a half hour Sunday

Let see if BBC has a Have Your Say saying that Judge rules NSA is legal.

Why would they? There isn't much to say that hasn't already been said. IT's legal, which we all already knew.

It's a fucking shame, i was really hoping for some goddamned activist judges rulling from the bench but the Judge in this case specifically washed his hands of that saying it's up to the other two branches of government to do their jobs. Don't get me wrong, I'm not pleased but nor am I shocked.

But that's the standard? If Meet the Press doesn't devote at least thirty one minutes the MSM has officially buried the story? No wonder you guys think the MSM is evil, they have to check with you before they do anything and if they don't do exactly what you want they are part of an evil conspiracy to keep you down.
 
Doesn't the conflicting rulings set up a SCOTUS showdown?

Ishmael

Exactly. One court ruled it was Constitutional, another ruled it unconsitutional (despite Dazzle1's claim to the contrary).

These are the sort of cases the Supreme Court ultimately decides. As such, it's not very newsworthy until the Supremes rule, again despite Dazzle1's angst over coverage.

There's a distinct similarity here between this case and the Is-Obamacare-Constitutional dustup two years ago.
 
Can't we all just get along and hope thise gets shot down? IT's the perfect time for us all to hold hands and sing.
 
Let's see if we get another preposterous ruling in favor of the state.
The case will be appealed, hopefully with a different result.

WOAH!!! WOAH!! WOAH~~!!!! Nice shootin' there Mr.Federal Supremacy.

Better respect the LAW for what it is son......the law, better not try and vote it out either, that would be downright anti-american. :D

No surprise another judge has said the NSA actions are legal not Orwellian

Why would they? Everyone voted their privacy away...it was a GOP favorite! Hell if you didn't support it you were a Marxist Al Qaeda lover....isn't that right??

Go ahead GBRW/Conservatives...lie and say you never supported it.:cool:
http://libertycentral.files.wordpress.com/2011/02/bush-patriot-act.jpg

Then it was so good the Dems even kept it around....go ahead and tell us some more about "Change" there dems...Bush 2.0 supporters.
http://news.antiwar.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/obama4.jpg

It's a fucking shame, i was really hoping for some goddamned activist judges rulling from the bench

Me too.

but the Judge in this case specifically washed his hands of that saying it's up to the other two branches of government to do their jobs. Don't get me wrong, I'm not pleased but nor am I shocked.

Judge knows better than to do anything but pass that one along.
 
Last edited:
WOAH!!! WOAH!! WOAH~~!!!! Nice shootin' there Mr.Federal Supremacy.

Better respect the LAW for what it is son......the law, better not try and vote it out either, that would be downright anti-american. :D



Why would they? Everyone voted their privacy away...it was a GOP favorite! Hell if you didn't support it you were a Marxist Al Qaeda lover....isn't that right??

Go ahead GBRW/Conservatives...lie and say you never supported it.:cool:
http://libertycentral.files.wordpress.com/2011/02/bush-patriot-act.jpg

Then it was so good the Dems even kept it around....go ahead and tell us some more about "Change" there dems...Bush 2.0 supporters.
http://news.antiwar.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/obama4.jpg



Me too.



Judge knows better than to do anything but pass that one along.

Yes. We can.
 
How about any of you learn about the justice system?? A solitary trial judge or two issuing a ruling does not remotely determine the legality of a law one way or another. This will end up at the Supreme Court, where there will be a 9-0 ruling in its favor, likely. The left supports the law, because the Obama administration has been the one carrying it out. The right supports it because it is central to the Bush-Cheney legacy.
 
How about any of you learn about the justice system?? A solitary trial judge or two issuing a ruling does not remotely determine the legality of a law one way or another. This will end up at the Supreme Court, where there will be a 9-0 ruling in its favor, likely. The left supports the law, because the Obama administration has been the one carrying it out. The right supports it because it is central to the Bush-Cheney legacy.

I'm sure somewhere there is a leftie who supports this but I've yet to meat them. The right hates it because they think the Left supports it which doesn't seem to be supported by any real facts.
 
You obviously haven't met The President of the United States. The right doesn't hate it. They have been pretty silent on the matter and are nearly unanimous that Edward Snowdon should be executed for treason.
 
Doesn't the conflicting rulings set up a SCOTUS showdown?

Ishmael


Nope. The Courts of Appeals may still rule, or not. Even if multiple appeals courts rule differently, the Supreme Court does not have to take it up. Happens all the time.
 
You obviously haven't met The President of the United States. The right doesn't hate it. They have been pretty silent on the matter and are nearly unanimous that Edward Snowdon should be executed for treason.

No I haven't met the President. I'm betting you haven't either. I didn't say however that he doesn't support it, I said the Left as a whole doesn't but touche I guess you have something resembling a point since we did vote for him. That is where you were going right?

And silent? I'm sorry, there isn't an NSA scandal going on? Edward Snowden did commit treason. Even if he did it for the right reason (debatable but I'll let you have it) that doesn't change what he did.
 
From Dick Cheney down to Sarah Palin, they have largely supported the national security efforts on this front. It is a remnant of Bush-Cheney for the most part. It has not been linked to any of the major budget issues in the last year, and it hasn't remotely been an issue like healthcare. Ask a conservative what they think of NSA, and they'll say Snowden should be hanged and let's talk about how shitty Obamacare is. The left was not against anything under Obama on national security that they were against under Bush, so they have zero moral authority on the subject, IMO.
 
No I haven't met the President. I'm betting you haven't either. I didn't say however that he doesn't support it, I said the Left as a whole doesn't but touche I guess you have something resembling a point since we did vote for him. That is where you were going right?

And silent? I'm sorry, there isn't an NSA scandal going on? Edward Snowden did commit treason. Even if he did it for the right reason (debatable but I'll let you have it) that doesn't change what he did.


Don't confuse a media scandal with an ideologial one. The media is all angsty about NSA, but who, exactly are they going after??? The President? The Attorney General? No. And most Americans reactions are first some mild shock, and then a largely overwhelming sense of, "yeah, I figured the government did that." Then they shrug and send emails to their buddy telling them where they left their suicide vest when they came over to "watch soccer" at 1 in the morning while having no thoughts at all of building IED's, in an effort to get their buddy on a watch list. I know I've done that.....
 
I guess. I mean it's not like this thread doesn't show that everybody is against it but I suppose if I have to start digging up articles and you can counter with people though there were bigger problems in the world and this could wait I guess.
 
Don't confuse a media scandal with an ideologial one. The media is all angsty about NSA, but who, exactly are they going after??? The President? The Attorney General? No. And most Americans reactions are first some mild shock, and then a largely overwhelming sense of, "yeah, I figured the government did that." Then they shrug and send emails to their buddy telling them where they left their suicide vest when they came over to "watch soccer" at 1 in the morning while having no thoughts at all of building IED's, in an effort to get their buddy on a watch list. I know I've done that.....

ha.

nice.
 
This thread shows nothing. This board is largely populated with the rather extreme left. And, I would hope all ideologies would find what NSA does to be gross, and somewhat uncomfortable. But when you offer the American people the choice of someone reading your emails and tapping your phones versus 9-11 or a nuclear suitcase bomb on the Washington mall, they tend to let the issue fade. And you tell them we are spying on foreign leaders and they say, yeah....that is EXACTLY who we should spy on....much like we did throughout the American 20th Century. It's a manufactured scandal, but treason isn't and that's why Snowden draws so much ire. I don't like The Jets, but if you offer me their tickets or tickets to see Wake Forest's scout team play, The Jets are awesome. And again, nobody is losing any job or even face over NSA.
 
Back
Top