Odd One Out [closed for lovestoinstruct

[lovetoinstruct]

Hi bites down on her nipple then raises his head. He keeps his still hard cock pushed against her pussy, his face turning red. "What the fuck do you mean you were fucking? Why didn't you tell us?" Jon thought of all the times he heard Jake talking about fucking this depraved slut of a girlfriend he had. "Do you know some of the things he told us?" He asked her, his cock twitching against her.

He was conflicted. He had wanted her for so long and now he had her, but she had betrayed him. He didn't really care who she fucked, he was angry that she kept it from him.

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali looked away from Jon's face. "I'm sorry I didn't tell you. I knew you and Taylor wouldn't take it well. I didn't want you guys mad at me. I'm sorry." She perked up when he asked her is she knew what he said. "What did Jake used to say?"

She felt so bad. She knew that her and Jon were never actually dating but she know felt like she betrayed him.

 

[lovetoinstruct]

He sat up, staying between her legs. Reaching down with both hands he pinched both her nipples, twisting them between his thumb and forefinger. "He told us all kinds of shit. He told us how his girlfriend loved to bob on his cock any time he was driving. He said she would look up at him from his crotch and beg him for his cum. He told us that she got off watching him get his cock sucked by another girl at last years homecoming dance. Is that you?"

While he said these things his cock got harder against her hot wet pussy, pushing his shorts against her underwear. He kept pinching and twisting her nipples, loving how hard they were in his grip.

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali moaned when Jon pinched her nipples. Jake had told her that he wouldn't tell anyone about what they did, the lying ass. "Well....you see.....yeah, that was me...." She couldn't lie to Jon. This is what she got for trusting the biggest player on the hockey team. But then again, Jake had said that Jon and Taylor were as big players as he was. "What about you? Jake told me that you and Taylor often double teamed girls on away games. Huh?"

 

[lovetoinstruct]

Jon moved one hand down her taught stomach, still pinching and pulling her nipple as he traced his hand down her body, lightly grazing her skin all the way down. Reaching the top of her underwear, he loops his fingers through them and tears the fabric, ripping them off her body as he tweaks the other nipple.

"Taylor and I fuck the same girl all the time. The dirty sluts we fuck love it. Are you telling me that you are a dirty slut Tali?" His eyes met hers, anticipation on his face as his finger trailed down to her bald mound, slowly massaging, causing the hood of her clit to move.

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali's eyes went wide when Jon ripped her panties off and moaned softly when he rubbed her. "I am not a dirty slut! So what if I enjoyed sex with my boyfriend and one other girl. That's not a girl a game!"

 

[lovetoinstruct]

Sliding his fingers over her clit, he leaned down onto her. "Dirty sluts get my cock so fucking hard" he whispered into her ear. "I think you have potential to be one" his finger slid down to her pussy, pushing into her hot, wet pussy as he breathed heavily into her ear. "He told us that when he told his girlfriend about girls getting double teamed on the road that he made her fuck him with her hair brush while she sucked his cock, because she thought it was so hot and wanted to know what it felt like to take it from both ends. Did you cum for him when you did that Tali?"

His cock was rock hard, but he was so conflicted. Was Tali as adventurous in the sack as he had heard?

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali looked up at him in shock. How bad did she want this. She moaned loudly when he put a finger in her pussy. "Yes, I came so hard when I did I. I came so hard." She ran her hands down Jon's back, feeling his back muscles.

 

[lovetoinstruct]

"Ohhh fuuuuck" he groaned into her ear. "Tali I never new you were such a dirty girl. I fucking love it so much. I've beat my cock so many times, thinking about you doing dirty things that I never thought you would do."

Moving his hips to the side and sliding off his shorts, he grabbed her hand. "Tali, I want to watch you make yourself cum for me, let me live out my fantasy right now." Moving her hand over her soaking wet pussy, he pushed her finger against her clit as he slowly stroked his rigid, cum covered cock. "Be the dirty girl you always were in my head Tali, be the freak in the sheets I've dreamed about."

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali couldn't believe that Jon had fantasized about her. When he put her hand on her pussy, she couldn't help but rub her clit slowly. She couldn't believe that she was actually going to finger herself in front of him. She slid on finger into her tight pussy, loving the feeling. She looked up and saw Jon jacking himself off. It was one of the hottest things she ever saw. Her pussy tightened around her finger so she added another one. She was already so close. "Uhhh Jon. I'm so close already. Mmm I'm gonna cum Jon. Mmmmmm!"

And at this moment, there was a knock on the door. 'What the hell....?'

 

[lovetoinstruct]

Jumping up from the bed Jon slides on his shorts, running to the door, his cock, just about to blow bouncing in them. He open's the door quickly, not even thinking that Tali is ass naked on the bed, two fingers in her red hot pussy.

He opens the door, his boner sticking out to find Taylor in the doorway. "Uhh, shit man, hey, do you mind coming back in a bit, I'm kinda...busy" Jon says, knowing that Taylor will know what he means.

"Get the fuck out of here, already? Tali is our roommate dude, what if she just comes in? And besides, don't tell me you found a slut that doesn't want two hard co..." his voice trails off as he pushes the door open, his jaw dropping to the floor along with his bag as he sees his twin sister, sprawled out on the bed, her puffy wet pussy pointed right at him.

 

[band_whore_22]

All Tali had time to do before Taylor stormed in was get her fingers out of her pussy. "He-hey Tay. What's up?" As she said this, she stood up, pulled her skirt down and fixed her shirt. She knew she was in deep shit with her brother. He always told her stay pure until marriage. Fucking hypocrite.....

 

[lovetoinstruct]

Taylor stood, dumbfounded, a blank look on his face as he looks at both of them. "Wha? Dude? Tali? What the fuck is this bullshit? What the fuck are you two fucking doing in here!?!" His voice raises as he stumbles over the words. Jon stands there, shame on his face, his cock still rock hard through his shorts.

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali walked up to her twin and got in his face. "Why do you care? Afraid that he was getting some without you? I know that you guys would double team girls on away games! What happened to you telling me that I should save myself for marriage? Fucking hypocrite! The whole time you were Protecting me'," she used air quotes for that,"you were off fucking sluts! So you have no right to tell me to do anything or question what I do!" She walked over to Jon and stood in front of him. "So if I want to fuck your best friend I fucking will!" With that, she jumped on Jon and kissed him, to prove her point to her twin.

 

[lovetoinstruct]

Taylor, stood, unbelieving that she would jump right up on him like that. Jon kissed Tali back hard, his hands pulling her skirt up, his fingers sliding over her wet pussy lips, turning her so Taylor could see what he was doing.

Stomping over to the door, Taylor slammed it shut.

Breaking the kiss, Jon looked at Taylor. "Dude, SHE is Jake's ex! Remember how hard we got when he told us about all the shit he did with her?"

Taylor sucks in his breath. "Fine, fuck him. And I'm going to watch you get fucked, since I know you like it so goddamn much!" Taylor was hoping that she would hear him and was still in control.

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali jumped away from Jon. "What?? You want to watch your twin fuck your best friend. You sick fuck! You fucking kill the moment that me and Jon had and you expect me to be able to get right back into it? Fuck you! Go to the girls school and fuck one of those std infested sluts!" She stormed away from them, into the bathroom, and got into the shower. How dare he?!? Sure she would have but he didn't need to make ot sound like she was a common slut. She knew her and Jon would end up dating but she didn't want to have sex with him until they are official.but Taylor...she would do it with the two of them if Jon asked nicely enough. But right now, she wasn't going to respond to being told what to do.

 

[lovetoinstruct]

"Fuck dude, you know shes a fucking firecracker, why get all in her face like that? I had her going, I bet if you would have sat down and said nothing,you COULD have watched us!"

Jon stood, talking to Taylor. They had made a pact years and years ago that no woman, ever, would have them at each others throats. Taylor looked at him. "Shit, what do you expect man? If you had said, 'hey, I'm gonna fuck your sister this year' then I wouldn't have been so surprised when I walked in. Give me some time to digest it."

Taylor walked out of the room to wander campus and sort out his thoughts.

Standing there, Jon went into the bathroom and stood outside the shower. "Tali?"

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali sank down into the tub. She couldn't believe that Jon and Taylor were fighting over her. She knew that they had made a pact to never fight over a woman. Just like how she made a pact with both of them that no relationship would come between them. She started crying, feeling like she betrayed them both.

She heard Jon call her name but that made her just start crying more. She didn't know if she wanted to keep whatever was going on between her and Jon going on if it was going to cause Taylor and Jon to fight.

 

[lovetoinstruct]

He could hear her sobbing and sat down on the floor outside the tub. "Tali, I can hear you in there. Look, I'm sorry that went the way it did. Just give Taylor a couple of hours to cool off. He was caught off guard. Lets get a bite to eat and sit down with him tonight and has things out here. We're all way to close to let a couple of fantastic orgasms to come between us."

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali giggled when Jon said that a couple fantastic orgasms shouldn't come between them. She stood up and opened the shower curtain, not even caring that she was completely naked. She grabbed a towel and wrapped it around her. "Ok. That sounds good. Olive Garden right off of campus sounds good. I just need to get ready." She went on tip toe and kissed him lightly on the lips.

She spent a couple of hours getting ready - straightening her hair, doing her makeup, and picking out the perfect outfit. Her hair was already pretty straight but she wanted it to be stick straight for tonight. She had a very natural look with her makeup going on that night. She had decided to wear a very cute white sundress with white lacey strapless bra and matching panties. Her shoes of shoes were white flip flops. She walked to the common area of their dorm. "Jon? Ready to go?"

 

[lovetoinstruct]

Jon was waiting on the couch. Tonight, he decided to wear a blue and white stripped button down dress shirt with tan dress pants and his light brown suede loafers, a bit of a change from his normal jeans and tshirt. He had his varsity jacket with him, although he was sure he wouldn't get cold.

He let out a low whistle. "Damn Tali, you look smoking hot." He stood, drinking her in with his eyes, his mind wandering back to how hot she looked splayed out on the bed earlier. "You look so pretty... I love your makeup." He walked to her, to give her a hug and feel her body next to his again.

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali smiled when Jon complimented her. "Thanks Jon. You look good to. It's good to know that you clean up good. Where are we going to dinner? I suggested Olive Garden but I'm good with wherever." She wrapped her arm around his back as they walked to the door. "Oops. Hold on." She ran back to her stuff and grabbed her white purse that had all her stuff in it. She got back under his arm. "Let's go. Are we meeting Taylor there?"

 

[lovetoinstruct]

Tali smiled when Jon complimented her. "Thanks Jon. You look good to. It's good to know that you clean up good. Where are we going to dinner? I suggested Olive Garden but I'm good with wherever." She wrapped her arm around his back as they walked to the door. "Oops. Hold on." She ran back to her stuff and grabbed her white purse that had all her stuff in it. She got back under his arm. "Let's go. Are we meeting Taylor there?"

"We are heading down to Georgios, that Italian place around the corner. I texted Taylor, he is going to meet us there. He told me he has had some to time to cool off and wants to talk to both of us."

He watched her sexy hips and ass sway as she went back for her stuff, smiling to himself.

After she came back, he slid his arm around her waist, his hand trailing down over the sexy curve of her hip as they walked out the door.

 

[band_whore_22]

Tali smiled at his hand on her hip. "Ok. Who's car are we taking? Mine or yours? You're driving no matter what."

 

[lovetoinstruct]

"Lets take yours. I love driving your standard. I hate that I bought an automatic. But the price was right, you know?"

He holds out his hand for her keys, looking at her profile. Her beautiful face, her slender neck, her fantastic, perky tits, her flat stomach, down to, what he now knew what a smoking hot pussy, her fantastic legs and her pretty feet, totally distracted by her body, like he was seeing it all at once.