pimsleur, or rosetta stone?

pete

Literotica Guru
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Posts
10,169
looking to get one of these, has anyone used either before?

would love some feedback, thanks :)
 
They're really different. It sort of depends what you're looking for. If you're wanting to learn enough to get by on a trip, Pimsleur's great. You learn useful sentences right from the start. The downside is that you don't really learn much structure or a wide vocabulary, and they only sell so many levels of any given language.

Rosetta Stone is great for vocabulary. You pick up the grammar as you go along - like you would if you were a child learning language by ear. The last time I tried it, I found their program to be a bit on the tedious side, though, and the illustrating photographs are sometimes unintentionally funny to a distracting degree. It's been a few years. It may be better now.

I've found a really good program, but it only covers a few languages. PM me with what you're studying and I'll link you if it's useful to you.
 
They're really different. It sort of depends what you're looking for. If you're wanting to learn enough to get by on a trip, Pimsleur's great. You learn useful sentences right from the start. The downside is that you don't really learn much structure or a wide vocabulary, and they only sell so many levels of any given language.

Rosetta Stone is great for vocabulary. You pick up the grammar as you go along - like you would if you were a child learning language by ear. The last time I tried it, I found their program to be a bit on the tedious side, though, and the illustrating photographs are sometimes unintentionally funny to a distracting degree. It's been a few years. It may be better now.

I've found a really good program, but it only covers a few languages. PM me with what you're studying and I'll link you if it's useful to you.

thanks :)
i'm hoping to gain a conversational-level comfort, so maybe RS then? a lot of the large construction companies in this area issue Speak In A Week to their contractors but that looks like something that just helps them "get by", and i'd like a deeper level of knowledge than that
 
Currently using Rosetta Stone. I found a draw back being if I don't know what word they are meaning, there is no translation. I've ended up looking up a lot words. They just show a picture.
 
Currently using Rosetta Stone. I found a draw back being if I don't know what word they are meaning, there is no translation. I've ended up looking up a lot words. They just show a picture.

oh yeah, i can see how that might be sorta annoying.
what language are you using it for?
 
Pete I've had much the same question for a while now

I'm looking for Latin American Spanish
 
I fully expect everyone to know English so I don't bother with their heathen languages.
 
KRC is right, everyone speaks English. Never had a problem in Japan, Germany, France, Holland, Italy, or Spain.

Actually a little bit of language is dangerous cuz you say shit like YOU SPANIARDS EAT SHIT when what you intended to say was I'M SORRY! I DONT UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU SAID. Or if your host offers you jellied ducks blood, you say NO THANKS I'D RATHER STICK MY SAUSAGE UP YOUR WIFES ASS.
 
I've tried it with Russian and my opinion is that something like the essential Berlitz books for your language are great for teaching you how to make sentences and then something like Rosetta stone helps you build vocabulary and have fun.
 
Try Duolingo. It's free. I like it.

You can also try your local library. My local library has something called Mango that's free online.
 
It took me close to a month but I have successfully downloaded 150 Rosetta Stone language modules via bit torrent. 30 gigs worth!

Where to start... :D
 
It took me close to a month but I have successfully downloaded 150 Rosetta Stone language modules via bit torrent. 30 gigs worth!

Where to start... :D

I actually tried doing that a couple years ago and couldn't find much and the ones I did find didn't work.
 
It took me close to a month but I have successfully downloaded 150 Rosetta Stone language modules via bit torrent. 30 gigs worth!

Where to start... :D

did you get the full-on versions of each language, or just one or two sections for each?
 
did you get the full-on versions of each language, or just one or two sections for each?

all five sections of every language (some languages only have three). Took me forever to find French 3, 4 and 5.
 
To answer your original question, I used Pimsleur to learn some Mandarin a few years ago. It's pretty brutal at first, but I was able to get around while in China.

I purchased the CD sets used on ebay for about $150 plus S&H, and then when I finished with them I sold them on ebay for about $150 plus S&H. I purchased two or three levels of Mandarin and learned them for the price of shipping and handling.
 
Back
Top