Prenuptial Agreements

PullnPray

Experienced
Joined
Mar 30, 2013
Posts
81
So how do you feel about prenups? Has it ever been a point of contention for you in a relationship? Would you be hurt if your partner wanted a prenup? A couple of years ago, my relationship with my fiance ultimately ended after I proposed we have one drawn up. What I had in mind was pretty fair to her in my opinion. She definitely would have walked away from the marriage financially better off than she entered into it. But she was offended by the very idea of a prenup, and had no interest in discussing the details. It was either a "real" marriage or no marriage at all.
 
So how do you feel about prenups? Has it ever been a point of contention for you in a relationship? Would you be hurt if your partner wanted a prenup? A couple of years ago, my relationship with my fiance ultimately ended after I proposed we have one drawn up. What I had in mind was pretty fair to her in my opinion. She definitely would have walked away from the marriage financially better off than she entered into it. But she was offended by the very idea of a prenup, and had no interest in discussing the details. It was either a "real" marriage or no marriage at all.

If you need a prenup, you can't afford to get married.
 
I tend to agree with her, all or nothing for me or why bother getting married?
 
If you need a prenup, you can't afford to get married.

What do you mean exactly?

I tend to agree with her, all or nothing for me or why bother getting married?

Why bother because I'm already thinking about the possible failure of the marriage? Or why bother because a marriage with a prenup wouldn't provide you with the kind of financial security that you would want from a marriage?

In Western Civilization I think we've finally moved beyond women as chattel. Or not.

I don't follow. What does a prenup have to do with treating women like chattel? If the female is the one with greater assets, does the prenup treat men like chattel?
 
What do you mean exactly?



Why bother because I'm already thinking about the possible failure of the marriage? Or why bother because a marriage with a prenup wouldn't provide you with the kind of financial security that you would want from a marriage?



I don't follow. What does a prenup have to do with treating women like chattel? If the female is the one with greater assets, does the prenup treat men like chattel?

I think you've made up your mind already.
 
I think you've made up your mind already.

About prenups? Yes, I would definitely want one. But I'd still like to understand what you are saying.

Prenuptial agreements can take many forms. Can you not even imagine one that you would be OK with? They don't all leave women high and dry. But yes, if the marriage fails after 7 years, it is important to me that I don't lose half of what I've worked my ass off to accumulate over the last 20 years.
 
I don't want to derail such a great thread (because I would never do something like that) but I need you to explain your name. Pull...what? Do you pull on your junk and pray that Jesus forgives you for what comes out? Not sure why that was my first thought. I'm sure that says way more about me than it does about your name.
 
darling, will you marry me? I want to spend the rest of my life with you. my worldly goods I thee endow. oh, but would you just sign this because I think that when we'll split up we'll act like vindictive arseholes incapable of coming to an adult agreement :)

I wouldn't marry a guy if he wanted one. if we don't trust each other not to rip each other off then we don't trust each other enough to get married. he isn't the man for me.
 
Trust owns everything....you own nothing....which means neither she nor the court can take what you don't have and most don't have the time/money/gumption to go after a trust as it's a PITA, and for anyone trying to get to you through the trust it's a legal fucking nightmare for anyone who tries, even the government and that's a large part of why these legal prophylactics exist. Sure keep whatever joint shit joint, the volvo, day job money, whatever the fuck...anything you are willing to cut as a loss and keep rolling without.

But keep your GT500KR, company and lake house covered by the snarling legal nightmare...fuck no one should ever even know about it until they try to legally fuck you and realize they can't take you out because you were smart enough to not put all your eggs in one basket.

No prenup no butthurt...got it? Great now pass the dutch....only on the left hand side :cool:

darling, will you marry me? I want to spend the rest of my life with you. my worldly goods I thee endow. oh, but would you just sign this because I think that when we'll split up we'll act like vindictive arseholes incapable of coming to an adult agreement :)

I wouldn't marry a guy if he wanted one. if we don't trust each other not to rip each other off then we don't trust each other enough to get married. he isn't the man for me.

What about universal legal protection of his assets...yes that includes from you, the gubbmint, loony fucks about the world and even his mamma?

Would you take equal offense to that?
 
Last edited:
About prenups? Yes, I would definitely want one. But I'd still like to understand what you are saying.

Prenuptial agreements can take many forms. Can you not even imagine one that you would be OK with? They don't all leave women high and dry. But yes, if the marriage fails after 7 years, it is important to me that I don't lose half of what I've worked my ass off to accumulate over the last 20 years.

You're 40 something and this is your first marriage?
 
So how do you feel about prenups? Has it ever been a point of contention for you in a relationship? Would you be hurt if your partner wanted a prenup? A couple of years ago, my relationship with my fiance ultimately ended after I proposed we have one drawn up. What I had in mind was pretty fair to her in my opinion. She definitely would have walked away from the marriage financially better off than she entered into it. But she was offended by the very idea of a prenup, and had no interest in discussing the details. It was either a "real" marriage or no marriage at all.

I think your former fiancee made a wise decision.
 
You can all just give me cash. I accept Paypal now, as well.



You don't get anything for it PER SAY, but I think just knowing you made my life a little better is it's own reward.
 
What I want to know is how the fuck she got "Women are chattel" out of "IF this goes to shit, you can't clean me out using our sexist as all fuck against men family courts."

That's my quershtun!

Doesn't matter had sex?
 
What I want to know is how the fuck she got "Women are chattel" out of "IF this goes to shit, you can't clean me out using our sexist as all fuck against men family courts." :confused: Offensive? Sure...."Women are chattel"??? bit fucking dramatic...

That's my quershtun!
http://lofifly.com/wp-content/uploads/LOFI-Hillbilly.jpg

Almost politically correct redneck is my favorite meme.

http://s2.quickmeme.com/img/41/41aca3cd2821af92032ed17a02b631a5dc495fe6f37da2a0c733e534b5008f62.jpg
 
Why bother because I'm already thinking about the possible failure of the marriage? Or why bother because a marriage with a prenup wouldn't provide you with the kind of financial security that you would want from a marriage?

I wouldn't want financial security from marriage, I would want an equal life partner. For better or worse...

Most states only consider assets acquired during the marriage as joint anyway. Most pre-nupts can be broken.
 
I don't want to derail such a great thread (because I would never do something like that) but I need you to explain your name. Pull...what? Do you pull on your junk and pray that Jesus forgives you for what comes out? Not sure why that was my first thought. I'm sure that says way more about me than it does about your name.

Your dirty mind is on the right track. It is a reference to a form of birth control... pull out and pray you pulled out in time. Infantile I know, but it seemed clever when I started using the handle when I was 18.

Trust owns everything....you own nothing....which means neither she nor the court can take what you don't have and most don't have the time/money/gumption to go after a trust as it's a PITA, and to get to you through the trust it's a legal fucking nightmare for anyone who tries, even the government and that's why they exist. Sure keep whatever joint shit joint, the volvo, day job money, whatever the fuck......

But keep your GT500KR, company and lake house covered by the snarling legal nightmare.

No prenup no butthurt...got it? Great now pass the dutch....only on the left hand side :cool:

In my situation, trying to shelter everything in a trust would be a big pain in the ass. Besides, I have no desire to go about this in a deceitful way.

You're 40 something and this is your first marriage?

I'm almost 38. I was counting college as part of the 20 years of hard work.

I wonder if mama's boy would sign a prenup if the situation were reversed?

So because I'm still single, this makes me a mama's boy? Funny! But I do love my mom. It is hard to imagine the situation truly being reversed. Because it is hard for me to imagine that I am a 2nd grade schoolteacher who'd like to one day marry the perfect woman and become a stay at home dad. And its hard for me to imagine a successful, professional woman wanting to marry a guy like that. But if I one day become engaged to a woman much wealthier than me and she wants me to sign a prenup, I would be perfectly fine with that.
 
I do see myself EVER being in a situation where I needed one. My divorce could be a case study in how to be simple, and not an asshole.
 


It's a classic...

It's no invisible Jay Z sex tape but what the fuck ever.


:rose:

Nothing really is now is it.....

:D

In my situation, trying to shelter everything in a trust would be a big pain in the ass. Besides, I have no desire to go about this in a deceitful way.

Well then don't QQ when ya get cleaned out or dumped for asking for a pre-nup.

Nothing deceitful about it!! You wisely set up a legal entity to shelter your assets as would any sane person with enough shit to worry about losing in the first fucking place would. And since you don't need to protect it from her anyhow because she would NEVER do anything like get bitter and clean you out it's not a big deal and since she never asked it just never occurred to you that she couldn't fuck you over in court if she decided to go all war of the roses on you. You just never thought that would happen :D In fact it's a total turn on for her because you're not a total fucking retard and wisely secured your shit. If she's mad your assets are in a trust then fuck her, run far run fast.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top