penguindance
Tingly all over...
- Joined
- May 2, 2002
- Posts
- 6,461
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
pretty_lil_stranger said:I think so, too. And I do kind of like it, but every time I hear it, that line about deciding not have a child makes it all seem too easy to me...
red_rose said:
I just thought I'd toss that out there and see what you all think. Should schools teach about abortion as part of sex ed?
At least it's still a decision that could be made. Keep abortion safe and legal. You can't speculate (on the evidence given) how "easy" this decision was to make. You don't have to speculate on what their lives would be like if they chose otherwise. But as I said, at least they had the choice.pretty_lil_stranger said:...that line about deciding not have a child makes it all seem too easy to me...
Freya2 said:Remember the hoopla over teaching about condoms? Multiply that by about a thousand.
Besides, unless they make it a Science subject, it's too easy to have personal viewpoints colouring the way it is taught.
red_rose said:Even science is coulored by personal viewpoints. When I was a jr. in high school, my chemistry teacher would occasionally take 10 or so minutes out of classtime to lecture us about religion. If he wasn't such a phenomenal teacher, I would have reported him for it. (Good teachers were few and far between in my high school.)
I definitely agree that it would create a lot of controversy - much more than teaching about condoms - but it may need to be done anyhow. More and more teenagers are having abortions.
Come to think of it, even my college level health class didn't touch on abortion in the least. I never really thought about it before.
Freya2 said:What I really meant was, if it's done completely scientifically, as in a description of the procedure, it's effects etc - not discussion on right/wrong, morals or beliefs. But even that could be tinted by the person's beliefs on the subject.
JazzManJim said:That's an impossibility, though.
Abortion isn't a subject which exists in a vacuum. Kids know that there's some sort of debate goig on out there in the world and at some point in some school year, one child is goingn to ask what the debate is all about.
That's where the giant can of worms gets opened.
If the teacher brushes off the question, it just drives it undergrouns. If the teacher opens the discussion, it's like to enrage one side or the other.
What I would favor, though, is a lesson plan wherein both sides of the argument are given equal time and equal importance. Lay the information out for the students and make very clear that this is something about which they have to think carefully to make an informed decision.
Freya2 said:Yes, very true. That's kinda why I said it needed to remain a science topic, rather than one in health class etc. I don't think you'll see that kind of advanced thinking in the school system for many years, if ever.
Freya2 said:Yea, but that wasn't science - that was him teaching his own personal opinions.
What I really meant was, if it's done completely scientifically, as in a description of the procedure, it's effects etc - not discussion on right/wrong, morals or beliefs. But even that could be tinted by the person's beliefs on the subject.
JazzManJim said:Hon, it's an impossibility. That topic can not simply be taught as a pure science subject because it isn't a pure science subject.
Freya2 said:I know. That's what I meant - only apparently I didn't say it like I meant it. It's too controversial a subject to be taught properly in any school, in any fashion.
JazzManJim said:You'd have to be circumspect about it if you did it. You could draw compelling arguments from both sides that have nothing to do with religion, thus avoiding that entanglement. But I do think it cold be done.