Reprimanding young children

T.H. Oughts

Oh the thoughts of Oughts
Joined
Nov 8, 2001
Posts
19,712
How about giving your suggestions on how to keep under the age of 10 year olds in line. Obviously we can not give them a goog wallop like some of us got when we were kids….

What tricks do you use when your child has been naughty and you feel the need to teach them a lesson or punish them for wrong deeds.
 
Well what worked for us is to remove privliges. If they did something bad or acted bad we would remove a privilege from them. Small things usually, but some bigger things as they got older. They soon understood in a direct way that to behave poorly was to court disaster.

Just use positive re-enforcement as much as possible and things seem to work out in the end. I have three kids that are doing allright now, and one is 22. the boys are teenagers yet and I have found that things change a lot at the teenage time of life. New challenges to overcome with boys too.
 
We talk to ours first, and warn her that a spanking is going to come next time. There's no shame in spanking. Beating them silly yes, but not in spanking.

Today sadly, if you so much as think about giving the child a "wallop", they call child protection services... Or threaten anyway.

Sometimes being "politically correct" is the wrong thing to be, like when it comes to correcting YOUR kids.
 
I grew up with the "Children will be seen but not heard" rule.

I think children have a right to have the answers to why you say no.... not just "because I said so" coming from the parent.

But sometimes it is hard drawing a line between givving them the freedom their spirt deserves and having them show repect that when you say no you mean no.
 
How can I have a serious conversation in this thread with my butt showing, lol
 
T.H. Oughts said:
How can I have a serious conversation in this thread with my butt showing, lol

I was just thinking that there are an awful lot of ass av's in here for a thread about discipline.
;)
 
RawHumor said:
I was just thinking that there are an awful lot of ass av's in here for a thread about discipline.
;)
Anybody think they were asking for a good spanking or something. :eek:
 
T.H. Oughts said:
How can I have a serious conversation in this thread with my butt showing, lol

don't worry, it's possible, beleive it or not.

Now on to business...

I nearly had my arm broken once by my father when I back talked him, when I was asked at the hospital how it happened, the nurses shrugged it off, as parental correction. Not like today when they bring in a Child Services person first and make the parent leave, so they can "get the truth" from the child, not what the parent says.

My incident made me very leary of people who are in a postion to help, because they let me down. I ended up telling everyone after that, I hurt it playing Futbol (soccer).
 
Last edited:
It depends on what the child has done. If it was something silly then a quick chat about them thinking through what they do before they do it. Getting them to think for themselves is a good skill.
Otherwise
Time out in their room
Loss of privleges
No pocket money
Extra chores
Being grounded
Earlier bedtime
No dessert

Sometimes I let them choose the consequence of their wrong doing. IE You have a choice of the following...
1 No pocket money for a week
2 No tv for a week
3 Time out in your room

Definitely talk to them about why they are in trouble. :rose:
 
Basically it goes like this

You simply tell them to do their chores and stop misbehaving or they have to play any and all video games on the hardest settings.

Should get them in line.
 
Depends on How Young

The littlest ones can only be redirected to more acceptable behavoir, I think. Once they get heavily into the terrible 2s though, I felt "time out" was most appropriate, bearing in mind that the younger they are , the less "time out" they can handle. School-aged kids (I have two) seem to respond to loss of privliges--at least mine do. The single most important thing, IMHO though, is to follow through if you make a threat. If kids think you make empty threats, discipline becomes meaningless.

And I never hit. Ever. I know a lot of people disagree with that (including one I used to be married to), but I think the only message it sends is "I'm stronger, therefore I overpower." Time enough for them to learn that one.
 
My mother was big into the *let the punishment fit the crime* idea.

If we fought with our siblings: we had to hug them for a half hour, or hold hands for a half hour

When my brother stole gum: he had to *work* for my dad to pay it off

If we yelled at anyone: we had to sit in silence right next to mom, who read a book while we were silent.

*shrugs* worked for us .. but we lived in the middle of nowhere .. we didn't have anywhere we could run off to .. so it might be different for someone not in those circumstances.
 
Mine don't get regular pocket money.

Hard to take TV away for a week when the other child wants to watch it in the same room....

Time out in the bedroom is fun for them cause they get to play with their toys...
I always explain and talk about why what they did was wrong.


PLS it is hard to keep them in line. When my son was five he a tiger for throwing a screaming wobbly. We just stuck to our guns and let him scream and rant to show him that it had no effect on us. Tough love was needed and it worked. The neighbours must of thought we were torchering him, but after a few days he learnt that screaming was not going to get him attention.

I think staying on gaurd all the time and when you say something that you mean it.... If you say stay in their room and they come out, drag them back in....

:)
 
Being consistent and unwavering helps as a baseline on standard stuff.

And, much like dealing with the flamers here, maintaining a chilled attitude to shenanigans helps.

Cultivating a reallly badass intimidating voice tone for special occasions is a useful tool.

Mine still respond if I start to count to three...they're like little Pavlovian dogs the way they (usually) alter course at "2" ....it's quite gratifying and requires no yelling.

Sometimes I used to get on the floor and start a little tantrum of my own....that usually got them laughing and laughter without shaming is a highly effective discipline tool.
 
pretty_lil_stranger said:
I don't want to argue, but how small of children are we talking about? My kids wouldn't respond to any of these thigns, except maybe time out in their room, which is something we do use.

Th said in her first post under the age of 10. I know her kids aren't littlies (younger than five) :)
For little ones star charts are cool, rewarding the good behaviour seems very effective.


Th the tv thing does work for me. If one is banned the child watches tv and the other child must leave the lounge and go read a book or find another activity to do.

If the kids are sent to their room, they know they are to spend 10 mins on their bed reading, thinking but not playing or the time is extended by five mins. (LOL I sound mean)

I use the counting to three method also, making sure I follow through with what I say I am going to do. Consistency is a wonderful tool.
 
T.H. Oughts said:
How about giving your suggestions on how to keep under the age of 10 year olds in line. Obviously we can not give them a goog wallop like some of us got when we were kids….

What tricks do you use when your child has been naughty and you feel the need to teach them a lesson or punish them for wrong deeds.

Why not it worked for us, maybe sparing the rod and spoiling the kid needs to re-invented, or re-discovered.
 
This is our method for dealing with our kids' behavior:

We set up a dry-erase board, with all 4 kids names along one side....and the days of the week along the top. With rows and columns made of the two.

We then set up a Red-Yellow-Green system. We listed the main rules of our house, along with a color beside each rule. Some rules are yellow, and some are red.

When a yellow rule is broken, a yellow check is placed under the corresponding day for that child. They are then sent to their room for an hour. After an hour, they are allowed to come out of their room if they can tell us what they did wrong. After another hour, the yellow check turns to green.

When a red rule is broken, a red check is placed under the corresponding day for that child. They are sent to their room for an hour, and after an hour, they are allowed to come out if they tell us what they did wrong. The red check is then changed to a yellow check, and it stays that way for the day.

If a child has a red check and does another red check offense, they get a double red check under the corresponding day. A double red check means that they will get a spanking. Then they spend the rest of the day in their room.

At the end of the week, if a child has 5 green checks, they are given something special....this could be a trip to the park, a trip to the lake, going to a movie etc...

The whole key to this method is consistency. Also, having the rules written down means that you don't have to appear as the judge and jury. When a child argues with you about a rule being broken, you just point to the board and show them the rule. It dis-empowers both you and the child.
 
Bob_Bytchin said:
This is our method for dealing with our kids' behavior:

We set up a dry-erase board, with all 4 kids names along one side....and the days of the week along the top. With rows and columns made of the two.

We then set up a Red-Yellow-Green system. We listed the main rules of our house, along with a color beside each rule. Some rules are yellow, and some are red.

When a yellow rule is broken, a yellow check is placed under the corresponding day for that child. They are then sent to their room for an hour. After an hour, they are allowed to come out of their room if they can tell us what they did wrong. After another hour, the yellow check turns to green.

When a red rule is broken, a red check is placed under the corresponding day for that child. I then put my dick in the childs mouth and make them suck and suck and suck until they start crying from the pain of lockjaw. They are sent to their room for an hour, and after an hour, they are allowed to come out if they tell us what they did wrong. The red check is then changed to a yellow check, and it stays that way for the day.

If a child has a red check and does another red check offense, they get a double red check under the corresponding day. A double red check means that they will get a spanking. Then they spend the rest of the day in their room.

At the end of the week, if a child has 5 green checks, they are given something special....this could be a trip to the park, a trip to the lake, going to a movie etc...

The whole key to this method is consistency. Also, having the rules written down means that you don't have to appear as the judge and jury. When a child argues with you about a rule being broken, you just point to the board and show them the rule. It dis-empowers both you and the child.

I'm not sure about the dick-in-mouth part though
 
Bob_Bytchin said:
Also, having the rules written down means that you don't have to appear as the judge and jury. When a child argues with you about a rule being broken, you just point to the board and show them the rule. It dis-empowers both you and the child.

I like that idea... also a good idea to write down as many jobs you do for them also. That way they can see everyone has even jobs to do around the house... I am always getting," Why do I have to do everything" from them.

Them: Feeding an animal.
You: Cooking children dinner.

Them: Making their own school lunch.
You: Driving them to school.

Them: Cleaning their bedroom.
You: Cleaning the bathroom and vacuming.
 
pretty_lil_stranger said:
Isn't an hour a LONG time to spend in their room? And the other one...the rest of the DAY in their room? Seems a bit harsh, aside from complicated. Just my opinion.

You know what? I've been going to parenting therapy and parenting classes (purely voluntary) because I have two daughters who have some emotional issues. Before I began these classes, my kids were always acting up, and were very hard to handle.

After instituting this method, at the suggestion of a child psychologist and family therapist, my kids have really changed for the better. We no longer have yelling matches in our house between parent and child. We no longer have to tell our kids twice to do anything.

An hour in a room is harsh? How so? No, beating the crap out of a kid and screaming at them is harsh.

A day in their room is harsh? How so? If they know the consequences ahead of time, then it's a choice they make themselves.

The whole key here is that we have the rules written down...in plain view...with the consequences as well. There is nothing harsh about a "break the rules, face the consequences" system.
 
Back
Top