Ridiculing the religious

Re: Re: Re: like minds

Black_Bird said:


I don't mean to be insulting, but just why is it that Wiccans, when ever they choose to mention their faith, feel they have to defend it? Of those who do not conform to mainstream beliefs, Wiccans just seem more afraid of persecution then the rest...

Relax - be yourself. :)

If anybody picks on you on these board for being different, Black_Bird the "Friendly Satanist" will be more then glad to rip them a new one.

My .... ( let me repeat that MY ) experience is that as soon as people find out I am Wiccan, I get 100 questions about something I know almost nothing about : Satanism.

Or people demand an explanation about my faith. As I am solitary ( meaning I do not belong to a group or coven ) I practice my own version of Wicca. I worship the Goddess and God, but I do so in my own way. I do not have long rituals, because I live with other people in my house, and there are small children who visit, I keep my alter in a trunk and bring it out when I need it. I tried putting it up, but the kids ( and some adults ) can not keep their hands off things.

This is my reasoning for defending my belief, I can not answer for anyone else. But the witch hunts of past days come right to mind. :(
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: like minds

SilverVeil said:
My .... ( let me repeat that MY ) experience is that as soon as people find out I am Wiccan, I get 100 questions about something I know almost nothing about : Satanism.

And the same goes for Heathens, Thelemites, Chaos Magicians, Golden Dawn Ritualist, Enochian Magicians and Shaman.

Any belief system that has remotely anything to do with magick or affective ritual is going to be called Satanism in the U.S. - regardless of how much you oppose to those beliefs. Constantly being on the defensive will not change this. Sad, but true.

This is my reasoning for defending my belief, I can not answer for anyone else. But the witch hunts of past days come right to mind. :(

*sigh* The more you worry about how to explain your religion to others, the less time you will have to be yourself. :)
 
Astro said:
Some atheists ridicule anyone with faith and any faith. However I dont think they will wage wars, burn people, drive people out of their homes and carry out terriost acts in the name of atheism.
I disagree; your assertion implies that all wars/etc. have only been waged due to religion, yet atheists have been the largest mass murders in history; Stalin murdered over 40 million people, and Mao Tse-tung murdered almost 38 million people (source - "Death by Government", Rummel).

Religion is an open war, Faith is a personal affair.
Over simplified.

To answer the original question, I do wince inwardly when I hear friends ridicule my religion (usually because they don't know I hold those views) - usually something about "stupid Christians" or "self-righteous Christians". I cringe not so much because it hurts me, but because up until that point I thought better of them than to expect a religious slur from them.

It is the same feeling I get when they say something about "towel heads" (Arabs, moslems, etc.), "niggers", "faggots", "dykes", and so on. They have just displayed their ignorance and bigotry.

As for freedom of speech - go for it, people should be able to say what they feel - or if they can think rationally (which very few people can for any length of time), then say what they think.

However, when bile comes spewing out of their mouths, don't be surprised when I turn and walk away; bile stinks.:eek:

If on the other hand people want to have an intelligent and rational discourse about religion, I don't have a problem with someone who disagrees with my beliefs, or if even if they think disparagingly about them. I have called certain other's beliefs BS before, and I will again, but I will back it up with why I think that, and I will generally avoid being personal, intolerant or bigoted about it.
 
perky_baby said:
the only thing that ever bugs me about religions is the definitions.

I got caught up in this recently. I believed a label being used by the poster meant something entirely different<I still do>. I don't fault anyone for their beliefs or their spirituality, it is something that is important in people's lives no matter what they believe or don't. It's the labeling as I know it being defined in a different manner that threw me for a loop.
I feel compelled to respond; I do not find it surprising that my definition of a fundamentalist Christian was confusing. The reason why is that I try to use words precisely and accurately. If someone else is misusing a word I do not let that stop me from using the same word in the way it was originally meant, especially if that is the way the dictionary defines it.

I encounter other's confusion with the way I use labels all the time and not just with my religious labels, but also political; I am a Liberal, but when I tell them I am against social programs, against any kind of gun control legislation, against affirmative action, and so on, people are confused. That is because a true Liberal is a different species from what many people commonly think of as a Liberal today.

Today, most people who call are labeled "Liberal" are somewhere between a "Progressive" and a "Socialist", and they are actually neo-Liberals.

True Liberals today are often called Libertarians, a label adopted by Liberals early in this century because Socialists took the Liberal label to disguise themselves (back when anything to do with Socialism was viewed as traitorous).

I do not play such word games; if the true definition is still in the dictionary, and there is documented support for the true definition, then I do not let others play double speak games with words that I feel are the most descriptive and accurate.

Like I said, this confuses people until they get to know me, sometimes even afterwards - but I do my best to disabuse them of their misconceptions, and sometimes they come through it having learned the truth, and not lies that people would have them believe.
 
Why Not?

How can any intelligent person not ridicule religion? Many religious dogmas are patently absurd (Jesus was born of a virgin mother, came back to life after three days, etc.). Religious fanaticism has been responsible for millions of deaths and untold suffering, from the Crusades to today.

Organized religion is particularly vile and a threat to humanity. Just look at the sinister machinations of the "Christian" fascists, who did a lot to help Bush usurp power last year. These woman-hating, gay-bashing fanatics must be crushed once and for all for the good of humanity! In general, organized religion and reactionary politics go hand in hand and work together. The clerics befuddle and ensalve the minds of the people so the rulers can more effectively oppress them. The tax exempt status of churches is an outrage which amounts to government subsidization of religion, in violation of the principle of separation of church and state. Not only should it be ended immediately, the churches should now have to pay all the back taxes they should have been charged in the first place.

Down With Organized Religion! Destroy the parson power, the spiritual forces of repression!
 
REDWAVE

That was very nearly the most perfect example of "bigotry" I have ever read!
 
I consider organised religion a form of social control, moderating and policing morality across the whole spectrum of human activity.
I consider the beliefs themselves to be interesting in what they tell you about people but not actually true.

But I also think that you can beleive what you like (after all, how can I stop you?). But a lot of violence, cruelty and intolerance and low grade nastiness has been commited in the name of religion. And that is not acceptable to me.

You can believe what you please, but if there is some practice that your beliefs lead you to undertake which I think is morally wrong you cannot possible expect me to just stand by and smile.
 
Ridiculing the Religious

Here is a different perspective: To look at Life and it's many choices as a buffet. ( In the case of this thread a religious buffet )
We certainly don't get all bent out of shape when we find a particular food on a buffet we dont enjoy. We simply pass it up and choose one we do. Or we choose not to partake at all if we are so inclined. I don't know too many people that react emotionally if brocolli is on the buffet vs say Pineapple. They certainly dont form special interest groups to make sure brocolli is included on the buffet because it is GOOD for humans. Or hate groups for the ones who fear brocolli because they do not understand it.(yes I am being ridiculous)
Am I making any sense here at all? When we seek to limit anothers choices (as humans so frequently do) We limit the experience of another. Wouldn't it be really cool if humans lightened up & allowed other humans their brocolli / pineapple preferences??? Ok, yes, I have really gone off the deep end with this one.
:D Actually a sexual buffet would be alot more fun to ponder....
 
Redwave

Faith and spirituality has also been responsible for uncountable charity and compassion also.

It has helped ease the suffering of millions and given comfort to the grief stricken. It has been a friend to the friendless and loved the unlovable. It has been a driving force for bringing people together and advancing civilization.

Any dogma can be used for good or evil- including the atheistic dogma of the past Soviet regime and the present one in China-that is up to the individuals espousing it.

To ridicule someone for their beliefs is only an invitation for them to ridicule you.

Your failure to see the implied moral significance of the circumstances of Jesus birth rather than the literal interpretation is just as shortsighted and rigid as the fundamentalist view of the bible.

FYI..the significance is not that Mary was a "virgin" but that such a being (son of God) would be born in such low circumstances. The lesson is that we shouldn't judge others solely on their social status or origins. Mary more likely was viewed as having a child out of wedlock and consequently had to "run away" to have the child to spare her family the embarassment. Our society did much the same thing in the 40's and 50's. You don't believe in the "virgin" birth so why would anyone 2035 years ago?

Just food for thought.
 
Re: Why Not?

REDWAVE said:
Down With Organized Religion! Destroy the parson power, the spiritual forces of repression!

If it wasn't for religion, we would just be blaming something else for the misdeeds of humanity in the past. Don't confuse the excuse with the intention - they are two very different animals indeed.
 
Charity & compassion

O yeah, I know all about the charity & compassion of the Bible-thumpers. They'll feed hungry people-- a little slop or gruel, and first make them wait in line, demean and humiliate them, make them sit through a boring sermon, etc. The so-called "charity and compassion" of organized religion is bogus and phony, just another tool for controlling people and bending them to their will.

The Christian fascists are responsible for making abortions virtually unobtainable in this country, especially for poor women. I've looked into the faces of those "holy" people at clinic defenses in L.A.-- howling mobs of bigots, foaming at the mouth!

And I just love the topsy turvy logic of one poster. Just because I don't want to subsidize churches so they can spew their poisonous, right-wing propaganda, blessing war and repression while telling me I can't have sex with whom I choose-- that makes me a bigot? Nonsense!
 
Hmmmm

The "christians" you cited, I suppose they are the sum total of all christianity? Those are the only Christians there are?

Lenin and Stalin were socialists, so using your logic all socialists are genocidal maniacs. Very narrow minded, but I can see how holding that view supports your opinion and any deviation would destroy your argument. The compassionate christian does not exist. Can't. No way. Doesn't fit your model. Form an opinion then throw away any facts that do not support it.

They tried to do that with the ether didn't they?
 
Yes REDWAVE

You are a bigot. You are an angry, irrational bigot. Sure, there are plenty of stupid irrational bigots among the religious right, but that doesn't prevent you from also being a bigot.

I don't tolerate racial hatred and bigotry, nor do I tolerate bigotry against religious people. I usually use tact when I interact with people who have different opinions, but your lack of moderation or tact deserves a straight forward response.
 
The flaming

The irrational outburst and sweeping generalizations is what I was initially talking about, and what ensued here was so predictable that it illustrates there is no One way, Right side.

I don't know any of you well who participated in this thread. Those whom I have had a chance to interact with, I have enjoyed you all. I don't think any less of anyone here for their personal views.

RED, I am a Christian for lack of another label. We have yucked it up a few times. Do you think less of me because I believe in God? I would never tell you were going to hell. I am pro-choice. Texan, do you or is there any pro-lifer who thinks I'm scum for my position? I like Ruby and appreciated her post. I hope she has the same respect and tolerance for me.

Do we have to throw the baby out with the bath water? I am an individual. I am not a religion. Among my friends who are religious, spiritual whatever term you want to use, I can't think of one of them who has swallowed some doctrine whole.

I don't believe in God because religion dictates that I do. I don't follow any dogma to the letter. That's not what a spiritual path is about. Nor do I want to be attacked and blamedfor those who wrongly slaughter in the name of God. I'm a pacifist if you must know.

Embracing religion doesn't mean you can't be a free thinker. I really wish those who despise organized religion would stop calling me a freak, stupid, insane.

If you don't want, like, need religion, I have no argument. If someone is an asshole please don't conveniently say it's all the fault of religion cause I won't argue you're an asshole just because you don't believe. When I call somebody an asshole he has earned it on his own merit.

Stupidity, ignorance, intolerance runs across the gamut. We all know that is true. This wasn't about who's the biggest asshole. It was about personal accountability. Funny how that's the first thing lost in the dust of battle.

Be well.

Peace,

daughter
 
Hey daughter

I have no problem with individual spirituality, especially yours, daugher, which I'm sure is pretty cool. My remarks were all directed against organized religion-- which I regard as an abomination.
 
Just about anything that has been said about religion, especially about the harm and death, could be said of a number of institutions, especially government. This century alone, government has murdered 170 million non-combatants. This does not include collateral damage to war or combatants in wars, nor does it include all of the suffering (famines, plagues, etc.) caused directly or indirectly by government action.

The more powerful the institution, the higher the likelihood that it will be abused. Religion, in many ways, is only second to government in the amount of power it has wielded over the minds and lives of people.

If you want to assert that religion has caused a lot of death and/or suffering, then provide specific instances (not broad assertions), numbers to compare to other causes/agents, and sources for your data.

Religion is a powerful social institution, and sometimes, maybe even often, that power is misused/abused, and yes a lot of people have been killed in the name of, and abused at the hands of religion. However, we've been over this before; unless the religion specifically calls for it, the religion is not responsible for the people that abuse/misuse it, or for the followers who kill in its name.
 
daughter,

Of course I don't respect you any less because of your religious beliefs. My mother is a christian and I love her. I'm sure that most people I know believe in god.

I consider STG and Todd friends of mine here at lit and I know where they stand on religion.

Frankly, I'm a bit envious of people who have faith. I'm sure it offers them tremendous comfort in life.

As I stated before, my biggest problem with religion lies with ones who proselytize. I believe that is very wrong and to that end, had no sympathy whatsoever for the christian women jailed in Afghanistan for doing it.
 
People wh ridicule someones's religion do so from their own insecurities and ignorance. Is there ever an excuse to do so? Not from my point of view there isn't. Being and overweight senior citizen, I have been ridiculed, some of it vicious but I choose to believe that these people have some deep seated ignorance about the facts. Since last Feb., I have lost seventy pounds, just a few each month. I'm a reasonably attractive man, but still I hear the snide remarks and it still hurts. I would never tolerate anyone of my acquainances who displayed any form or religious intolerance and everyone knows it. If you want to worship flying saucers, that is your right. I hope that you have not been the victim of such stupidity.
 
daughter, I am also pro-choice. And while many members of organized religion are pro-life, there are many religious people who are pro-choice.

I have witnessed the flames with which racists are burned on this board. I'll light the match for anyone who flames an outspoken ignorant racist. I challenge anyone to reread REDWAVE's posts and do a little word substitution. For each of REDWAVE's references to "religion" or "organized religion", substitute a derogatory term for "African Americans". Then tell me REDWAVE is worthy of a reasoned reply.

Does anyone (other than REDWAVE) actually believe bigotry against religion or religious people is "not as bad" as bigotry against people of color? I believe this was the original question behind this thread. It appears to me that the tolerance with which REDWAVE was treated on this board is an indication of the existance of that "double standard". I know people disagreed with REDWAVE, but there was an attitude that maybe he was justified in spewing his bile and hatred.

daughter, I believe it is more politically correct to attack religion and religious people than it is to even criticize other "groups". I think this double standard is wrong... but I think it exists...
 
Re: Hey daughter

REDWAVE said:
I have no problem with individual spirituality, especially yours, daugher, which I'm sure is pretty cool. My remarks were all directed against organized religion-- which I regard as an abomination.

Here's the first line of the post to remind you:

Why not? How can any intelligent person not ridicule religion?

The "cool" smilie doesn't make it all right either...

*shrugs* Oh well...
 
Last edited:
Nice buns

Well, let's see-- Texan: "African Americans and reactionary politics go hand in hand." Nope, doesn't work.
 
Re: Redwave

Thumper said:
Faith and spirituality has also been responsible for uncountable charity and compassion also.

It has helped ease the suffering of millions and given comfort to the grief stricken. It has been a friend to the friendless and loved the unlovable. It has been a driving force for bringing people together and advancing civilization.

Any dogma can be used for good or evil- including the atheistic dogma of the past Soviet regime and the present one in China-that is up to the individuals espousing it.

To ridicule someone for their beliefs is only an invitation for them to ridicule you.

Your failure to see the implied moral significance of the circumstances of Jesus birth rather than the literal interpretation is just as shortsighted and rigid as the fundamentalist view of the bible.

FYI..the significance is not that Mary was a "virgin" but that such a being (son of God) would be born in such low circumstances. The lesson is that we shouldn't judge others solely on their social status or origins. Mary more likely was viewed as having a child out of wedlock and consequently had to "run away" to have the child to spare her family the embarassment. Our society did much the same thing in the 40's and 50's. You don't believe in the "virgin" birth so why would anyone 2035 years ago?

Just food for thought.


Your words touched my heart, Thumper! I had to think carefully not to make this sound like a flirt, but it would seem to me that you have it all together!

I agree with many who have posted here, with some differences.

Mainly, prostelysing (or however it's spelled). According to my faith, I know the path to eternal life and happiness. Why would I NOT share that with others, especially those I love.

Also, I've put up with so much religious ridicule I was sick of coming here. There are those loud uneducated, bigoted few who make the world just a less nice place to live in.
I'll never make the generalization that you're like every other _______ I've ever met if you'll do the same for me. I also never ridicule another's beliefs.
 
Back
Top