Roger Maris's 61

Irishdragon

Really Experienced
Joined
Jul 14, 2001
Posts
135
In light of all of the people in baseball now relying on the chemicals to give them that little extra pop, could we say that Maris's 61 homers might be the most impressive record in all of baseball. Maybe even all of sports? Nolan Ryan's 383 k's ia another one, but Maris's seems much more impressive considering he was not taking pills.
 
Well...

There IS that little footnote you have to always attach to that accomlishment, that he did it in a longer season than Ruth hit his 60 in. And Ruth did that when he was fat. If you give it up for Maris you have to give it up more for Ruth. But, I get your point, them there boys of summer got their records the honest way, and that's something of which to be in awe.
 
Right I agree with Ruth. But there is almost something godlike about Ruth's records. He is bigger then the game itself and deserves his own catagory. I mean nobody will ever be able to do what he did in the game so the only person he can be compared to fairly, is himself.
 
Dimaggio's 56 in a row might be it. Especially considering that after he was stopped (by 2 diving plays), he hit in 16 more consecutive games.
 
Irishdragon said:
In light of all of the people in baseball now relying on the chemicals to give them that little extra pop
Fuck that. You have no honest clue how many baseball players are totally clean, how many are using legal products like creatine, and how many are using banned substances. You want reasons why there's been an offensive explosion? Smaller ballparks, better conditioning, better-made bats, tighter-stitched balls, and thinned-out pitching through expansion. Don't leap to the steroid conclusion just because junkies like Ken Caminiti and Jose Canseco pulled some arbitrary percentage out of their beefed-up gluteus maximi.

Irishdragon said:
could we say that Maris's 61 homers might be the most impressive record in all of baseball. Maybe even all of sports? Nolan Ryan's 383 k's ia another one, but Maris's seems much more impressive considering he was not taking pills.
Depends. Are we talking single-season or career? Any shmuck can have a hell of a season (last pitcher to win 30 games: Denny McLain, 1968), but building a career is harder.

I have to go with history here and say Ruth's 60 is more impressive than Maris' 61. And if you want a Ryan record for the ages, I think seven no-hitters tops them all. That and DiMaggio's 56 are probably ones that will never be broken.

Gehrig's 2130 and Ripken's 2632 are worthy accomplishments, but the biggest factor in both of those is luck. Sure, Cal stayed in games others wouldn't with a sprained knee or twisted ankle (or broken nose), but he was lucky he never suffered a major injury, and that the owners never got around to using replacement players during the strike of '94-'95.

Aaron's records in home runs and RBI will probably fall, by Griffey almost certainly if Bonds and Sosa don't get to it first. But Cy Young's 511 wins won't even be approached.

As far as all of sports goes, it's too tough to translate things into other sports. Is Walter Payton's rushing record more impressive than Kareem Abdul-Jabbar's points total, or Pete Rose's hit numbers? Whose record is cooler, Gretzky's, Aaron's, or Rice's? Where do you put someone like Michael Johnson, Muhammad Ali, Pete Sampras or Secretariat?

I certainly won't try.

TB4p
 
I think the fact that 60 has been broken 3 times since mac did it, gives at least a little bit of an indication that steroids have been used. Mac 70 and 66. Sosa 66, 63, and Bonds 73???? 5 times 60 has been passed in 4 years. Can somebody say Steroids!!!
 
Unregistered said:
I think the fact that 60 has been broken 3 times since mac did it, gives at least a little bit of an indication that steroids have been used. Mac 70 and 66. Sosa 66, 63, and Bonds 73???? 5 times 60 has been passed in 4 years. Can somebody say Steroids!!!
Sosa's done it three times. He hit 64 last year.

In 1998, there were two new teams, Arizona and Tampa Bay, which means there were two dozen-plus more pitchers who were minor league-level pitching in the majors.

McGwire put together two healthy seasons. Last year, he didn't hit more than 60 — because he was hurt. He hit 66 without androstenedione. Sosa finally learned not to swing at everything. And Bonds moved to a ballpark with a short porch in right field.

Once again, not necessarily steroids.

TB4p
 
teddybear4play said:
I have to go with history here and say Ruth's 60 is more impressive than Maris' 61. And if you want a Ryan record for the ages, I think seven no-hitters tops them all. That and DiMaggio's 56 are probably ones that will never be broken.

Gehrig's 2130 and Ripken's 2632 are worthy accomplishments, but the biggest factor in both of those is luck. Sure, Cal stayed in games others wouldn't with a sprained knee or twisted ankle (or broken nose), but he was lucky he never suffered a major injury, and that the owners never got around to using replacement players during the strike of '94-'95.

Aaron's records in home runs and RBI will probably fall, by Griffey almost certainly if Bonds and Sosa don't get to it first. But Cy Young's 511 wins won't even be approached.

As far as all of sports goes, it's too tough to translate things into other sports. Is Walter Payton's rushing record more impressive than Kareem Abdul-Jabbar's points total, or Pete Rose's hit numbers? Whose record is cooler, Gretzky's, Aaron's, or Rice's? Where do you put someone like Michael Johnson, Muhammad Ali, Pete Sampras or Secretariat?

I certainly won't try.

TB4p

A few points.

1. I don't think Ryan's record, or Dimaggio's are great indications of a great record because their worth in baseball terms. Ryan pitched the worst no-hitters ever(Or some of them.) Lots of walks, lots of HBP. A no-hitter by Ryan was not as well a pitched game as a 2-hit shutout by Greg Maddux.

Dimaggio, over his 56 game hitting streak, hit around 400 with a certain amount of doubles(13?) homers(12?) and Triples(2?). But if he had those same numbers over a 56 game stretch where his longest hitting streak was 2 games would he be less valuable to his team? No, maybe more. So while Dimaggio's hitting streak is an interesting statistical anomaly it isn't a great feat(like hitting for the cycle.)

2. The major factor in Ripken and Gehrig's streaks is toughness. They played through sprained ankles, sprained wrists, flus and anything else. No Major injuries sure but lots of guys have had no major injuries and sit out games with a hangnail. Is it luck that prevents serious injuries? Or is it conditioning, healthy living and smarts? They are legitimate accomplishments. Much more so than, say, Dimaggio's hot streak in 41

3. Young's record should be across the Ancient/Modern Records line. The recognized career win leader should be Warren Spahn. Young, Johnson, Mathewson and Alexander played a different game for much of their career.

4. Pete Rose's hit totals aren't impressive.
 
I agree with TB4P, not necessarily steriods. I'll bet you $10,000 to anyone's $1000 that A-ROD and Berkman aren't using steroids. Lance takes absolutely nothing, not even multi-vitamins. It is possible to run 20+miles under 6min pace everyday and it is also possible to lift upperbody everyday and play 162games a year-talent and work. The majority of these guys are stronger because they get paid 10's of millions to kick ass-their backs will go out earlier but money will be in the bank. Hack Wilson's 191 RBIs has my vote. 511 wins is an awful lot.
 
70/30 said:
511 wins is an awful lot.

Yeah but can you imagine how many wins Roger Clemens would have if he only had to throw 10 good fastballs a game.
 
Still gotta go out and do it. Baseball is a competition, Young went up against another team and prevailed 511 times. I'll agree to a point and say Johnson's career (417 wins and 110 shutouts) is more impressive than Young's. Rumor has it that he had a decent fastball.
 
70/30 said:
Still gotta go out and do it. Baseball is a competition, Young went up against another team and prevailed 511 times. I'll agree to a point and say Johnson's career (417 wins and 110 shutouts) is more impressive than Young's. Rumor has it that he had a decent fastball.

Not at all. The game was so different that the record is invalid. The nature of the game today(There isn't a man alive who could start 60 games in todays baseball) makes the record a piece of the past.

Not to mention Young never faced black hitters.
 
Weevil said:


Not at all. The game was so different that the record is invalid. The nature of the game today(There isn't a man alive who could start 60 games in todays baseball) makes the record a piece of the past.

Not to mention Young never faced black hitters.

If you'll notice I initially said "511 is an awful lot of wins". I didn't say it was the most remarkable record, Hack Wilson driving in 191 runs in a season has my vote. The guy had to go out and pitch an insane amount of games and he won most of them, he deserves credit for rising well above his competition.
 
70/30 said:


If you'll notice I initially said "511 is an awful lot of wins". I didn't say it was the most remarkable record, Hack Wilson driving in 191 runs in a season has my vote. The guy had to go out and pitch an insane amount of games and he won most of them, he deserves credit for rising well above his competition.

Sure, no doubt. He deserves all sorts of credit as the best pitcher in 1900's baseball(Which ended around 1919)

He shouldn't be the standard against which modern pitchers are judged. That's Warren Spahn.

It's like Hugh Duffy. You don't see him mentioned much as the all time single season batting champ.

It's not an insane amount of times. It was standard for the era. A pitcher back then was much more like a Hockey goalie today. And wins, in measuring hockey goalies, isn't very fruitful.
 
I think Walter Johnson had an equal career as Spahn, even taking into account the differences in era (born 34yrs apart). Who was a better "pure" hitter in their career Cobb, Hornsby, Williams, Musial, or Gwynn? Not a distinction I think can be made without giving Ted recognition for the 5 seasons he missed because of war.
 
70/30 said:
I think Walter Johnson had an equal career as Spahn, even taking into account the differences in era (born 34yrs apart). Who was a better "pure" hitter in their career Cobb, Hornsby, Williams, Musial, or Gwynn? Not a distinction I think can be made without giving Ted recognition for the 5 seasons he missed because of war.

I'd agree about Barney if it wasn't for the fact that he never faced black hitters and that he had his best years before batters got to hit against white balls
 
Weevil said:


I'd agree about Barney if it wasn't for the fact that he never faced black hitters and that he had his best years before batters got to hit against white balls

I'm curious about the percentage of MLB hitters that were black or latino in the mid1950's. Doubt it is anything like today.
 
70/30 said:
I agree with TB4P, not necessarily steriods. I'll bet you $10,000 to anyone's $1000 that A-ROD and Berkman aren't using steroids. Lance takes absolutely nothing, not even multi-vitamins. It is possible to run 20+miles under 6min pace everyday and it is also possible to lift upperbody everyday and play 162games a year-talent and work. The majority of these guys are stronger because they get paid 10's of millions to kick ass-their backs will go out earlier but money will be in the bank. Hack Wilson's 191 RBIs has my vote. 511 wins is an awful lot.
Damn, I didn't even think about Hack Wilson. I should have, being a Cub fan. He had 56 homers that year also (1930). Jimmie Foxx and Hank Greenberg hit 58 shortly after Ruth smashed 60, too.

Another note about the game being different in Cy Young's time: foul balls weren't considered strikes until around the turn of the century. Foul bunts and foul tips were considered strikes even later.

TB4p
 
70/30 said:


I'm curious about the percentage of MLB hitters that were black or latino in the mid1950's. Doubt it is anything like today.

No, but it was significant. I mean, Spahn pitched against Mays and McCovey. Johnson didn't face Pop Lloyd.
 
teddybear4play said:

Another note about the game being different in Cy Young's time: foul balls weren't considered strikes until around the turn of the century. Foul bunts and foul tips were considered strikes even later.

TB4p

Sure, but nothing, absolutely nothing, compares to the difference in pitching after the coming of Babe Ruth.
 
spahn's career era was 3.09 and www.baseballreference.com goes further and says since he pitched in a pitcher's ballpark, that the adjusted figure would be 3.65. Ever take into consideration that Spahn had Aaron and Mathews batting on his team.
 
70/30 said:
spahn's career era was 3.09 and www.baseballreference.com goes further and says since he pitched in a pitcher's ballpark, that the adjusted figure would be 3.65. Ever take into consideration that Spahn had Aaron and Mathews batting on his team.

No, not really. He was one of the best pitchers in the league before they were on his team.

But that's besides the point. Take it in context not just in park effects but also in terms of the era. Lots of runs were scored in the 50's.

But even accepting that it is only valid in comparing him to other post-1919 pitchers. Since we were talking about wins and not ERA his ERA is a side issue.
 
Ruth's 60 is the most impressive to me for one reason... His single season total was more than other teams totals! To be so dominate like that is the most impressive of all.

Another record that should be mentioned is Bob Gibson's 64? 67? season where his ERA was 1.19. And that was also during a time when batting was the dominate force.

Hack's record is also a good one. So is Henderson's 122? steals and career total.

Oh and I can't forget Aaron's career homerun total, which included hitting 30 or more homeruns 15 seasons... amazing feat of consitantcy.
 
1924 Walter Johnson went 23-7 with a 2.72 and the Senators won the pennant. His ballclub hit 22 homeruns by far last in the AL. However they gave up just 34 homers. The YANKs were 2nd in the standings but hit 98 homers and gave up 59 homers. Competition along with context.
 
SleepingWarrior said:
Ruth's 60 is the most impressive to me for one reason... His single season total was more than other teams totals! To be so dominate like that is the most impressive of all.

Another record that should be mentioned is Bob Gibson's 64? 67? season where his ERA was 1.19. And that was also during a time when batting was the dominate force.

You're thinking of 68 with a 1.12

But you're completely wrong about hitting being a dominating force in the mid sixties. Rule changes were enacted to make it easier on pitchers. 68, remember, is the year when YAz won the batting title with a .301 average. The lowest of all time. The league average was .230. It was a pitchers year. Context.
 
Back
Top