Say WHAT???????????

Our nation's educational system has been designed around testing schedules, which every state is required to follow. The last major change to that system that I am aware of is the No Child Left Behind program, instituted by Bush II. Therefore, school systems are federally mandated to promote or hold back students based on how they perform on standardized tests. There is little to no room within these programs for much of anyone's opinion, whether it be a parent's or a teacher's opinion. Whether moneys flow into each school system or not is hugely dependent on how their students fare during standardized testing.
 
Our nation's educational system has been designed around testing schedules, which every state is required to follow. The last major change to that system that I am aware of is the No Child Left Behind program, instituted by Bush II. Therefore, school systems are federally mandated to promote or hold back students based on how they perform on standardized tests. There is little to no room within these programs for much of anyone's opinion, whether it be a parent's or a teacher's opinion. Whether moneys flow into each school system or not is hugely dependent on how their students fare during standardized testing.

That is certainly part of the equation, but obviously there is some latitude to keep the money flowing in, like giving the parents veto power. If the cash flow was cast in concrete, on a per child basis, then there is no way that provision could stand. It is my understanding that the cash flow is dependent on the overall school rating.

I can see a serious problem with that particular method as well. As long as the overall districts rating is within the bounds of obtaining the checks, who really cares about the individual student or and particular school? The system has been reduced to cash flow analysis as opposed to educating the child.

Ishmael
 
That is certainly part of the equation, but obviously there is some latitude to keep the money flowing in, like giving the parents veto power. If the cash flow was cast in concrete, on a per child basis, then there is no way that provision could stand. It is my understanding that the cash flow is dependent on the overall school rating.

I can see a serious problem with that particular method as well. As long as the overall districts rating is within the bounds of obtaining the checks, who really cares about the individual student or and particular school? The system has been reduced to cash flow analysis as opposed to educating the child.

Ishmael

To the best of my knowledge, there is no per-child requisite. The money is based on overall success or failure. But here is the other piece of No Child - it is a cumulative program. Or maybe, cumulative is not the word I am searching for? The school systems are required to have substantial increases of successes over previous years. So, every child who passes or fails weighs more heavily on school totals now than they might have a few years ago. There are a number of states that are talking about suing the federal government now because No Child has become insanely stringent, although I don't know if any have actually done so.
 
To the best of my knowledge, there is no per-child requisite. The money is based on overall success or failure. But here is the other piece of No Child - it is a cumulative program. Or maybe, cumulative is not the word I am searching for? The school systems are required to have substantial increases of successes over previous years. So, every child who passes or fails weighs more heavily on school totals now than they might have a few years ago. There are a number of states that are talking about suing the federal government now because No Child has become insanely stringent, although I don't know if any have actually done so.

Let's start with the pass/fail criteria. That criteria is based on test results, not whether the child is held back a year or not. Consequently holding the child back has virtually zero impact on the cash flow. Meaning that the child has already failed the test, it's all past tense now. The issue now becomes what is in the best interest of the child as an individual and who is better able to determine whether a 'do over' will aid the child or not, the individual who was chartered to teach the child, or the parent who, in most cases, is reacting emotionally?

The whole role of the federal government in education is a different subject.

Ishmael
 
Let's start with the pass/fail criteria. That criteria is based on test results, not whether the child is held back a year or not. Consequently holding the child back has virtually zero impact on the cash flow. Meaning that the child has already failed the test, it's all past tense now. The issue now becomes what is in the best interest of the child as an individual and who is better able to determine whether a 'do over' will aid the child or not, the individual who was chartered to teach the child, or the parent who, in most cases, is reacting emotionally?

The whole role of the federal government in education is a different subject.

Ishmael

I'm not sure how it works on a national level; I'll put that out there up front. Here, the standardized testing happens every few years, almost an indoctrination for students approaching the Year That Counts. If a student cannot pass the MCAS in 10th grade, they have to take it again. If they have not passed it by the time they finish school, they are not awarded a degree. By 10th grade, they will have taken grade-appropriate MCAS exams multiple times. The purpose of the testing in younger years is to train the child to be able to pass the final one. If they cannot pass the younger ones, it does not cost the system anything, but the school has the option to hold the child back for another year to prep him/her to retake the exam. The ultimate goal of public education at this point is to get the maximum percent of students to pass the MCAS in 10th grade.
 
I'm not sure how it works on a national level; I'll put that out there up front. Here, the standardized testing happens every few years, almost an indoctrination for students approaching the Year That Counts. If a student cannot pass the MCAS in 10th grade, they have to take it again. If they have not passed it by the time they finish school, they are not awarded a degree. By 10th grade, they will have taken grade-appropriate MCAS exams multiple times. The purpose of the testing in younger years is to train the child to be able to pass the final one. If they cannot pass the younger ones, it does not cost the system anything, but the school has the option to hold the child back for another year to prep him/her to retake the exam. The ultimate goal of public education at this point is to get the maximum percent of students to pass the MCAS in 10th grade.

Does the term "Mandarin" ring a bell here?

Ishmael
 
Not sure? Reference?

goggle 'Mandarin (bureaucrat)'

China was the first nation to institute formal testing for bureaucrats. Parents of promising children became obsessed with making sure that their children were instructed in all of the subjects necessary to pass the formal examinations. (One of the reasons that the Chinese as a whole are so education oriented. Also one of the reasons that China ended up with such class disparity.)

The good news was the above mentioned results, ie. education oriented. The bad news is that that education (indoctrination) was strictly focused on the needs and desires of the state. They served the Imperial whims, not themselves or the populace. Of course the theory then, and now, is that ALL government employees are the servants of the people. Any attempt to obtain any permit from a government entity should disabuse you of that notion. He who signs the checks makes the rules and no government employee was ever disciplined for telling a 'civilian', "No".

Ishmael
 
Although that was a google fail, I have seen the potential comparison for years. Or, to be more accurate, what I have watched (under the guise of making us more internationally competitive) has been a systemic plan to slowly indoctrinate students to be good followers with limited capacity to think for themselves.
 
Although that was a google fail, I have seen the potential comparison for years. Or, to be more accurate, what I have watched (under the guise of making us more internationally competitive) has been a systemic plan to slowly indoctrinate students to be good followers with limited capacity to think for themselves.

If you trace the history of public education in this nation back to it's origins you'll find that that was the goal to begin with. Hive mentality.

Ishmael
 
lol

this is one of those topics where you read the headline and think
"why would anyone argue the point"

and then you actually go and read about it...

This is not about children not being able to read
we are not talking about illiterate 8 year olds

OR about children failing a grade and parents being able to
say they wanted their child to move on anyway

This is about a child in the 3rd grade, not getting a third
grade reading level on 1 state standardized test.

The debate is weather a child who by all accounts has
PASSED third grade, should fail and repeat, if they dont
test out at a third grade level.

Frankly many teacher hate the state standardized tests
some children are just not good at them. There are a myriad of
reasons a child would not get the required score on them.

Im uncomfortable with bills that are written with no wiggle room.
Each child is different, and this one test shouldn't determine whether
a child passes. The teacher should.

This bill is taking that decision out of the hands of the teacher.

Oh, and note, the parents dont get to "decide" if their child moves on
if they fail the grade, ONLY if they fail the reading portion of this test.
 
If you trace the history of public education in this nation back to it's origins you'll find that that was the goal to begin with. Hive mentality.

Ishmael

I am completely unprepared to speak to this at the present time. However, I am willing to do the research. My knee jerk response is that early public education in this country was very rudimentary at best, and designed to meet the barest of essentials, while not interfering with planting, harvest, etc.
 
I am completely unprepared to speak to this at the present time. However, I am willing to do the research. My knee jerk response is that early public education in this country was very rudimentary at best, and designed to meet the barest of essentials, while not interfering with planting, harvest, etc.

Public education began in Boston as a means for the 'blue bloods' to segregate their children from "those Irish riffraff."

Modern (organized) public education began back in the 1920's and followed the European model which followed the Chinese model. Segregation was still the order of the day. Still is to a very large extent. The very notion that by somehow sending blacks to predominantly white schools, or sending whites to predominately black schools would improve the quality of education escapes me.

Ishmael
 
That didn't sound right, so I went digging... from ehow:

Colonial Education
Before the mid-1800s, most children were taught on a one-on-one basis or in small groups. Besides basic knowledge, students were taught trades. In some colonies, such as Connecticut, there were government-run schools. However, most children were uneducated or taught by tutors. Education was more for religious reasons in the New England colonies of Connecticut, Massachusetts and New Hampshire in the 17th century when the only existing groups were Puritans and Congregationalists. However, with people from different countries and faiths immigrating to America, the concept of religion in education weakened, and public schooling became the standard by the mid-1700s.

Thomas Jefferson's Influence on Public Education
Thomas Jefferson led America in the concept of education being available for all people, regardless of their religion, culture or status in society. Jefferson's beliefs that education should be free from religious biases were shared by other trailblazers in public education such as Noah Webster, Benjamin Rush, George Washington and Robert Coram. However, challenges such as economic transformations and more people immigrating to America made it hard to carry out these ideals.

As for the rest of your post, well, we'll save that for another day. :)
 
First of all many parents don't agree with the teachers when it comes to their children. Quite frankly a child that can't read by the third grade is most likely NOT coming from a home that puts a premium on learning. That being the case the parent is more likely than not to blame the teacher.

The problem is simple, who should have the last word on whether the child is capable of advancing or not? The parent or the teacher?

Age is not a overriding factor here. Most children are capable of rudimentary reading at the age of four. Biblically speaking the age of reason is 7. To start using age as an excuse would, to one extent or another, be to say that the human race is regressing as far as mental capacity is concerned. I don't subscribe to that notion.

Ishmael
The Bible doesn't say the age of reason is seven years. Some pope said it.
 
Back
Top