Seasteading

Won't work, oh, I agree that it's going to be tried eventually, but it still won't work. Cultural dynamics favor dissolution, not aggregation. Just look around.

Ishmael
There's a neverending cycle of dissolution and aggregation, but it takes place against the bigger picture: constantly increasing technological and economic change and constantly shrinking travel, shipping and communications times, resource depletion, growing population and environmental degradation (Oceans fished out by 2048 they're now saying).

I understand why libertarians feel increasing panic and claustrophobia. We're on a shrinking planet with no elbow room. Daniel Boone it is said would pack up as soon as he could see his neighbor's chimney smoke. The next Daniel Boones will be spacemen perforce.
 
Thinking that you can bring order by social hierarchy is always utopian, and only becomes traditional when it has been tried for a long enough time, despite its constant failure. Remember that to elites, this is their Paradise, one where they rule and others are reduced to serfdom. "Hunger Games" is probably their biggest fantasy ever brought to film.
 
There's a neverending cycle of dissolution and aggregation, but it takes place against the bigger picture: constantly increasing technological and economic change and constantly shrinking travel, shipping and communications times, resource depletion, growing population and environmental degradation (Oceans fished out by 2048 they're now saying).

I understand why libertarians feel increasing panic and claustrophobia. We're on a shrinking planet with no elbow room. Daniel Boone it is said would pack up as soon as he could see his neighbor's chimney smoke. The next Daniel Boones will be spacemen perforce.

Forget space. I might go literally underground. Subterranean life. Or to the forests of my native state. Go Galt completely.
 
Forget space. I might go literally underground. Subterranean life. Or to the forests of my native state. Go Galt completely.

You can't go Galt. Going Galt is actually impossible in the real world and always was but you can only go Galt if you're so important to the world that you leaving would fuck the rest of us over. That nobody else could look at what you did and sucessfully copy it.
 
You can't go Galt. Going Galt is actually impossible in the real world and always was but you can only go Galt if you're so important to the world that you leaving would fuck the rest of us over. That nobody else could look at what you did and sucessfully copy it.

Don't ruin my fantasy. :( The difference between myself and many others on the Right is that I know that my current wishes aren't likely to happen soon....until some tragic events occur that will cause more suffering in the process than I'd care for. Yet they will happen, because the State is its own worst enemy.
 
Last edited:
Don't ruin my fantasy. :( The difference between myself and many others on the Right is that I know that my current wishes aren't likely to happen soon....until some tragic events occur that will cause more suffering in the process than I'd care for. Yet they will happen, because the State is its own worst enemy.

No they are outright impossible and all of human history is based on the fact that the state is a good thing. We didn't take down mammoths with your everyman for himself attitude. We didn't cross the oceans and populate the world with it. No matter how much you wish you were in this by yourself you're not.
 
Therein lies the difference between us. You think that society is government. I think that society is one thing and government another. The "going Galt" thing is just for me a desire to escape the State, not a desire to escape society.

I believe that society should take care of the poor, the sick, the disabled, etc. I believe that it should help unwed mothers and others get back on the feet. I believe that the State should not, because the State shouldn't exist in the first place. Society doesn't require the State, though the State requires society, as it is a cancer on society.
 
Last edited:
Therein lies the difference between us. You think that society is government. I think that society is one thing and government another. The "going Galt" thing is just for me a desire to escape the State, not a desire to escape society.

I believe that society should take care of the poor, the sick, the disabled, etc. I believe that it should help unwed mothers and others get back on the feet. I believe that the State should not, because the State shouldn't exist in the first place. Society doesn't require the State, though the State requires society, as it is a cancer on society.

You honestly believe this, but you're wrong. The State is just a fact of life, like death and taxes.:rose:
 
Last edited:
No they are outright impossible and all of human history is based on the fact that the state is a good thing.



Show me one major state that hasn't imposed suffering on it's people or others through war, imperialism, occupations, financial slavery and or various other human rights violations at some point? Straight up insano evil shit....

Show me one major state in the history of man that didn't end with a self destruct? Greece? no....Rome? no.....England? no....USSR? no....

On the flip side however one could argue what major society ever became the innovative crazy advanced for it's era society/culture (greek's/romans etc) without the state?

Is there a solution? Can one have a truly awesome ground breaking society without the government having a microscope shoved up everyone's pee hole 24/7? Prob not.....

Personally I think it's a sociological paradox....can't have success without the one thing that doom's you to be a victim of your own success.
 
You honestly believe this, but you're wrong. The State is just a fact of life, like death and taxes.

Not sure taxes are so much a fact of life as the easiest way to collect for a society. Still over all this is true. There is no truly defining line between state and society or for that matter business and government.
 
Not sure taxes are so much a fact of life as the easiest way to collect for a society. Still over all this is true. There is no truly defining line between state and society or for that matter business and government.

Well, for a socialist, this is just mother's milk.:rose:
 
Thinking that you can bring order by social hierarchy is always utopian . . .

Bullshit. Medieval Europe was hierarchical and struggled for order, but it was not based on any utopian ideas -- the only utopia was in the next world.
 
Therein lies the difference between us. You think that society is government. I think that society is one thing and government another. The "going Galt" thing is just for me a desire to escape the State, not a desire to escape society.

Bullshit. No state, no society, unless it's a primitive pre-state society or a modern-tribal failed-state society (either way, you'll find the collective authority of your tribe or village just as heavy if not more).
 
That would be leaving society. And you won't be able to keep it up long.

Bullshit....an individual does not need society/state to live. Just need it to live with all the modern convinces our society provides, they are nice and convenient but not necessary. A family or small tribe/commune would make things a lot easier and nicer but even then, still don't NEED state/society to make a living.
 
Bullshit....an individual does not need society/state to live. Just need it to live with all the modern convinces our society provides, they are nice and convenient but not necessary. A family or small tribe/commune would make things a lot easier and nicer but even then, still don't NEED state/society to make a living.

Well, I believe that even in a larger society, the State can be replaced by voluntary co-operative associations.

As for the other thing....Thoreau would be very surprised to hear that. :devil:

Anyway, thanks for calling people on their actual BS. :cool:

Personally, I like Sean and KingOrfeo, but I firmly disagree with their premise, so naturally I don't share their conclusions.

You're alright in my book, Frizzle Fry.
 
Well, I believe that even in a larger society, the State can be replaced by voluntary co-operative associations.

As for the other thing....Thoreau would be very surprised to hear that. :devil:

Anyway, thanks for calling people on their actual BS. :cool:

Personally, I like Sean and KingOrfeo, but I firmly disagree with their premise, so naturally I don't share their conclusions.

You're alright in my book, Frizzle Fry.

Frizzle's some combination of dead wrong and a dreamer. I suppose if you want to attempt to make the argument that we've come so far as humans that we no longer need each other to survive that's. . .I don't know what it is but it's something.

There is no replacing te state with voluntary co-operative associations. You simply can't do it. People aren't wired that way for one reason or another. It kinda, sorta works if the group is small enough that roles are designated even on unspoken terms but other than that it simply does not function. Even if it could we are where we are in the world because our ancient ancestors rejected that bs, and rejected before we even became human.
 
I think some bully conned people back in the Stone Age in believing that he was ruling them for their own good, to be perfectly blunt. And others followed his example. And the rest is history.
 
I think some bully conned people back in the Stone Age in believing that he was ruling them for their own good, to be perfectly blunt. And others followed his example. And the rest is history.

Not history, nature. Human nature. We evolved to be group-animals like wolves or bison, not mostly-solitary animals like deer or cats. The same appears to be true of primates in general, or at least of the anthropoid species like chimps, bonobos, gorillas -- they all live in bands and can't thrive alone.
 
I think some bully conned people back in the Stone Age in believing that he was ruling them for their own good, to be perfectly blunt. And others followed his example. And the rest is history.

It's rather difficult to bully people (especially in the Stone Age) who have the option of walking away the first time you stop paying attention to them. In fact it's quite a bit easier to not get bullied in that world than it is to get bullied.
 
Believe what you must. I wash my hands of this. I disagree with your premises, and thus with your conclusions. Peace, out.
 
I think some bully conned people back in the Stone Age in believing that he was ruling them for their own good, to be perfectly blunt. And others followed his example. And the rest is history.

It's rather difficult to bully people (especially in the Stone Age) who have the option of walking away the first time you stop paying attention to them. In fact it's quite a bit easier to not get bullied in that world than it is to get bullied.

It's a common misconception held by people who do not understand leadership, especially leadership of a small group. People follow a leader because they think it will make their life easier. "Easy" is a very relative term. The smart guy, who can get others to work together is much more powerful than the strong guy who can kick everybody else's ass.

A leader and bully both have to sleep sometime. The leader is more likely to wake up.
 

You know how this "thief" avoids paying taxes like the example you so amatuerishly apply? I don't drink.

I don't smoke, either; nor do I own a car or drive, or own property. I intentionally choose to live in a state which doesn't command its citizens to pay income taxes. I purposely live a lifestyle that doesn't require the involuntary confiscation of fellow citizens' private property...

...and you lazily call me a "thief" because I intentionally choose to disengage as much as I possibly can rather than submit to statists thieves like you who reckon they always have some claim on other individuals' stuff? Too friggin' funny.

By the way, tyrannical baby buddha: what you got to say about the outcome - both criminal and political - of the tax insurrection you cite?

What happened to those Whiskey rebels you call "thieves" and who were tyrannically charged and sentenced to death?

What happened to the tax they rebelled against?

What happened to not only the individual who was most responsible for the statist tax but the political Party he basically created?

The only practical difference between me and the Whiskey rebels is that I've intentionally chosen to disengage defensively and wait for now, rather than to recklessly strike out offensively and attack. I abhor violence because I've experienced its deepest depravity, and I believe I understand the revolutionary political dynamics involved a little better than they, which is only natural since their example has been quite educational to me.

I'm totally more of a Benjamin Martin kind of guy: I believe defense of individual liberty is the most effective offensive weapon known to political man and when unleashed physically, absolute war is declared...

...a putz like you is only of any practical concern because of what you enable: lemming statists will always have someone else come to involuntarily take another's property for what you champion is the collective's share, because you're too pvssy to face the automatic consequences of that crime against Nature's Law itself; that's why you favor big government to do your stealing for you, while you sit behind your keyboard in air conditioned, guru-wannbe utopia, never honest enough to show the whites of your socialist eyes.

I'm purposely out here about as far away from your socialist world as Americanly possible today, baby buddha, intentionally living our founders' promise of individual liberty with other individuals who cherish that unalienable blessing more than they cherish life itself...

...so:

Anytime you get to feeling like you individually actually wish to do something about "thieves" like me instead of just sticking your head up your azz to think up the word...

...you can always mount up and start riding my way, hoss.
 
Last edited:
You know how this "thief" avoids paying taxes like the example you so amatuerishly apply? I don't drink.

I don't smoke, either; nor do I own a car or drive, or own property. I intentionally choose to live in a state which doesn't command its citizens to pay income taxes. I purposely live a lifestyle that doesn't require the involuntary confiscation of fellow citizens' private property...

...and you lazily call me a "thief" because I intentionally choose to disengage as much as I possibly can rather than submit to statists thieves like you who reckon they always have some claim on other individuals' stuff? Too friggin' funny.

By the way, tyrannical baby buddha: what you got to say about the outcome - both criminal and political - of the tax insurrection you cite?

What happened to those Whiskey rebels you call "thieves" and who were tyrannically charged and sentenced to death?

What happened to the tax they rebelled against?

What happened to not only the individual who was most responsible for the statist tax but the political Party he basically created?

The only practical difference between me and the Whiskey rebels is that I've intentionally chosen to disengage defensively and wait for now, rather than to recklessly strike out offensively and attack. I abhor violence because I've experienced its deepest depravity, and I believe I understand the revolutionary political dynamics involved a little better than they, which is only natural since their example has been quite educational to me.

I'm totally more of a Benjamin Martin kind of guy: I believe defense of individual liberty is the most effective offensive weapon known to political man and when unleashed physically, absolute war is declared...

...a putz like you is only of any practical concern because of what you enable: lemming statists will always have someone else come to involuntarily take another's property for what you champion is the collective's share, because you're too pvssy to face the automatic consequences of that crime against Nature's Law itself; that's why you favor big government to do your stealing for you, while you sit behind your keyboard in air conditioned, guru-wannbe utopia, never honest enough to show the whites of your socialist eyes.

I'm purposely out here about as far away from your socialist world as Americanly possible today, baby buddha, intentionally living our founders' promise of individual liberty with other individuals who cherish that unalienable blessing more than they cherish life itself...

...so:

Anytime you get to feeling like you individually actually wish to do something about "thieves" like me instead of just sticking your head up your azz to think up the word...

...you can always mount up and start riding my way, hoss.

You wouldn't last long.
 
Back
Top