Serious Question...honest responses appreciated

G

Guest

Guest
Since this board seems to be so open and honest when discussing topics of sexual nature, I feel I can pose this question here. Thank you in advance to any of you fine people who respond.

Suppose you were dating someone...a really attractive woman who is as beautiful on the inside as she is on the outside. She's funny, intelligent, bubbly, compassionate, loving and quite possibly everything you've looked for in a mate (or at least seems that way so far). You want to take the relationship to the next level and become sexually involved with her, however, she has continuously backed away each and every time you've attempted.

One evening, while cuddling by the fireplace, you initiate a conversation about becoming intimate. At this point, she seems extremely uncomfortable, and despite reassuring her that you're not going to walk away if she wishes to not engage in a sexual relationship with you yet, she pulls away and has a disturbing look about her. At this point, she cautiously begins opening up to you about her past. You learn that 6 years ago, this woman was raped and that the encounter has left her with a sexually transmitted disease. While her disease is not life-threatening (herpes), it has scarred her emotionally, as well as physically, in a lot of ways.

At this point, you know very little about herpes, other than the fact that if you do become sexually involved with her, you risk infecting yourself with the disease. So my questions are:

1) Do you stop dating this woman in order to protect yourself?
2) If you did stop dating her, would you feel badly about judging her on something she had absolutely no control of?
3) If you wouldn't stop dating her, and used protection to prevent transmitting the disease, would it ever be possible for her to have children (something that's very important to you)?
4) Overall, how would you feel about being confronted with this information? Would you feel led on in any way due to the fact that this was not disclosed to you prior to becoming emotionally involved with your partner? (I believe this could be a situation where the roles were reversed and the guy could be the one disclosing this info to the woman)

I've done some research on the subject (online) but unfortunately, the information I've found doesn't deal with these particular issues. The sites only state the "facts" and don't allow for emotion to factor in on how to handle situations when confronted with them.

At this point, I feel a tad lost, and confused on how I feel about her. I appreciate her honesty, and more importantly, the fact that she did not become sexually involved with me without telling me about it, but a small part of me feels uncomfortable with the fact that I have become so emotionally involved with her, and led to believe that there could be a future here...and now I'm confronted with this information and don't know how to feel. I don't normally consider myself to be a judgemental person, but this is a fairly serious issue and I'm trying to figure out how to digest and deal with it all.
 
A friend has herpes, and has two kids. Her doctor monitored her throughout the pregnancies, and one was a C section because of an outbreak close to delivery time. Both kids are free of the disease.

You might try asking your own doctor about all the medical ramifications, and safe sex procedures.

Personally, I give her a lot of credit for resisting intimacy until telling you. I can understand your feelings, too, but if she's really that wonderful, it would be a mistake to end a good relationship over a lousy virus. It isn't life threatening, and there's no reason you can't have a great life together if it works out that way.
 
Woah. Tough one. I think I would keep seeing her. If she's perfect for you in every other way, why not? You will have to be careful if you ever are intimate but it's not the worst thing in the world. Being in a polyamorous relationship I speak from personal experience. The condoms just become habit after a while.

Maybe someone with a medical background can answer this better than I can, but as far as kids, I would think it possible for her to have them, but you would of course risk infecting yourself and maybe the baby as well. Would you consider adoption?

I think if someone stopped seeing me for that reason I would think/feel 2 things: either that he dumped me because I wouldn't put out, or I would become even more scarred because I was punished for something that wasn't my fault.
 
1) No.... She's funny, intelligent, bubbly, compassionate, loving and quite possibly everything you've looked for in a mate (or at least seems that way so far).


2) N/A

3) i have no idea..... Sorry...


4) No... You learn that 6 years ago, this woman was raped and that the encounter has left her with a sexually transmitted disease. While her disease is not life-threatening (herpes) she didn't tell you because of the Rape part not because she was 'leading you on'... Rape is hard to talk about especialy if it'sa your own rape your discussing...

Kiss her, Hug her and tell her you Love her..... do Not leave her because she has a non-life-threatening disease....



.....Remember.....She Ain't a leper....
 
I agree Iris and CreamyLady and MinkSoul..

emotionally torn, You have a Special Relationship with this woman.. She Trusts you Enough to tell you about Her Rape and what had happend with that.. You should Kiss her and Hug her and just hold her.. and do talk to a Doctor about how to handle Herpies.. there are procedures that will help with them and having Children is posible and Very Common as CreamyLady has stated about her freind..

Be Patiant with her, Listen to her and don't push her into anything that she doesn't feel comfortable with.. It is tough living and trying to understand some one that has been raped.. it is a pain and a memory that will NEVER go away.. but with patiants and understanding and TRUST You can help the pain and the memories feel less painful..

She Trusts and Respects you.. that is something that is Hard for her to do.. You should hold her and thank her for the gift that she has put torwards you..


E
 
Congratulations on meeting someone really special!

1) Keep seeing her.
2) Do not dump someone who moves you like this. How often does life give you the gift of another human being?
3) Yes
4) She had an obligation to reveal these circumstances to you before becoming sexually involved with you, and that's all. She did this, and she should be admired for it.

Many, many people have fulfilling sexual relationships with partners who have herpes. You should always use a condom, and abstain from sex during an outbreak. These can be frequent or as rare as once or twice a year.

Conception is more complicated but very possible. It is frequently recommended that female HSV carriers attempting to concieve embark on a course of supressive antiviral therapy and then have unprotected sex with their partners while they are asymptomatic.

This situation should *not* panic you. The simple truth is that 1 in 4 Americans carry herpes. Following the recommended precautions, you actually have less chance of contracting herpes than if you have unprotected sex with a random partner.

There is a forum here where you can get answers to your questions from an HSV support group:

http://www.herpes.net/forum/ Just scroll down :)
 
do what happens, you know, follow your gutt feeling and if it goes wrong you cant say you didnet try,,,there are some strange sets of cucumstances out there in the world,,,you just got to try or walk away from what you have been dealt.... dont know if this will help but I dont know what else to say..Its a tough call
 
Back
Top